Welcome to the Veeky Forums challenge: Vote Thread: PIZZA PIE Edition

Entry The Tenth by sinistersalmon

>bechamel, fig, bell pepper, spinach
>garnished with balsamic

Entry The Eleventh by LickMyBalls

>Hubby loved it, kids went back for seconds

Entry The Twelfth by moyen

>And here it is.

>Tomato, onions, pepper, chili, pickles, chorizo, (leftover) sausages, gruyère cheese and mozzarella.

Entry The Thirteenth by Shake-kun

>1. Proved.
>2. Deflated.
>3. Flattened.
>4. Spinach sauce.
>no 5 lol
>6. Cheap smoked cheese (provolina sarda affumicata)
>7. Pulled garlic chicken.
>8. Blanched purple cabbage.
>9. Baking.

>Spinach sauce pizza with smoked cheese, garlic pulled chicken and purple cabbage. And a pint of chestnut beer.
>Not including the drink, this cost about $3.13 worth of ingredients to make and this pizza is two servings, so fairly economical, if time consuming to make the sauce and topping.
>Leftover spinach sauce and pulled garlic chicken will find other uses during the next several days.

Entry The Fourteenth by envelope guy

>it's a hawiian 'go 'za

Entry The Fifteenth by Haburashi

>First entry ever.

>Stuff't crust spinach garlic 'za topped with roma tomates and shiitake shroom.

Entry The Sixteenth by Hillary Clinton Should be in jail

>Prep time: 5 mins
>Cook time: 5 mins

Sorry that I've been gone for too long, had to take a...
>mental health break
Make of that what you will.
And vote.

I'm voting for thos pizzas;

Glad to have you back, numbaz.

This one is the bomb. only good one.

Hey numbaz sorry to be a priss but you used the wrong image for my entry

Oh shit you're right!
Sorry!
This is the right picture for

no worries, good to have you back. hope the break did you well.

You have to vote in all four categories for all entries for your vote to count.
So that's zero votes so far.
Bugger.

ok

-Presentation: 3/10
-Originality: 3/10
-Appeal: 3/10
-Challenge Goals: 3/10

-Presentation: 10/10
-Originality: 10/10
-Appeal: 10/10
-Challenge Goals: 10/10

A little too generous with most of them, if you ask me.

Too many to vote on right now but bump.

Thanks for de bump, brub.
Vote niggas!
Please, justify my existence!

Although I appreciate this, I don't think it's very fair. Also, you rate out of 5 not out of 10, you retard.
I will rate later when I have the time.

I'll probably make this some time soon, looks great and easy to make.

Thanks in advance bb

Suggest themes if you like, but I'm pretty sure I know what next month will be.
Also, batch votes are for fags.
Vote proper or fuck off.

I vote for him

(1/2)
P:1
A:2
O:1
G:5
Dude, this looks like ass cheeks

P:1
A:3
O:4
G:5

P:5
A:4
O:4
G:4
Fantastic presentation but if I asked for a pizza and got this I'd be kinda pizz'd

P:1
A:2
O:1
G:5
THICC crust

P:2
A:2
O:3
G:4

P:3
A:5
O:5
G:5
This should be in a blog

P:2
A:2
O:4
G:4

P:1
A:2
O:1
G:5
No description, shitty picture

P:3
A:3
O:3
G:5

P:2
A:5
O:5
G:5

P:1
A:1
O:1
G:1

P:2
A:4
O:5
G:5

P:2
A:3
O:5
G:5

(2/2)
P:2
A:2
O:3
G:5

P:3
A:4
O:4
G:5

P:1
A:1
O:1
G:1

If people want their entry taken seriously then they really need to add some kind of description. But there's a lot of good 'za here. Suggesting soup for October.

What should the theme for October be?
Turkey?
Pumpkin?
Orange and red?
Spooky?

cranberries

Thanks for the votes!

