So for some time now I've been discussing with a friend on the origin of countries. Frankly the fucker hasn't budged an inch and literally states the following countries were founded by nords.
>Britain (ok I can see this one being right but still) >france >Italy (lol) >Spain (wut?) >Russia >Fucking TUNISIA lmao >Baltics (including Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania) >Ukraine
He reasons simple invasions = an entire culture shift. Is this true in regards to the following nations?
*pic unrelated*
Liam Williams
Maybe Russia and Ukraine can be counted for Kievan Rus being founded by Vikings. They haven't done more than pillaging in the rest.
Brandon Gray
Yeah but it helps to have sources on why he's wrong.
Parker Sanders
>britain they got violently expelled frome england and borderline genocided >france wat literally wat >italy there was like one nord in sicily with a title >spain lol >russia the tsars were descendants of rurik, a nord, but that's about it >tunisia i want whatever he's having >baltics no maybe estonia if you really stretch it >ukraine just no
Blake James
Your friend is a moron.
The reason he lists Tunisia is probably because he doesn't know the difference between Vandals and the Nords.
Xavier Wilson
At the moment his current reasoning is Germanic = Nordic therefore vandals = nords
Dominic Allen
North Germanics have (probably) had a hand in the emergence of the following historical states: >Britain >Russia >Ukraine (both Kievan Rus') They have played a large role in the history of the following: >Baltics >France (Normans) And East Germanics (Goths, Burgundians, Vandals, Alans etc.) have founded kingdoms in the following countries: >France (Burgund) >Italy (Ostrogothic Kingdom) >Spain (Asturias) >Tunisia (Vandal Kingdom, stretched over Tunisia, Algeria and mediterranean islands)
I hope this has been helpful.
Logan Sanchez
So what is the difference between Germanics and Nords? Or is there none? And how much influence would you say they have over those countries today?
Colton Cruz
Nords denote Scandinavia, Germanic is a massive family.
Crediting Nords for states like France or Britain would be like crediting Italy for the Spanish colonizing South America.
Alexander Lee
He's getting Germans and Nords mixed up.
Alexander Kelly
I assume he means kievan rus
Adam Brown
Polish-Lithuanians (including Letts) and Finns/estonians are more or less the same people as Scandinavians. Russia and Ukraine were both founded by Swedes (modern finnish word for sweden = "Ruotsi", land of the rowmen) and of course there is some similarity between parts of the populations, these are big countries with differing influence however.
Jaxson Clark
goths came from sweden, afaik they weren't overtaken in italy after the conquest of western rome, britain is self-explanatory, russia and ukraine from rurikids
tunisia is just dumb as they were driven out, though they could be responsible for the idea of tunisia as a nation, same goes for the balts
William Barnes
About Estonia: With the fall of Rome and the period of migrations in the early Early Middle Ages resulted in a decline in the level of culture and prosperity in Estonia. People were more concerned with survival than wealth in 500AD. With the beginning of the Viking Age changed this. With vikings establishing contacts and trade routes which went right by island of Ösel and the coast of Viru. This brought the estonians into the influence of the cultural and economic network of vikings. A few of the companions of Rurik have estonian names. Ösellians adapt the longship and become renowed traders and raiders. Lennart Meri makes a case of that-famous-arabicish-explorer-describing-a-funeral-on-the-Volga of them being if not estonian then nearby finnourgics. By this time the local situation has also recovered and estonians contribute to the trade and the kaupang system as well by exporting iron and weapons and fur with commercial production. No viking jarl establish themselves in the territory, though raids agains neighbors are common. In the 11th century Rus manages to conquer the fur exporting region but is driven out after a few decades by a concentrated effort by the other counties.
>Spain - Goths >Tunisia - Vandals Vandals left Tunisia and most of them returned to modern day Poland.
Not sure about Spain-Gothic connection, since Goths were R1a carriers.
Michael Stewart
Regarding Latvia, no.
Latvian tribes (4 of them) were a thing long before the teutons came.
Did their own raiding/warring, trade etc. The Germans then came, invaded and pretty much united the 4 Latvian tribes by force. Nords had no part in this,in fact we BTFOd ths Nords a couple of times
Elijah Morgan
And you are mixing Germans and Germanics.
Andrew Ramirez
I can tell you about Finland, he's somewhat right about it.
Finland was a province of Sweden until 1809 when Russia took it over. For some reason the russians gave it autonomy and kept the existing swedish laws in place, basically creating a mini-Sweden inside Russia. At that time like 20% of the population of Finland spoke swedish and they made up the upper class. Fast forward 50 years and nationalism finds its way to Finland. Funnily enough it was the fennoswedes who first started embracing it, many of them changed their names to finnish sounding ones and started speaking finnish in their daily lives. If you look at the most famous finnish nationalist artists you'll find out that almost all of them spoke swedish as their native language.
Jace Gray
what kind of autism is greater corsica?
Matthew Hernandez
Ukraine and Russia was both Rus, user.
