Why did France get a reputation as being incompetent at war when fucking Italians exist?

Why did France get a reputation as being incompetent at war when fucking Italians exist?

Other urls found in this thread:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suez_Crisis#French_response
rarehistoricalphotos.com/weeping-frenchman-1940/
fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bataille_de_Menton#Le_combat_de_Pont-Saint-Louis
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

The only people who believe France is incompetent at war are amerimutts who are still ass-flustered about Iraq

They don't have a reputation for incompetence, they have a reputation as being cowards.

No man, the French really messed up last century.

It´s a deception move by Germany and Austria.

France was the dominant military power of Europe for centuries, then they got humiliated a couple of times so the meme got turned upside down.

It's like how Dark Ages were so overstated that people started counterjerking in the other direction so now you have genuine retards smugly talking about how the Dark Ages never happened at all.

because the only proof for the battle of pont saint-louis happening was a french propagandistic journal published in 1943,and because of that the article got removed on wikipedia,altough the french copy still exists

Was he the "DO IT AGAIN BOMBER HARRIS" of the Italian military in WW1?

Because people (including you OP, it seems) learn about history via memes and not research

>Messed up WW2
>Maybe Algeria?
>Vietnam

Thats it.

Only half-nigger amerimutts and anglomutts believe this and considering French founded both of their shithole they should be humble.

Because a cartoon character said so.

Plus there's not a huge population of easily offended Frenchmen in the US.

France died with napoleon and they havent accomplished anything since then

>t. amerimutt

The Italians never made the leclerc

>Plus there's not a huge population of easily offended Frenchmen in the US.

I'm going to assume the myth didn't spread to Canada. Also Canada was the place were a war with the French actually took place so perhaps Canadian British kept some sort of respect for their former enemies.
Also
>US never fought a war with France and were even allies at some point.
Negative myths about French military prowess
>US fought two wars against Germany
Positive myths about German military prowess

It might have to do with how some may tend to exaggerate the qualities of the enemies.

Italy has been an irrelevant shitpit for centuries
Modern Italians are literally living amongst the ruinous vestiges of more glorious predecessors, like sub-Roman Britons or Ottomans
Maybe at some point in the next half-millennium an Italian will do something relevant once again

>Italy has been an irrelevant shitpit for centuries
>Maybe at some point in the next half-millennium an Italian will do something relevant once again
Eighth largest exporter in the world, 8th greatest nominal GDP, part of G7, founding member of G7, G20, OECD, EU and shit, 13th commercial shipping fleet worldwide.
Must suck to be that irrelevant.

americans also lost nam and ww2 was mostly because of ww1. the brits would have been beaten just as hard if it wasn't for their moat

The Simpsons

>RRRRRREEEEEEEEEEEEE IDS DA AMURIKANZ ;'((((((((
Calm down you assblated frog

Bullying the Italian military is like making fun of a cripple, there were little to no expectations of them. France is a world power that performed well below its weight in WW2

...

>It might have to do with how some may tend to exaggerate the qualities of the enemies.
What are the other examples of this? I know Anglos love to do that
>muh Zulu, can run 50 miles per day, it's totally fair that modern army lost to primitives
>muh Rommel, our failures were totally not about our army incompetence, they were because of the genius of enemy general!

Because of 1940, Diem ben Phu, and Iraq.

CHEESE
EATING
SURRENDER
MONKEYS

No credible information exists for this so-called "battle".

they still got btfo a bunch of other times.

Stop bullying Italy. Inept countries can't wage wars with several million soldiers and win with roughly even losses. If the Italian Front of WW1 was its own war then in terms of soldiers deployed it'd be like the fourth largest in all of history.

>top two Italian commanders were both named luigi

JUST

Again this meme battle that pops up every once in a while? It never happened you guillable idiot

Piles of garbage lying on the streets, thousands of niggers everywhere and people cleraly dont take a bath too often

>and people clearly don't take a bath too often
But they iterally invented the bidet and are the only ones who regularly use it

Is it only the south where they've got African scum or is it the north too? Am going to Europe this year but might just stick to the north.

Most immigrants are in the north for obvious reasons.

Americans because our education is pretty shoddy. We instead base things on petty and frivolous things. Its why jocks and cheerleaders are considered "top careers" instead being a scientists or an educator.