(P)resentation and (A)ppeal rated as described by Numbaz.
(C)reativity/(O)riginality rated on its commonality and/or whether I've seen this on the back of a sack of flour or something
(G)oal rated based on:
is it pizza? (yes = 2 pts)
is dough homemade> (yes = 1 pt)
does it look/sound tasty/tempting? (yes = 1 pt)
is it something new and/or does it stand out from the other entries? (yes to either = 1 pt)

P:1
all dat burnt shit
A:3
few pizza can ever be below 3/5
C/O:1
is pepperoni, the most unoriginal topping ever
G:2?
is pizza but not sure if dough is homemade. is nothing new

P:2
all dat grease
A:3
looks tasty despite grease
C/O:3
potato and ham are uncommon toppings in most places, but not where i'm from
G:4
is pizza, dough is homemade, but isn't too tempting and is nothing new

P:5
pretty pretty
A:5
tasty tasty
C/O:2
facebook-mom-tier idea
G:5
is pizza, dough is homemade, is tempting and is something different from the rest

P:2
clean, but ain't nothin' there
A:3
C/O:1
pepperoni, nigga
G:2?
is pizza, but not sure if dough is homemade

/P:3
kinda plain but leaves make it look good
A:5
grew up on this shit and love it
C/O:3
not common outside of naples area so it's a bit creative
G:5?
is pizza. while not sure if dough is homemade, corkscrew describes making it so benefit of the doubt. is tempting and is different from the rest

Continued from P:5
looks like a fucking cookbook cover. impressed
A:3,5
crust looks a tad too thin/crunchy for my liking as well as a bit too white but otherwise good
C/O:4
roast pork and broccoli rabe with provolone is my favourite american sandwich but an uncommon combo for pizza topping. coupled with red pepper sauce, it's different enough to be warrant some points on originality.
G:4?
is pizza and, considering mamushka's past entries, i'm guessing the dough is homemade. while it sounds tasty, it's not removed from the norm enough for me to grant the last goal point.

P:2
it looks kinda bad. :(
A:4
i fucking love eating lecso with langos and i bet it'd be good in pizza form, too
C/O:5
it's barely recognisable as a pizza variant but when you take a second glance after being told what the fuck you're looking at, it becomes clearer. very different.
G:3
again, it's barely recognisable as a pizza variant though i'm sure the dough is homemade. and while it sounds tasty and it's very different, it might be a bit too different because it leaves me questioning whether this is pizza at all.

P:3
i can't really tell what anything on it is, but it still looks good
A:4
i fucks with it
C/O:1
without knowing what the fuck i'm looking at and no description at all, i can't even begin to guess what's actually there so can only assume it ain't nothin' new
G:3
is pizza and sounds tasty, but not sure if dough is homemade and without knowing what's on it, it just looks a bit typical

P:3
user gave me wood. with pizza on it. +1 for giving me wood
A:3
C/O:1
pepperoni, nigga
G:2?
is pizza, but not sure if dough is homemade

is there still time for me to make an entry?

Continued from and P:2
looks nice, but is that on your floor? wtf, m8?
A:3
while it doesn't sound very nice to me, sorry, i have to say that...
C/O:3
...the combination of ingredients is very different. woulda been higher had you found a cheese and wine to pair with it
G:3
is pizza, but not sure if dough is homemade. is different enough to get an extra goal point but it doesn't sound too great to me.

P:3,5
nicely taken picture and nicely presented but...
A:2
... it's just storebought crackers with storebought shit on them
C/O:1
it's just storebought crackers with storebought shit on them
G:0,5
it's just storebought crackers with storebought shit on them

P:4
sometimes, when the food looks good enough, leaving it in the pan is a great way to take a pic of it
A:3
looks good, but undercooked
C/O:2
pretty typical, but never thought of gruyère on a pizza
G:3
is pizza but not sure if dough is homemade. it sounds tasty, but it doesn't stand out.

P:4
nice to look at, colourful and extra point for beer.
A:5
sounds good as fuck and looks a lot like a pizza from naples does, but not as burnt. also beer.
C/O:5
never heard of spinach sauce on a pizza, never heard of purple cabbage on a pizza, never heard of this smoked cheese, never heard of pulled garlic chicken. completely new combination of ingredients.
G:5
is pizza, dough is homemade, sounds/looks tasty and it's very new but still looks unmistakeably like a pizza.

Continued from / / P:1
does not look appetising at all. like you already took a bite out of it. and it looks like a pie missing its top crust.
A:1
it just looks bad
C/O:1
hawaiian pizza is a meme and 'go 'za is a meme. meme^meme is not a good look
G:2?
it's a pizza, i guess? but it doesn't look/sound good and i'm not sure the dough is homemade. while it stands out, it does it in a very poor way, sorry.

