Are the french proto-marxists

It didn't work so well in Indochina

Yes it is, but not the nice anglo nationalism, it is the french nationalisme, all is for the state and the nation, french is just a fascist democracy.

>French nationalism implies killing your own culture
True poetry

Well it work, they don't have serious indepandant party.

>it's about politcial parties
>they
>indepandant with a

>destroyed regional culture and language
Sure thing. It's not like if we don't spend millions to preserve local languages and patrimony.

>It's not like if we don't spend millions to preserve local languages and patrimony.
There would be no need to do that if they weren't destroyed in the first place

You do not want to fuck with the Vietnamese mon user.

But they weren't destroyed... wtf are you talking about?

I'm sure there will be billions crying over the loss of the Arpitan, Picarde or Provencale. This is what happens when a country centralises, dialects disappear. Do you think English did not have dialects? Or there weren't literally dozens in Italy?

There was no French culture before revolution.

>there was no culture before the revolution
Yup - Proto-Marxist

Only what, 25-30% of the population actually spoke French at the time. You can't be a global empire if you have 20 dialects each fighting for supremacy.

No you stupid fuck. There was no unified French culture. There were regional identities like the Breton, Occitan or Burgundian. The only thing "French" in the whole country was the king and the institution of kingdom itself.

>a Revolution creates culture
no insult will change the fact that such a thought can be considered Proto-Marxist

What does Marxist even mean to you? It's an economic theory it has nothing to do with language

Stop taking the bait dumbass

The Revolution created a nation. A nation wiped out all regional identities and imposed a single one.
You are a retard throwing buzzwords around, go away.
>Only what, 25-30% of the population actually spoke French at the time
Literally just ile de France.

>a nation is created by a single act
>a nation has to be a nation state
>a nation has to be absultely monolithic

Frogs are quite retarded
Aslmost as bad as arguing wih a commie but then again they are all the same

It has to be monolithic if it wants to survive. Look at cuck states like the UK and Spain. If they had enforced a singular monoculture they'd be fine, but now that they're cucked they're suffering tons of internal issues.

"""cucked"""
what does this even mean anymore

>France
>calling anyone cucked

Your nation is
>cucked by the eu as a junior partner seen to retarded to be seen as on par with Netherlands
>cucked by Africa letting in hords to fuck up your capital city to an estimated 15% and massively devaluing property
>cucked by commies having unions causing the french economy to be uncompetitive
>cucked by the uk the french president has to do rallys in London due to the amount of wealthy Frenchmen that move here since France is such a shithole

If you had wiped out the Irish, Scots and Welsh you wouldn't be facing total collapse of your union.

JUST

>a nation has to be a nation state

>I'm underage and have no understanding of geopolitics

Fuck off back to pol

Like I said, it should be if it wants to survive. UK and US are artificial constructs because they didn't enforce the dominant culture on everyone.

What? It worked well for the French, no one complained. Germs also had their Kulturkampf, it's just the divisive Anglos facing 90000000 million independence movements that they never tried to crush.

>Germs also had their Kulturkampf
You shouldn't cite that as a success, it failed on every level

>no one complained
>Kulturkampf was a success
just no man

You're talking about geopolitics. No one stopped them. They were Chad Nations that did as they pleased, and now have not a single relevant independence party.

>uses chad unironicly

You might be autistic senpai

Are you an idiot? Serious question, Bavaria is probably the most influential state in any German election and has far more autonomy than the rest of Germany

Cringe.

What about France? Can't cite a single one huh? BTFO.

>talking about geopolitics
what does the post even mean, seriously please enlighten me
also:
>it's about parties

Why would I cite French shit when you decided to bring up the kulturkampf as a success story? Nice moving goalposts you fucking dipshit

You brought it up first. As for parties, it's pretty important not to have independence movements if you want a collective and stable nation. Unless you're an ancap retard, in which case fuck off back to /pol/ yourself.

Because I used both as an example?

>Because I used both as an example?
But why? Bavaria basically ruins your narrative, why the fuck would you even mention it?

not me friendo

Bavaria yes, but there was no Hanoverian identity anymore for example. It wasn't a complete and total success, but a lot of the more minor kingdoms were completely wiped out. If Prussia had survived longer as an entity instead of ending after WW2, guarantee you Bavarian identity would've been destroyed.

>has a long history of collectivism
Yes, they do, older than early protestant ''reformers''(the 12th century saw many communist sects in France). However social liberal revolution was invented in england and later perfected by germans.
The roots of the french revolution can be found in John Wycliffe

>thread starts with me calling France a proto marxist shithole
>you agree

Why are we arguing?

I have nothing against social liberation
At allowed the uk to be majority literate in the 1600s

>guarantee you Bavarian identity would've been destroyed.
Well yes if the Nazis went all out on it like they planned certainly it would have died at least in public life

you are wrong Mr Frog

>At allowed the uk to be majority literate in the 1600s
and they produced nothing of value. It's better to have a society with a small elite of very intelligent people than a mass of idiots who brag about being able to read the bible and newspaper

>mr
You mean master?

why would i?

Hahahahahahahahahah

It implies the poster is underage

Quick reminder that Germany has no pre-ww2 regional culture left. Only East and West.

Collectivism is only bad to ancap retards. Enjoy your collapsing union England lmfao.

So, yes, we agree.

>The Chad Ampelmännchen
>The Virgin Ampelmännchen
But which is which?

Hamburg?
Bavaria?

both social reformers and motel whores use laugh as an argument.
According to your logic the social revolutions were good because the trash of society learned how to read and write
As if it improved their lives in anything other than being able to work at retail

Forgot pic

My only understanding of economics is from what /pol/ told em

with their iphone, fast food and cheap dress they surely are making worth all revolutions whose goal was to ''free'' society from the evils of monarchy and church

"At least I'm not considered an extremist on facebook and twitter" - the climax of western society

No, it's all generic Rhinelander or "poor bydlo" german.

Modern commercialism is cancer but monarchism is just as retarded.

Are the german proto-marxists

>has a long history of collectivism
>chimped out going to war with the whole continent
>treats it's people as disposable "I spend 40000 men a month"
>history of flirting with socalism "refugees should benefit from our wellfare !"
>very large non white population(slavs, afro-deutsch, refugees, and turks)
>smelly (saussage, garlic, cabbage, and so on)
>gave birth to socialism
>gave birth to national-socialism
>gave birth to scientific socialism aka communism
>gave birth to cultural marxism

I think Germans are just autistic

>gave birth to socialism
It was the british though. Not that germans are any better than the french
Both are the trash of europe