A place for discussing all things vegan ethics, politics & health
Meat consumption is ruining the environment. - Pollutes rivers - Forests cleared for livestock - Causes soil degradation - Massive inefficiency - Major contributor to global warming.
The most common and well known argument is the argument from marginal cases. Loosely speaking, the argument contends that animals as sentient as retards should have the same moral status
Morality is relative - Science, logic, mathematics are all based on axioms that are not proven, what is different about morality and moral axioms? Think this argument through before arguing for it, it is not as simple as you think. (most philosophers are moral realists and believe moral propositions can in fact be true)
Meatcucks please realise the difference between normative ethics (what we ought to do) and descriptive ethics (what beliefs do people have). Normative ethics is what is being discussed with regards to veganism and morality.
e.g. - people should not eat animals for x reason (relevant normative claim) - people eat animals for y reason (irrelevant descriptive claim)
Hey, im a meat eater, but one day i'd like to go vegan.
My problem is:
>The price of food while still maintaining a 3000 calorie diet and hitting all the macros i need.
Im a uni student. If i was in a full time job, i'd do it in a heartbeat, though. Thoughts?
Camden Campbell
Why is she so perfect guys?
Also, as a university student how do I maintain a vegan diet. I live in a traditional dorm leaving me to eating what the school is serving which at most aren't vegan. Anything cheap and easy I can prepare and snacks will be great.
Ayden Powell
Beans, rice, lentils, bread, pasta, and vegetables aren't expensive.
Dominic Brooks
This is true, but hitting a 3000 calorie diet while eating vegan food would require many huge meals a day, yeah?
Jonathan Thomas
Banana's in morning. Scary how much calories those guys have. Also, peanut butter. Not necessarily. A Banana, oatmeal, peanut butter shake in the morning is about 800 calories. Adding a little bit of protein powder can help greatly.
Justin Richardson
Hitting 3000 calories should require huge meals regardless of diet unless you're eating garbage like cake.
However, it is true that vegan foods aren't as protein dense as food like chicken breast, but you still shouldn't have problems hitting your macros as long as they're reasonable.
Ian Reed
I've wanted to go on a plant based diet for a long while it's just that I've been brainwashed by the protein recommendations and while I know that you can eat some powders or shitload of tofu I'm not necessarily hyped about that. I'm gonna try to get more plant protein sources in and move away from meat step by step. I'm not a scientist but AFAIK there are no studies matching for food quality and vitamins/minerals while measuring protein recommendations and my common sense tells me we might be getting roused. Anyways wish me luck friends!
Nicholas Phillips
Rice, lentils, black beans, and quinoa are all godsent quinoa is p exspensive tho but everything else is relatively cheap
Gabriel Anderson
lentils pack huge amounts of protein and adding greens like kale and spinach will help as well
Parker Morgan
If you ever need to achieve more carbs, protein, micros, etc. Just look up "vegan solution for 'x' ". You'll find it. Be sure to get all your vitamins and minerals you need.
Cooper Sanders
While you're on a meal plan diet it's pretty impossible to get the right nutrients with no meat. My schools food sucks ass and their veg options are trash.
Oliver Jenkins
Like others have said, finding the right nutrients without meat really isnt that hard. Start slow with eating less meat, maybe only 3x a week then 2x, etc. Soon you might realize you don't miss meat at all. Plants are packed with protien and vitamims as well.
Good luck!
Jose Young
Thanks, user!
Joseph Wood
>Vegan thread without any meatcucks whining Wow, this is really nice, I’m glad.
Aiden Evans
If you actually think being a vegan is good for the earth you are retarded indeed. There are seasons and you can't effectively grow enough shit to feed the entirety of Europe through the winter with only plants. You need massive shipping from places like Peru, Chile and so on. Eat meat. Grow your own food.
Elijah Wright
>A place for discussing all things vegan ethics, politics & health How about you fuck off retard? This is Veeky Forums, not /lgbt/
Camden Nguyen
But somehow you can grow enough plants to feed the billions of animals you're going to eat. Be real bud.
Cooper Richardson
Id like to learn more about how meat consumption is damaging the environment. Can you link me to any information sources besides > Wikipedia or > reddit posts Much appreciated
Angel Price
Right, gonna go enjoy my vegan breakfast of antibiotica and grass now.
