What exactly is the soul meant to do? What would demonstrate the presence of a soul, or lack thereof? Is it art, advanced tool, or something else?
The Function of the Soul
Thomas Robinson
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
plato.stanford.edu
twitter.com
Christian Gray
The soul is etched in a human being, even a brain dead person would have one. A lack of a soul in a human would mean that the body expired. It's sole purpose is to give immortality to humans.
Cameron Morgan
...
Kevin Gutierrez
...
Anthony Jones
Can't demonstrate the presence of something that doesn't exist.
Leo Nguyen
>What would demonstrate the presence of a soul, or lack thereof?
A clear falsifiable definition would help get the ball rolling.
Evan Nelson
The soul is consciousness, or the overall "rhythm" of activity in a living system the cessation of which means death (Aristotelian definition)
Jackson James
Fuck off.
Anthony Diaz
Here's the hard truth. I've read the origenal philophical text that talks about the soul. What these people were actually trying to describe was brain function. In other words "soul" as it was origenally concieved is covered by neurology and science.
The early philosophers assumed the brain had an existence outside the body because they noticed certain information was known without being learned. Something today we would call "instincts" or "subconscious".
The reason that we still beleive "soul" is some magic thing is because certain religions promise an after-life.
Jaxson Morales
this board is a slightly less retarded /b/
Nolan Torres
how can atoms create sentience?
Jeremiah Torres
What stops them from?
Sebastian Stewart
Look in a mirror dumb ass.
God you empirical types are fucking morons. Do you believe you are incapable of having 'fun' because there is no atomic structure to 'fun'?
Juan Bell
>What would demonstrate the presence of a soul, or lack thereof?
Divine inspiration...
Adrian Hall
Empiricism is the exact philosophy that calls "the soul" into question, as it finds no evidence for such a thing.
Daniel Carter
Either you didn't follow the discussion or you are the most retarded person I have ever seen on this board.
Oliver Fisher
...
Jordan Ramirez
...
Christian Roberts
...
Aaron Jackson
Body and soul problem is the same problem as the physical and mind problem.
> It's sole purpose is to give immortality to humans.
You are a dreamer. Wake up! It´s time to get to work.
Connor Anderson
...
Cooper Stewart
The 'hard truth' ladies an gentlemen. Thank god this good gent is here to educate us because they have, by good fortune, read "the original philosophical text" that talks about the soul. And they were able to translate this text into talk about about neurology. Whew.
Robert Brown
Also - the soul and the afterlife are not always found together philosophically or religiously so I literally have no fucking clue why you would suggest that the only reason we believe in souls is to justify the afterlife. Seriously questioning how well you read that one text.
Henry Cook
You are your soul; your soul is wearing this temporary body and commands it via your spirit.
How can you be a soul, and not know it?
Lucas Nelson
The problem is this one:
>what is the relationship between thoughts/ feels/ sensations/consciousness/qualia/mental states, and the physical, objective world of matter/brain/body.
The answer to the question is materialism or mind/brain identity theory:
>states and processes of the mind are identical to states and processes of the brain.
Owen Stewart
So not only do we have no idea what a soul is, but now we have to also figure out what exactly a spirit is.
What a quagmire.
Jaxson Reed
By that definition, the E coli that causes the UTI my dumb sister got from wiping back to front has a soul.
Dominic Sanchez
The soul is the physical source of personal awareness. It is a monad with an informed nature. It's nature is one of self-referential knowing : You know that you know.
The brain is a means of imbuing the soul with energy. That is why the two are so related.
Our Spirit is the awareness of God.
Justin Scott
That doesn't explain anything.
Connor Murphy
think, feel, speak, see, hear, cognize, will, act, perceive, discriminate, imagine etc
Luke Gomez
All of society is on that gradient.
Xavier Brown
The soul is the struggle between the abyss and the consciousness, as described by Nietzsche.
As you discover and learn more about the origin of mankind, its (lack of) divine nature or mission, your own insignificance in the grands scheme of things, it becomes harder for you to justify doing anything. The soul here is the instrument that prevents you from falling into depression, as it helps you lie to yourself that you matter, humans are special and each inherently valuable, and there is a great continuity in our lives, it all culminates in an ultimate victory we all contribute to, etc.
Nolan Thomas
That is, the soul is a defense mechanism, an evolutionary trait that was installed to make sure we are both smart, and not suicidal and depressed.
Elijah Long
>tanzania
Recent findings show that people come from Thrace, aka BULGARIA
Matthew Taylor
>Thrace, aka BULGARIA
Thrace is in Greece, Turkey and Bulgaria (for now), not just in Bulgaria.
Sebastian Howard
Given that the soul is, according to Aristotle's theory, a system of abilities possessed and manifested by animate bodies of suitable structure, it is clear that the soul is, according to Aristotle, not itself a body or a corporeal thing. Thus Aristotle agrees with the Phaedo's claim that souls are very different from bodies. Moreover, Aristotle seems to think that all the abilities that are constitutive of the souls of plants, beasts and humans are such that their exercise involves and requires bodily parts and organs. This is obviously so with, for instance, the abilities for movement in respect of place (e.g., by walking or flying), and for sense-perception, which requires sense-organs.
Nicholas Lee
It explains enough.
All conscious beings should have a soul.
The difference in humans would be that the awareness is capable of being directed at itself. Self-awareness.
Hudson Mitchell
>the soul is a defense mechanism against suicide
99.9~% of the common conceptions of the soul are specifically contrived to make the idea of death more palatable
David Lee
>The soul is the physical source of personal awareness.
If it is a physical source should it not be detectable empirically?
>The brain is a means of imbuing the soul with energy. That is why the two are so related.
Why is the soul not extraneous? Couldnt awareness simply be a product of the brain
Justin Jenkins
It could be a kind of dark matter, not directly interacting with matter besides the brain. Hypothetically one could be able to detect it in the brain as it manifests its free will.
Well, as a matter of investigation one should question the plausibility of the brain, but it has so far not produced the answers we are looking for. The soul is a simpler solution to an age old dilemma.
Brody Sanders
>It could be a kind of dark matter, not directly interacting with matter besides the brain
What do you mean by dark matter here and isnt this introducing a pretty complex solution rather than the simple one you talk of?
>Well, as a matter of investigation one should question the plausibility of the brain, but it has so far not produced the answers we are looking for
Do you think it can never provide those answers?
How would you question the plausibility of the soul?
>The soul is a simpler solution to an age old dilemma.
As your first sentance shows it raises even more complicated ones about the nature of reality.
Do you think something should be true because it is simple?
Connor Ross
kek..
There is. Its called dopamine, endorphin, adrenaline etc.