How would pic-relateds fare in westeros?
They arrive at the beginnng of the 1st season.
Who would do it better then others others?
Who would Who ends up on the thrones
What happens if all of them arrive together?
P.S. Sister of Battle has a chainsword. We already agreed that a SM willing to go for diplomoacy would win, what about a nerfed SM?
Other urls found in this thread:
1d4chan.org
twitter.com
Jack would hang with that black pirate from braavos.
Geralt would probably take the black voluntarily the moment he hears the legends about the Others.
>Conan
Westeros gets BTFO, claims throne, turns it into Lemuria 2.0.
>Gandalf
Westeros gets BTFO, tries to kill him for revealing the corruption, prefers diplomacy.
>Sister
Westeros gets BTFO, Sister chews through everything thrown at her with the chainsword, wins over most females in the setting, claims the throne for the Emperor
>Jack
Becomes a very very hated man in Westeros, known for not being able to die. Becomes a minor noble and drinks his sorrows away in solitude.
>Big Boss
Westeros gets BTFO. Organizes targeted coups and riots, brings down the entire monarchal system over time, also has guns.
>Geralt
The only one out of all of them who would beneficially contribute to Westeros. Takes the Black as soons as he can, then later probably becomes a knight of Stark, enjoys a sort of diplomatic immunity because of his prowess in actually being able to face things like dragons and undead head on.
As for if they are all together...
The only one with true aspirations to lead would be Conan, and because he is indeed a fair and just ruler, Gandalf, the Sister (who might even think Conan is the Emperor himself) and Geralt would all vouch for him.
Jack doesn't care either way. Just his own survival. And Big Boss disagrees with monarchy alltogether.
So really, it boils down to Conan's New Lemuria vs Big Boss.
>Takes the black
>becomes a knight later on
That's not how that works, you take the black, you're there until death.
I don't think geralt gives a shit
>Conan
Robert Baratheon IS Conan. Or at least was inspired by him. Conan would conquer westeros and then let it decline as he drinks wine and fucks whores.
Still in asoiaf he wouldn't have plot armor and not being a noble chances of him dying would be big.
>Gandalf
I wonder... In this wa between man and Other would he be 100% on side of men? Or owuld he go to the far north to speak with the ice lords and understand their motivations? Or being the wielder of the flame of Anor would make him an enemy?
>Geralt
Book Gerald is not even the best swordfighter. He is only good vs monsters cause of his tricks. Here all of his lore is rendered pointless.
And taking the black ?! No more wine, whores and gold? He would not do it unless he have no choice. Would probably end being a sellsword that drinks his pay in kingslanding.
No, that's how it used to be. After the Wall falls, after the Others are defeated, will there even be the Night's Watch? I don't think so.
>Or owuld he go to the far north to speak with the ice lords and understand their motivations? Or being the wielder of the flame of Anor would make him an enemy?
Who knows? We don't know much about what the Others want. Melisandre thinks they're sworn enemies of men who won't rest until everyone is dead, but no matter how good her intentions are, Melisandre is very often wrong about everything.
By the way, this just made me think that Melisandre is ASOIAF version of Gandalf.
Gandalf never seemed to care much about the Orc's viewpoint in his own story, I think he'd just defend mankind.
But he knew his enemy. He knew very well what Sauron was. In westeros? Would he need to investigate personally?
Also if a group of knights decide to hang him from a tree can he survive?
If nobody can kill fucking Beric in Westeros, they won't be able to kill Gandalf.
Is it even possible to kill a mayar with mundane weapons?
How would he fare?
Assume that he is not constrained by Bioware plot writing.
Crap.
>not even the best swordfighter
He only got beaten by a wizard using his caster supremacy and died due to being overwhelmed by crowd. Even if there are no monsters in Westeros and without the use of alchemy, Geralt is still a genetically modified killing machine with superhuman senses, agility, strength, endurance and training. I doubt there is a fighter in Westeros capable of taking him 1v1, and they don't have actual wizards.
Big boss will own everyone in westeros. He took giant robots so a couple of dragons would be no problem. In snake eater we discovered he has no trouble finding food in locations away from civilization. And he have exp in organizing people in fighting groups, creating followers and leading them.
The onl question is will he sit n the iron thrones or decide to go with a completely different political order?
>not the best swordfighter
No, but he still kills the fuck out of pretty much anyone in Westeros in a one on one fight
>Conan would conquer westeros and then let it decline as he drinks wine and fucks whores.
You haven't read a single Conan story, I see.
>You haven't read a single Conan story, I see.
Have you?
Because that's what he does.
THis night and all nights to come oath breaker!
>Because that's what he does.
Maybe you forgot the part where he lowered taxes in Aquilonia and made it the best country in the world for commoners.
*tax policy intensifies*
Ian mckellan would fare just fine. He is a gay homo faggot and Game of Thrones is the place for him
Big Boss would just be Mance Rayder writ large across all of Westeros. Migt even start with organizing the wildlings, but then puts them on a boat rather than raiing the wall. Takes over an island, organizes a merc company to rival the golden company, frees more slaves than Dany, hires a few specialist Maesters from R&D...he could create a utopia. An Outer Heaven.
Fucking this. He was so based that even when some scheming little shits took over the country, many duchies still recognized him as their true king and even wanted to secede and proclaim a new kingdom under his rule. You don't get that kind of loyalty for being drunk and fucking whores.
>Or being the wielder of the flame of Anor would make him an enemy?
Why is his being a wielder of the flame of Anor relevant here in the first place? Do you even know what that is?
Not to mention that above all else, Conan despises getting soft. Either he'd change the Realm, or he'd fuck off and go back to being a barbarian.
flame of Anor, flame of the sun + Narya ring. He is very fire aligned dude. And they are ice.
Seems natural enemies to me.
like the scottish and the english.
or the scottish and irish
or scots and other scots
Damned Scots! They RUINED SCOTLAND!!!
If all of them arrive together, it basically becomes a contest of who can dissolve the entire political geoscape first: Conan or Big Boss. None of the characters in the show stand a chance against either one.
They would then spend the rest of their natural lives in constant conflict because their ideals are mutually exclusive. Unless Conan gives up the throne and goes back to being an adventuring barbarian, in which case Big Boss is free to act as a mercenary force without anybody being able to contest him.
Geralt and Jack would be minor figures in the grand scheme of things. They'd both fit into the setting pretty well and carve out a niche for themselves.
Gandalf strikes me as the sort who wouldn't act overtly when displaced from his world, but would support a righteous cause.
The Sororita would probably end up regarded as a demigoddess of some kind, but it's only a matter of time until her armour runs out of power and her weapons run out of bullets, at which stage she's just a really burly chick. Also the implications of a world that has no God Emperor of Man mean she'd probably have a crisis of faith.
>Also the implications of a world that has no God Emperor of Man mean she'd probably have a crisis of faith.
They'd probably just assume they were stranded on some random planet in their own universe. Even if they never leave the planet they'd never have reason to doubt that the Imperium is still out there chugging along without them.
> a world that has no God Emperor of Man mean she'd probably have a crisis of faith.
But Conan is right over there.
>So really, it boils down to Conan's New Lemuria vs Big Boss.
I'm okay with that show.