Post your backup deck(s). What do you play when you want a break from your primary deck? Why play it?
Mine is mono black pox. It was the first legacy deck I ever built. Started without Lili and Wasteland, just a cheap-ass rack pox deck. Then I started building DDFT, and then picked up the Lilis and Wastes once I got a job. Now it's mostly a loaner deck, but it's fun to jam once in a while.
Why not double sleeve your deck in some Dragonshields, user?
Jayden Brooks
cause i took this picture a while back, before I learned the wisdom of double sleeving.
William Morgan
I just played the DDFT mirror match on MTGO. Any chance my opponent also frequents Veeky Forums?
Evan Torres
Tourney guy here, we got 7 people last thread who would be interested, with a majority vote favoring Xmage. I'm away for the weekend but when I get back if the thread is still around I'll make a Challonge signup. Maybe having weekly tournaments to practice, play shitbrews, or whatever you want can generate some more interest in the format.
Leo Gonzalez
I missed the last thread but you can count me in as the eighth man.
Landon Bailey
...
Luis Collins
I usually play cockatrice but would download xmage for the chance to duke it out against my fellow anons.
The question is: do I play a shitbrew or something actually competitive?
Kevin Ward
If I don't run force of will (semi-poorfag) in my reanimator shell, should I run faithless looting instead?
And by that effect, wouldn't that make daze a lot less consistent?
Liam Gutierrez
if you want to play reanimator without force, go the BR route with faithless looting and unmask. it's put up decent results online.
Sebastian Miller
follow your heart, user
Lincoln Thomas
I voted no on the poll but i'I'd probably play. I just don't really like cockatrice/xmage. I put up with mtgo because it relatively consistently enforces the rules. I've had too many people try to cheat on me with cockatrice. Not that I think other fa/tg/guys would cheat.
Nolan Taylor
Xmage has a rules engine and it only bugs out occasionally.
Gavin Baker
Do any of you Legacy guys use chinese fakes? Where do you get the best ones from?
Jason Taylor
Xmage's rules engine doesn't have support for every card. A lot of legacy cards aren't supported.
John Sanders
I've played jank like Parfait on there and never had a problem. What cards aren't supported?
Hudson Brooks
I'd love that
Asher Carter
Great, when I get home I'll make a signup and we can get a final player tally. Now, I would guess most anons have differing schedules, so maybe I can post pairings then the anons contact each other, play, and confirm results. This way the anons can try to chose a platform they are both familiar with and find time within their schedules. The matches could be played over the course of a week and after we have a winner we can host another. Alternatively we can just agree on a few hour block of time to play.
Jonathan Martin
Just play sanic speed BR reanimator and kill on T1 every game with Ten Drills.
Backup Deck: 4 Elvish Spirit Guide 4 Vampire Hexmage 4 Lotus Petal 2 Expedition Map 3 Into the North 4 Crop Rotation 4 Not of This World 4 Sylvan Scrying 4 Thoughtseize 2 Duress 2 Inquisition of Kozilek 1 Sylvan Library 4 Verdant Catacombs 1 Ghost Quarter 1 Sejiri Steppe 1 Snow-Covered Forest 1 Snow-Covered Swamp 2 Bayou 4 Dark Depths 4 Thespian's Stage 4 Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth SB: 3 Pithing Needle SB: 1 Bojuka Bog SB: 3 Abrupt Decay SB: 2 Surgical Extraction SB: 4 Chalice of the Void SB: 1 Karakas SB: 1 Maze of Ith
Carter Wilson
I played a modified version of that when my shop started doing no-ban modern events. I 6-0d two weeks in a row and then people didn't want to play the format anymore. If buy into it in legacy of I hadn't already committed to force of will decks.
Dylan Bennett
The deck is bonkers and nobody expects it at all. I'm really liking it, it's the only shell that's more consistent than the blue cantrip cartel: why run 8 cantrips when you can just run 13 tutors?
The Delver matchup is just so absurdly good, they run maybe 10 pieces of relevant disruption, and you have 12 answers. They might stop the first token, they might stop the second token, but who cares when they're casting Thought Scours and drawing Pyromancers while you're drawing 1-mana Tinkers.
Caleb Rodriguez
what do you think it's worst matchup is? I'm getting all hyped up thinking about it.
Ryan James
D&T is horrendous, almost impossible preboard. They just have so many good cards against you. Wasteland is good, Karakas kills the token, StP kills the token, Flickerwisp kills the token.
Luckily there are no regulars that play D&T in my current meta, but when I play larger tournaments I sometimes run 4 pic related sideboard. It's just that bad.
