Rape

Did German soldiers raped Soviet women in their way to Moscow?
How common was rape in Soviet concentration camps?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=AnjxckldHuY
youtube.com/watch?v=frSQ9FPG3kM
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_during_the_occupation_of_Germany#Analysis
gegenwind.info/175/sonderheft_wehrmacht.pdf
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_crimes_of_the_Wehrmacht#Rapes_2
phdn.org/archives/www.ess.uwe.ac.uk/genocide/USSR5.htm
youtube.com/watch?v=jXrsSGEvDf4
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

*Nazi concentration camps

Yes, there were cases of mass rapes on both sides. Germans invading Russia and Russians invading Germany.
Depends on who was where, the gulags were essentially opening the window of any form of abuse the guards saw fit.

Wehraboos and neo-nazis love to make a big deal out of Soviets raping German women is East Prussia, and while that was certainly horrible, the Germans committed far more rapes on a far larger scale when they were occupying Russian soil. Don't know anything about rape in concentration camps but I'm sure it happened.

Rape is an unfortunate reality of war, and when you get a racially motivated war like you had on the Eastern Front it really exacerbates the problem. If you've been brainwashed into believing your enemy is genetically inferior or subhuman, it's a lot easier to commit horrible acts like raping and murdering civilians and to justify those crimes to yourself.

Except didn't the Russians rape the same villages and towns that the Germans raped, maybe several years earlier? Not to mention that they mass executed the Partisans which aimed to aid the Soviet forces and destroyed the majority of towns and villages they came across because it was under "suspicions" of Germans and pro-National Socialist movements and the occupants of the towns.

>Did German soldiers raped Soviet women in their way to Moscow?

No, they sent flowers and chocolate.

Speak of the devil.

>be polish
>get raped

The funny thing is some people will unironically claim almost this exact thing.

I've seen people post a picture of a German soldier being nice to an old Russian woman or something and using it to argue that the Germans were perfectly polite to the USSR's people.

The Germans behaved "OK" in the initial invasion, this is where most people get the image of the nice Wehrmacht from. But during the terrible retreats and partisan war behind the lines, the Germans fucked the Soviet civilians up far harder than the retreating Red Army and NKVD did, hence the millions of dead Soviet civilians thing.

Imagine "Come and See" acted out in thousands of villages and you get some idea of what German counter-insurgency tactics were like.

Nope. The jews didn't even bother to make up a mass rape.

"the holocaust didn't happen look at this jpg proving it"

That'd be pretty fucking nasty even by wartime standards. Rapeing a emancipated untermensch sounds pretty disgusting.

I was about to call bullshit until literally proved what you said

All of that in mind plus just the fucked up mindset that a war like that has to give you. Your views of right and wrong would become very skewed. Plus I'm sure it's easy to think "I'll probably die tomorrow, might as well get pussy today."

There are post-war reports about the psychology of the Einsatzgruppen, rear-area units that were in charge of executing Jews, commissars, Gypsies and other undesirables. After the first few executions, many simply became numb. They were able to systematically execute hundreds of people and then play a cheerful game of football with the lads.

Group pressure, delegation of responsibility and military authority can make perfectly ordinary people do basically anything. And what's even more interesting are the self-preservation mechanisms that the brain deploys in such instances.

But how many pics or videos are there of Soviet soldiers being nice to German women?

Practicually none even though they wrote history, yet there is lots for vice versa.

Skip to 5:07

youtube.com/watch?v=AnjxckldHuY

>Plus I'm sure it's easy to think "I'll probably die tomorrow, might as well get pussy today."
If you're some hedonistic fuccboi, yeah sure.

not an argument

So basically WWII was just everyone raping Poland?

...

Well the holocaust is usually "proved" by a bunch of pictures too.

.

