Anyone else /peakoil/? I've been following it for a while now, and I am having difficulty really imagining a world where progress and discovery is not at the center society. I understand why it would be more sustainable, but is such a world even desirable?
No fracking or nuclear shills please, only enlightened peakoilers allowed to respond
Every year they say "ZOMG WERE RUNNING OUT" and every year we find new reserves.
Scare tactics to instate a one world government, like climate change.
Zachary Torres
I used to follow theoildrum.com from about 2007 through its retirement in 2013. The physics and potential consequences of peak oil are sound, what gets the movement in trouble are the hard dates they try to claim for the global "peak" of oil production. Either way they're right that as oil increases in scarcity and demand, new resource wars will be fought and global instability will result. Arguably we've already seen the effect of peak oil on US foreign policy, or at least the fear of peak oil and how that influences the minds of policymakers.
Ayden Myers
...
Andrew Cox
It's basically malthusianism. It was wrong in the past, but at some point it will turn out to be right.
Eli Wright
it is a definite problem once you recognize how much more energy intensive fracking or tar-sand harvesting is compared to conventional drilling. it seems like we are close to getting to the point of decline, and I don't see anything being done about it
Austin Lee
>It's basically malthusianism Wat.
Benjamin Robinson
do you think you'd be able to live in a world where there is no progress, where we only work 4 hours a day and spend the rest of the time sitting around shooting the shit with our neighbors? This is what people like chris martenson or richard heinberg seem to be imagining.
Luke Bennett
True, the worst thing is politicians kicking the can down the road as long as supplies seem sufficient for the short term. If we had just implement the proposals in the Hirsch report back in 2005 we would be in a way better position to deal with the inevitable decline in global oil supply.
>"The peaking of world oil production presents the U.S. and the world with an unprecedented risk management problem. As peaking is approached, liquid fuel prices and price volatility will increase dramatically, and, without timely mitigation, the economic, social, and political costs will be unprecedented. Viable mitigation options exist on both the supply and demand sides, but to have substantial impact, they must be initiated more than a decade in advance of peaking."
We could have prevented this.
Liam Howard
I don't know about Martenson but Heinberg seems like an ecotopian with too optimistic of a view on human nature in the wake of a collapse situation. Ted K. did a pretty good takedown of that kind of thinking in the primitivism movement and I'm inclined to agree. Having said that, Heinberg's scenario would be preferable to the cancerous infinite growth in a finite world ideology we are forced to exist in right now.
Landon Roberts
it's nice to meet another peak-oiler, where does everyone hangout nowadays after the oil drum?
Brayden Morgan
It will unironically be a good thing. Libe*alism in all its forms will finally die. No way in hell is the current system sustainable in the long term.
Angel Hill
Honestly I stopped following the movement closely after theoildrum stopped posting new material. That also coincided with increased work and school responsibilities so I only infrequently would check out posts on Gail the Actuary's blog and look at articles on dieoff.org
One place I did check out pretty frequently is John Michael Greer's blog, thearchdruidreport.blogspot.com/ Which I just checked out again for the first time since early summer and apparently that has been shut down now too! Or at least moved, not sure if the old content has been reposted.
It does seem like the movement "peaked" (ha!) sometime around 2009-2011 and has been in decline ever since. I think energy related issues seem too stable right now and people (including myself to a degree) have become too complacent.
Also, living in California, the problems with water supply have become much more relevant to me than the issues of oil supply. Especially in the wake of increased fracking and natural gas production in the state.
Carson Long
>infinite growth oil will just gradually get expensive until it is replaced by alternatives
Mason Collins
Look at the panic when GDP is only 2% annually and tell me that a zero-growth economy is possible within the current economic and financial framework of the global economy. Economists have never had to deal with a zero or negative growth situation and none of their models know how to deal with it. Even Keynes' solution is to throw money at the economy until it gets back to a growth trajectory.
Nolan Bailey
More free time means more creatives will create more. I'd say we may see more if not the same amount of progress in that kind of world.
Michael Smith
I'm petroleum engineer / mining engineer. And i belive peak oil is a hoax made by drilling-oil cooperation to pump prices of good
Brayden Russell
Of goods
Sorry for my english
Joseph Jackson
Great contribution, thanks.
