Who has tried no fap, only edging?

Everyday? How long do you edge?
Sounds pretty retarded, like you don't want to give up porn or something. I bet you've spend hours edging, wasting your time. Obsessing over girls, feeding your brain a constant stimulus. Wtf, dude!
Time would've been better spend reading a book or meditation.

Bro I always do this, but I never last more than a week no cum. I've fucked some shameful bovines because of it. And just feel shitty in general cos losing no fap. I'm going no porn from tonight try it with me bruv

couple of hours per day usually, it feels about as good as fapping and cumming desu

It's retarded, you don't gain anything out of it and you're giving your brain constant dopamine. It's not nofap not even close.

It's retarded. The point of nofap is not watching porn, if you do the shit your doing you're becoming a subhuman

>Edging
>With porn
I'm not gonna say this is absolutely retarded because it certainly trains *something* (doing pretty much anything trains something) but it's probably training your ability to consciously not cum while actively of stimulating yourself with porn and your hand. Is that an ability you want trained?

For myself (and I assume at least some others), my goal is to fix my ED in order to improve my sex life with my gf. noporn helps reverse PIED; nofap helps reverse desensitization. I have no expectations of superpowers or test boosts or whatever, so edging with porn would not help me in any way.

For another group of people, they expect a boost in self confidence, energy, well being etc stemming from satisfaction at a goal achieved or a buildup of test or whatever reason they come up with. I'm not a believer so I won't try to speak for their reasoning. But most of them seem to agree as well that edging and porn are at least risky and at worst detrimental to their goals.

Also the semen that enters your piping while edging has to end up somewhere if you don't let it out, and from what I've heard ends up in your bladder. No guarantees about the healthiness of doing that long term; the bladder is made for urine.

>edging
This isn't any better. The point is to resist the temptation. If you still can't help but touch your dick you're not fixing any problems you have. You're missing the whole point.

I casually watch camwhore streams as preworkout and abstain from fapping. You want to have an erection as often as you can as this keeps your dick from shriveling. If you do nofap+noporn as I did at first you may risk unknowingly distancing yourself from anything sexual. Watching erotica increases T, lowers cortisol and prolacting and makes you squat bigger. Using it as PWO is not dangerous since you're not conditioning yourself to the instant gratification of self-release as soon as you get aroused.
This is my two cents. I think the real killer here is (((commercial porn))) and the option of going under the fence by self release and distancing yourself from the need of real life sexual encourters.
Edging seems pretty extreme to me but it may be very effective as a way to kickstart the healhtier lifestyle-change since you're denying yourself the self-release which effectively forces you to seek contact. Just be careful not to actually rape anbody and don't cave in to fapping.

Dis nigga know what up

i just tried to not watch porn.

normally i can't get a hard on without porn.
but 4, 5days in to no porn, no fap, i can fap just staring at the celling.

This is a terrible idea as the point of nofap is to reverse the effects of porn addiction/pied. Try to not even look at arousing pictures

Then keep on not watching porn... There's literally not a single reason for myself to watch porn ever again. I can't speak for anyone else but porn has been detrimental to my sex life. I read on here many people who can watch copious amounts of it and still maintain a healthy sex life but not me (and many others).

I watch camwhores to lower my libido.
They are nothing but Venezuelan female slaves and pseudo homo men all strung out on cocaine, viagara, and Lord knows what else.

>It depresses me to think that's their only choice of employment.

You will fail a number of times, but as long as you continually reduce the amount you fap to porn then those thoughts will go away. I had a similar thing. Never give in

What's the point of nofap? Just discipline?

Addiction to fapping and porn can make it impossible for you to get hard with a woman. It's literally just a way to break the addiction and return you to normal, like an alcoholic abstaining from alcohol or a weed addict abstaining from weed.