P:3
like the presliced pic. looks like a fancy pilaf.
A:3
not my thing, but doesn't sound bad. like i said: few pizza can go below a 3 in appeal
C/O:2
combination of ingredients is typical, but combining them in that way is not
G:4
is pizza, dough is [presumably] homemade and stuffed crust + devil's pentagram makes it stand out.

>>
P:0
troll entry
A:2
but i'd still eat it
C/O:0
college dorm tier shit; it's just storebought shit put under a grill
G:1
is not pizza, dough/crust not homemade, stands out in the worst way, and it's not really tempting

P:2
O:1
A:2
G:3
P:2
O:3
A:1
G:3
I don't see how those potatoes could have gone well in a pizza.
P:5
O:5
A:5
G:3
Damn, great job snowman!
P:2
O:1
A:2
G:3
P:2
O:4
A:4
G:5
P:4
O:4
A:2
G:4
This would be a lot better if it weren't for the crust. Still, pretty gud.
P:2
O:4
A:3
G:4
P:2
O:2
A:4
G:2
P:3
O:1
A:3
G:2
P:3
O:5
A:5
G:5
P:2
O:2
A:1
G:3
P:2
O:3
A:4
G:4
P:3
O:5
A:5
G:5
P:2
O:4
A:1
G:3
P:3
O:4
A:3
G:5
P:2
O:3
A:1
G:2

My vote, for the next challenge goes for... OATS, my brother? I am quite famished.

Please disregard my vote for since it was a different entry.

P:2
A:4
O:2
G:5

Sorry mang, but the entries are all already in.
Stay tuned for next month, where all kinds of opportunities await your culinary might!
Thanks for the votes!

Thanks for the votes Dormio!
>Dormio is a pretty good app for sleepytimes

No probs, bobs, it's been accounted for in the Final Reckoning Of Judgement By A Bunch Of Wanglords.

Ottomatic 20/20 for the username

Please go choke on eachother's dicks.

Let's be civil, and not act like a bunch of cunts.

Well, here's my ratings, I noted my rating scale down here just to make it easier for myself. Also my entry in FULL HD because it's so A E S T H E T I C.

Presentation
5 Blogpost worthy
4 Looks nice
3 Looks meh
2 Looks unappealing or bad
1 Looks like shit

Originality
5 Unique in the challenge, and in idea
4 Unique in the challenge or idea
3 Nothing special
2 Boring
1 Original in a bad way

Appeal
5 Delicious
4 Looks good
3 Nothing special
2 Barely edible
1 Disgusting

Challenge goals
5 Fits the challenge originally and with almost everything self made
4 Fits the challenge originally
3 Fits the challenge, nothing special
2 Fits the challenge somewhat
1 Doesn't even fit the challenge

P:2 Looks kinda messy
O:2 Pepperoni pizza, nothing original
A:4 Seems tasty enough
C:3 It's pizza, nothing special though
11/20

P:3 Looks neat enough
O:4 It's something different alright
A:3 Seems tasty, but a bit weird
C:3 It's kind of a weird pizza
13/20

DISCLAIMER: MY ENTRY
P:5 I am really proud of my picture, took some effort
O:4 It's something different in the pizza context
A:3 Expected them to be crispier and juicier, was a bit dry. Could use more sauce and a hotter oven.
C:4 Everything of a pizza but with a twist
16/20

P:4 Looks good
O:2 Pepperoni pizza, nothing special
A:4 Looks like a tasty pizza
C:3 It's pizza, nothing special
13/20

P:3 Looks a bit messy
O:4 Deep fried is pretty original
A:3 Certainly looks tasty, but pretty small
C:5 Deep fried is something original, while still pizza for sure
15/20

P:5 That shit looks amazing
O:4 Original toppings
A:3 Dough looks kinda undercooked and not that much sauce
C:5 Nice pizza with interesting toppings
17/20

P:2 Looks kinda greasy and thick
O:4 Stuffed pizza is something quite different
A:4 Looks kinda greasy but still tasty
C:5 Nice and original pizza idea
15/20

Cont.