Henry Brooks
It's still happening regardless of what fracking shills say
Pic related even the oil companies know it's coming
Caleb Rodriguez
The low interest rates after the 2008 financial crisis have managed to keep the oil industry afloat, oil companies have been consuming massive amounts of debt to maintain production and many were barely even profitable when prices were $100 a barrel, since the crash in prices in 2014 oil companies have been hemorrhaging money but still refuse to go under, many theorize it's because they can get funding by selling junk bonds, investors keep buying the bonds because they yield 10% or whatever which is better than 2% or whenever you're going to get from government bonds, once there's another financial crisis and the oil industry can't get any funding then shit is going to hit the fan
Luis Robinson
I still read art berman's blog, our finite world, and james howard kunstler's blog, the comment sections are the best part
Ayden Bell
uhhh no. Oil is not limitless like planting food is. Malthus was wrong because he didn't forsee new agricultural techniques and the change to levels of below replacement birth in developed nations. Oil on the other hand is limited. And alternative sources will likely be then fall under the same "birth rate lower than replacement" type usage.
New agricultural techniques rely entirely on oil technology you nitiwit.
Aaron Stewart
Most 1st world countries are in tacit acceptance of 2-3% per annum growth, wtf are you on about?
>Economists have never had to deal with a zero or negative growth situation and none of their models know how to deal with it
Okay you're just uneducated, lol
Grayson Adams
Are you saying no alternatives will be established?
Jayden Cooper
>work in Canadian oil sands >all the major oil companies have abandoned Alberta >no new projects, some major projects are finishing up here soon and 10,000 workers will be laid off nowhere to go >economy is still shitty but has stabilized at least >my company is being kept afloat by a single company that still has money to spend >can't even get a pipeline approved
Does this have to do with the recent OPEC stuff where they are trying to drive the prices down to make more expensive oil operations shut down? Oklahoma has taken a hit from this aswell, our state government relies on oil revenue and our education system and state government in general are underfunded and the state government refuses to fix the budget problem because they're in love with the state oil companies.
Joseph Lee
What kind of economic courses have you been taking that state that a 0% growth rate is fine? without a growth in GDP, per capita GDP (one of the main indicators of living standards) inevitably falls in tandem with growing populations, so unless you're calling for the stagnation of all human life, and economies, in which case i know for a fact you hacen't done any economics in your life.
Bentley Lewis
>peak oil This meme again. The Permian Basin alone has a minimum of 500 years of oil in it.
"If Gilmer’s estimate is correct that the Permian Basin holds an additional half a trillion barrels of recoverable oil, that would be a 500-year supply of oil at the current production level, and at 2 trillion barrels, a 2,000 year supply! And if that’s an accurate forecast of Permian Basin reserves, Gilmer’s description of the Permian Basin as a “permanent, near infinite resource” makes perfect sense because the probability is pretty close to zero that we’ll be using fossil fuels even 100 years from now, much less 500 years or 2,000 years in the future."
Jason Martinez
Yes it started in 2014 with the collapse in oil prices, which was caused by US fracking rather than OPEC who just maintained steady production
We had a conservative government that was friendly to the oil industry, however they had a streak of corruption and incompetence and we basically saved no money from the oil boom, the economy went to shit and the NDP party(left wing) won the provincial elections, oil companies were worried about new regulations and on top of the expensive cost of operations in Alberta they decided to leave, it's good for Canadian oil companies I suppose because they got some sweet deals buying up their assets, but in the future it's going to be hard to expand production because they have less access to capital. I have a feeling oil companies will be crawling back due to the 5% depletion rates on conventional oil fields
Do basic research next time before boring me with econ 101 questions lol "none of their models know how to deal with it"
Asher Wood
>500 years i dont see how that negates peak oil
Christopher Phillips
>And if that’s an accurate forecast of Permian Basin reserves, Gilmer’s description of the Permian Basin as a “permanent, near infinite resource” makes perfect sense because the probability is pretty close to zero that we’ll be using fossil fuels even 100 years from now
lmao where do people find this garbage?
Hudson Wood
Not the "soft" version ("we will at some point run out"), but it negates the "hard" version ("we are rapidly running out and we need to start prepping").
Kayden Gray
>US energy independence
Where does this meme come from? They still need to import 50% of their oil, they're still the largest oil importer in the entire world.
Adam Scott
>every year we find new reserves
Modern reserve finds are minuscule compared to what they were discovering in the 1930's-1960's, they require extremely high oil prices to be profitable to extract, with the collapse in oil prices there hasn't even been any exploration or discoveries since 2015, in fact it's at the lowest amount in the history of the oil industry
>Conventional crude oil discoveries totaled just 2.4 billion barrels in 2016, versus the average of 9 billion barrels in the last 15 years, according to a new report from the IEA
9 billion barrels a year discovered on average, world consumption is 30 billion barrels a year, so every year we find only 4 months worth of oil and that was with high oil prices. Once the supermajor oil fields deplete(5% a year depletion rate) there's not going to be enough new discoveries to make up for it
Juan Kelly
It's a meme that people gobble up from politicians. Because logically, you would think that having more of a resource would directly benefit, and be dispersed to, the population. In reality, the resource just gets shipped out of the country.
