Friend of mine does belly dancing and I went to see her show the other night. While eating dinner and watching her and other dancers entertain guests it got me thinking about how completely haram belly dancing must be for Muslims. But then I wondered about Arabian culture other middle east culture BEFORE Islam was a thing. What was it like? I am sure that it wasn't all fun and dancing constantly but it must have been better than in currently is at least. Did women have more freedom and rights? What did the men do? I think the Babylonians were polytheistic, what about other cultures of the time?
Can any history buffs in Middle Eastern history help me satisfy my curiosity?
You made me realize I've never seen a male belly dancer. What the hell is up with that?
Charles Green
holy shit!
absolutely Haram!
Joshua White
You're thinking of it from a flawed perspective of either having or not having certain rights, liberties, and pleasures, when instead the Middle East both before and after Islam was until very recently divided mostly between what was allowed and not allowed in public.
It's not that belly dancing is haram so much as doing so publicly goes against the concept of public morals. In private, most anything goes, and while some Muslim thinkers say various deeds in private are forbidden or discouraged or neutral but not praiseworthy, it's just theory and most Muslim households ran themselves however they liked to run themselves.
Juan Nguyen
that room is definitely full of sweaty throbbing brown choads so is this one
Benjamin Perez
It sounds like Allah is the policeman on the street, and Jesus is the policeman in your head.
Brandon Myers
>a goddamn Paki drag show Thanks. I needed to see that.
Ryder Morales
That's not a bad way to think of a lot of what happened when either Islam or Christianity decided something was unforgivable or had to be upheld without compromise. Apostasy, heresy, agnosticism, and so on are generally not considered crimes in Islamic jurisprudence if it's kept to oneself.
Josiah Campbell
so if i am in Saudi Arabia and in my house I tell my wife to pole dance for me, it's all good?
Alexander Turner
Yes, or at least that's how it used to be. Modern gulf kingdoms and Islamic Republics are a lot more invasive and might send in police to raid and root out any treason/sin.
Blake Harris
Fun fact: Orientalism has memed you into thinking that is the belly dancer's outfit.
Actually it was this.
Liam Gomez
>Fun fact: Orientalism has memed you into thinking that is the belly dancer's outfit. Is she wearing it? Is she belly dancing?
Then it is a belly dancer's outfit.
Michael Martinez
I prefer the meme desu
Jose Ramirez
Yes and no. It's also because something done in private without adequate witnesses cannot be held against you in an Islamic court. So you could privately have homo sex and if there's no witnesses there's no legally punishement and it's officially in the realm of between you and God on judgement day
Leo Evans
user how did you even come across this video?
Carter Cruz
Are Arabs ass-men? Beginning to notice it amongst them.
Julian Fisher
you never see a man unironically twerking, do you?
Evan Sanchez
Women had more rights in Mohameds time than they do in modern day Saudi Arabia.
William Adams
According to polls, apparently pretty much everywhere outside of Europe and east asia prefers ass to titties.
Benjamin Jones
I'm something of an expert on Pre-Islamic Arabia, as in I actually know things about it in a world where people don't even know its a thing.
Arabia was divided between settled peoples who were either farmers around a settlement, or urbanites within a settlement, and then the Bedouin, semi nomadic pastoral tribes people. Though these peoples lived in the same areas and had frequent contact, their cultures were quite different.
Our biggest insight is the Qur'an, it being a reaction to Pre-Islamic Arabia. The settled Arabs were clearly a lot more lax, women probably dressed in a similar manner to Byzantine women, nudity and belly dancing was almost certainly a thing, as the Qur'an being Abrahamic encourages women to cover up (though crucially not a burqa as I'll get to) and not shake their lady parts protectively. The Bedouin Arab women were different, they wore burqas and totally covered up and were not even allowed to be seen by men, we know this because the Islamic tradition of this stems from the Bedouin Arab culture, not the Urban Mecca culture.
It's the same with rights too, though Pre-Islamic Women had very pitiful rights, we know they at least had some, Muhammads first wife was a wealthy widow who owned property and had her own merchant business. However it was common practice to kill female babies on birth because they were undesirable. It seems again the Bedouin women had absolutely no rights, as the majority of reforms in the Quran given to women, such as their right to own property (which must surely be aimed at the Bedouin, as clearly city women could), the right to inheritance and the right to divorce, all seem to be aimed at Bedouin women. In any case, reforms such as these demonstrate that pre-Islam, it must have been a bad deal for women without wealth and influence.
Isaiah Peterson
Kinda true, I guess.
Adrian Martinez
But at the same time western women have the biggest breasts so that may be why.
Jacob Fisher
Truly the master race
Christopher Williams
Again, kinda true. USA is being the retard of the bunch as always.
Jaxon Price
is this Mata Hari?
Lincoln Wright
To be fair, we're only about 60% white.
Andrew James
Ass-uming you are correct, the blue area should have a larger percentage of white people, than the red are.
Justin Russell
>But at the same time western women have the biggest breasts so that may be why.
Yeah you don't know how hard it is to be a man in Norway walking on the beach during the summer holidays. Even women who are not particularly attractive in general have massive mammaries.
Brayden Ramirez
>Norway >beach >summer
Angel Ward
It's fucking warm here m8. 25'C now.
We also have beaches.
Samuel Martinez
Shit, color me surprised. I always pictured Norway a frozen wasteland, kinda like Skyrim.
How's life treating ya up there?
