My favorite is the one where a young, white male in New England stumbles upon a horrible, yet indescribable secret and almost dies, but manages to escape and remains haunted by it for the rest of his day.
But for real, Rats In the Walls is the best one. Polaris and the Doom that Came to Sarnath are honorable mentions for stories without a protag.
Adam Russell
Lovecraft sucks, faggot. Fuck off.
Jason Gonzalez
Hmm... I don't remember that one.
Ayden Wright
Mine is the one where the spooky monsters are metaphors for biggers
Daniel Baker
Fuck you, unpublished faggot.
Isaiah King
Fucking pleb, we all know that the superior racist boogeyman is the yellow people from the arctic who want to flood western civilisation.
Ian Lewis
>unpublished >implying
Brandon Johnson
Why are you posting?
Chase Hill
How did Lovecraft discover the Cthulhu "mythos"?
Samuel Cooper
The Rats in the Walls
Logan Price
The Outsider
Aiden Scott
At the mountains of madness
Anthony Roberts
The Outsider stands out imo.
Jason Hernandez
The Colour Out of Space
Zachary Thomas
This one.
Jacob Rodriguez
"Nyarlathotep" has to be my favorite short story, the imagery of an approaching calamity and the city going mad is Lovecraft at his finest. "The Dreams in the Witch House", I read this at midnight last night and was the first H.P. story to give me some spooks, the surreal environment of the dreams along with the "everything is going to shit" setting on May-Eve which is, as stated above, Lovecraft at his finest. "The Colour Out of Space", if this isn't the most alien and unique story Lovecraft has wrote I don't know what is; H.P. stated himself that this is his most favorite short story he has ever wrote.
Andrew Phillips
I need to read his stuff again. I've been reading many of the authors that influenced Lovecraft and it's interesting how much of a leap in bizarreness horror literature took when Lovecraft came on the scene. Writers like James, Poe, Machen, Blackwood, Bierce, etc wrote some very strange stories, and you can see how the separate elements of their stories were combined by Lovecraft, but on their own they never achieved the kind of cold, nightmarish vision of reality that Lovecraft exhibits in a tale like At the Mountains of Madness. There could certainly be someone major I'm missing, but it seems like Lovecraft was seriously ahead of his time.
Liam Morales
This
Jackson Foster
Dunwich Horror. Best of his that I had the luck of reading.
Jace Fisher
The one where he uses lots and lots of adjectives
Kayden Diaz
>The Colour Out of Space
Fugg, that was some creepy shit.
Jaxson Morales
He didn't discover it. You make it sound like it always existed. Anyway he never intended to make a structured mythos, he just kept making the similar story, as the OP cheekily points out.
For me the Innsmouth story is the best. Just a comfy read in general.