>People actually believe this pseudo-intellectual filth
Why am I surprised by this?
Now tell me the one about Dresden being a war crime.

see

History is basically the mass raping of various different countries by various different armies and other countries. In full, almost every political ideology, religious movement, and nation has raped or been raped by another nation, ideology, or religion. So, Germany or Russia, they have been and have raped other nations in full at one point in their existence or another. It is neither unique nor is it to unexpected.

You're the one making the outrageous claim you fucking dimwit, YOU are the one required to provide evidence to support your "argument". Not that there is any evidence in the first place.

Those poor civilians thought the Germans would be fair and even-handed liberators, maybe even giving them independence from Russia. They had no idea of the 3 years of hell that awaited them. Pic fucking related.

Except didn't they incorporate members of these Balkan and Baltic states into their military, including the Schutzstaffel?
I think nearly several million troopers were recruited, even going as far as to having blacks servicing in their ranks. The Germans even aided Estonia and Latvia in their efforts to remove the Soviet forces, even into the later war. Not to mention Finland and Ukraine were against the Soviets as well and worked with Wehrmacht and Schutzstaffel to coordinate attacks and remove the "Untermensch" from their areas. So, technically speaking the civilians that were rounded up for concentration camps from the East and French blocs were partially done so by their own countrymen.

Shit happens in war, but the war crimes committed by the Allies make the Axis look like saints.

Those 3 years you're referring to must be Soviet re-education camps. Pic is probably partisans or killed by partisans. They killed civilians, even their own, that sympathized with national socialism.

Bulgaria, Ukraine, Slovakia, Croatia, hundreds of thousands of Slavic volunteers, etc.. Those Nazis sure forgot to exterminate a lot of them. Any educated person can deduce the "Untermensch" is just a load of Allied bullshit.

The SS and their foreign volunteers were far from the only ones massacring and raping. Not that any of this can be used to justify the massive war crimes and outright attempted extermination the Wehrmacht committed in the USSR.

All those German losses still don't even come close to those experienced by the Soviet Union.

>Those 3 years you're referring to must be Soviet re-education camps. Pic is probably partisans or killed by partisans. They killed civilians, even their own, that sympathized with national socialism.

He says based on nothing at all.

I guess the fact that conquerors always use native auxiliaries means they always consider them their equals, huh?

Funny thing about pic related, is that The Greatest Story Never Told actually brings up the Croatian massacres of Serbs. Is that just pseudo-intellectual filth? It simply doesn't hide the massive amount of crimes committed by Partisans as well.

>Germany lost almost 25% of its population according o this bullshit document that you probably made

Well, most of the Schutzstaffel's premiere objective was to eradicate the Jewish inhabitants of the East and West bloc.
>Those Nazis sure forgot to exterminate a lot of them.
Most ideals in politics meets a moment in which realism and idealism separate. Idealistically, Adolf Hitler viewed a majority of Slavs as untermensch based off of their governmental choices and phenomenons occurring in the East bloc when Adolf was writing "Mein Kampf." However, when countries like Romania, Estonia, Latvia, and various other segments of Ukraine and so on offered to aide the German movements into Russia, Adolf Hitler was realistic in accepting and giving military power and relief to them, during the war. So, realistically the Germans were rather accepting of Slavs into their societies and military. Idealistically, they were not considered "high enough" to be equated with a German. But that is considering idealism over reality and what happened.

>All those German losses still don't even come close to those experienced by the Soviet Union.

That's because the USSR valued the lives of their soldiers less than they valued the bullets they shoot.

>I guess the fact that conquerors always use native auxiliaries means they always consider them their equals, huh?

You were told 4 independent countries that Germany didn't invade, that choose to ally with Germany, that the Allies would have you believe Germany wanted to exterminate.

I'd add on to this by reminding that Soviet war crimes came out of a place of retaliation against some of the most brutal oppression imaginable. Most Soviet soldiers had relatives who were slaughtered by the Germans. Their crimes were horrible, but we as modern Westerners are in no position to judge their reaction against genocide.