Owen King
Go for her, mate I believe in you
Jonathan Peterson
>I always pictured Norway a frozen wasteland
It is though, most of the year.
>How's life treating ya up there?
Pretty good. How's life in your part of the world?
Hunter Campbell
Great. We're actually not so far apart. I'm from Netherlands - the land of sunny beaches and tropic climates.
Gabriel Flores
That's more of a thing in Central Asia like video is in Afghanistan
If it was so forbidden how did it survive 1400 years under islam also women had significantly less rights before islam. For example they couldn't inherit.
Elijah Morgan
I think literally all of those states are in the top 15 whitest states
Ethan Collins
I'm a chink in Malaysia so i get a dose of islamic history thru curicullum
They actually kinda ignore pre islamic arabia, claiming all is jahillia, where he prosecuted by his own clan, and there are yunani and the arab christian. I'm actually curious on this topic so please continue
Oliver Ward
"Islamic culture" is not a monolith it has basically never been. People would drink alcohol and draw Mohammed at points for God's sake.
Jaxon Wood
Oregon is pretty fucking white and east asian, so what's up with that?
Michael Bennett
You guys all realize Arabs used to be significantly more liberal in their society as whole several hundred years ago as compared to today, right? There's no fucking way Omar ibn Abi Rabi'ah could ever write half the lewd shit he wrote in Mecca anywhere in the modern ME. Nigga literally was peeking out foreign booty at Hajj and wrote about it all
Robert Gonzalez
Omar Khayyam's poetry about drinking alcohol also. Also random assortments of poetry and songs about love, sex and romance.
Carter Howard
Arabia was extremely patriarchal pre-islam. Believe it or not islam made it one of the most liberal socieites on earth at the time, which is where all the "islam supports womens rights" bullshit comes from
Jackson Morales
But Muhammad lived in the 600s. I doubt belly dance was banned in the Caliphate for centuries yet still managed to survive.
Anthony Watson
Oh yes, Muslims love to deny Pre Islamic Arabia was anything other than simple tribesmen. Here is a classic example.
>The most remarkable feature of the political life of Arabia before Islam was the total absence of political organization in any form. With the exception of Yemen in the south-west, no part of the Arabian peninsula had any government at any time, and the Arabs never acknowledged any authority other than the authority of the chiefs of their tribes. >The modern student of history finds it incredible that the Arabs lived, century after century, without a government of any kind. Since there was no government, there was no law and no order.
This is bullshit. Ancient Arabia is a lost land, ignored by most archaeologists, mostly blocked off by the Saudis, we only have glimpses, but the sand has preserved some very obvious things. There were cities all across ancient Arabia, huge cities, huge kingdoms. From what little archaeology has been done shows us these kingdoms lasted centuries, some, like Saba in Yemen, the only one they can't downplay, lasted over 1200 years. These Kingdoms were rich as fuck because Frankincense and Myrrh grow in Arabia, which were widely needed in European pagan religion, so they were sold at a hefty price. Likewise the spice trade from the east passed through Arabia. So Arabia was rich. It was also more fertile back in the day, at least along the western side, we have evidence of large scale farming, and complicated land ownership laws and rights. We also know about the huge Marib dam, such a thing could only be build by large scale organisation. We all know Petra as the famous rock carved city, but Arabia is actually full of cities carved into the rocks, simply ignored by historians and Arabs alike, except for a few.
Austin Adams
Thanks for the historians here who know about Arabia and Islam. It's good to know things weren't always like this..
Jace Johnson
I'm surprised that there aren't many historical sources surviving describing Classical Arabia. You'd think the Greeks and Persians would have a lot to say about the region. We barely know anything about the Nabateans and they were a pretty big deal.
Joseph Ross
You idiots know that's because of obesity, not because there are a bunch of busty petites walking around?
Colton Rodriguez
THIS
Any cow can be 250 pounds with double D's, I like boobs too but a nice firm, nicely ass requires actual work at the gym in must cases, instead of being fed hormones and corn syrup from birth to grow fat floppy titties that start to sag at age 20.
Christian Roberts
*Nicely shaped ass
Justin Wilson
So where was the split between them and Rome? Who banned shota first?
Noah Stewart
Yet the traditional view isn't entirely wrong either. The Quran does mention the existence of these cities and kingdoms, but most tellingly refers to them as ancient and lost. Arabia in Muhammad's time was not the same as it was in Zenobia's time. The kingdoms of Arabia by then had all collapsed, leaving a few generations of anarchy that despised the notion of kings in favor of tribal sheikhs. The only thing that could unite Arabia then was something above the notion of a king, and that was a prophet.
Colton Fisher
No In pre-Islamic Arabia women were second class people just as they are in Islam. They were poor nomads who lived in tents like the Mongols and had little architectural feats except for some clay brick buildings which is what Mecca used to be. They would constantly war with each other and often engaged in raiding and plundering and the defeated side would often leave the women behind. That habitude simply transferred into the Islamic era with maybe a few changes. Even facial and head coverings like the burqa have their roots in pre-Islamic and Semitic culture. South Arabia is a different story but that culture was usurped by the Islamic culture of North Arabian origin . The other exception perhaps is the few Persian and Roman vassals such as the Ghassanids who probably enjoyed somewhat of a more favorable arrangement due to their relational standing.
Ryan Green
Maybe porn doesn't correspond to race.
Jacob Perry
These are the same people who call the west deviant... Jesus Christ