Should students be denied admission to school because they pinged evil under a detection spell?

I'd post a graph on gang violence but I'm not that racist.

>evil students are far more likely to murder their fellow students than evil students
>evil sduents are more likely than evil students who are more likely than the first evil students who are more likely etc.
WATCH OUT IT'S GONNA BLOW!

Not all black people are evil user

>Using detectable alignment system in an RPG
>Using alignment system at all

>#notallgnolls

Oh, I know that. I grew up in Detroit and I've mentally separated black prople into the categories of "Black People" and "Niggers"

Depends on the school.

I mean a magic school shouldn't really care, nor should a bard collage, though a warrior training program should deny them admission, while paladin training temple should all but force them to join, they just don't get to graduate until their alignment changes.
>self taught Lich
Give him an honorary doctorate and get the guy to guest lecture.

in any setting where detect evil is easily available for common people to enter a school then that means there is a very powerful church in control. for that there is probably a very powerful evil attempting to overtake or corrupt it. in that case EVIL is NOT aloud AT ALL. but im sure there are other ways to work your setting.

Thats why you put them into the same school where they cant hurt neutral and good aligned students and hopefully kill each other.

Evil in any setting means going out and doing bad cuz your a bad guy. there is a physical realm of evil and there are great powers of good and evil fighting. evil means they are gana do bad shit.

are you saying we put all the evil people together and educate them?
that sounds like a terrible idea. they will just do evil shit and kill the good/neutral schools as a mass murder. probably use their corpses to destroy the rest of the town and spread there idea to trying to conquer the world.

no
something similar was actually a plot point in an old story we ran, but it wasn't so much a detection spell as it was that the student was from a generally evil tribe

So if they are going to do bad shit why wouldnt you try to re-educate them into the righteus path of chaotic neutrality?

Double-X deathknight there's going to get fucked up, they're way to close for him to be doing that.

Education cures bigotry, which is fundamentally what evil is.

changing an entire person is not easy even today. that isnt really possible. you try to educate someone who wants to kill you. you know how many prison teacher die each year?
best thing to do is smite and slash

No, because then you run into the problem of having to trust the people who use detect evil, AND you have to trust that detect evil is a good enough metric for whatever you wanted to avoid.
Do not put a single point of failure in your education system that would allow an unscrupulous mid-level caster to subvert the whole thing.

...

i think detect evil is a paladin thing. and if paladins are doing the job the guy who hired him is going to trust him to the full.

Evil student here.

My classmates refuse to help me kidnap lolis to mindbreak, my classmates only ever want to set fire to things and blow up "meatbag pinatas" for "XP".

I thought this place would be more accepting of my magical realm damn it, not just a fucking ... Bro Fest of DPS-crazy Douchebags.

if that anti-paladin isnt a pussy and commits to that swing that paladin is gana get rekted.
not that i support the lawful evil cunt.

>trusting paladins
They literally act as servants of their God. They are gonna use their position to spread their God's values.
Yes, they aren't gonna lie about who pings Det Evil. but they're gonna use that to shove their particular brand of Good, and shove it hard.

Again, don't make a system with a single point of failure for subversion.

your in the wrong thread boy.

>making a claim without actually knowing anything
What's it like in retardland?

>black woman paladin
He's just performing some well-needed [PURGE]ing to restore the world to its natural state and eliminate mary sues.

>What's it like in retardland?
Everyone wants to roleplay and whines at the DM when game mechanics offer a challenge and impair us in some way.

ANd then you end up with someone faking being a Paladin who is capable of detecting stuff who starts reporting a bunch of kids as being SUPER EVIL when they're the ones who are super goody goodgood.

i dont see anything wrong with your scenario. not like those kids needs to build cars and shit. most people will need to be farmers if we have town big enough for a school. let the farmers get that good old fashion home education. not like it will be any better then a different person saying "and this is a rake jimmy!" old pappy will do just fine.

>school of magic
Literally everyone there is evil.

Suffer not the witch.

Fuck right or wrong, I'll teach anybody who wants to learn the ways of the universe instead of getting laid. Lord that shit over that community bardic college shit heads.

Well so long as there are multiple schools and students are free to choose which one to attend, yes.

do you know how paladins works. its not like oh hey thats guys is in full plate must be legit. they all tend to know each other and must practice in a church for a long period of time. anyone willing to lie through the process of becoming a paladin would fail a detect evil test for sure.
im sure you dont go to church. but people tend to know each other.

>going to school to learn how to run your fucking family farm instead of learning from dad/grandpa
>multiple of these fucking schools with no point in 1 town
>letting your children choose which school they go to

What the flippidy fuck?

can anyone post NOT LEWD casters? male or female. i dont need your lewd shit and shame on OP for posting it. go to /d/ or /b/ or some other board for your lewd porn.

knowledge belongs to everyone, regardless of alignment

the act of withholding knowledge is evil itself

in the real world i would agree but giving power to evil in a realm where evil has a physical world and there are evil gods questing to do great harm means its better to say no.
its not a " bad" person its and "EVIL!' person. totally different.