Kayden Clark
>Polish-Lithuanians (including Letts) and Finns/estonians are more or less the same people as Scandinavians. Look at this and say it again, I dare you. Poles are already different enough from Balts, and Finns are even more different from Balts, while Scandinavians are further divided from them.
Cooper Clark
>haplomemes
yaaaaaaaay
Connor Ross
Nords are native Norwegians or native speakers of the Norwegian language. Germanics are the ethnicities whose native languages are Germanic languages. That is West, East and North Germanic languages. Northmen, Norse, or North Germanics represent the North Germanic branch. They have historically had sway in the countries we listed, but they don't have any influence there anymore. Everything else is a matter of population genetics. Yes, and in eastern Germany and other parts all over Europe. I only listed the countries that OP spoke about.
Mason White
So at least you could say that Germans (which OP's friend seems to include in his understanding of """"nords"""") erected the first state on Latvian soil when they founded the State of the Teutonic Order?
Adam Russell
An official state, yes. The monastic state of the Livonian order, something like that.
But the Germans called the 4 Latvian tribes as duchies/kingdoms and the chiefs as kings (rex) in their chronicles.
Ryan Cox
let me rephrase that
there were official states on Latvian soil before as well, but they didnt have the name Latvia in it. This name only appeared after all of 4 tribes assimilated each other forming one entity.
Brandon Rogers
I wonder why did Germanics differ so much in genetics. Some of them carried l1, some of them R1a and most of them R1b.
Seems like almost entire Europe is Germanic.
Anthony Allen
Because R1b=/=germanic and R1a=/=slav
Christian Peterson
for
Jordan Stewart
They were both present in Germanics though, in some cases at really high frequencies.
Ethan Harris
so hol up where the hell did the germanics come from if they weren't all fucking nords? oh wait, nords are the germans bitch if you're not of nordic descent you're not european.
what about the viking invasions huh? also fuck you butthurt romaboo, you're the nords bitches
even byzantium was cucks to the nords, their armies were so shit they had to hire vikings as the emperors guards fucking read a book mudslime
Cameron Bailey
You're fucking retarded if you think germanics = germans.
Logan Torres
>Nordic >Aka Easterlings >European
Daniel Scott
For Tunisia is he talking about the Vandals? Because they weren't nords, they were Eastern European, not to mentionany semblance of a society they had got wiped clean with the Arab conquest
Cameron Parker
no bitch germanics are literally nords, where the fuck do you think they migrated from dumbass? oh wait thats scandinavia isn't it?
Daniel Martin
vandals are germanic dumbass
they literally migrated from scandinavia
Aaron Diaz
Don't look at Ireland
Xavier Young
No they didn't you retard. The earliest records place them in Poland and there's no way of knowing that they started there
Ayden Taylor
prove it to me then bitch
Aaron Ross
>Britain (ok I can see this one being right but still) well, there were some Viking influences and Normans founded "modern" Britain even though they were more French than Viking >Italy (lol) your lol is premature, they had a rather prosperous kingdom on Sicily >Italy (lol) >france >Spain (wut?) >Fucking TUNISIA lmao calling Lombards, Franks, Visigoths and Vandals Nods isn't quite correct >Russia >Ukraine yes, however Early Kievan Russia = Ukraine, later Muscovy Russia had more in common with Tatars >Baltics (including Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania) they had some influence, not sure how big
David Johnson
you can tell your friend that he is just a norse version of a weeaboo. which makes him norseboo?
he is on the same level with "we wuz kangz", "milady", "turks are the true hyperboreans", "russia is the continuation of the Roman Empire", etc
Luke Watson
Is that some shit map from /gsg/ or something?
Elijah Taylor
>The Vandals are believed to have migrated from southern Scandinavia[2][3][4] to the area between the lower Oder and Vistula somewhere in the 2nd century BC, and to have settled in Silesia from around 120 BC >believed Just like people call them "german" despite them being genetical ancestors of modern Western Slavs.
Gabriel Collins
Not to mention that names of the Vandal rulers mean nothing in German, yet have a meaning in Slavic languages.
Noah Moore
>believed to have migrated from southern Scandinavia Why do so many peoples com from Scandinavia? It seems like every 200 years a load of people migrated from there and those left behind started reproducing for the new wave.
Luis Ramirez
This is a probably a bait thread fir some retarded purposes, but alright, I'll bite;
ALL of the WRE was taken over by germanics that established kingdoms there during the 5th and/or 6th centuries. Italia, Galia, Hispania, Britania and North Africa. The origins of modern European countries can be traced back to when they stopped being a province of the Roman Empire and became their own separate thing under these Kingdoms.
As for Russia and Ukraine, the origins of Rus are related to the merchant activities of Varangians sailing down the big russian rivers and aiming at Constantinople, that eventually evolved into a more sort of political nature, networking and mixing with the local slav population and producing the first russian states, the most relevant early one being Kievan Rus.
