Are transgender people examples of Bodies without Organs?

...

Other urls found in this thread:

web.archive.org/web/20160331140911/http://ropeculture.org/2016/03/01/the-fag-agenda/
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

No, but Veeky Forums is

Ash piles without Ovens?

It is an example of psychopathy

There are basically three schools of thought
A) Gender is a social construct
Different cultures have different definitions of how a male or female should behave, though sex cannot currently be changed, an individual with who feels they are another gender are in fact that gender [those who argue that gender and sex are synonymous are being purposely obtuse since gender is not share aesthetics across cultures by necessity]
B)Utilitarian
Transgender people are delusional but the surgery allows them to live a better life without hurting anyone. It's their bodies, and even though I think changing gender is bullshit it's really not my business anyways. [Life and let live, though a subgroup of these people try to virtue signal about 'trans rights' without believing in the idea of 'trans', the justify it by saying it doesn't matter what they really believe.]
C) Transsexuals are degenerate and I must stop them
These people fap to traps and feel bad about it, afterwards they oppose SRS claiming they're looking out for the best interests of those opting for the surgeries. Really they're just trying to preserve a spook and enjoy being angry at things

All the people I've met irl who believe C are either evangelical Christians or have fapped to furry gay porn so I have a hard time respecting that position

it is a mental illness and some traps could experience that state of consciousness im sure considering how psychotic and high iq they are, and also autistic.

is ur pic a trap

What if I think transsexualism is degenerate but should be treated with empathy like any other mental illness and not scorned outright as in option C)

Then there is me, the one who is right.
>Mind over matter, but mind isn't perfect nor correct all the time
>Sex is biological, but biology has its errors (Down syndrome, siamese, intersex etc.)
>We have unknown amounts of unknown chemicals in circulation due to increased medication and industrialization and of course, birth control
>There is also the pattern of Mice Utopia...
>Cutting your genitals and getting your age wrong indicate a mental disorder, I think (hope) it is distinct from transgenderism

Please let's not make this a purely political debate. The question is specifically about BwO.

what's that matter to you
basically (b), compare it to phantom limb syndrome
nice meme, but what do you mean by 'getting your age wrong'

someone explain the body without organs to me

t brainlet

I say no, from what I can tell they focus heavily on organs. 2 spirited people are closer to it.

Now that I think about it, the movement from "traditional" transexuals to the more recent conception of genderfluidity is a perfect example of the progression the Baudrillard's sign-order.
Progressive sites such as tumblr have laid host to an emerging struggle between two groups which can be most broadly identified as trans, but are more accurately understood as composing two distinct classes, almost diametrically opposed in their perception of gender and identity.
There are transgenders as they are popularly understood: a person who identifies as the opposite gender, and wishes to alter their body and appearance in line with their adopted sex. However, this desire implicitly perpetuates and reinforces the notion of an antipodal gender dichotomy, which is increasingly regarded as oppressive in-of-itself.
The new school of transgenders do not see themselves as placed upon the wrong pole, but rather as though they do not fit within any established notion of gender whatsoever. In its lesser form, they may believe themselves to be suspended somewhere between two poles of a gender spectrum (not a dichotomy), but in it's more completely articulated form, they believe that there are no stable poles by which a range of identities can be established and demarcated in the first place.
This runs parallel to the sign-order:
1. The symbol is faithful to the signified :: cisgendered people
2. The symbol is a perversion of the signified :: traditional/dichotomous transgendered people
3. Pure simulation, where the symbol is divorced from any reality :: genderfluid.

If bodies without organs are understood to be the fluid substrata that underlies the reified artificialities of stable forms and maps, then perhaps genderfluid, rejecting both dichotomies and spectrums, have effectively deterritorialized their own sexual identities, embracing a sort of rhizomatic assemblage of pure and unbounded potentiality.

In a mental state exam not being orientated to person, place, or time indicated you have symptoms if mental illness.

Thanks

B for sure

Traps are cute and it's none of my business anyway

It's not.

web.archive.org/web/20160331140911/http://ropeculture.org/2016/03/01/the-fag-agenda/

Give this a read. Just do it.

The Catholic Church teaches us that sex and gender are identical, and granted to a person by God. Thus anyone who asserts that they, as a man, are actually a woman, or vice versa, are in effect putting their own will above God's will, essentially following Satan with his refusal to submit to God's authority.

Basically trannies are demonic.

>Sarah
Shiieeet I'd vote dis nigga pope

well, the 2nd post is the christian so the first poster should clear their browser history before their friends see the furaffinity cookies

>You don't like gays, you must be a closeted gay!
What is Natural Law?

Stop projecting your insecurities my man.

>arachnophobes want to fuck spiders.jpg

A very French post but a good one