Anthony King
- Pollutes rivers So do a lot of things - Forests cleared for livestock Don't give a shit - Causes soil degradation Like a lot of things at a much higher degree - Massive inefficiency Bait, the meat industry is extremely efficient compared to waiting 9 months for your faggot veggies to grow - Major contributor to global warming. >global warming >real
Jayden Butler
triggered
Kevin Nguyen
>appeal to futility fallacy Interesting analysis, meatcuck
Jacob Butler
fresh link
discord.gg/HMYSwbC
Juan Hughes
>pretending we're the ones whining
David Foster
...
Gabriel Perry
chill brah
Carter Parker
So?
Levi Bell
Pigs are food, dogs aren't >implying the consumer kills the animal itself
Jackson Foster
cant see the double standard
sad
Jordan Butler
>Pigs are food, dogs aren't interesting
John Mitchell
Sorry to break it to you but humans kill dogs all the time. How cute you thought i'd fall into your "trap". But, in general, vegans go out of their way to make meat eaters lives inpleasant while meat eaters mostly mind their own buisiness. So yes you guys are whiny
Elijah Nguyen
>Breed one animal for meat/leather >breed another for companionship >WOAH DUDE DOUBLE STANDARD MUCH??
Thomas Johnson
yes meatcucks really live and let live
Caleb Parker
>he waited this whole time until some meat eater would show up in this thread >no one does, its a civil conversations that are taking place >user gets mad, why doesnt he gets bullied all of the sudden? >finally some dirty meatcuck appears >he doesnt even criticize veganism or vegans in any way >muahua hua now its my time to shine, that picture i saved will surely show him his place you are the problem why vegans arent taken seriously
Adam Edwards
>be vegan >lift for a decade >snap your shit yo benching slightly more than lmao2pl8 VEGANS ARENT FRAGILE GUYS
Noah Harris
>vegan creats thread for people who are interested in being vegan >you "not a vegan and against vegans" decide to come on this thread and start arguing >yeah you seem to really live and let live buddy
Isaiah Martinez
Fig. 1 is okay and accepted in societiy if person 2 is the owner.
Of course unnecessary cruelty is a different story, but that is the same for killing pigs.
Isaiah Cook
>butchering your dog is okay
the absolute state of meatcucks
Jayden Russell
How the fuck do I reach 120g of protein per 1500 calories without eating a fuck ton of soy, resorting to protein powders and while still being able to hit all my nutrients?
Chase Torres
It's not a double standard, there is nothing wrong with killing dogs either.
Ian Richardson
spotted the chink
Landon Martin
People put down their dogs all the time. Pet shelters often kill them after only 72 hours.
Jaxson Ortiz
yeah and that's a bad thing ...
dumb owners should think about the dog before they make an impulsive decision to buy one
Asher Taylor
Why do you switch subjects? What happened to
>the absolute state of meatcucks
I thought what I said before was odd and savage?
Jose Adams
meatcucks are still in a state if they think it's morally neutral to butcher their dog
Brody Ortiz
You mean it is morally neutral to kill a pig? But not morally neutral to kill a dog?
Logan Garcia
>Fig. 1 is okay >Fig 1 is man butchering dog
what don't you follow
Noah Myers
If you mean killing a dog with a knife, that is not the normal procedure. Just like killing pigs with a knife isn't the normal procedure.
Both dogs and pigs are supposed to be killed by humane methods in the US and Europe.
So both figures are factually incorrect unless taken figuratively, describing the act of killing itself rather than the act of killing with a knife in particular.
Landon White
Morality doesn't exist and you don't have a single shred of tangible evidence to prove it.
Owen Harris
morality is a concept, no one thinks it's a force of nature
fucking brainlets
Xavier Reyes
>dogs are killed in society >therefore dogs are not the victims of said killings
???
plz explain
Cameron White
kek was this supposed to be clever
William Diaz
>child slaves used to gather veggies and fruits all over the world >literally starved to death when they're not capable of working more >vegans are still pretending they're morally superior lmoa, if you want to be vegan go ahead but don't bring morality into this.
