Has real communism been tried?

has real communism been tried?

No. Socialism has though and look how that turned out

retard alert

>not understanding the difference between socialism and communism.
You my friend is the retard here.

>You my friend is the retard here.

In terms of marx's actual idea? No, but that's where there's a difference between concept and implementation.

No but the multiple failures of every attempt to implement it says everything you need to know about its fallibility.

It's not supposed to be implemented. It's supposed to come about naturally.

Nobody has claimed to have tried to implement communism. USSR stands for Union of Soviet Socialist Republic. All so-called communist countries identified and identify themselves as socialism. Communism is the final step where utopia is achieved and government becomes redundant. Yes, Karl Marxist utopia is an anarchist one, but after the socialist government achieves utopia.

Then why does every communist government come about through violent revolution?

They just can't seem to get past the Socialism stage. Gee, I wonder why.

Because they're retarded. So are you for not seeing the difference.

Will this board ever shut the fuck up about communism and fascism? This isn't the politics board

Because the government won't allow it to come naturally.

Don't know what the other guy is smoking, Marx clearly expects the revolutions to be quite violent

It is in Scandinavia and it's shit

Scandinavia is capitalist.

It's socialism with Scandinavian characteristics

No, it's literally just capitalism with some regulation and welfare, like every other nation on Earth.

yes, and it was lit

Indeed

Scandinavia is no different to Australia, Canada, and New Zealand. Stop spreading Scandinavia is socialist meme.

just gonna leave this here

Seems like you got the wrong door, the LOL thread is two blocks down

Go outside of your mom's basement

Scandinavia is a literal commie wet dream with the State being in control of everything and Norway is literally by commies since the 40'

Wtf i hate freedom now

>the State being in control of everything
They have private business. Haven't you ever played a Paradox Interactive game?

It's worth noting that we've never seen a successful society based on real communism.

Go outside of your mom's basement

Scandinavia is a commie wet dream. Scandinavian states own everything(alcohol must be purchased in state-owned shops) in Scandinavia, and Norway is literally ruled by commies since the 40'.


fixed

...

thatsthejoke.jpg
Or are you actually enough of a brainlet to think China is communist?

Communism, as in "the movement to abolish the present state of things", has been tried, but the problem is to overthrow the yoke of capitalism requires sufficient material development, which to date no communist country has had. That's why every communist country has kept a mostly capitalist mode of production and attempted to rapidly develop capital.

>literally every attempt apart from the paris commune was influenced by leninism
hmmmm

Not him, but it's what Varg says. Probably got it from him.

yes

>implying the Kulaks didn't deserve worse

Those are ideology. And politics from the past = history.