Are cultural and economic Marxism mutually exclusive positions?

Are cultural and economic Marxism mutually exclusive positions?

Other urls found in this thread:

marxists.org/reference/archive/adorno/1944/culture-industry.htm
youtube.com/watch?v=1VEZImfFCTU
youtube.com/watch?v=Tsgc0k594Js
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

Define the terms "cultural Marxism" and "economic Marxism".

[spoiler]I somehow think it's gonna be the expected bullshit from /pol/, but there is a tiny chance you might not be a retard.[/spoiler]

Well economic Marxism is like equality with money. Cultural Marxism is like equality with rights and representation.

Just read Marx
Start with "The Critic of the Gotha Program" for an overview
Both of those concepts have nothing to do with Maxism

Cultural marxism is literally rebranded 'cultural bolshevism' namely nazi propaganda

Stop thinking like that political compass chart.

HERE IT GOS BOIS ANOTHER MARX THREAD

There is no such thing as 'cultural Marxism'. Take two seconds to think about the term and you will realise it's fucking retarded.

Equality with rights and representation is a liberal, not necessarily original Marxist idea. Nazis are against those things which is why they brand them cultural marxism.

...

Also Marx's thesis is that everything in society is derived from economics so calling something economic Marxism is redundant

The absolute state of his

There was a glimmer of hope

...

There is, it just has different meaning than the meme. It's about criticizing the influence of capitalism on culture. Hillariously enough you'll see bits of it recycled by modern reactionaries who claim to fight against "cultural Marxism".

>marxists.org/reference/archive/adorno/1944/culture-industry.htm
inb4 anyone gets rustled jimmies, it's translation of Adorno

Nigga do you even understand the implications of your statement? You realize you're basically saying that the founding fathers fought for a Marxist nation?

I'm going to go out on a limb and wager that O.P. is an American asking if somebody can be socially conservative but believe in left-wing economics.

>falling for the "everything i don't like is marxism" meme

I hate when the terms left and right are applied to economics.

It's very close to not making sense. I mean, it does, but only barely. There are many different schools of economics. The whole left-right false dichotomy, I am glad to say, cannot really be applied to economics.

Cultural marxism isn't the same as a marxist analysis of culture.

>theodore "if you disagree with me on literally anything then youre a fascist" adorno

this meme point you faggots do where you try to pretend "he was totally just like you guys!" is fucking retarded. Because all your excuses and deflections and talking points aside, at the end of the day, you and all other modern marxist support this shit. If any of you voiced ANY opposition to any of this SJW shit in front of a group of left wingers, you would be dragged off the stage and everyone here knows it.

Not OP but I'm an American who supports socially conservative values while at the same time supports Marxist economics. There's absolutely nothing wrong with this position, social and economic values don't often intersect. The only thing is that if you try to explain your position to anyone normie Republicans will call you a Democrat Commie and normie Dems will call you a Republican Nazi, soley because Americans don't understand politics.

>soley because Americans don't understand politics.
this. the main thing I come across is people who bitch about how much they hate liberals while extorting the greateness of the founding fathers. Like that stupid 3% militia that gets its name from the fact that only 3% of colonist fought in the revolution, even though a quick google search will reveal that it was the most popular war proportionally in American history. I basically hate anyone that goes on about the constituion, but knows nothing about it other than the first two amendments.

Wasn't Marx part of those people?

Marx spoke favorably of the American Revolution (and Civil War) for what it's worth.

>I basically hate anyone that goes on about the constituion, but knows nothing about it other than the first two amendments

>treats constitution as sacred and unchangeable for perpetuity
>favorite parts are 2 of the amendments

Just checking is Marx still alive?

He was when the Civil War happened.

Which one?

Yes in the sense that economical marxism exist while cultural marxism doesn't.

>cultural marxism doesnt exist
youtube.com/watch?v=1VEZImfFCTU

youtube.com/watch?v=Tsgc0k594Js

Are you going to stop repeatedly posting the same thread?

Neo-Marxism is a new branch of Marxist throught by Antinio Gramsci

What you’re posting in the pictures are just liberal shills with their identity politics

fuck off lefty /pol/ the correct term is Judaeo-bolchevism

>Jews rely on capitalism for power
>communists want to destroy capitalism
>communism is Jewish
???

>not having your cute loving Jewish wife teach you 4d chess
>not following her to cabal meetings and laughing at how much they confuse the goyim with 4th dimensional reasoning
Never going to make it.

Marx wanted to destroy Jews as an ethnicity and kicked feminists out of the party. "Cultural marxism" is about as relevant a term as "alt-right". Like the latter, it's a made up term assigned to an opponent to decredibilize him.

>i-its just liberals! I swear!
>still wont stop shilling this stupid shit.

>you and all other modern marxist support this shit
First, I'm not a Marxist, second vast majority of commies doesn't support it.

It literally is, by definition.

>second vast majority of commies doesn't support it.
sure thing chief. Are you trying to convince us or yourself?

>Cultural Bolshevism (German: Kulturbolschewismus), sometimes referred to specifically as "art Bolshevism" or "music Bolshevism", was a term widely used by critics in Nazi Germany to denounce modernist movements in the arts, particularly when seeking to discredit more nihilistic forms of expression. This first became an issue during the 1920s in Weimar Germany. German artists such as Max Ernst and Max Beckmann were denounced by Adolf Hitler, the Nazi Party and other right-wing nationalists as "cultural Bolsheviks". The propaganda term persisted after such art forms became disapproved of in the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin as bourgeois, in favor of the more realist-orientated aesthetics of socialist realism.

There are also funnier -bolshevisms, like the "Sexual Bolshevism".

El goblino strikes again...Remind me again, what are the world's strongest Marxist parties?

Cultural marxism doesn't exist. "Economic marxism" is just marxism.