Every other matchup is fine: nonblue non D&T fair decks (Jund, Maverick, Nic Fit) can't win, Delver decks and Shardless are favorable for you, Miracles and the slower combo decks are even and grindy (ANT, Elves, Sneak, Omni), the faster combo decks just become a race (TES, SI, Belcher, Oops), and D&T is really difficult as previously mentioned.
Benjamin James
forgot pic
Joshua Hill
>tfw every deck I want to play has a bad dnt matchup
Connor Morgan
You should play elves and put those stupid whiteknight fags in their place
Jayden Richardson
Do GWx decks, namely called Maverick, stand a chance in this meta? I really like playing with it, as it is a hard deviance from DnT but share some cards.
Asher Reed
I prefer Aggro Loam
Josiah Price
GW toolbox decks are quite adaptable to your metagame, with GSZ hitting all of your silver bullets. I think if you know your meta and change around it they can be great.
Colton Ramirez
I always search for good Green creatures with useful abilities, but the best rules bending cards are White. What I like about the deck is the splash can change your gameplan a lot.
I failed to find new info or discussion about the deck. Some new posts on MTGSalvation forums, but not a fresh and updated compendium.
Julian Murphy
Last I checked Doomsday wasn't supported.
Luke Moore
Doomsday is showing up in the card list so it has to be supported. I know what you mean though because for a while Squandered Resources wasn't supported either.
Xavier Young
If it is now that's great and makes me much more interested in a tg tournament.
Austin Baker
What's condired the "deck to beat" in the format?
Luke Diaz
miracles
John Turner
That's Countertop with the extra inevitability of drawing into Entreat, right? I've never played Legacy and want to learn about it.
Ayden Hall
yeah although some lists are moving away from entreat toward monastery mentor. those still play terminus, though.
Carter Morris
What are some other of the more prevalent decks? I know about ANT, Grixis Delver, Merfolk, and Death and Taxes but not about much else
Andrew Gomez
Merfolk isn't very prevalent. other big decks are shard less bug, eldrazi stompy, and sneak & show.
Camden Cruz
also lands, nic fit, stoneblade, infect I feel deserve mentioning
Caleb Morris
So is Eldrazi like the (banned) Modern deck at all? BUG seems like it uses Sharless Agent to cascade into other threats, is that it or is there more to it? I've heard about Sneak and Show but know little about it besides the cheating out big threats early deal.
I'm reading the Lands primer right now, seems cool. No idea what Nic Fit is. Stoneblade sounds somewhat straightforwards. I'm also assuming that Infect is similar to the Modern variant.
Nathan Scott
eldrazi is like the banned modern deck but it gets to play even more 2 mana lands. shardless also cascades into ancestral visions and hymn to tourach, and plays other threats like jtms and lotv. sneak and show and the similar omni-show are pretty straightforward combo decks that lots of people here think are brainless. nic fit is a fair gbx deck that abuses the interaction between veteran explorer, cabal therapy, and the fact that most other decks don't play many basic lands, then plays big ass threats. legacy infect is kind of like the modern version but it gets invigorate, berserk, force of will, daze, and crop rotation.
Michael Peterson
mandatory: >pay to win general
Carson Gutierrez
So Nic Fit gets to ramp up and do some nasty discard action at the same time? Seems pretty fun. What's the rest of the deck like, as in threats/other stuff?
Isn't that every non limited/pauper format, though?
Colton Richardson
>Isn't that every non limited/pauper format, though while every format is 'pay to win' at some degree, in most of them you won't find as much trouble using a cheap, well-built deck. This is just not true in Legacy. If you don't have the objectively optimal cards, you will lose.
Cameron Lewis
basically any >=6 cmc edh creature. usually like grave Titan or old sigarda. also, I know you're new, but the "pay to win" guy is a troll, so just ignore him please.
Evan Flores
How's Burn?
Logan Torres
more like countertop plus one mana wraths
entreat isn't even always used these days
Josiah Williams
in addition to costing money, mtgo doesn't even have the whole card pool
I don't know about everything it's missing, but as a lands/loampox player I do know it's missing tabernacle, and that's kind of a big deal
James Russell
?
Evan Morris
fuck I got mixed up somehow
anyway I don't wanna buy ports online
Blake Morgan
Lol you have your shit completely backwards. Tier 2-3 decks can will Legacy 5-rounders, that shit just isn't true of Standard and only happens in Modernw hen the lower tier deck is a strong anti-meta call.
The more cards there are in a format, the less necessary it is to play the best 75 in order to win.
Jason Gonzalez
at first I hated this and thought it was a fucked up joke, but then i really looked at it and you're a fucking madman but i like it. underrated post
Isaac Robinson
Currently have 4c Loam whats a backup deck I can reasonably make?