>The Greatest Story Never Told
holy shit

>Is that just pseudo-intellectual filth?
Yes. The Ustase were some of the most savage and inhuman people who ever lived, even the Germans who saw their crimes acknowledged this.

I'm sure some Polish women were raped by both sides, but Red Army rapes were mostly against German women in modern-day Poland.

>The SS and their foreign volunteers were far from the only ones massacring and raping.
You are correct, except I never made mention of the foreign volunteers or legions making the moves to eradicate the civilian populations. The matter was that the local nationalists and pro-national socialists aimed to aide the Germans and would often times vary between revealing local partisans to unveiling hideouts used by both Soviet and Jewish escapees/refugees. So, the local population would easily aide the Schutzstaffel and it was not uncommon for local nationalists and national socialists to work with the Schutzstaffel in rounding up civilians accused of being Jewish/socialist/ect.

>That's because the USSR valued the lives of their soldiers less than they valued the bullets they shoot.

Unlike Nazi Germany, which valued its soldiers' lives so much they refused to allow them to retreat or surrender when hopelessly outgunned.

Anyway, the USSR lost like 27 million people. Not even half of those were soldiers.

>you were told 4 independent countries that Germany didn't invade

>Germany didn't invade Czechoslovakia (Slovakia wasn't an independent country until the Germans invaded and carved it out of Czechoslovakia as a puppet state)
>Germany didn't invade Yugoslavia (Croatia wasn't an independent country until the Germans invaded Yugoslavia and carved it out as a puppet state)
>Germany didn't invade the USSR (the Ukraine wasn't an independent country until Germany invaded the USSR and carved it out as a puppet state. And even then it wasn't even nominally independent)

Gee, I wonder why Nazi puppet states would ally with the Nazis.

Except didn't the Soviet kill random civilians who had nothing to do with the invasion or the outcomes of the war?
Taking regions back from the Wehrmacht they essentially raped and pillaged the surrounding towns and villages. Going to Berlin and Poland, they pretty much enslaved them and took them into submission, raping and/or killing them because they were German, Estonian, Latvian, ect.

Both sides raped because every side in every war rapes.

Not the Unsullied

Slovakia was created before Germany invaded Bohemia and Moravia. They were given the option of either declaring independence and gaining German protection, or letting Poland and Hungary divide them. They chose the former, quite understandably.

>Going to Berlin and Poland, they pretty much enslaved them and took them into submission, raping and/or killing them because they were German, Estonian, Latvian, ect.

Not only did this not happen on any large scale, the GERMANS are in fact the ones who did quite a bit of enslavement and deportations. Their entire fucking war economy was dependent on slave labor imported from captured territory.

Is this a defense?

What the hell kind of a choice is that?

>become puppet state
or
>get annexed
wow great choices provided by the nazis

The point is they were crypto-fascist and separatist years before Hitler even got to power.

Yeah, except the Soviet Union was as well. Neither country can claim absolute innocence as they both slaughtered and raped the opposing sides women and killed numerous amounts of them. In reference to the number of opposition from the countries they took down, they were still experiencing massive wartime killings and rapes, which involved civilians who had little to do with the war at all, even after the Third Reich had been destroyed.

>mfw I discover patient zero for wehraboo-ism

Are you pretending you're arguing against a single person?

Wouldn't surprise me, you same-fagging nazi piece of shit.

I'm not a nazi at all.

Are you the same guy who posted this:
I am guessing based on the amount of swearing involved into a comment on a random chat forum online...

Furthermore, I made these two posts: and What mental gymnastics did you employ in order to become convinced I'm a "nazi" or a "wehraboo"?

It has been a back and forth argument between holocaust deniers and pro-Soviet pushers.

The whole point of this discussion was about war crimes and it is such a muddied line as to "who did what" that it just becomes dribble after awhile.

>Did German soldiers raped Soviet women in their way to Moscow?