Ian Russell
> vegans aren't perfect > therefore animal abuse is justified
tu quoque fallacy
nice
William Allen
If it's not anything real then it's not an argument
Easton Perez
>child abuse is fine >animal abuse is wrong explain this then
Andrew Cooper
You are again switching subjects. How is killing a dog in humane ways different from killing a pig in humane ways? You are saying one is worse than the other, but you can't justify why. Both happen in society regularly, but you get outraged over one in particular, you can't explain why.
But okay lets switch subjects if you have no answer.
>dogs are not the victims of said killings An animal can't be a victim, because a victim is per definition a person. And a person is by definition a human being.
Victim implies a crime against a person. So you are misusing words here.
Jonathan Adams
This.
Morality is a dumb thing people believe in because they can't handle the idea of it not being there. It's not real, it's made up, and applying it to real things makes you mentally retarded.
Kevin Carter
i think the argument is that child abuse and animal abuse is worse than just child abuse, not that child abuse is the hip new thing
Tyler Jenkins
I said child abuse is fine?
There's always more we can do to promote good. Vegans who act like it's some magical moral baseline are stupid. We're better than meatcucks but there's still more we can do
Austin Gomez
Nigger you aren't real, doesn't mean you're not a faggot
Gabriel Cox
but you don't have child slave workers in meat industry, so I could argue that vegans are abusing children while I'm only abusing animals. >Vegans who act like it's some magical moral baseline are stupid >acts like magical moral baseline you're not much better
Charles Jackson
*tips fedora*
Andrew Harris
Nice argument moralcuck
Adrian Edwards
>Meat consumption is ruining the environment. Citation needed. >- Pollutes rivers Citation needed. >- Forests cleared for livestock Citation needed. >- Causes soil degradation Citation needed. >- Massive inefficiency Citation needed. >- Major contributor to global warming. Citation needed.
You can't go around making baseless statements and expecting people to take you seriously. If anything it harms your credibility.
Xavier James
nice rebuttal steinersoyim
Aiden Rogers
*tipping intensifies*
Easton Stewart
do you have a meat-only diet? your shits must be atrocious
Chase Jenkins
reminder eating meat is degeneracy
Isaac Hall
Meanwhile you waste a fuckton of water growing almonds and avocados. Then you waste a fuckton more turning almonds and peas into milk because you're too much of a pussy to accept what you preach and just actually eat plants.
Then you throw some slave labor sugar cane in the milk because you're still addicted to processed food.
Those veagan brownies, cornbread, cookies, "chicken tendies", bean burgers, and all the other items you use to trick yourself into thinking your shitty diet is normal cost more than you think.
Ryder Hernandez
You know it always amazes me how many atheists are in the vegan community yet the same arguments and insults the vegan community uses against moral relatavists and moral nihilists are the exact same that religious fundies use against atheists.
There are valid health and environmental reasons to limit animal product consumption. Why make your main argument (that I've seen) be the made up concept of morality?
Joshua Reyes
of course it is since people value morality. In the eyes of the public the vegan argument is won once autists like you admit you're amoral
Jaxson Martin
This research was copied directly from the journal of broscience.
Justin White
Read: morality is a thing when it aligns with what I’m already doing morality is not a thing when I actually have to make a sacrifice.
If morality is not a thing, then presumably you don’t have any moral objections to child rapists either?
Jack Smith
I can't be amoral if morality is an imaginary concept.
Jose Bennett
So you have no objection to people raping children either? That’s cool bro, wow so edgy.
Jordan Wood
You don't need 120g of protein for 1500 calories. I know www.youneedproteinbuyourproteinpowder.com told you protein is super duper important but it isn't.
Aaron Lopez
I don't. Why would I? Obviously the practice shouldn't be allowed by society, not because of some imaginary concept - but because it's detrimental to society. As I don't subscribe to morality I don't have any moral issue with anything.
Yes, that includes you raping and killing me. I don't have any moral qualms about that. Clearly I would desire the opposite in act in accordance with that. It wouldn't be allowed under society as rape and murder are significantly detrimental to society, but there's no baseless moral rule against it.
Wyatt Gomez
are you retarded?
