Was Revolutionary Catalonia the only true example of a working anarchist society until the fascists destroyed it?

Was Revolutionary Catalonia the only true example of a working anarchist society until the fascists destroyed it?

Still no, lad
Check in again next week

>3 years
>Adequate time to call a government, or lack of, working
Pick 1

>edgelords take over a province by their totally noncoercive free association of militias who will firing squad you for horrible crimes such as having a rosary in your house in heavily Catholic 30s Spain.
>get btfo within a few months not by fascists as you say but by your fellow commie "comrades" in the republican government actually because you're too annoying and stupid.
Wow it's fucking nothing.

No there still was a Republican goverment in their region and the CNT has to sacrafice an actual Anarcho-Syndaclist society for working thoghetter with Liberals and Communists wich eventually brought them to their downfall.

Looks like a potato.

Fascists never expect potato to shoot.

It was the Stalinists that ruined it, THEN the fascists showed up

>working
>got btfo in 3 years

Kek. Is this the leftist ideea of "working"?

>anarchist society

It was a state mate

How come aesthetically wise men looked more or less the same but women were butt ugly.

>until the fascists destroyed it?
t. Stalin

This

Stalin was all like

>OH HAI GUIZE WHAT'S GOING ON IN HERE?

>HOW BOUT I SEND SOME ADVISORS AND SPIES TO TURN YOUR COMMUNE INTO A JACKBOOTED COMMIE POLICE STATE?

>I'M NOT REALLY ASKING

>I'M GOING TO DO IT ANYWAY

they're proto sjws

Dios y Patria y Rey

They failed because they were Satanists and didn't support the one True King of Spain, Ave Maria.

Slander and lies.

Soviets and the Spanish Communist wanted to unite against the fascists threat but the anarchists rejected this. They teamed up with the infantile POUM (and Orwell) and alienated most of Catalonia and the countryside. The PCE were right to stamp out the revolt.

Spiteful anarchists like Cipriano Mera backed the Casado coup and turned the country over to Franco.

>not smashing down religion wherever it dares to appear
I bet you're a fan of burkinis too

>Don't you understand? The only way to defeat this plot to turn our country into a totalitarian dictatorship is by turning our country into a totalitarian dictatorship!
Standard communist logic

>It's never our fault! It's the capitalists/kulaks/poles/westerners/anarchists/Trotskyists
Tankies fuck off and kys please

>totalitarian

Nice buzzword. Literally the original "horseshoe theory" to conflate fascism and communism

t. Stalin

What do you mean fault? Revolutionary Catalonia was one big exercise in contradiction.

>I don't like it therefore it is untrue
yet more impeccable communist logic

what comes around goes around

The term “totalitarianism” is not a scientific term, but simply a tool. Its place in history was on the side of capitalism when it sought to find a way to equate the USSR with Nazi Germany.

Hannah Arendt's (who came up with the word) theory of “totalitarianism” has never measured up in the real world. There has never been a so-called “totalitarian” society. Hannah Arend has no understanding of how socialism and fascism work and grossly distorts them both. From the way she describes it, the Nazis and the Soviets should have been on the same side against the capitalist and liberal nations.

The concept is simply an invention of reactionary intellectuals in the NATO bloc.

>is not a scientific term

News flash: no political terms are scientific terms.

>we're not like the fascists because A BLOO BLOO BLOO

>Nazis and the Soviets should have been on the same side against the capitalist and liberal nations

They were more than happy to make an alliance to conquer Poland

My history is shaky but I don't remember the liberal western democracies conducting joint military operations with Nazi Germany

You're a boring memer.

First, the Soviets had tried to get the Polish government to participate in mutual defence efforts against Nazi aggression. The Polish government, being reactionary, itself fascist-inspired, and having ambitions on Soviet territory, refused. Second, the Nazis had intended to invade Poland with or without a non-aggression pact with the Soviets.

When the Nazis invaded the Polish government fled. The eastern portion of the country had been annexed to the Polish regime in 1920 and was inhabited by oppressed majorities of Ukrainians and Belorussians who had struggled since then for national liberation. Since the Polish government fled, the Nazis considered it permissible to move into these areas as well.The Soviets stopped them.

All they were "partitioning" was a part of Poland that was not actually Polish and which had been annexed to Poland twenty years earlier.