What can car makers and engineers do to keep manual transmissions competitive in the modern day Veeky Forums?
It used to be that it took more skill to be a good competitive driver because you had to have the skill to operate a stick shift. Manuals used to get better mileage, were cheaper and easier to repair, and most importantly faster than the slushboxes of old. Now any old fart can be just as fast as you just by pushing a pedal. Skill, motor coordination, and quick movement are no longer rewarded.
How do we go back to the good old days for vehicles?
Jason Lopez
You're confusing skill with habit.
Austin White
Why do you think there is such inconsistency in quarter mile times with manuals depending on the driver? Some people can just shift faster and smoother than others. Automatics are much more consistent.
Colton Carter
>driving a car in a straight line >skill
Brayden Murphy
>How do we go back to the good old days for vehicles? We don't. The future is inevitable. Accept it.
Noah Jones
Yes driving requires skill and experience numb nuts. Not everyone can be a drag racer or track racer.
Asher Diaz
>Self driving cars >Self flying air vehicles >Teleportation >Brain encased in a robot connected to the hive mind
OR
>Collapse of western civilization
Dam future
Justin Thomas
>Yes driving requires skill and experience I did not deny this. >Not everyone can be a drag racer literally anyone can with a deep enough wallet.
Oliver Watson
they should just let manual die and not waste money
Cameron Bell
>What can car makers and engineers do to keep manual transmissions competitive in the modern day Veeky Forums? Why they automate them and have a pair of input shafts with a clutch on each. There's your modern day competitive manual transmission. With all due respect, I don't think you have any fucking idea how bracket racing works.
Justin Parker
>Why they automate them and have a pair of input shafts with a clutch on each. There's your modern day competitive manual transmission. Explain
Liam Hall
Bracket racing or not, the idea is the same. Drag racing is the final destination of cars, in that people think by stripping away all elements of the game that the skill will shine through, but instead highlighting the players' inability to cope with and adapt to changing elements.
Jose Long
>skills >to operate a stick shift Is this what bad drivers actually think? That they are somehow special for being able to move a gear stick and operate a clutch?
Ryder Rodriguez
He's probably referring to the practice of rev-matching which I guess does require an element of skill if you want your blips to be perfect.
Regarding racing, it doesn't make a difference since they all eventually end up on a sequential gearbox
Aiden Young
He's talking about a dual clutch transmission, which has even and odd gears on separate shafts and based on what the car is doing (accelerating and approaching red line or decelerating) it will determine whether to rev match either the higher or lower gear is anticipation of when you tell it to shift. For instance, if you were accelerating in 2nd it would ready 3rd gear on the odd shaft but it wouldn't be engaged because the clutch for the odd-numbered gear shaft isn't engaged, when you press the shifter it disengages the even-number shaft's clutch and engages the odd-number shaft's clutch which is a much quicker process than operating a "stick shift" manual. The driver operates with paddle shifters(as opposed to a clutch pedal and stick shifter) and there is usually also an automatic shifting mode.
Ryan Harris
The only way to make a manual transmission faster is it to automate it. If you were to engineer that trasmission to be faster than a automatic, then you would simply end up with a dct.
Hudson Williams
Since you're so good at it, go wow them and become a top fuel drag racer. Prove us wrong.
Jace Cook
Why would I burn so much cash to prove I can drive stick in a straight line?
Jeremiah Moore
If you're so good they'll pick you up just for being good shitfuck
Benjamin Price
I'll bracket race you for pinks at your local strip.
The bracket racing part COMPLETELY removes the fact that my car is faster than yours from the equation so you don't have to worry about the bigger wallet winning.
Evan Thomas
Actually they can because automatics are faster than the human mind.
Grayson Richardson
>He believes brackets are 100% accurate Kys
Zachary Johnson
I knew you'd pussy out.
Ryder Perry
Race me in a formula car, only true way to determine driver skill
>bbbut I can only press the skinny pedal and hold the wheel straight! Exactly as I tho8ght
Jaxson Baker
You said drag racing involves no skill, don't try to change the subject now pussy
Matthew Clark
>Drag racing is the final destination of cars, in that people think by stripping away all elements of the game that the skill will shine through, but instead highlighting the players' inability to cope with and adapt to changing elements. Literally what the fuck are you talking about? As was explained, a computer controlled transmission that functions with constantly meshed gears, shift forks and clutches. As opposed to hydraulic pressure, clutch packs, crushing disappointment and planetary gears.
