Why were so many leading communists jewish?
My history teacher told me that jews would lead revolutions because they lived in ghettoes and were poor.
But i looked up German-Jewish red revolutionaries and majority of them were very wealthy and well educated.
Other urls found in this thread:
vocabulary.com
twitter.com
Post this on /pol/ and don't come back
Why do you think kurds/blacks/natives are overrepresented among communists in the middle east/murrica/latin america?
Jews were a minority (minorities are overrepresented among communists), urban (urban people are overrepresented among communists) and more educated (educated people are overrepresented among communists). That being said, they were nowhere near as overrepresented as /pol/ pretends.
>Persecute Jews continuously for 2000 years
>Commit multiple genocides against the Jewish people
>durrrr why they want to overthrow gubment?
8 out of 14 main communist leaders in Germany were jewish.
But the jews involved in German revolution were not the poor opressed ghetto jews.
See i used to think that jews were opressed and fought back to get put of poverty.
But all these people were wealthy intellectuals.
Let's see top three
>Liebknecht
>Ulbricht
>Thälmann
How many of them were Jews?
Antisemitic laws affected all jews.
Liebkinecht had jewish parents and was a jew.
Kurt Eisner-jew Paul Levi-jew Karl Radek-jew Eugene Levine- jew Gustav Landauer-Jew Ernst Toller-jew
What antisemitic laws?
Anti semitic laws were in effect when Hitler rose to power.
Jews were not persecuted before that and had no reason to revolt.
>Liebkinecht had jewish parents and was a jew
And the stormfag pathological lying begins.
I meant antisemitic laws through history. If you bother reading the chain of posts, it started with some user saying ""Persecute Jews continuously for 2000 years".
His wikipedia page says that he was jewish.
Also he looks like a jewish stereotype.
Why would you lie about shit people can check in two seconds?
Name the laws that were in effect during early 20th century Germany.
No more jews making excuses for centuries ago like they do with Palestinians
>name something nobody said existed
Great argumentation tactics.
If you were not lazy and had an open mind you would see that i am correct
So revolting for something that happened centuries ago is a legitimate reason?
Seek help.
>Liebkinecht had jewish parents and was a jew.
So much for your credibility.
Also how the fuck are those Jews of yours more relevant than Honecker, Mielke or Brandler?
Lol these Jewish surnames are hilarious. Lieb, of course, means love or loves in German, and knecht means servants! It's like they think they're literally god's chosen people.
It's not about reasons, it's about understanding motivations. There's no anti black legislation anymore in murrica but blacks are still overrepresented in extreme egalitarian ideologies. Do you think that is unrelated to slavery and racial segregation?
History is not about justifying people. Unless you are a stormtard, of course.
They are no more relevant but 7/14 prominent leaders that i mentioned above being confirmed jews is too big of coincidence to ignore.
They're the ones he read about in a /pol/ infopic.
You ignored Levi, Rosa Eisner and others.
You are just being intellectualy dishonest
>arbitrarily pick people
>call non-jews jews
>wow! so many jews!
:^)
Oh yea, fucking Honecker was no more relevant than random theorist like Landauer. Totally no zhidpicking on your side.
Reasons matter. If jews were not opressed their revolutionary movement was not noble.
It was a fraud and motivated by greed. Similar to modern black rights activists who only fight to obtain more money out of suckers
Revolutions are usually carried out by Intelligentsia groups, and since Jews are usually overrepresented among Rich people they tend to have intellectual roles
>Ignores 7 people
>2 of them have levi in their names
Intellectually dishonest revisionist
/POL/ PRIDE SITE WIDE
41/99 MACE THE MIMES SPACE WAR NOW
LE MAGA PRAISE ST. KOK AND DONALD TRUCK
DOG BLESS OUR LORD JIZZASS CRAIG! DEUS CULT!
>Similar to modern black rights activists who only fight to obtain more money out of suckers
Have you got one shred of evidence to substantiate that claim?
I only agreed with you.
You said that blacks are not opressed so they must be greedy and exploiting the past.
Can you stop spelling oppressed incorrectly, you fucking pollack?
Go read a book, shitforbrains.
I am not Polish.
I am half jewish Ukrainian.
>It was a fraud and motivated by greed.
Does not follow from your premise. Communist kurds/blacks/jews/natives thought they were fighting for a humanitarian cause that benefited humanity as a whole. They are/were wrong. If you turn the people you dislike into some unidimensional cartoon caricature that represents evil you are refusing to understand history.