Matthew Rogers
>but is such a world even desirable?
Of course it is. Right now thousands of semi-literate troglodytes are wasting actual tons of oil driving past my inner city apartment on a daily basis, just because they are unable to plan their lives further than the next meal, which is invariably either pizza or Chinese food, because of course they can't cook, and wouldn't if they could, because they are very busy and important people going to and from their wageslave jobs. These are the children of Ford and they exist only because of oil.
The absolute waste that our society encourages, because the amazing power that oil gives us is to be squandered to turn imbeciles into superconsumers and superbiollonaires, rather than get us off this godforsaken mental vacuum and spread our cancerous existence to the rest of space and time.
It won't really change anything, but at least with electric cars, there will be less noise and less cancer while I live out the rest of my life, made completely pointless by consumerist slavery, on this metaphorical desert island.
Connor Jones
...
Jaxon King
>my anecdote is better than your source kill yourself
Jordan Wood
is this really bumplocked?
Julian Walker
> Climate change deniers stating that oil will be around forever.
Gee I wonder (((who))) could be behind this website.
Dominic Phillips
I remember following this topic around 2005.
This has been debunked.
Bentley Sullivan
No? Testing.
Brody Lee
How much would loosing access to petrol affect our society outside of energy? I know that a large amount of our fertilizer uses petrol as a component, so how will the ag industry be affected? How important is petrol as a material to electronics and hardware? Would it affect our trajectory towards automation? Anything else I may be missing?
Grayson Morales
It's not that we find new reserves, its that known reserves that were a bitch to tap into are now being made economically worth it to try and get due to diminishing reserves. Nobody wanted them before because the cost of utilizing them wasn't worth it. Well now they are getting desperate. This is why fracking is such a big thing now.
Charles Scott
>How important is petrol as a material to electronics and hardware
Anything requiring petrochemicals would be affected, particularly plastics and rubber. So yeah, electronics and computing would be fucked in the event of a disruption in petroleum supplies.
Carter Wright
Retard here, why did the oil prices collapse if it's becoming increasingly rare?
Kevin Edwards
Market manipulation behind the scenes in order to eliminate new competition by pricing them out of oil and gas exploration. Once those competitors have failed, the established players raise prices again. Pretty standard business practice in industries with monopolistic characteristics.
How much sweet crude does America have. Is it enough to propel us to Norway and Dubai wages and if so when are they going to start using it?
Adam Murphy
>Conveniently peaks at year 2000
scaremongering ideologically motivated theory, into the trash it goes!
Hudson Brooks
>How much sweet crude does America have Not nearly as much as in the past.
>Is it enough to propel us to Norway and Dubai wages and if so when are they going to start using it?
No, that only works if you have so much oil you are a net exporter. All US production barely covers half of the demands of the domestic market. Since we still have to import shittons of oil, high wages won't result.
James Davis
Americans started fracking hard because the oil industry got access to low interest loans in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, they fracked too hard and there was too much supply, coincidentally oil prices started falling once the US federal reserve stopped QE in 2014
But the excess supply is close to being used up, and there's been no exploration since 2015 so oil prices will probably skyrocket sometime 2018-2020, also interest rates are going up and oil companies have massive debt burdens which will limit their future production expansion
Jaxson Garcia
I see. I guess I was under the impression that they hadn't tapped into all of it yet.
Lincoln Reed
So... stock up on gasoline? Buy a bike?
Jason Powell
>stock up on gasoline
Gasoline goes bad after a few months in storage, so that's a bad idea. A better one is to invest in oil futures while the prices is relatively low.
>Buy a bike?
Yes.
Henry Turner
Electric bikes have existed for several years now.
Austin Jenkins
bump
Dominic Lopez
The idea of society having material progress continually is fairly recent. For most of history people were perenial they just did what their dads did and would expect their sons to carry on what they did.
Since we are going to run out of resources it is better to switch back to this world view. The current world view of infinite material progress is un sustainable.
Jace Cox
>sent from my iPhone
Wyatt Fisher
>2005 : ZOMG PEAK OIL HAS ALREADY HAPPENED INDUSTRIAL SOCIETY BTFO PREPARE YOUR ANUSES >2017: oil supply continues to increase globally, prices are lower than a decade ago, economy is still growing *crickets from PO crowd*
It's been debunked, time to move on.
Austin Green
>So yeah, electronics and computing would be fucked in the event of a disruption in petroleum supplies.
Does this mean robots ain't going to be takin my job?
Jason Moore
I don't get it. The specific start has been debunked, but we are going to run out of oil at some point, aren't we?
Juan Martin
>Scare tactics to instate a one world government, like climate change.
