Should the world community have listened to the french, and completely dissolve all industrial capacities of Germany...

Should the world community have listened to the french, and completely dissolve all industrial capacities of Germany, and occupy and divide the country post WW1? It probably would have prevented WW2.

No

GOD want the world to be like this

GOD has plans,lets just wait for it

Well duh

For centuries, most peace treaties sought to obliterate the memory of war, a practice stretching back to the 1648 Treaty of Westphalia, which called for “perpetua oblivio et amnestia”, or “perpetual oblivion and amnesty” on both sides. It was only after the 1919 Treaty of Versailles assigned guilt to Germany for igniting the first world war, and demanded the arrest and trial of German officials, that the promise of oblivio et amnestia was abandoned.

Yes. Aryan """"culture"""" is nothing but warmongering and attempting to destroy everything of beauty. Instead of the Holocaust there should've been an Aryancaust. The Germanic (Aryan) race is nothing but an menace, a cancer that has been allowed to exist for fat too long.

Of course. The Germans are subhuman manbeasts, and Europe will never be at peace for as long as the unholy chimera known as "Germany" exists.

In theory, possibly, but that was never the case in practice.

"What I say to you, I say to everyone: 'Watch!'

Therefore you have no excuse, O man, every one of you who judges. For in passing judgment on another you condemn yourself, because you, the judge, practice the very same things."

Should Germany had completely dissolved all industrial capacities of France, occupy, and divide the country past the Franco-Prussian War?

The answer is: No. Everyone was at fault for the First World War the main instigators being Serbia and Austria. Both sides should've been more rational and working towards peace after destroying each other's empires.

T. American

I think think both the French and the Germans should have been dissolved as unified peoples

To be quite honest, both peoples should have been wiped from the face of the Earth.

Why didn't we dissolve UK instead? Biggest warmongers in history.

>main instigators being Serbia and Austria

Yeah, Austria really inspired those pre-existing mobilization plans of their allies. And Serbia REALLY deserves some blame for the actions of extremists.

>T. American
No need to clarify, we could tell by how utterly retarded your post was.

a course of action that drastic I would only leave for the Russians

*state-funded extremists
also every country has "pre-existing mobilization plans" especially when peace is fragile moron

>comparing modern mobilization plans to WW1-era mobilization plans
>implying "state-funded" is remotely accurate in describing the Black Hand

>Implying the serbian military wasnt arming terrorists

the Black Hand consisted of Serbian Army officers so it's pretty accurate in that sense
also what the hell do you mean by comparing mobilization plans? France and Russia were pretty much prepared for war as well

Impossible to answer this question with a definite yes or no. The number of variables and counterfactuals would take a supercomputer the size of the moon to crunch through.

So many different outcomes could have sprung from this decision. Perhaps all it would have done was delayed Hitler's rise by ten years as he rebuilt Germany's industrial base. If anything this would have just gotten the Germans more pissed at France.

Should the world community have listened to the Germans, and completely dissolve all industrial capacities of France, and occupy and divide the country post WW1? It probably would have prevented WW2.

Yeah, but we're talking about the Black Hand.

No, it's pretty inaccurate. That's like saying the USMC is responsible for the assassination of JFK. And WW1 mobilization plans were nigh impossible to stop once they started because of how the militaries prepared them.

Are you retarded?
Care to remind me what happened to Napoleon (a French oggicial) at the end of the Napoleonic Wars?

>Should Germany have completely [...] divided the country past the Franco-Prussian War?

If France had been a barely 50 years old country (like Germany was in 1918) in 1871, then why the fuck not?
France wasnt realistically disolvable by 1871, while Germany was by 1918

>implying Austria would have pulled even half the shit they did in that situation without Germany's carte blanche

Remind me who chimped out and attacked 4 countries in a row after Austria attacked Serbia?

they should have either dismantled G*rmany or slapped some meme concessions on them and forced them to array themselves against the Soviets
Wilson's "muh compromise" was a mistake

He got a pretty sweet deal before the 100 Days.

Should have dismantled the Jewish claw which swept across all the european countries

>completely dissolve all industrial capacities of Germany, and occupy and divide the country post WW1?
So, what, hand it to the Soviets?

Ww2 was becouse of the heavy economic sanctions impose by France, plus the french didn't do shit in WW1 they were losing but germans knew they were running out of resources so they decided to stop but butthurt frenchies wanted vengeance for being humiliated (again) so they punish Germany with irrational terms, too bad, if they were actually more rational, nazi germany would have never existed and we all be communist by now

>plus the french didn't do shit in WW1
They held 85% of the Western front by themselves you retard. Also the stock market crash had much more to do with the Nazi's rise than French economic sanctions ever did.

"Should" and "if" don't apply in history. It is what it is, not what it should be.
I'm getting tired of this alt history threads.

>the french didnt do shit in ww2
>fielded the 3rd largest force and was the most strongest by the end of it
>most of the largest battle not only in the war but in history was fought in it

bad english
no facts
loves frace
t.french

>have an entire war plan created around the fact that the russians are slow to mobilize
>if the russians mobilize the germans consider themselves screwed
>Russia mobilizes
>Germany chimps out

Europe was in peace for more than 50 years before Germany founded itself though.

In the end of the day all wars in Europe since then were about Germany trying to find its place in europe, and Russia trying to expand west.

>Europe was in peace for more than 50 years before Germany founded itself though.
Why do you lie on the internet?

>economic sanctions
Which were either lifted later or ignored by the germans

t. amanglotard