Culture of Critique

Ok boys I just read this book and I need to know if it's legit or not. Some of the claims are hard to accept but it seems to be backed up with a decent amount of evidence. What do you guys think? Bullshit or legit?

Not just good scholarship but obligatory reading .

All of the people who claim MacDonald is a fraud resort to ad hominem, so I'd say he's spot on. It really takes all three books to get a proper picture on the Jewish psyche and how it developed, though. CoC is the culmination.

>All of the people who claim MacDonald is a fraud resort to ad hominem,

Indeed. I never saw a refutation of his arguments.

>Mark Potok of the Southern Poverty Law Center has said of MacDonald that "he put the anti-Semitism under the guise of scholarly work... Kevin MacDonald’s work is nothing but gussied-up anti-Semitism. At base it says that Jews are out to get us through their agenda... His work is bandied about by just about every neo-Nazi group in America."

>The Anti-Defamation League has included MacDonald in its list of American extremists, Extremism in America, and has written a report[19] on MacDonald's views and ties. According to the ADL, MacDonald's views on Jews mimic those of anti-Semites from the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

S E E T H I N G

It's complete nonsense. MacDonald claims that Judaism is a group evolutionary strategy that is aimed at promoting some sort of insularity and continuity of bloodline. He falls flat on his face if he bothered to look at what intermarriage rates are in every country that doesn't impose restrictions (from the outside) on such things. It's been going on since at least the time of the Roman Republic, if the Jewish catacombs underneath Rome, with all their syncretic religious imagery, and the mix of Greek, Roman, and traditionally Jewish names are anything to go by.

He further asserts that policies that Jews tend to back are demonstrative proofs of a Jewish group survival strategy, based on evolutionary psychology. He never seems to deal with the problem that Jews are a rather widespread group these days from an evolutionary perspective, with different diasporic communities having more genetic sharing with their host countries than each other. And that relatively small ethnic groups akin to the Jews have no shortage of times when they've torn themselves to little pieces. See any given Chinese civil war, Russian-Ukranian ethnic hatred, the 30 years war, Anglican religious conflicts, or what the Mexicans did to each other before the Spanish showed up to stop the fun.

>le nordics are cucks because biology meme
Bullshit. Why is it throughout Nordic history they never had a problem terrorizing Latins, terrorizing Catholics. terrorizing Polish people and Russians to an extent barbarous even by the standards of the era as well as being among the most hostile to foreigners in general ?Lets face it. Nordics are cucks because they are barbarians. Any time, any place, they'll find the most barbaric position and stick to it.

Wat

A critique of jareds opinion on why nordics are internationalist cuckolds today. He thinks it's innate biology, I disagree. Nordics are just as racially collectivist of Jews throughout history, and facts vindicate this. only recently do nordics take this internationalist stance and that's only because they are barbarians who seek to destroy European ( Greco-Roman) civilization at every turn.

The SPLC and ADL are terrorist organizations.