P:3 Looks overloaded and messy
O:3 Just a pizza with all the works, nothing special
A:4 Sure looks tasty, especially after a night of drinking
C:3 It's pizza, nothing special
13/20

P:3 Looks decent, nothing special
O:2 Pepperoni pizza, nothing special
A:4 Looks pretty tasty though, bacon is a nice addition
C:3 It's pizza, nothing special
12/20

P:3 Looks a bit messy, nothing special
O:4 Interesting and unique choice of toppings
A:3 Not sure about the toppings, and the crust is very big
C:4 Nice pizza with some interesting toppings
14/20

P:2 Looks pretty shit
O:2 It's different, but not really pizza
A:2 Could be a nice snack, but not that great
C:1 It's barely pizza anymore, didn't do anything yourself
7/20

P:4 Looks pretty neat
O:4 Pretty standard, bonus for not being round
A:5 Looks pretty tasty
C:3 It's pizza, nothing special
16/20

P:2 God that looks like shit, colors are weird too
O:4 Ingredients are pretty original choice
A:3 Eh, ingredients might be a bit off putting, but might be good
C:5 Original ingredients for a pizza, lots of home made stuff too
14/20

P:2 Doesn't look very special, dough looks a bit undercooked
O:4 Deep dish is pretty original, also only one in the challenge
A:3 Could be decent, but not so sure
C:3 Looks more like a pie than a pizza, I guess that's deep dish for ya
13/20

P:5 Looks pretty nice
O:3 Spinach based pizza, pretty nice
A:4 Looks very doughy and a bit dry because of no sauce, otherwise tasty
C:4 Nice pizza with some original ideas
16/20

P:1 Looks like storebought shit
O:1 Just tiny pizzas with cheese
A:2 Looks small and boring
C:1 Didn't do anything yourself
5/20

That should be everything. Quite a lot of entries this month. Looking forward to October.

Thanks for the votes!

Four votes so far, keep 'em coming!

>Four votes so far, keep 'em coming!
But senpai there's so many to vote for!

Also suggesting X ingredient challenge as an idea. (Herbs/spices don't count, premade stuff != 1 ingredient)

I was honestly surprised at the number of entries, figured on topping out at 12 or so.
16 is a lot of pizza, which is a good problem to have.

first time at deep dish. By CAVVY
folded butter layered into made crust
Fresh mozz
homemade sauce

double down entry BY CAVVY
new York style

Sorry CAVVY, but entries ended on the 24th.
Keep that enthusiasm up though my man, next month is just around the corner!

Looks good, bud!
This piece of greasy cardboard, not so much.

I'll keep an eye out!
Could could I still get an informal r8?

I see you have a style you prefer. It was surprisingly not as greasy as you may think.

If folks want to r8, they will.
Thanks though, it's people like you that make me realise why I do this... alcohol.

I'll give you an informal rating

P:3 Looks messy but tasty
O:3 Deep dish is different, but nothing that special
A:3 Looks decent, nothing special
C:4 Alternative take on pizza, still being pizza
13/20

P:3 Looks neat but very greasy
O:2 Pepperoni pizza, how boring
A:3 Looks pretty tasty, but also very greasy
C:3 It's a standard pizza, nothing original
11/20

it's the heat window by the line at my job, not the floor lol

and yes we make dough in house then freeze it

you know it would be cool if you were gonna do this, dont fucking disappear when people were still submitting, you fucked this month up, literal shit show...

This, how were people suppose to submit by the 24th when you didn't have a thread?

You don't owe anyone here anything.
You are doing this out of the kindness of your farts.
I appreciate that.

Also, you made m e cri IRL in life. I'm dorry.

P:2
O:3 buter crust is different
A:3 definitely good or a first try
G:4 not 'za

P:3 only good looking roni pizza
O:2 pretty standard
A:4 looks good
G:5 it's 'za

Nice job, cavvy

My suggestion for next month even though Numbaz said 'i already have an idea for next month lol' is Mexican dishes that do not include any sort of tortilla. Thoughts?

I like this idea but people are going to sperg out over 'muh authenticity', as they already do with every challenge though.

Chocolate chip challenge

Maybe if faggots didn't flood this board with absolute shit like Jack threads, McChicken threads, /mlp/ raids, pointless questions and endless memes, the good threads wouldn't need bumps every hour just to stay on the board.

Mexican-inspired, then? Rather than muh authenticity.
You can shove anything into a tortilla and call it Mexican. I just wanna see typically Mexican ingredients and flavours utilised in non-tortilla ways, is all. Though I think I'd detract points for simply taking typical taco fixings and just shoehorning it onto a bowl of rice or something.

I was away from both computer and phone, so I kind of couldn't post the threads.
Take this well timed bump as a form of consolation.

just quit making threads if youre gonna half ass it

I got back as soon as I could, to continue the glory!

