How would you change the monstergirls encyclopedia setting to make it better suited to an ttrpg game?

How would you change the monstergirls encyclopedia setting to make it better suited to an ttrpg game?

Other urls found in this thread:

mgewiki.com/w/Main_Page
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

Burn it and grab a book that has a setting that isn't pornography.

Here you g-
Oh. Wait.

I don't understand the question. What parts of Monstergirl Encyclopedia setting are unsuited for a ttrpg?

You need rule for pleasure, build up, and release.

You aren't doing that without just remaking it from the ground up.

All conflicts with the titular monster girls end up with either death, death leading into sex, or sex, with it being heavily weighted towards the latter if you're anything but a male fighting to the death, being that females can be raised as zombies and they'd probably treat anything less than a credible threat on their life as a mating display.

This is so deeply ingrained in the setting and writings that detail it that the only excuse you have for playing a game in the setting is ERP.

A game where all players play as Lilims commanding their own armies and pockets of fuck-you-demonic-energy-tainted land, rather than having a bunch of autistic people who played MGQ making self-inserts and trying to hook up with their monster of choice, would at least be mildly interesting in this respect.

Include monsterdudes.

Bam.

Done.

>How would you change the monstergirls encyclopedia setting to make it better

All of the monstergirls have a 50/50 gender split where in the other half is cute monster boys who are just as slutty and as big a semen demens.
Wait, sorry, what was the question?

Flip it. There are only rape-monsters, who breed by raping human women (like in Goblin Slayer.)

The PCs are fighting not to get cucked. Or if they're female, they're fighting not to end up a monster incubator. Or getting fucked to death by Minotaurs with foot-long cocks.

It's a porn setting. Unless you make all the monstergirls male rapefugees, it won't work.

Nerf the Demon Energy bull-bullets by toning down the Mind Rape & Corruption fetishism.
Rework the Demon Queen so she's actually got a coherent plan besides "keep having sex and Demon Energy will make it all work out".
Give the Order more of a leg to stand on so they're still gray without being let off on grounds of stupidity.
Give the Gods believable goals, in particular either have a faction actually working for peace or make the Chief Goddess less of a monomaniacal idiot who just wants to relight the cycle of slaughter.
Completely rewrite the Pantheon's membership to be something other than all-female Greco-Roman deities.
Create a more obvious distinction between the asshole Elder God who set up the Cycle of Slaughter and the Chief God who currently "leads" the Pantheon.
Broaden the setting so there's stuff to do that isn't waifu-hunting or erotic slice of life; aka you can still be an adventurer, whether you want to bring about a Mamono victory, an Order victory, or even just ignore the war and focus on filling your wallet, Slayers style.

Eh, in theory only thing you'd need to do is have the current Demon Lord die or otherwise lose control of Demon Energy, which then turns human men into regular versions of monsters.
The Order keeps itself afloat now that people actually want some monsters killed.
Maybe set it up so players have an option of purifying Demon Realms for cash and glory.
Other than that, sums it up pretty well.

>corruption and lust spells can be blocked by willpower.
>monsters still need a significant other, however food grants more spirit energy, making them less sex-crazy.
>the corrupted gods don't work for the demon queen. Some do some don't.
>humans can reach the physical or mental power of most monsters through training.
>order isn't full of mustache-twirlers.
>monsters don't hurt humans, but still cause problems and need to be removed.

>follow the spirit not the material
>play japano fantasy styled setting
>introduce whatever gets my dick hard
>also glorious 80s/early 90s aesthetics

>80's aesthetic

Nuclear age MGE.

Bueno

Use a good system.

I would play that so I finally have the opportunity to play my Filena expy

>monstergirls encyclopedia setting
People actually think that shit is salvageable?

I mean, no offense, but you'd have to remake it from ground up in order to end up with something actually interesting.

Give all the monster girls bigger tits.

Wait there is a setting?
All I ever see is clips of random entries about sheep girls and bee girls.

I've never seen much of a setting at all.

>Goblin Slayer
would you recommend it. at first it looks like an awesome different berserk wannabe. I really like he never shows his face. but then every other character is your generic manga style with little girls. I don't want to read more of the same shit they make daily nowadays.

For any and all information, this'll set you up:

mgewiki.com/w/Main_Page

It's not something you'd ever find about by reading just the web stuff, but yes. There's a couple of books which cover it in much greater detail.
It's still massively shit, though.

No, that's why I said go with the spirit. No use in playing some random guys magical realm. You play your own.