Yes.
If they ping, they might have demonic ancestry, and that means they might be a FILTHY FUCKING SORCERER.

well I assume that's why the OP asked
admitting a student that lewd is surely some kind of evil act itself, and hell, the student may even be a succubus in disguise for all they know

What the FUCK is wrong with that niggers shield? Holding it by one strap, using a shield obviously designed to be used with a spear with a sword instead, gripping the fucking shield like you want to shake it's fucking hand. Holy flopping gnat tits what an awful picture.

I'm honestly more concerned by the disproportionate limbs and the fact that either her tits look like eggs hanging from nails or her neck is long as fuck.
But she is black, so maybe she has those neck ring things.

sometimes you gotta use what you have around you.
she is a paladin just smite and slash god will do the rest.

you cant see her tits..... she is in heavy armor you cant really judge her neck....
her limbs look good enough.

How can you not see the super pronounced boobcups on that armor? They're giving me cancer.

Actually, it's the opposite, Evil candidates have lower admission criteria, it's called Affirmative Action.

No, they get assigned to the green part of the school associated with snakes along the other evil ones and taught how to be evil; what's a world with heroes without its villains?
Introduction to monologues
Dramatic backstory writing trainings
Probability and statistical analysis of cliches
"should you hate or love your nemesis?"
Philosophy and how to misinterpret it
Foreign exchange program: Contact with the weebs

Depends on the setting.

For real though, some DMs rule that there's a roughly even split between the alignments, and "evil" could really just mean "at least a bit of a cunt".

Of course not, but they do have to step through the Corrective Thinking portal.

The Corrective Thinking portal reverses the alignment of anyone who steps through it. It also reverses their gender, too.[/Spoiler]

It only works once per person, and the second attempt strips them naked and dumps them outside the tomb- I mean, school. A very kindly lich donated it to us.

Of course they should, they are the best students, pulling up the whole level of the school, pass the official assessment and bring much-needed funds to the schools.
The only to learn anything is to put skill points in the appropriate skills. The only way to get skill points is to gain levels. The only way to gain levels is to accrue experience points. The only efficient way to accrue experience points is to kill things.
All knowledge is paid with the life of others, and Evil people are the one who are okay with treating the existence of people as mere tools.

Don't forget Backstabbing 101 and Minion Management.

So if you're motivated by greed or sadism, that's not evil regardless of what you do?

With a split in fourth grade between students specializing in Absolute Evil and Applied Evil.

A school is a place to teach and educate children. One of the things schools should do is teach them not to be evil.

A magic school is a school that does so through magic, and so is entirely right on the money. Wrong alignment? Magic can fix that!

It's part of being a wizard and teaching underlings properly.

Selfishness is the bigotry of identifying others as not part of yourself. An unbigoted sadist would take as much pleasure in hurting themselves as much as others, and his greed would be to give wealth to all.

Become one with the collective. All will become as one.

Despite the spoiler, I still can't tell if you're being serious.

>Selfishness is the bigotry of identifying others as not part of yourself. An unbigoted sadist would take as much pleasure in hurting themselves as much as others, and his greed would be to give wealth to all.

Less confusingly (and to cause less "they said 'bigot' as if it was a bad word, THE SJW ARE INVADING THE BOARD !" predictable reactions), you could rather talk about empathy and the difference between considering others as people equal in essence to you or just as objects and tools.
When you begin treating people as things, Evil begins. When you treat people as you would an other yourself, Good ensues.
You can be a good sadist if you apply your sadism while knowing plainly that the other would actually appreciate such attention. You can be a good greedy person if you admit that everyone would also like a bigger part of cake and proceed to make a bigger cake for all including yourself.
Inversely, you can be an Evil masochist if you take the pain on yourself to cause culpability and humiliation in the one who caused you pain, and an Evil charitable person if you instrumentalize charity and poor dudes for your own benefits.

In America students with rightwing beliefs are all but ostracized from academia.

right but we are talking about letting evil people into schools not normal people.

Evil can't be brought back to a single core concept. It's the category of all actions that are abhorred. It includes actions that deny people human dignity but it's much broader than that, there are like six pillars of human morality and every culture is attuned to them in different ratios.

*Google* Interesting, and thank you for pointing this to my intention. But, without disparaging the merit of the Moral foundations theory IRL, in D&D, it, well...