Can't rape the willing.

>The first time Culler escaped, in May 1944, he and two companions got lost and nearly died of exposure in the mountain forests along the Italian border. In excruciating pain from the bleeding scabs on his feet, and so sick from accidentally eating poisoned berries that he could barely walk, Culler returned, by himself, to Adelboden on the same train that he and his companions had taken south to Bellinzona, the largest city on the Italian border. “The most amazing part of my escape was that I had traveled more than five hundred miles on the Swiss public transportation system, and not one time was I ever questioned or asked for any identification.” One of the reasons was that he had been passing through the Italian, not the German section of the country, where the police were more vigilant. A report from the Swiss Commission of Internees and Hospitalization, issued after the war, offered an additional explanation. “We did everything we could to prevent the escape of internees. Unfortunately, our efforts were hampered by the fact that a large part of the population felt honor bound to help internees escape in any possible manner.”

>After reporting to the commandant of Adelboden, Dan Culler was sentenced to ten days’ solitary confinement in the Frutigen jail. His companions, he learned later, were caught by Swiss border guards and imprisoned. After serving his sentence, Culler was taken to a high-security punishment prison called Straflager Wauwilermoos or, in English, “punishment camp at the swamp of Wauwil,” a village near Lucerne. Culler was never told why he was sent there, or for how long. As he passed through the gates of the prison, his military guard whispered to him. “I’m sorry to bring you to this hellhole. Watch your every step. There are some awful men in here, and you are so young.”

>Wauwilermoos was a closely packed compound of mud-splattered barracks surrounded by a high barbed wire fence and patrolled by guards with machine guns and attack dogs. Built in 1941, it was a disciplinary camp for lawbreakers and escapees among Switzerland’s ballooning population of military internees from nearly a dozen countries. To run it, Swiss authorities could not have chosen a more odious character. Capt. André-Henri Beguin, a former officer in the French Foreign Legion, was as corrupt as he was cruel. At the time, he was under investigation by Swiss authorities for adultery, bribery, embezzlement of prison funds, spying for the Germans, and unlawfully wearing a Nazi uniform (while living in Germany before the war he signed his correspondence, “Heil Hitler”). Grossly overweight, he rarely entered the prison grounds, preferring to run things from behind his desk, where he was occasionally entertained by one of his four mistresses, and where he could conveniently confiscate aid packages mailed to inmates. The officers he appointed were as coarse and corrupt as he was. They treated us “like scum,” said Eighth Air Force bombardier James Misuraca. “The Swiss called this a punishment camp but it was more like a concentration camp.”

>When guards shoved Dan Culler through the door of Barrack Nine he nearly passed out from the stench. Every Indiana barn he had ever been in smelled better than this place. The wooden floor was covered with filthy straw, which the prisoners slept on and used for toilet paper after they vacated in the miasmic slit trench just outside the front door.

>“What happened to me that night, and many more to follow, was the worst hell any person ever had to endure,” Culler wrote in his searing prison memoir. A group of Russian prisoners held him down, stuffed straw in his mouth, and sodomized him repeatedly. “Coming from a small farming community, I never heard of men doing to me what they did. I... hadn’t even been with a girl, except to hold her hand and give her a light kiss on her cheek or mouth. I was bleeding from all the openings of my body, and I prayed to God to take my life from me.”

>He was raped again the next morning and forced to have oral sex with several of his assailants, who stuck sticks in his mouth to pry it open. After being knocked unconscious, he awoke to find blood running down his throat. Too weak to move, and with his hands tied behind his back, he was thrown into the waste ditch outside the barracks. “When I finally came to my senses, I crawled from the ditch and tried to wipe myself with straw. I noticed something was hanging from my rectum, and realizing it was skin from the inside, I tried to push it back in.”