Remove the actual setting part, the corruption and rape aspects, the whole "demonic energy needing to feed off of Spirit energy", make the presence of monsters be in both sexes, nuke Wonderland from orbit, and actually give the monsters a personality and culture outside of hunting for boys to rape.

So in otherwords, don't use the setting, or anything really, and just the idea of monstergirls

It's ok.

Japan and the monsters have a Mary Sue problem, but that kinda cleans up when you realize the setting books are written by a pro-monster Japanese man.

That's like expecting North Korean TV to give you unbiased and clear messages about North Korea.

Two whole world guides full.
Though its a porn setting, not really a fiction setting, so you'd be hard pressed to find much of any conflict in there

A good question would be how to make it a more decent erotic setting. It's boring as fuck, pun intended.

It's serviceable as a porn setting I'd say, save being a bit indistinct so that you can insert wherever you want.

In my opinion the hottest ERP doesn't happen in porn settings.
When everything is powered by jizz or some other stupid contrivance to facilitate fucking you just make everything a joke. Feels less immersive, devalues the fucking, removes the sexy taboos, makes everything feel ridiculous when the sexual organs are not in use.

I would make the plot contain the sex, but not the whole setting.

So like, write your own?

Do you think we should make a Veeky Forums monster girl setting?

It's LITERALLY the magical realm

Are you stupid?

>Do you think we should make a Veeky Forums monster girl setting?
I don't see who magical realm design by committee would benefit.
And I suspect Veeky Forums has already tried that anyway. Possibly multiple times.

>So in otherwords, don't use the setting, or anything really, and just the idea of monstergirls

I'd do that by making it so alchemists learned to extract monster essence by pulping them and infuse it into people. So take for example a displacer beast, turn it to displacer juice, then inject that juice into a person so they can do displacer beast shit.

we have to have these two things
>reason's to hang around humans
>reason for monster features

My problem is that they're all there for cocks.

No, seriously. Shit's univentive as fuck, give the girls a tiny veneer of personality. Hell, even fetishes for them would be an huge improvement.

>I might sound crazy but I'd give the girls a civilization of sort to characterize them a bit more, even

some of them have personality. the big issue is that the entries are a generic species guide.

you are supposed to write your own waifu.

Again this is one of those things where the setting is super indistinct on purpose, so no not really. Like it isn't expanded on a ton, but demon realms have culture, there are warrior types, artsy noble types, types into just about anything people are into in real life. But the thing is this doesn't receive a bunch of attention because the profiles are so short. The world guide has like a lists of activities and things various monsters engage in in demon realms.

unironically this

Meh. Waifu generator when?

Look, I'm not gonna dispute that, but... I dunno, let's say it doesn't really give me ideas that I think even I could write. Monster Musume is not exactly Shakespeare but the girls are way more distinguishable. I realize why they can't, say, go the Tio way, but still.

Oh yeah, I'm not arguing against it being bad for non porn writing, I'm just saying theres enough there that anything you need to do to make your dick hard you can do
Except like guro and snuff I guess. And hell maybe you could do that with undead even.

Virtual lack of internal logic or balance, KC intentionally made Mamano overpowered in order to better sell his magical realm to frustrated Jap salarymen.

Maybe make it so that literally every creature doesn't subsist entirely on semen.

They don't.

>A mystical, metaphysical substance, spirit energy is generated by all living things except monsters and elementals. Small amounts are contained in organic foods like meat and plants [2], but it is intelligent life which produces it in the greatest abundance.

Make all the monster girls lolis.

Well yeah that's the setting it's a straight up unsalvageable human extinction scenario. You can't get rid of that aspect without gutting the entire setting.

By not changing the setting but playing a system that already suits the material

Its not though, its a hugbox in the other direction. Whenever a monster and human fuck the demon lord gets a bit stronger and once she's strong enough she can make it so that humans and monsters can give birth to human incubi. Then monsters and humans live together in harmony and so on

Not have them all be girls.
Not have all of them look like they're 5-35 years old.

