Why is prophet Muhammad holding a Book, was it not The Recitation, an unwritten Qur'an in his lifetime...

Why is prophet Muhammad holding a Book, was it not The Recitation, an unwritten Qur'an in his lifetime? Image is not Ali ibn Abi Talib.

Other urls found in this thread:

quod.lib.umich.edu/k/koran/browse.html
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

I thought Muslims aren't allowed to depict him.

It's Ali

Fuck off jackass.

Image search:
>best guess: prophet mohammad
I dunno, it´s just a guess. Why is it not Mohammed? Why is it not Ali?
But overall, it shouldn´t be Ali either. I guess I am sitting with fellow history nerd who know that it was first around the year 750 that the book was written down.
Ali should had been dead by the book was written down

Beats me user.

Allah said, "Depict him; Depict him everywhere."

Peace be upon him.

Why do those Shia Persian devotional images display their subjects like they were stoned?

As far as I can tell, no other religion does that, including Catholics, the Orthodox and Hindus.


That's not Muhammad either. Pic related.

Were there ever paintings or images of him? When was the rule made that he could not be depicted in image?

There must have been something drawn during his lifetime, right?

>Why is it not Mohammed?
"Muhammad's the author of the Koran; he wrote it, and he's holding it.
Everyone noticed the fuck-up so now the Big Lie is that it is not him."

"Peace be upon them."
~ Allah

>Why is it not Ali?
"Ali ibn Abi Talib did not write the Book;
Muhammad did. See his Book in hand."

"Peace be upon them."
~ Allah

...

It's likely not Mohammed for two reasons. First, there's the writing at the top; 'No God but God and Mohammed is his messenger'. Taken out of context this might suggest that the depiction is actually Mohammed, but if we think about it it's probably just making a point of Ali's lineage and his holiness.

Second, he's holding the Quran, which according to traditional Islamic scholarship wasn't compiled into one book during Mohammed's lifetime, although parts of it were written down. The first definitive Quran was supposedly written during the reign of Uthman, so earlier than 750, and interestingly he ordered all previous copies to be burned, implying that the Companions already had Qurans of their own that they'd written down themselves. This was especially the case for Ali, who some muslims believe already had his own version that he refused to burn (which could be the one he's holding in the picture)

Why does he look like a faggot?

You don't actually think that image was made any earlier than the 21st century, do you?

Both were alive when the book was NOT written but it was an oral tradition.
Damn muslims, can never get their own history right.

>Were there ever paintings or images of him?
Absolutely. Muawiyah I destroyed them in AD 666.
>When was the rule made that he could not be depicted in image?
Cover-up and the Big Lie began in AD 666.
>There must have been something drawn during his lifetime, right?
Absolutely. Destroyed in AD 666.

>"Muhammad's the author of the Koran; he wrote it, and he's holding it.
>Everyone noticed the fuck-up so now the Big Lie is that it is not him."
Obviously meant the so-called fuck-up.

Muawiyah I, the 6th Caliph,
1st in Umayyad Caliphate.

>Why does he look like a faggot?
Ali was an excellent artist.

>You don't actually think that image was made any earlier than the 21st century, do you?
Ali made these portraits.

SOURCE MOTHERFUCKER.

...

All praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the Worlds.
The Beneficent, the Merciful.
Master of the Day of Judgment.
Thee do we serve and Thee do we beseech for help.
Keep us on the right path.
The path of those upon whom Thou hast bestowed favors.
Not (the path) of those upon whom Thy wrath is brought down,
nor of those who go astray.
Those having Ali portraits of Muhammad shall inherit
the Paradise; they shall abide therein.

Allah, the Beneficent, the Merciful

>Ali was an excellent artist.
So he was actually a faggot

...

It's symbolic, same reason why the book is glowing with cosmic energy, why he has a golden aura, and why the sky seems to be tripping acid.

Someone holding a book like this generally symbolizes a knowledge or law bringer.

How many times do I need to report you to the FBI and to Homeland Security for promoting that vile terrorist Muhammad? piss be upon him. That fucking pedophile is a terrorist! Fuck Islam! Fuck all muslims! I hate all Muslims! I hate Islam! I hate Pisshammad piss be upon him!

Haha! O, you can't make this shit up! G-D

Haha! O, you can't
make this shit up!

G-D

libtards btfo

Shias don't really care that much

this but unironically

Islam is a false religion created from Christianity, Judaism and various pagan elements of the middle east. Mohammed was a savage warlord from the desert that waged war across the Saudi peninsula and brutally executed hundreds of people himself. Islam is a barbaric war cult that has no place in Europe or the rest of the western world.

>false religion
>false
>religion

as opposed to?

Baby steps. One step at a time.

>post about Mohammed
>pic of Ali
>"that's Ali"
That happens everytime, is it an inside joke?

ya Ali

That's Ali.

This is a modern meme, there are plenty of historical depictions of muhammad

Yes. Absolutely.
They are not Ali.

Tabernacle under Stonehenge

1. Moses said, "I wrote The Five Books of Moses:
Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy."
2. Jesus said, "I wrote The Five Books of Jesus:
Gospels Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, and Revelation."
3. Muhammad said, "I wrote The Holy Qur'an:
quod.lib.umich.edu/k/koran/browse.html "
4. G-D said, "Give these Authors their Due:
Dig up the Heelstone and unearth Mishkan."

YHWH Allah
(LORD God)