Started last week, just finished everything. Here's my blog:
>>FUN-TIER
>WARRIOR
The writing was good all around, and serves as a good counterpart for the KOTOR 3 feeling the Knight had. There was something amusing about the fat Darth throughout the story. The companions were great, even the AYYLMAO scum. I wish the kind of care put into Jaesa was present in other companions.
>AGENT
I hate the Agent only because it shows how much potential the shitty non-Force stories could have been. Meaningful choices, engaging plot, and that ship is fucking sexy. Meh companions.
>>NICE-TIER
>INQUISITOR
I was able to overlook the pokemon collecting with the political intrigue going on. Overall it was a pretty fun story, and really satisfying to finish each chapter and move on to the next. Enjoyed all the companions.
>KNIGHT
I get why people call it KOTOR 3. Good at showing Jedi-Army relationship, and the plot was pretty neat. Loved the feisty Padawan, but the rest of the companions can get spaced.
>>SKIP TO CH3-TIER
>CONSULAR
Story was dull in comparison to the other Force users, it's definitely the bottom of the four. I liked how it shows the other side of the Jedi, the more peaceful, less warmongering side. Bland companions.
>SMUGGLER
Like a J.J. Abrams movie; cliché one-liners to cover up missing plot. I liked that you could remain neutral throughout the run, though I couldn't betray the qt togruta at the end. Companions were amusing and somewhat interesting.
>>SPACEBAR-TIER
>HUNTER
The entire storyline is just killing generic NPCs. Even the final climatic ending was killing a generic guy you never met. It wasn't even that satisfying to kill him; the only excitement came from knowing it was ending. Companions were pretty neat though.
>TROOPER
The worst, and I like military stuff. You're either literally repeating the same 'Yes, sir!' lines or a psychotic criminal who somehow evades the law even after murdering a Senator in public. Companions lacked depth.