>A few hours later, Culler staggered into Beguin’s office, screaming uncontrollably. “They all stared at me as though I [was] some kind of freak, and a sort of nasty grin came across their faces.” For the first time in his life, this son of a Quaker minister found himself cursing at another human being. But no one understood him, no one spoke English. Tiring of Culler, André Beguin stood up and pointed toward the door with the riding crop he always carried. His guards promptly tossed Culler out the door. Lying facedown on the dirt path, Culler prayed that the free-roaming guard dogs would finish him off.

>Within days Culler’s entire body was covered with boils from the lice and rats in the feces-contaminated straw. The rapes continued and became more violent. He began to vomit blood and an unknown yellow substance, and he developed chronic, bloody diarrhea. When a British sergeant major visited the camp to check on the English prisoners, Culler asked him why the Red Cross had not come to inspect this place, why he was being held without trial, and why had the American military attaché in Bern, General Legge, not been informed of his imprisonment? On a later visit the sergeant major told Culler that he had intervened on the American’s behalf to the British authorities in Bern but had been told that General Legge refused to believe that the Swiss had a place like Wauwilermoos, and that his official position was that if an American airman tried to escape, he should be subject to Swiss punishment. In Culler’s mind, the country he fought for was abandoning him, and Switzerland, the nation that was sending Red Cross representatives to monitor conditions in German prisoner of war camps, was not interested in visiting a medieval-like holding pen less than a hundred miles from the Red Cross’s international headquarters in Geneva. “There isn’t any abuse [at Wauwilermoos],” an International Red Cross inspection report noted, “but on the contrary strict control on the part of the commandant of the Camp.” There was “iron discipline,” said a Swiss major who looked into conditions at Wauwilermoos, but this was “necessary.” And Beguin, he added, was the “dream man... to direct a camp of this type.” The officious Swiss officer concluded his report with the highest praise he thought he could offer. The camp documents, he said, were “kept in perfect order.”

Post more like that please.

>When Culler was finally taken from Wauwilermoos and given his day in court, he discovered that Swiss justice was a mockery. The military court proceeding was conducted entirely in German, and when it was over, Culler was handed an English translation of the transcript. He would be sent back to Wauwilermoos without medical treatment and for an unstated period of time. The transcript did not contain a single word of his oral testimony describing his rape and the conditions inside the prison. The final indignity was a bill Culler received for 18 francs—compensation for the court’s time and trouble.

>Back in prison, Culler was tormented by a loud ringing in his ears—the result of beatings suffered at the hands of the Russians. They had been transferred, but sitting alone in a corner of the barracks, wrapped in a thin blanket, Dan Culler felt he was losing his mind. “The last I remember at Wauwilermoos, I was acting like a madman, trying to stuff straw down my throat so I could not breathe.” As he began to lose consciousness, he heard the British sergeant major shouting orders at two Swiss guards who were trying to revive him. “After that everything went black.”

youtube.com/watch?v=frSQ9FPG3kM

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_during_the_occupation_of_Germany#Analysis
>estimates of the numbers of German women raped by Soviet soldiers have ranged up to 2 million.
>According to historian William Hitchcock, in many cases women were the victims of repeated rapes, some as many as 60 to 70 times
>According to Natalya Gesse, Russian soldiers raped German females from eight to eighty years old.
> Female deaths in connection with the rapes in Germany, overall, are estimated at 240,000.

This is what happens when you conscript a bunch of filthy, poor and uneducated slavs and sic them on a civilian population.

>This is what happens when you conscript a bunch of filthy, poor and uneducated slavs and sic them on a civilian population.
what does that make the germans then, seeing as they had committed rape on an even greater scale

I see no proofs of this so far
They certainly did a lot of murdering but it is hard to beat the Soviets during the mass rapes of '45.

>swastika
>bloated numbers
Sure thing.

not much better

>on an even greater scale

yeah I'm going to need a source on that though. It seems that Russian rapes during the later days of the war are much more well documented with actual figures and numbers.