Carter Murphy
kek
Nolan Cruz
>do you think you'd be able to live in a world where there is no progress, where we only work 4 hours a day and spend the rest of the time sitting around shooting the shit with our neighbors? This sounds like paradise desu
Grayson Hughes
Climate change and the associated wars and migrations will wreck our civilization long before we actually run out of oil, and hopefully me and anyone I care about will be dead before either of those things happen. I'm not holding out hope though.
Christopher Clark
"Peak Demand" has been written a lot about lately--the idea that demand for Oil is going to peak in the next few decades and start to fall well before current reserves are in jeopardy of being exhausted. Already we see fossil fuels like coal being phased out across the western world and China & India (the two countries whose FF demand is projected to increase the most) have embarked on some of the world's most ambitious alternative energy schemes--China is far and away the world's greatest producer of 'clean energy' and is trying to accelerate that trend.
Peak oil seems to be falling into the same pitfalls as Malthusianism.
Samuel Brooks
Bump for OPEC did nothing wrong
Dominic Hill
bump because I know nothing about oil
Asher Richardson
What a waste of quads.
You have a bucket of oil. It comes out of the ground like water. How much is it worth? How do you get people to pay more for the oil than for the water?
You tell them that the supply is running out, and the price will skyrocket in the near future.
It's worked for 100 years, and it will continue to work, so long as people think oil is "fossil fuel".
Protip: Oil is found at twice the depth of any fossil.
Twice.
Brody Diaz
They literally didn't though. In the energy business, its kill, or be killed.
Adrian Lopez
Coal can be made in several years with organic mats buried in dirt.
Eli Sullivan
Daily reminder that Matthew Simmons was killed to cover up the true extent of the 2010 BP oil spill.
>Simmons was found dead on August 8, 2010, in his hot tub.[21] An autopsy by the state medical examiner’s office the next day concluded that he died from accidental drowning with heart disease as a contributing factor.[22]
Jack Cox
Remember when you were told that the BP oil "disaster" would be consumed by the ocean without a trace?
Did you notice that actually happened?
Dylan Mitchell
Frack is whack!
David White
yeah, good luck creating a hadron collider in that free time of yours you stupid fuck
Mason Carter
>so long as people think oil is "fossil fuel" But it is. Do you really think that the name means people believe it's literally made out of fossils?
>Protip: Oil is found at twice the depth of any fossil. Twice. That's because it's made of algae which died long before organisms large enough to create fossils existed.
If you don't believe that it's made of dead ancient organisms, then what is crude oil made from in your expert opinion?
Carter Robinson
Peak phosphorus is the only relevant peak. If you are reading this, you will suffer the consequences of peak phosphorus.
Adam Murphy
What do they use phosphorous for and how important is it?
Ryder Sanchez
I misread the OP at first glance and thought it said "peak loli" and was really worried for a second then read it again and now I don't care.
Christopher Stewart
Just google it, n*****
Brayden Powell
Hell no the oil sand operations are down to $27/ barrel break even. They need high prices to expand AND pay out business as usual.
Are petrochemicals used in any electronic/computer parts outside of the plastic casings/structure? Is it used in the computer itself? I can't seem to find anything on google.
Isaiah Reed
>peak anything
Stupid. If price is allowed to be free we will never run out of oil or anything else.
Elijah Williams
Doesn't matter, even if they don't use petrochemicals directly the entire transportation network is powered by oil
In the modern globalized economy supply chains are extremely long and complex
Levi Morgan
>Doesn't matter, even if they don't use petrochemicals directly the entire transportation network is powered by oil Wouldn't this be mitigated or at least temporary when electric cars become more widely utilized?
Samuel Hall
Phosphates are key in fertilizers. A field with phosphates can outproduce a field without phosphates by up to 300% as much.
Robert Turner
That graph is a little misleading. US domestic oil production is at an all time high of about 10 million barrels a day.
Jacob King
It was clearly put there by God 6000 years ago. Not a fossil at all but rather Satan's bile bubbling up from the depths of hell.
Parker Rogers
Prove it. That's definitely false if you are looking at crude oil only, not including everything else.
James Ortiz
right, fair enough
Jace Garcia
did you notice the billions of dollars that was spent on the clean up and insurance costs?
David Flores
Nah it was mainly the microbes in the gulf. There was some dispersal agents put in but they may not have done much. The amount that was leaked was actually around the total amount that annually seeps naturally into the gulf.
Adam Johnson
>The amount that was leaked was actually around the total amount that annually seeps naturally into the gulf.
This is bullshit and you know it. If that were the case the gulf coast would constantly look like this.
Kayden Wright
Look it up. You won't believe anything I post so look it up. There is a huge amount of oil that seeps naturally.