Amoral: having no moral standards, restraints, or principles; unaware of or indifferent to questions of right or wrong:
how is that contingent on whether morality is a concept or not?
literally like a 12yr old who thinks he's smart for discovering nihilism
Jaxon Martinez
English isn't my first language
Eli Nelson
i'm a sheep farmer, i just think 'morality is a social construct' is the last refuge of the faggot when you consider how much of our lives are made up of social constructs
assuming that something doesn't matter just because it doesn't have a physical basis is stupid and harmful to society (another thing that doesn't exist)
Aiden Diaz
If your diet composed entirely of meat you could make that argument... you’d also be dead of scurvy because only carnivorous animals can get all nutrients they need to live from meat
Ayden Perry
Notice how no one in this thread so far has given a valid argument to believe in morality.
>b-but child rape tho >b-but edgy tho! >b-but tips fedora also I'm an atheist lol
Thomas Taylor
I never called it a social construct. I said it wasn't real and was made up.
It is made up, you seem recognize that right? I see no reason to lower myself into deluding myself into believing something made up.
Upholding society's arbitrary moral values for the sake of society or yourself is fine. Believing moral values are necessary for society, whilst I'd disagree, is fine. Genuinely believing these things are intrinsic makes you retarded.
It's funny we're on the sides of the argument we are. I'm actually a vegan. Moralfags give the rest of us a bad name. I don't give a shit what faggy moral values you have, I want real evidence supporting arguments. But other vegans literally just shout their moral opinions and then act smug like they won
Here is a direct link from the European journal of clinical nutrition on environmental impact by diet. Vegans have the lowest impact of any group.
Evan Kelly
>society doesnt exist
society: the aggregate of people living together in a more or less ordered community.
? pls explain
moral statements refer to natural properties of the world
e.g. x is bad may mean x causes suffering
you edgy retards are just too stupid to realise non scientific words can still refer to things that exist
whether you value morality or not is an entirely different question
Michael Wood
fuck that video manee
Ryan Jackson
>x is bad
You'd first have to prove that good and bad exist
>suffering is bad
After proving good and bad are real things, you'd have to prove that suffering is bad
Or you could take the easy route where you don't have to prove anything and admit it's a made up concept to umbrella existing properties such as suffering and misery that humans typically have a negative human reaction to. Which it is. And since it's not real and it's just something humans made up, there is no actual good or bad. Calling things good or bad is retarded since good and bad aren't real things. And since it's a made up umbrella concept, it has no place in an argument.
There's your two options. Prove good and bad are real things, or admit it's a made up concept based on what we find emotionally displeasing and that it has no place in an actual argument.
Jackson Nelson
Veggiecrops do the same harm to the environment and body - Pesticides. Literally annihilating Bees worldwide. So the damage to the environment is way more serious.
Hunter Davis
>x is bad may mean x causes suffering
Suffering based ethics are the basis of some sets of morality. Moralities that are not shared by most people by the way. People do not agree on that criteria, so it is dishonest of you to claim that this is a thing everyone agrees with. And by the way it is inherently defunct, since life relies on constant suffering to function.
You can choose any other criteria for what is good and what is bad.
Michael Ross
>it has no place in an actual argument.
every argument is going to be
if you value morality, you should do x
if you value the environment, you should do x
if you value your health over taste/convenience, you should do x
there's no argument that avoids the 'if'
Ayden Sanchez
>told you protein is super duper important but it isn't. Not everyone wants to be a fragile soyboy, some of us actually want to get big.
Jace Richardson
>Wants to get big >Eats 1500kcal
fucking brainlet.
Robert Russell
>be on a cut >don't want to lose muscle >eat more protein to reduce the amount of muscle lost, maybe even building some while still losing fat
You've got to be a 77IQ moron to not understand this.
Christopher Wright
>Reduce calorie deficit >Don't be a shortsighted sperg >Don't lose gains at all
I doubt anyone that lifts has a 2000kcal need, at a minimum 2500 so you are at a minimum 1000kcal deficit. That is fucking retarded, reduce it to a 500kcal deficit and 120g can easily be hit. With a protein powder it's easy to hit 120 at 1500 too so either way you are a retard.
Jacob Allen
Post more Earth chan
Brody Hernandez
Hi I am interested in being vegan. Basically the only non vegan thing I eat anymore is milk. What is something that I can substitute for it (high calorie/decent protein). I usally drink like half a gallon a day as well so it's almost half my calories. Also will I have to start keeping track of amino acids?
Lincoln Nelson
Don't understand the retaliation of people not eating meat.