Caleb Long
Correct, but Russia became a thing in 1500s
Robert Howard
For Spain it is the Visigoths for Asturias, and Goths of unknown origin (vassals of the Franks) in the case of Catalonia (Gothalaunia)
Levi Cooper
hmmmm
Joshua Kelly
really made me think
Lincoln Anderson
Where do you think the East Germanics came from if not from the Germanic urheimat, i.e. Denmark and southern Scandinavia? Nobody calls them German. They never were German. They predate the very concept of Germans. They are East Germanics. It is no surprise that they are ancestors to Western Slavs, because they lived in the same area at some point in time. Do you have some examples for that?
Parker Anderson
Jordanes mentions during the 5th century three Gothic kings, apparently living under Hunnic rule, called Valamir, Thiudemir and Vidimir. These names are quite odd, as the first two almost certianly translate to Walamar and Thiudemar. The last seems odd in the normal Germanic naming scheme. Unless the letter "n" was left out and it actually read Vindimir. In that case it would translate to Wendemar, and the three kings would have names meaning famous Celt/Roman, famous German and famous Slav.
Isn't "mir" slavic for peace or world? Or is it only in Russian borrowed from Goths? Whatever the history is "Vidimir" have a slavic vibe.
As for Vandals. Their names that mean nothing in Nordic languages, mean a lot in Slavic languages, like Visimar, are germanized Slavic names (Visimar - Widzimir "sees the world" or Radagaisus latin version of Radegast "happy to host")
Isaac Murphy
>Isn't "mir" slavic for peace or world? Or is it only in Russian borrowed from Goths? >Whatever the history is "Vidimir" have a slavic vibe. That's all just folk etymology. Modern Russian does not exist for one and a half millenium after the Vandals left Poland. The name of the Vandals themselves derived from the place they came from, Vendel in eastern Sweden. It is cognate with German "wandeln" and English "to wander".
Jaxson Rivera
>Nords denote Scandinavia "Nords" is not a well-defined term, it could mean germanic scandinavians or it could even just refer to norwegians
>so hol up where the hell did the germanics come from if they weren't all fucking nords? it is true that the germanic urheimat is assumed to be scandinavia so in that sense this shows how OP's friend could be right in a way
>oh wait, nords are the germans bitch ???
>if you're not of nordic descent you're not european. what does that "european" mean to you? the concept of europe was invented by the greeks and all indo-europeans are in a way immigrants to the continent (if you define identity over language)
Blake Sullivan
>The name of the Vandals themselves derived from the place they came from, Vendel in eastern Sweden. It is cognate with German "wandeln" and English "to wander". Exactly.
And you know how Germans called Western Slavs? Wends, meaning Wanderer as well.
According to Gregory of Tours, Vandals returned to their homeland.
Mason Ross
>Brittain Anglo-Saxons >Italy Lombards >France Franks >Spain Visigoths >Russia&Ukraine Kievan Rus >Baltics Teutonic Order and Swedes >Tunisia Vandals
The only one he's deeply wrong about is Tunisia, because the Vandals were destroyed by the Romans and Later Muslim rule has nothing in common with the vandals.
Andrew Wilson
Current East Germany was populated by Slavs. Over time they got mostly germanized.
Jose Reed
Not that guy, but i guess you could say that. Also the name Latvia appeared only much later on, and Livonia incorporated both what is now Latvia and Estonia in a single state, yet they are separate countries with separate national identities today.
Camden Martin
The name Livonia was assigned to the whole land because the first people the germans encountered after landing were livonians.
Chase Ross
But those "slavs" didn't really come there from Ukraine, like the Germans tried to manipulate.
They were native to this land.
Jackson Wood
Vendel got its name from the river, which was named simply for its movement - it was called "one which wanders". Wends, in turn, derived from the Latin term Veneti or at least from the same PIE root: *u̯en-, 'to strive; to wish for, to love'. It is cognate with the name of the goddess Venus and the German name component or for friend.
Cameron Barnes
Some people believe that Vandals were the same people as Veneti.
Andrew Jenkins
Brits >Conquered by the Normans (from Norway) The Frogs >Conquered by the Normans Italy >Ancient mosaics display blondes and statues are painted blue eyed with blonde/red hair. Same with Greece. Spain >No clue mate, maybe because the Gailic, Gothic, Celts and Vandals had all made that place their home at one point. Russia >Nobles I guess... Predominately slavic though Tunisia >I know very little about Tunisia Baltic States >I know they were developed a lot in the middle ages by german merchants (particularly Estonia), but I have no clue about Nordic interference.. Makes sense because they're close to the Swedes Ukraine >No clue
Elijah Sanders
>The Frogs >>Conquered by the Normans "No."
Brandon Ortiz
I suppose the frogs just had to relinquish Normandy to them.
Bentley Hall
.
Nordicist memes die hard apparently.
Jaxon Scott
But that's the opinion of a small minority. With a good reason.
Justin Myers
That's what I'm saying. East "Germans" are actually germanized West Slavs, which is why their haplogroups are closer to Slavs than West Germans.
Parker Butler
So wait, most of Europe is nordic or germanic? Wouldn't that mean OP's "retarded" friend was corect and you're all wrong?
Asher Anderson
Balts -> Latvia contained may different tribes, one of these tribes Curonians in 8th-12th century raided pretty much Sweden and Denmark coasts.