I'll use this post to vent a bit.
1. Really? Monsters are a constant problem, but they're are barely any villages or nobles or churches prepared to deal with them?
2. Why doesn't the main character teach anyone other than kawaii healer girl how to deal with goblins?
3. How does every high-level adventurer have so little loyalty to their hometown that they would abandon it to fight peacefulish dragons or whatever in the wilderness? I would much rather live a life in my home village and protect from murderous rapist goblins than go to the edge of the earth to fight things that are more deadly but less important.
4. It seems pretty convenient that there's a 60/40 female male adventurer gender split, and that all of them are either teenagers or young adults. Somehow there isn't a single old witch or wizard, there isn't any female adventurer who is ugly, and none of them wear serious armor.
5. Fuck adventuers guilds in general.
If I wanted a rape doujin, I'd read a rape doujin, not this shitty excuse for a fantasy story.

Sorry I forgot to actually answer the question.
No I do not recommend it.

it was pretty implied, user.

>nuke Wonderland from orbit

Couldn't agree more. Boil the eggs.

SABBATH GO AND STAY GO

>The image
>The response
kek

its the japanese version of pokegirls, what did anyone expect?

Reskin Call of Cthulhu, it's what the Japanese do.

Can confirm. They'll run literally anything in CoC. Shin Megami Tensei and Persona being a couple of examples.

>A game where all players play as Lilims commanding their own armies and pockets of fuck-you-demonic-energy-tainted land, rather than having a bunch of autistic people who played MGQ making self-inserts and trying to hook up with their monster of choice, would at least be mildly interesting in this respect.
This. Make it into a Mamono civilizations boardgame.

Only if there's also an option to play as a minor god standing against them.

Just let me be the ANGRY island volcano goddess.

>Monstergirl dominions

I am 100% ok with this.

>Monstergirl dominions
>dominions
>Dominions

>MONSTERGIRL ERMOR

please no

I find all of these fine and inoffensive.

Think about it user.
>lilium and minor gods duke it out for power in the demon queens domain.
>they also have to defend against 2 other factions (the order and the fallen god) as well as monster factions (sabbath)
>players can play any role from order paladins to sabbath incubi.

Combine this with and we have cured the Mary Sue issue and created a source of conflict.

This might actually be workable!

How is that going to stop the skeletons.

Could be pretty neat yes.

I'm fairly sure paladins are the natural predators of skeletons.

That or you know, maces.

You know, this has promise.

really sad user, I dig his helmet so much, he looks awesome. but yeah, artists don't have the balls to make something interesting or different anymore, it's all about the cash.

Make the god of war not a piece of shit that makes all points of conflict moot. Or just kill the bitch

Do the same for the god of death.

New setting information dropped a month ago, /jp/ found a translation, Hel (goddess of death here) is on the Demon Lord's side.

>more variety among factions. Church isn't all assholes, squabbling nobles infighting and allying with monster tribes, gods do their own stuff, various wanna-be demon lords infighting and actually having a chance
>monsters bond with humans not for because they have to, but because it makes them stronger. Monsters on spirit energy have more control over their bestial side and are thus not such arseholes
>spirit energy is transmitted via magic ritual instead of sex, but because the monster lord is a succubus, the most well known ritual still has sex in it
>male monsters, a few male/female species are alright
>clear mechanics for monster transformation to accomodate for the male monsters. Consequently, different views on transformation for specific cultures. Elves put converts to death, centaurs treat them as second-class citizens, undead are pretty chill about it because they have to.Mermaids have a fetish for turning guys into girls or whatever
>humans are actually powerfulv enough to fight shit. Paladins exorcising the unded, monks firing spirit energy blasts, monster hunters powered by the dead-but-dreaming Elder God who hates monsters because they have turned his world into a masturbation fantasy.
>Fill the history with shit getting done so people have actual ruins to explore

So basicly, make it into a normal fantasy setting but where 95% of enemies are humanoid.

>hating best monsters

Tasteless muffins, you two.

I don't think it'd still be worth it.

Now, the monstergirls encyclopedia setting used for a vidya, maybe made with the RPG maker software; that'd have more potential.

I think that someone already tried exactly that

Ignition would probably work.

>Hating based trumpart

>wanting to be raped by unhatched eggs

You're already mad.

>not wanting to hang out with the Cheshire Cat/mad hatter/trumpart/Alices

I mean let's be real here, the eggs are rare and there are far worse things in the over world (parasite slimes anyone?)

You just invoke the Joseph joestar technique whenever you bump into an undesirable.

Quads of truth.

So I'm thinking about writing this with gurps. Questions:
>should I make a stat that measures corruption?
>should I do the main species first?
>should I be writing for a specific fix? The dominions one seems the best right now.

I'd say go for the Dominions one, yes. Also, corrupting tracking is good for players.

Must you keep making this thread?

Must you bump a thread you don't care about?