Noah Morgan
It's more easy to find and build rogue decks in Eternal formats than non-eternal constructed.
Grayson Barnes
I don't have a backup deck yet but leaning towards either ANT or DnT, love both the decks but haven't actually built them or played a whole lot with them. I'm the Esper miracles guy if that'll help with deciding
Grayson Richardson
fuck yeah sea king
Nathan Myers
those efeets
Liam Bell
Look at all dem non-English cards!
Christopher Lee
>Efreets >Mulldrifters Play on, you majestic beast
Just got back into magic and bought a few cards to go with my old collection
Tips to improve?
Eli Murphy
>Recurring Nightmare Ive been stomped hard by this card, reanimation decks arent that good in the current meta tho
Brayden Lewis
>The more cards there are in a format, the less necessary it is to play the best 75 in order to win good luck finding other cards that aren't force of will to avoid losing on the first turn.
i'm talking about decks that can win.
Justin Johnson
Oh my god your deck is like pure cancer. You'd just delay the game and go to time if your one creature gets exiled.
Gabriel Rivera
Why would anyone pay $800+ for that effect?
William Harris
Wow I guess Painters been completely pushed out of the metagame, its not even a slot on Goldfish anymore. Guess ill buy into Lands instead.
Jonathan Collins
I heard it's more that Recruiters are so hard to get that no one player it.
Hudson Hughes
T R I G G E R E D
Mason Bennett
He can still kill people with The Rack and Cursed Scroll if someone StPs the Nether Spirit.
Jackson Hill
Doesn't excuse the un-interactive cancer he's got going on. He might as well say "Don't bother playing permanents, just put them in the graveyard".
Jack Adams
>discard, land destruction, creature sacrifice/removal
>un-interactive
lol
Jace Campbell
I think you missed a turn, buddy. Standard general is this way .
Wyatt Gonzalez
>those bolts are you the same guy who occasionally posts a goblins list on the modern thread? either way, I love you.
Brody Sanders
>interaction is only interaction if it happens on the battlefield
Legacy is not for you.
Daniel Clark
>get to stay at the oni onsen for free >get a loving oni wife as part of the package deal
literally want to end myself because this isn't real
Elijah Rogers
FUCK YOU
Julian James
Welcome to control decks, son.
Xavier Wood
>Have most of what's needed for Pox >Don't have Sinkholes
...think I could get away with using Blights?
Jayden Martin
No
Brody Clark
Is Ignornt Bliss implemented on Xmage?
Ryan Moore
Why not? It's effectively the same. Two black, destroy land.
Carson Baker
>enchanted land never taps
what then?
Samuel Perez
They still get a use out of it. It doesn't destroy the land, it turns it into a lotus petal. Or just does nothing if its an Eye of Ugin or Dark Depths
Eli Brooks
They get mana off of the land, they control when it dies, and they can potentially remove your Blight.
Jaxson King
dude ema sinkholes are like $12
Nathan Evans
EMA Sinkholes are only 10 bucks. You can grab 'em.
Christian Gray
Burn is pretty strong actually. It's terrible against fast combo decks, but it has a decent to good matchup against almost every other deck. It's a solid pick if there aren't many combo decks in your meta, and it has the benefit of being one of the most budget friendly competitive decks.
Austin Brown
Noice. It's the thing I've been looking at due to its (relative) cheapness. What can be done for the combo matchups?
Gavin Sanchez
Depends on the combo. Pyroblasts are decent vs Storm variants and especially Sneak and Show/Omnitell/High Tide, tormod's crypt and surgical extraction vs Dredge/Reanimator/Tin Fins and Mindbreak Trap vs Belcher. Painter is a good MU for burn despite being a combo deck since you have tons of bolts to point at Servant and their lockpieces do nothing vs monoR that doesn't need the combat step.
Justin Bailey
hope that you draw/mulligan into your hate cards.
Adrian Davis
I actually don't like Pyroblast in burn. I prefer Bridge against Sneak and Show and Eidolon against High Tide and Omni
Ethan Kelly
Eidolon is already in the mb, gets removed with Hydroblast/whatever bounce without pyros to back it up. Bridge works but it's slow since there's no accel, t2 show isn't too outlandish and after drawing 14 with Griselbrand they usually have some removal for Bridge.
Cooper Perez
True. I removed the Pyroblasts from my sideboard after I realized I almost never used them and I haven't missed them since.
Adrian Thompson
You rarely cast a bridge. They rarely run artifact removal in sneak and Show, omni may be a different story, but your 1 Pyroblast isn't going to win any stack wars. Also, how are they drawing 14 with Griselbrand?
Owen Wilson
Zozzle
Lucas Kelly
You are a pleb of the highest order if you can't emotionally handle a pox deck.