For me the pizza is about the crust. Dough needs to be made at home and hand rolled to get a good thick outside crust. If not it needs to be deep-dish/detroit/sicilian style. These will be the considerations for the goals part of the rating
P:2
A:4
O:2
G:3
A decent looking if uninspiring pizza. But something about it is very tasty looking

P:2
A:3
O:4
G:4
I've heard of doughs containing potato but not so much huge chunks of potato with ham and cheese. what it loses in appeal for that reason it gains in originality

P:5
A:2
O:3
G:3
Great looking dish but if I ordered pizza and got that, I'd be a bit disappointed.

P:4
A:3
O:1
G:3
Can't tell if it's a homemade crust and looks a bit too rich and thick

Rating myself
P:3
A:4
O:4
G:4
Biased of course but something like this is what I want when I think of pizza. Could've been bigger and shot better.

P:5
A:4
O:3
G:3
Would've been the runaway winner for me if the dough was hand-stretched and cooked to a darker color.

P:2
A:3
O:4
G:3
With a better pic and some more explanation might've had a better score

P:3
A:2
O:2
G:3
Not a fan of everything on it pies and with access to a real oven this could've been much better.

P:4
A:3
O:1
G:4
Standard pizza but the crust looks good.

P:3
A:3
O:4
G:4
Too much crust to topping but otherwise a great entry.

P:4
A:1
O:1
G:1
you put in more effort in framing the shot than in making the pizza

P:4
A:3
O:2
G:3
crust looks store-bought and pin-rolled. but too many ingredients on there

P:3
A:4
O:4
G:4
Good work all around. could've presented it better.

P:2
A:2
O:2
G:3
good looking crust is the saving grace

P:4
A:2
O:3
G:3
doesn't work for me from an appeal perspective but ticks other boxes.

P:2
A:1
O:1
G:1

I wanted to enter but the thread was kill, I'll just repost my pics. Don't have to vote though unless you really want to.

Fresh mozzarella with birds eye chilis, ghost peppers in the sauce (also included: fresh garlic, a healthy amount of oregano, dash of cumin and thyme). Extra sharp cheddar on top and salt & pepper along with pepperoni. This one had a lot of green onions on top

after baking

Same sauce etc but this one had the pepperoni on top and far less green onions. Oh yeah, also made the crust from scratch (meant to be thin, very little rising)

After baking.

Fucking delicious honestly. Made the sauce starting with plain tomato puree

Oh yeah that one had some ricotta on it too. Made it nice and creamy.

P:3
A:3
O:3
G:3
dough could've been stretched out better. solid topping choices that work but not really next level.

OP here submissions will run until the end of the month. Thanks for all the participation

Thanks for the votes!
Nice try buddy.

I see multiple anons saying the dough looks store-bought, it isn't though. Granted, it doesn't look that good so it's understandable, but it was maybe the third or fourth time I made one, which probably explains it.

remember that we can't taste what you cook so descriptions of the processes and ingredients you used are important. you didn't say anything about your dough so i couldn't know whether or not it was homemade or storebought. and i never said it was storebought, just that i wasn't sure one way or the other
tbf, i also said that your pizza looked good enough that leaving it in the pan was a great way to present it, so i don't doubt your ability to make something that looks or tastes good, just that i didn't know if your dough was homemade or not

>pepperoni first, cheese on top
finally some who know how it is done!

Thanks for keeping the spirit alive!
Also, I done made a thing.
thrilling-tales.webomator.com/derange-o-lab/pulp-o-mizer/pulp-o-mizer.html

much better than my 4th attempt if that's any consolation. like the other user said, you have to make a call based on description and pic alone.

Better than I could do, good on ya.

I'll give you an informal rating just for posterity. Also, because the thread needs a bump
P:3 Looks nice enough, but rather greasy
O:2 Another pepperoni pizza, not very original
A:4 Looks good, sauce sounds nice
C:4 Just a standard pizza, nothing special, bonus for handmaking everything
13/20

What's next month going to be?
I want to prepare.

Don't worry m8, I'm just clarifying since I forgot to make a good description. And if something doesn't look good, well, that's on me anyways!
Thanks for the appreciation.

Instead of going with the easy pumpkin route, I'd suggest tomatoes. Jersey tomatoes are fucking incredible this time of year and available to most americans. Outside America, I think it's tomato season in most of the tomato growing world too.