The six foundations of morality are
Care: cherishing and protecting others; opposite of harm.
Fairness or proportionality: rendering justice according to shared rules; opposite of cheating.
Liberty: the loathing of tyranny; opposite of oppression.
Loyalty or ingroup: standing with your group, family, nation; opposite of betrayal.
Authority or respect: obeying tradition and legitimate authority; opposite of subversion.
Sanctity or purity: abhorrence for disgusting things, foods, actions; opposite of degradation.

So, yeah, in D&D, Care is totally a foundation of Good.
But Fairness, Loyalty and Authority are foundation of Law.
And Liberty is foundation of Chaos.
(Purity is not clear, since there is no clear alignment that seems concerned by disgust. Wallowing in filth doesn't cause an alignment change. I would probably associate it to Good, since ugly awful people tend to be Evil (but it's not a rule), and the use of certain arbitrarily prohibited substances (poisons) cause an immediate, no-recourse, no-excuses shift away from Good).

Nothing turns fantasy mundane faster than fucking detect alignment spells. They are banned in my campaigns.

All children under the age of 16 profile as sociopaths.

It's the ones that DON'T ping as outright evil that you should be scared of.

he's just going to slam his enormous elbow into her face

If she tries to block it, the shield will slam into her mouth and knock out all her teeth because she's a fucking retard and is holding it wrong.

I think in terms of metaphysical good and evil in D&D, purity can be seen as an abhorance of things that are corrupted and fell, things like undead, lycanthropes, demons, and devils

>Wizards
>Caring about right and wrong

Pick one and only one.

>wizards just toss a helm of opposite alignment on them if they're being disruptive

Mindbreak: the perfect form of punishment

An evil only magic school is literally a BBEG factory. Every year would basically be Battle Royale, except the students are psychotic enough to WANT to be there.

Hell, a setup very similar to this is the one where Dracula learnt how to be the immortal bloodsucker we all know and love.
In his case, the Scholomance wasn't even that stupid of a setup. Every year the final exam would involve the 13 students they take in being put in a corridor and told to run, the slowest guy would get eaten by the Devil, the rest would get magic powers.

Except in HIS year, Drac, realising he's been skimping on track and field turns around and makes a deal with Satan, RIDONCULOUS magic power and immortality in return for the other 12 students.
So that year the Scholomance only had the one graduate.

In settings with alignments, yes.
And I know it's irrelevant to settings with alignments/OP's proposed hypothetical situation, but settings with alignments are dumb.

Outside of settings with alignments, they could maybe put some sort of dampeners or limiters on students until they prove themselves responsible or whatever, or maybe just start off with like really rudimentary teachings for the first year or two; if it's a high-fantasy setting it's all stuff anyone could proverbially google and learn form street magicians. Then the megalomaniacs would be all, "I'm better than this! This is a waste of time!" and the psychos may start strait up complaining about not being taught how to kill/destroy stuff. Then those students can be weeded out and actual classes could start being taught on like the 3rd year or have their dampeners taken off, or both or whatever.

That means the student has at lest 5 hit dice. That means you are dealing with a very advanced student getting a post graduate degree or someone getting a second education.

The issue is that you are not spelling out what the school is for, nor why the student was put to the detect evil spell.

>Outside of settings with alignments, they could maybe put some sort of dampeners or limiters on students...
...until the end of their lives. No need for any additional overseeing, since we're gonna keep them in concentration camps anyway.

Wouldn't denying someone education be evil?

>not enabling Evil, by giving it additional tools and opportunities, is the real evil

Poacher turned gamekeeper, user. The security guy at my work used to be a burglar and he knows every damn trick in the book. I trust him far more than an alleged "expert" to know how to secure a building from thieves. He has first-hand experience in breaking into buildings, so he knows what will stop a burglar in his tracks.

...

Why is a lanky nerd pushing his foot ineffectually at an unlocked door.

Wouldn't they just all go to slytherin house?

because true burglar wouldn't get caught on camera

Why? What the hell are we gonna do with all these fucking black robes?
Plus, it keeps the little shits from messing with things they don't understand.

if we banned all evil children from school, there would be few children that had any education at all

Post pics of wizard students.

They should be denied and executed, because you have to be incredibly evil to be evil in the only settings I can think of that have detect evil.

No?

>Every year would basically be Battle Royale, except the students are psychotic enough to WANT to be there.

That sounds like every highschool anime with a tournament ever.

Wouldn't alignment detection spells be in violation of privacy?

Children are inherently evil.

people today have everything they do be documented on a giant computer and noone gives a damn.
why would people of medieval ages who have little concept of privacy give a damn about someone casting detect evil? the person casting it is probably a paladin and doing it in the name of god the highest authority no complaint to your kind will help you.

Depends on the school system's ethics code.

Evil wizards that are denied a benevolent mentor will definitively become bitter magical Hilter. It's hack writing 101.

did this guy take a bite out of his knife? it's always bothered me.

THIS MAN KNOWS.

>The blood of the innocent doesn't cry out to god for justice in his campaign