Roman Empire

Why do "Veeky Forumstorians" deny the fact that Italy is the successor of Rome? Is it just dumb Snowniggers and Turks or are people really that stupid?

Because it isn't.
The real heir to the Roman Empire is the papacy.

Most normal people I talk to who barely know about history automatically assume that.

However Veeky Forums is full of edgy contrarians, and triggering M*ds is fun,

Italy is full of lombard, ostrogoth, frankish, norman, spanish and arabic rape babies.

It's a shitty, corrupt state, founded on the ideas of 19th century nationalism.

It has fuck all to do with Rome, bar geography.

MORE ROMAN THAN YOU ODOACER

this desu

>X IS IN THE SAME PLACE AS Y
>ERGO X IS TOTALLY Y

No.
Stop.
Get help.

are you guys retarded? Did the original Romans all get abducted by aliens? No? Then the people who lived in Rome (modern-day Italians) still live there, which makes them the successors of the Romans.

No, they just got raped by the and don't exist anymore.

>What is population movements
>What is Ostrogoth invasion
>What is Lombard invasions
>What is Frankish invasions
>What is German invasions
>What is Norman invasions
>What is Greek occupations

nignog, what?

Romans aren't a genetic thing. It's citizenship. Went from 'People who founded the city of Rome' genetically, then got granted to the city states they absorbed. Then later to everyone.

No Roman state exists, so no romans exist anymore.

>t.amerimutt that doesn't know what Romans were

fucking nigger faggot. The ITALIANS were the ones who founded Rome and then conquered the subhumans. Sure they gave citizenship to some Germs and such but genetically Rome was Italian.

Italians.

Guess the Holy Romans also weren't actually German?

It wasn't one big racial utopia like you're making it sound though.

Latians were an italic tribe. Not all Italians were Latins (later Romans).
Heck, the south of Italy was settled by the Greeks. It was greek till the late medieval period.

Racial utopia? Nah.
But not a 'Romans are a genetic group'. 'specially not post Kingdom. More a cultural group that moves into being a blanket term to citizens.

>t.angrypastaman

Roman Kingdom
>Latin italics
Roman republic
>Latin Italics, slowly integrating other italic groups
Early Roman empire
>Italians, slowly integrating gauls/greeks/etc (elites getting citizenship/senators)
Late Roman Empire
>Everyone gets to become a citizen
Medieval Roman Empire
>We're ethnically greek, but legally Roman
Holy Roman Empire
>Franks and Germans cosplaying

ironically the only correct answer

this meme again

Ok i want to ask everyone here: how much you know about Roman history? because for me, they're exactly the same belligerent, loud, sleazy people they were back then. Romans were just fucking Italians with strange tastes in food, most of them dumb as fuck plebs obsessed with sports and gossip, most of them lazy and working half the day then napping and slacking in the afternoon at the baths, most of them not giving a fuck about laws and constantly having petty disputes, most of them simple and with tacky, horrid tastes, most of them being annoying bickering retards. That's what Romans were.

And they weren't some mythical noble race lost to the ages, they didn't succeed over others because they had traits you associate with success today like being stern, steadfast and introvert like the anglos or germans, they just were what they were and that worked out because of a few extremely gifted, visionary and tenacious individuals who roused their passionate nature into achieving extraordinary goals.

>most of them dumb as fuck plebs obsessed with sports and gossip, most of them lazy and working half the day then napping and slacking in the afternoon at the baths, most of them not giving a fuck about laws and constantly having petty disputes, most of them simple and with tacky, horrid tastes, most of them being annoying bickering retards

So pretty much most of humanity?
Also
>genetic national traits exist ('steadfast and introvert like the anglos')
>implying these aren't just cultural values from the social elites that non-natives take as fact

Rome fell in the 400s/1400s, depending on what half you prefer.

Italy wasn't founded as a unified nation until the 19th century. Hardly a successor state.

>So pretty much most of humanity?

no, these are traits which define the character of this group of people, you wouldn't call Germans loud and lazy, that's an Italian thing.

>genetic national traits exist ('steadfast and introvert like the anglos')

the only argument people muster to say Italians today aren't descendent from ancient Romans is that they aren't a glorious dominant empire, but genetically, culturally and geographically, that holds no water. Genetically, these populations have remained mostly static and the invasions from other peoples have all been insignificant in their impact, Culturally, the Italians of old share the most common traits with them independently of their world relevance, and geographically, the old empire's heartland, the Italian peninsula, is still a unified self-governing entity. It succeeds Rome, perhaps not what it accomplished, but it's no use ignoring that it's there.

>anons confusing cultural stereotypes with genetical/racial tropes
>Italians acting like they aren't lombard rape babies

>Implying you can conclysively define either

Cultural = People can be raised this way. It is due to nurture.
Genetic = They are born to act this way, it's nature.

Kidnap a load of italians newborns and raise them in Germany as Germans? They'll act like their peers.

Now define "stereotype" vs "trope"

>I, a half Afghan half European male born and raised in North Florida, can claim the heritage of the North American Timucua peoples

Genetic/racial tropes = Refering to the debunked idea of different ethical groups being separate races with pre-determined strengths/weaknesses (e.g. the 'all italians are always lazy/blacks are stupid' etc etc)

Cultural stereotype = A behaviour or practise from some members of a cultural group that people outside the group exaggerate (e.g. All Irish are drunks).

In this thread, the previous user was suggesting that Italians and Romans are genetically identical, due to an claimed shared racial tropes between them (' dumb as fuck plebs obsessed with sports and gossip, most of them lazy and working half the day then napping and slacking in the afternoon at the baths, most of them not giving a fuck about laws and constantly having petty disputes, most of them simple and with tacky, horrid tastes, most of them being annoying bickering retards' )

Modern Italy is a meme state created in the 19th century destined to fall apart within our lifetimes.

Based user, comin thru wit de facts

True, nordic Italians would be better off without Sicilian niggers anyway.

>and the invasions from other peoples have all been insignificant in their impact
Didn't a huge portion of the Italian Peninsula's population die during the wars following the Byzantine invasion?

Plague and war ruined it.