Luigi "Leave the Italians to me" Cadorna

>Calm down you assblated frog

>Piles of garbage lying on the streets, thousands of niggers everywhere and people cleraly dont take a bath too often
Yes, I know the US are also in those ranking, but we're talking about Italy right know.

Everynone tended to do that honestly. Good old Gaius Julius did the same to the Belgium gauls.

>Got rekt by krauts in WWI until Britain stepped in
>Got rekt by Turks right after
>Got rekt again by krauts in WWII until Britain and America liberated them
>Got rekt by gooks in Indochina
>Got rekt by kangz in Suez
>Got rekt by niggers across Africa
>Got rekt by Arabs in Algeria
>Got rekt by peaceful refugees in their own country
France is a mess

You mean win when the Austro-Hungarians finally started crumbling under the burden of fighting a 3 front war for several years while under a blockade that was pushing them to the breaking point.

You meand after being kicked by Serbs, Russians and finally Italians?

France won WW1, the Turks weren't worth it, France had a catastrophic disaster in 1940 just like everyone else on the Allied side, it lasted as long as the Americans did in Indochina, it won militarily in Suez, it never has lost any wars in Africa, it won militarily against the Arabs

Yes that's what a three front war is. Throw in some Romanians and Montenegrins and you have basically the whole mix.

jaaaa, what ever. Now shut the fuck up your lose baguetter, and remember to raise the Freaking white flag

Jaaa, freaking Frog Leg eating sucker

Why does France have a reputation for cowardice when Denmark exists?

>f-france won WW2

t. De Gaulle

probably because its expected that a small country would surrender rather than getting themselves completely destroyed and all killed

unlike the french who would have been able to at least prolong the defeat if they actually bothered and counterattacked instead of retreating and filibustering

>France won WW1
Lol. Britain and America won WW1

>peaceful refugees

...

That's the smart choice though. There's no way in hell Denmark could've stood against the Nazis on their own. At least Belgium and the Netherlands could reasonably expect France and Britain to support them and send soldiers

>>Got rekt by krauts in WWI until Britain stepped in
Nope we with the Russians single-handedly curshed the Austro-Germans

Cowardly english lost battle after battle, it was such a shameful sight that they weren't allowed to fight without French watching over so to be sure that they didn't lose anymore of them.

>Got rekt by Turks right after
In which timeline ?

>Got rekt again by krauts in WWII until Britain and America liberated them
Losing war even happen to the best(the French)

>Got rekt by gooks in Indochina
We colonized them for centuries, and our country was devastated, so we had no ressources to crush their rebellion

>Got rekt by kangz in Suez
LMAO

That's the english

>Got rekt by niggers across Africa
never happened

>Got rekt by Arabs in Algeria
Never happened

We rekt them at the battle of algiers

>Got rekt by peaceful refugees in their own country
Not really

english children have indeed their assholes rekt by Pakis tho

>Nope we with the Russians single-handedly curshed the Austro-Germans
>Cowardly english lost battle after battle, it was such a shameful sight that they weren't allowed to fight without French watching over so to be sure that they didn't lose anymore of them.
Actual high quality shitpost

Learn to read.

But that's what you are, nigel

A bunch of cowards whose only tactic consist to flee and hide on your island

I feel bad for the French. They fucking mobilized 67% of their adult male population from ages 18-40 in WW1 and were constantly bombed, yet people still remember them for WW2.

WW1 was won with British ships and French and Slavic blood

Lmao, get fucking real, Pierre. Great Britain won that war and Russia and France would've gotten absolutely rekt by the jerries if the Empire didn't stand with them

>Nope we with the Russians single-handedly curshed the Austro-Germans
>curshed
Is that French for "losing literally every worthwhile part of your country to the Germans"?

>Cowardly english lost battle after battle
Glad to see you're still grateful for us saving your arse on every front, Pierre.

>In which timeline ?
This one.

>Losing war even happen to the best(the French)
In six weeks, and with your entire border with Germany covered with impregnable fortification?

>We colonized them for centuries
More like 60 years lmao
At least Britain held on to India for a century

>That's the english
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suez_Crisis#French_response

>never happened
That's some denial you got there Pierre

>Never happened, We rekt them at the battle of algiers
You lost the war, in case you forgot.