>The Greatest Story Never Told
>documentary
>facts
ahahahaha

>whitewashing war participants in any way

Stop being such a slavaboo. If you're not interested in facts, then you may fuck off from this board. History isn't a superbowl.

ebin :D
here's one: gegenwind.info/175/sonderheft_wehrmacht.pdf
the wehrmacht itself estimated about a million troops born as a result of rape on the eastern front
now it's time to go back where you belong

Soviets deported like a third of the baltic population to concentration camps during and after the war. Read some history commie.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_crimes_of_the_Wehrmacht#Rapes_2

>In the Soviet Union alone an estimates regarding the rape of Soviet women by the Wehrmacht range up to 10,000,000 incidents, with between 750,000 and 1,000,000 children being born as a result.

Furthermore, rape was not punishable in the operation barbarossa regions by fuhrer decree of may 13. So you can imagine the nazis had jolly good fun with the women there.

phdn.org/archives/www.ess.uwe.ac.uk/genocide/USSR5.htm

You thought wrong

>one picture

WTF! I love nazis now!

>Unlike Nazi Germany, which valued its soldiers' lives so much they refused to allow them to retreat or surrender when hopelessly outgunned.

The USSR literally sent positioned soldiers to shoot other soldiers if they so much as turned their heads around.

Exept soviet troops at end were from rest of country far from frontline and they were fueled by propaganda.
Also they often didn't care where Germany begins and may take "revenge" on other nations like Poland. Not to mention actual liberation of land conquered weren't far from those nasty crimed aimed at Axis countries.

>I watched Enemy at the Gates so I think I'm an authority on the Eastern Front

That wasn't near as common as certain media would have you believe.

The Soviets killed off Partisans, members of other resistances which even aimed to assist the Soviet Union, though. The matter was that the Soviets were almost as nasty as the Schutzstaffel and did plenty to kill off civilians and members of their newly "liberated" societies that were "suspected" of being alongside the Germans. Not to mention that a fair amount of Eastern Europeans did not want to be made victim to the Soviet Union and resisted, nations like Latvia and Estonia.

Never watched it, unlike you I don't learn history from media. According to the media Stalin was good ol' Uncle Joe, the mass killings and oppressive dictatorship were never mentioned.

Parlons du fond du coeur de la vérité vraie du monde
Depuis toujours c'est les vainqueurs qui violent et qui fécondent
Pour dire "On a baisé vos femmes on est les leaders génétiques"
La domination animale, ce vieil instinct archaïque...

Why is it in French?
Anyways, here is my response (poorly translated)
Oui, cela est certainement une raison pour laquelle il y a eu tellement d'agression sexuelles dans l'histoire, cependant, garder à l'esprit que des multitudes de cultures ont fait de tels actes pour diverses autres raisons. Certains effectué cet acte à la naissance d'autres enfants dans leur pays, alors que certains ont utilisé pour manipuler une société dans la soumission mentale, ainsi que politiquement et socialement.

>germans killed by jewish commanods
strictly apolitical post

That poor hohol at the end though

Its lyrics from a semi popular Song, I thought it was relevant.

This looks like it should be the opening to a sitcom.

youtube.com/watch?v=jXrsSGEvDf4

yep. that's what the movie the reader was about.

The Germans had it coming.

When you invade and wipe out a native population, referring to them as subhuman scum, what the fuck do you expect would happen when the shoe's on the other foot?

I'd even go so far as to say that no act was more crucial to the breaking of Germany's back than the absolute obliteration of Nazi pride by the Soviets.

poor pooland

Wie gefällt es dir jetzt, Polak?

>>In the Soviet Union alone an estimates regarding the rape of Soviet women by the Wehrmacht range up to 10,000,000 incidents, with between 750,000 and 1,000,000 children being born as a result.
t. Soviet Ministry of Propaganda

So basically WWII was just everyone raping Poland?

As a Hungarian, this bothers me a lot.