Jason Collins
>He believes brackets are 100% accurate What the fuck are talking about? Literally dial in your own index.
Cameron Wright
>no corners >no racing lines >no downshifts >foxbody only >final destination
Lincoln Phillips
Which doesn't counter anything said.
Anthony Richardson
Competitive shouldn't be the goal. DCTs are objectively superior in every aspect except cost. The goal for a car sold as a manual should be fun and driver engagement.
Samuel Thompson
except for the assertion that drag racing requires skill.
Julian Murphy
Which doesn't counter the argument that success in bracket racing is nothing but skill. Whether or not it involves the arbitrary tasks you've brought forward.
Camden Price
You're just pretending to be retarded, right?
Robert Bennett
>Which doesn't counter the argument that success in bracket racing is nothing but skill. Bracket racing IS nothing but skill, because the quickness of the car is eliminated. All you need to win bracket racing is; >Know your car >Know how to drive it consistently (launch the same every time, shift the same every time, know when it's going faster than the dial in and thus when to let off just a bit) >Know how to time your launch by the tree perfectly literally all are skills you cannot do without skill building (this thing called "practice")
Kayden Cox
Bracket racing with a manual transmission is hard.
T. motorcycle drag racer.
Grayson Martin
Yeah, I'm agreeing. I presume you simply linked the wrong post. My kettle isn't black m8.
Kayden Davis
>What can car makers and engineers do to keep manual transmissions competitive in the modern day Veeky Forums? Nothing.
Some companies (BMW, Porsche) will always cater to enthusiasts with a variety of RWD and manual models offered along with their insistence on using outdated engine layouts (straight six and flat engines). Others (Honda, Ford) continue only to offer manual on some performance models (Civic Type R, Fiesta ST, Focus ST and RS) solely because it suits the character of the vehicle.
Forget about lap times, and 0-60 times, and instead focus on enjoyment. Do you drive a manual vehicle, user? Do your friends? Are they interested? Show them that your piece-of-shit $3k Honda Civic can be fun when you're revving its guts out like a boyracing nonce.
The burden of keeping manual transmissions relevant is not on the automakers, but on enthusiasts.
Julian Peterson
Chicken strips pls
Chase Martinez
Nah my drag bike has a slick on it and I spend more time on my 636 carving the mountain roads than you spend on Veeky Forums.
Evan Richardson
Manuals can never be faster because the human hand can't shift faster than those computers shifting at like 0.08 secs.
>The burden of keeping manual transmissions relevant is not on the automakers, but on enthusiasts.
Nice trips. I was thinking along the lines of innovations like "Active Rev Matching." You can turn it off if you want the traditional experience of driving a stick but it's a feature that you can turn on if you want that competitiveness. It's a small step to keeping manual relevant because you just put it in a gear and the engine automatically keeps the right rpm for not only a quicker shift but also much more smoother. Also, stick shifters with a shorter throw so the movement is quicker and feels tighter. Surely there are other innovations to be made assuming the engineers want to. I think a nice technology that can be developed is making it smoother and easier on the car if you want to dump the clutch. And making it easier for mechanics to access the clutch if it needs to be replaced instead of having to drop the entire drive shaft and tranny. Technology like line lock allows manuals to have easier burnouts. Just a few example ideas.
Connor Barnes
>What can car makers and engineers do to keep manual transmissions competitive in the modern day Veeky Forums?
Give us 8-gear transmissions for ultra-efficient highway driving.
Sebastian Scott
>Technology like line lock allows manuals to have easier burnouts They sold Mustangs with line locks and a burnout mode here but road safety losers had a whinge about it and they made Ford take the burnout button out.
I think they still came with the line lock installed but we've been smoking rubber without issue since time immemorial. I doubt it's stopped anyone from ripping hectic skids.
Ryder Rivera
Nothing. 99% of sportscars are not bought by actual racing drivers to be used on actual race tracks in actual races for monetary prizes. Manual is just more fun than automatic. Plain and simple. It's competetive too, because you're talking about a few hundred millisecond difference between manual and automatic. Only on upshifts since downshifts occur while braking into a corner and have no effect on you unless you fuck up and upset the weight shifting.
You may be a benchracer with an automatic that shifts in 0.08 seconds but so what, you'll still get rekt by a guy who knows how to drive in a civic.
David Barnes
This would be cool. I know the corvette has 7 gears and the 7th gear is probably even longer than 6th. It would help if I want to cruise at 80,90,100 mph at 1500 rpm