>Not really
Enjoy your truck of peace Pierre

its well documented, even wikipedia has it. They just merged the article with the overall Italian invasion of France you mongoloid

>inb4 cadorna memes

>Germans finally decide to go on the offensive
>front nearly collapses and they manage push through

>britain and america won ww1

The stereotype extends farther than just memes on the internet. It's largely due to post WWI battles and British propaganda. But by all means stick your head in your ass it's all you're good for anyway.

This, everyone with a brain larger than a peanut knows it was Austria-Hungary who won the war for Entente.

Frenchfag here, I'd say it's more about the perception of states and what "France" and "Italy" can mean. France's been made an united state with a somewhat structured army in the late 15th century, and has been more influential (as a body of power) in european politics than Italy. Italy was unified in the 1880's, and thus has had less occasion to behave as a state at war since (except for these two unfortunate events that are ww1 and ww2).

But the italian city states and sovereign provinces have a glorious history of fighting, from the Genoan crossbowmen to the Condotierri, Italia definitely has a strong military culture (and check that old renaissance sport, Calcio Fiorentino, played with a heavy leather ball and a lot of grappling. Much more violent than modern soccer).

I'd say France and Italy have been the relative "victims" of the last conflicts they've been engaged in (world wars and the numerous colonial theatres), not being able to realistically change the outcome of these wars. (No colonial war of independance was ever won by a european power, and their influence in WW2 was limited, may it be by a lack of economic, diplomatic or military means)

But overall, I'd say both countries have shown positive examples on the field, and that the matter is in fact much more related to other factors, organisation, logistics, political will, than military might alone.

/thread
Also because France almost got btfo in the first weeks of ww1, got btfo in a month in franco-prussian war, and got btfo in 6 weeks in 1940

>Not Guadalajara
Of course, that battle displays both Italian and French incompetence.

I am sympathetic to France because during ww1 they nearly lost all there young men so after that they were risk averse to going to war again. And im american

>and are the only ones who regularly use it
Argentina has something to tell you

face it, clement, half of france capitulated and the other sided with your conquerors
the anglo tried to help you and made a tactical retreat
interesting how it's shameful to retreat across the channel, but not to retreat halfway across france
does crossing water somehow make it worse?
fucking gallic cunts

rarehistoricalphotos.com/weeping-frenchman-1940/

It's insidious propaganda perpetuated by the Eternal Pastanigger

>linking to an image
>on a fucking imageboard

The text is the thing to read. Why would i post the same image huh?
It is always good to know the story of a picture

Missing the Franco-Prussian war that's really the start of the bad record for france.

kys

Germany uniting and industrializing really fucked them up

This is not even some made up shitpost they really fucked up on every front that wasn`t Luigi deciding losing 2 soldiers for everyone of the enemys is a good strategy

Serbs/Montenegrins/Romanians didn't do shit.

...

because the french were trained, equipped and prepared for war whereas the italians weren't

second post best post

He was a secret Algerian agent sent to exterminate Sh*talians

France was nigh unstoppable until 1815 and then completely shit afterwards
>French-Mexican wars
>Franco-Prussian war, an entire army of 300,000 men gets captured along with the Emperor notwithstanding numerous defeats in battle and lost sieges
>all of their wars in the 20th century which are self explanatory

the only major war to my knowledge that France did well in since Waterloo was the Crimean one, where they contributed the bulk of the allied forces but lost 140,000 men and made marginal gains aside from propping up the sick man of Europe for another decade or two.

France also got wrecked by Prussia too though, whereas Austria right before had to snap defeat from the jaws of victory with some super retarded generalship to avoid totally annhilating the Prussian army.

Argentina is an Italian colony

germany did not actually do very much right in WW2. frogs just fucked everything up horribly.

the fall of france may be the luckiest moment in human history

Why is it so hard for people to get the difference between the adjective and the noun, Belgian / Belgium

You know that wikipedia article doesn't actually exist, right?

It got deleted.
fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bataille_de_Menton#Le_combat_de_Pont-Saint-Louis

>t. Frog

italy still won more WW than germany

The French used to be god-tier at war, so when they got BTFO in 40 days in WW2, it felt like a shock

Italy on the other hand had always been shit at war, so no one expected much

Italy isn't relevant, even as a punching bag.

if you don't count big cities,south italy is top tier on everything