That's not me. Also, you seem to have hallucinations.
It was about freeing the humanity, not only the Jews.
>19th century nationalism, Jews are people without a country
>communists preach a new world without borders claiming that the real struggle is between classes, not between nations
It's not hard to realize why these ideas attracted educated Jews.
Another idea appeared in 19th century that was very popular among the Jews. Much more popular than the communism. It was Zionism.
Why would jews fight for entire humanity?
What did jews do after conquering Russia in 1917?
As a half jew to a pure bloded one stop lying. You are the reason the people hate us.
>Why would jews fight for entire humanity?
They weren't fighting as jews, they were fighting as communists. The same way nazis, social democrats, and everyone else thought they were making a better world. And you can find jews in all of those groups.
>What did jews do after conquering Russia in 1917?
Imaginary history.
>As a half jew to a pure bloded one stop lying.
As a non jew to a /pol/tard, stop being a retard and open a book.
> What did jews do after conquering Russia in 1917?
>jews conquer Russia in 1917
>jew Trotsky is denied power
>when Lenin dies, non-jew Stalin takes power
>massacres jews in the party and elsewhere
>creates SR for jews in the far east with a gay coloured flag
What a strange plan for world domination, isn't it?
>oh I know I'll just call him a Jew that's a great argument
Neck yourself
a thoroughly oppressed group of people who were constantly expelled and displaced from their countries finds their way into a political party which, using it as a political tool, espouses acceptance and revolution for acceptance.
"B-but this was a world conspiracy!!!"
consider the position of the jewish people in tsarist russia and you will understand that this was not a conspiracy of any kind. most of them were athiests and didn't give a fuck about their roots, they were persecuted because historically they were jewish. orthodox christianity has always hated jews, that allowed pogroms against them pretty much 24/7 under the tsar.
and even after the revolution, they didn't "control" the soviet union. stalin took over. and then stalin officially implemented a "socialism in one country" doctrine, which means he didn't give a fuck about world revolution anymore because it failed everywhere else.
and to the naysayers who will claim "There's a reason they were displaced! They're EVIL!" that's just reading directly into propaganda, they've always been a scapegoat. being a scapegoat for the entirety of europe and having no economic stability will lead you to specialize so people value your skills more and there's less of a chance of state-sanctioned brutality against you and more protection from the churches in your area.
I assume you meant to quote someone else.
You assumed correctly
>Don't ask questions about history
I'm not a poltard but this shit is just cringey. Just shut him down with evidence instead of doing your high tower bullshit
presume*
Overwhelmingly the problem Europeans had with the Jews was that they followed a different a religion. They share a central holy hook, the Old Testament, but the Jewish interpretation is totally different.
I'm not a native english speaker, why would assume be incorrect?
>Assume and presume both mean to believe something before it happens, but when you assume you're not really sure. If someone bangs on your door in the middle of the night, you might assume (and hope!) it's your crazy neighbor. If your neighbor knocks on your door every night at 6:30, at 6:29 you can presume she's coming over in a minute.
vocabulary.com
Jews are the most privileged demographic in human history and yet we're obliged to pretend they're the most oppressed.
it wasn't even just europe that hated them.
>
>If jews were not opressed their revolutionary movement was not noble.
Noble? Jesus, what are you, fucking 12?
Do you claim that Jews never did anything to deserve being kicked out of their respective host country?
I'm just wondering, because it sounds as generalising as saying that they were always at fault for the shit they presumably did or not did.
Dhe look south italian
Plenty of Jews do.
Ever looked at Italian vintage porn?
Try and spot the Jew or Italian.
Read one claim that said they intermixed for a long time with them
Or maybe they are south italian converts
Hebrews are long gone and these jews do not have hebrews blood, they claim they do because they have right in israel
Yes, also heard about that.
Also something about refusing to dna test Solomons tomb. No clue if true or not.
>My history teacher told me that jews would lead revolutions because they lived in ghettoes and were poor.
Your teacher is full of shit, poor people don't start and lead revolutions, the middle class does and all the Jews in the Russian Communist movement were middle or upper middle class, just as with the American Revolution and French Revolution and every other revolution.
Dumb poor people don't have the education, time or money to be revolutionaries, they're too busy busting their ass 16 hours a day.