Tfw you will never live in revolutionary catalonia

>tfw you will never live in revolutionary catalonia

Was this the pinnacle of human society until the fascists came and destroyed it all?

No

>The committee dictated rules that the militias coerced you into accepting but it was totally unhierarchical and voluntary!

Weren't they raping nuns in the streets and burning churches to the ground? Sounds like typical commie shit to me.

>literally not a single qt in sight

It was before Stalin's goons started shooting up the place and exiling all the democratic-socialists

Was this the pinnacle of human society until the fascists came and destroyed it all?

It was a social experiment that is impossible to evaluate asit only lasted 6 months and then under wartime conditions.

We look back on it with rose tinted glasses because it was crushed while still in the honeymoon revolutionary phase. Had it lasted longer it would have turned into a Stalinist purgeathon

Or being executed by the tens of thousands, with the female revolutionaries being raped by the Fascist troops.

This

Fucking tankie retards always ruin everything

>Anarchism will never, ever, ever happen

Was this the pinnacle of society until it wasn't?

No.

The early years of the republic were a blessing for Spain, despite the great depression and having a gdp per capita about the same as modern day Pakistan, they managed to overthrow a dictator and set up democratic institutions. However the revolutionaries just saw this as an opportunity to go nuts, raze churches and eventually revolt and murder people for no reason whatsoever.

Catalonia is in close proximity to France and had a more democracy oriented society, this is why Anarchist Catalonia seemed less messed up than the hardcore communists and fascists in poorer sections of the country. It was not due to pure ideology. Also it was their revolutionary nonsense that undermined democracy and hurt Spain's fortunes. Caballero was just another warlord and their most heartfelt beliefs were just spooks used to manipulate people.

probably because stalin was literally in control there. Like, red army troops on the ground purging CNT/FAI figures in control

u wot m8?

I hope you get shot and your revolutionary fiancee' gets BLACKED.

(just like what happened to those losers in your pic OP lol)

>pinnacle of human society
no, it just shows that any anarchist society is powerless against an order

Anarcho-communism still exists though, all you have to do is go to Somalia

did someone say traitors?

...

Somalia isnt anarchic at all, the states are pretty much in control of everything.

It's patronship based, more feudal really.

>have no state
>individuals form governmentships
>but it is the state that is exploiting the people by retaining the private property of the bourgeois!

>Have no state

What is Somaliland, Puntland, Khatuumo and Hiran?

>Individuals form govermentships

Lmao, you can't just form a government, they belong to clans and stuff.

>but it is the state that is exploiting the people by retaining the private property of the bourgeois!

What exactly do you mean by this?

>literally turning all cities into rubble
>gangs of marauders murdering nuns and burning down churches
>instead of the so-called unity, the various factions spent more time arguing whether they should call each other "officer" or "comrade" than actually beating the enemy
>in the end the leftists chimped out and started murdering one another while Franco just had to sit back, watch and laugh

Yeah if Mad Max or Fallout is "pinnacle of human society" then you're probably right.

There is no "state" there is individuals carrying out their will not a collection of bourgeois using state power to enforce their property over the prole.

Commies don't exist and are just mentally ill retards.

Just like today, leftist chicks are either plain or plain ugly.

>There is no "state" there is individuals carrying out their will not a collection of bourgeois using state power to enforce their property over the prole.

What does this have to do with what I was talking about? There are property rights in somalia, you know that don't you?

property rights defended by individuals not a state of capitalists.

>property rights defended by individuals not a state of capitalists

How do individuals in somalia defend their property rights when vigilantism is heavily punished here? You realize that there is absolutely no right to self defense here?

there is no one to enforce to take away the right of self defense.

There are police in Somalia.

Please KILL this fucking teenage meme

That would be like saying those Jordis were not the original Stalin's goons

>fascists

I think you mean stalinists

Their biggest mistake was trusting the liberals and tankies.