>Be part of Pathfinder campaign for ~11 months, first experience of tabletop RPGs >Great fun, but wanting to try out other groups/systems as well >Guy comes into FLGS we play at advertising a homebrew 5th Ed Campaign he's starting >Sure why not >Invites me to a dropbox folder with campaign materials, instructs me to read "Backstory" >Backstory is a 53 page novella written at an 8th grade level. Can barely get through a chapter of this garbage.
What have I gotten myself into...
Pic related, it's the "cover art" for the backstory.
Jordan Rodriguez
Sounds like a GM problem, not a system problem.
If your pathfinder game had 53 pages of backstory would you have the same difficulty?
Jaxon Allen
post extracts, you can't leave us hanging
Gavin Allen
Oh I'm fully aware of this. What I'm concerned about is that I've committed myself to a campaign run by this guy, and it sounds like it's going to be terrible.
Easton Anderson
Post the dropbox contents.
Juan Lewis
Ok, here's the first few paragraphs of chapter 1. Don't say I didn't warn you.
>Aywin squats in between two crates in the back of the caravan that is pulled along by four horses. Sweat drips on his face and falls onto his brown pants. His yellow shirt was already soaked in sweat stains but this didn't bother him. As long as his brown hair was tied in a pony tail and didn't get in the way. Also because Buckley, the merchant driver, allowed him to travel with him for three gold coins. Which is a rip-off to most locals and travellers that can afford their own transport.
>"If you break it, you pay for it," were the words Buckley told him the first time he hoped into the back of the caravan. Those words stuck in Aywin’s mind, as he carefully adjusted himself in a more comfortable sitting position while he uses his backpack as a cushion.
>He faced many issues before getting to where he was. One of them included having a limited understanding of Common and having limited knowledge of the location he was going to. He needed to get to the town of Terahn to visit his friend Sal that he has not seen for almost three years. Both of them came from the same tribe in the northern realms where his friend departed on a long quest. He didn’t receive many letters from his friend but he did know where Sal’s last whereabouts were.
Nathan Brooks
Well I fucked up the quoting but whatever
Blake Jenkins
You're not committed to anything. If it's shit and you know it'll be shit, just apologise and back out. Just consider, will you miss out on anything good?
Ian Jones
Come on, novel-length explanation of the setting is not that ba-
-oh, a literal novel.
Dylan Powell
Well I'm not entirely sure. I mean my RPG experience is still very limited, and I've only ever played under the 1 GM. I have certain...assumptions about the kind of person this GM is based on what I'm reading here but I don't know if those assumptions are justified.
Leo Perez
More
Austin Morgan
Well, how many main characters are there? Are they going to play a part in the story? Are they in fact going to be the centrepiece of the game instead of you playing?
With limited experience you might still have fun! But trust your instincts that lead you to asking Veeky Forums for advice on whether something was a good idea or not.
Andrew Brown
This isn't really bad in the sense that is fun for me
William Ross
thats ok, Veeky Forums has seen greater horrors
Xavier Cooper
he's written 53 pages of garbage like this?
im gonna quote Snoop Dog here and say >Drop it like its hot
Angel Adams
>im gonna quote Snoop Dog here and say >>>>reddit.com
Ryder Cook
If you have naught else to do, go for two sessions. You'll either have fun or have a good life lesson. In particular you would gain a horror story that you can regale Veeky Forums with later, and that is the important part!
Jeremiah Taylor
Ok.
"The last letter he received was from the realm of Falderia in the town of Terahn and the tribe chief became concerned about Sal’s whereabouts. As Aywin graduated from his training as a skilled Hunter, the tribe chief allowed him to go on this adventure to find Sal. The chief gave him a bag of gold coins and sent him off on his journey. He had to pay his way, to go on board a merchant ship that travelled to Caldier, and then boarded another ship to Falderia. Where he met Buckley who wore a brown coat over his white tank top and brown pants, at Port Devridge. He owns the wooden enclosed caravan that he uses to transport his goods to other towns.
The caravan hit a small rock that lodged itself in the road which woke him from his thoughts. He sees the sky darken as the sun goes down. The driver slowed his horses to a trot and stopped before the large town gates of Terahn.
“We’re here, you can get out now," Buckley shouts from behind him as sweat from face drips to the dirt ground.
Aywin stands up slowly grabbing his backpack and stepping over the crates, with his long legs, to avoid breaking them. He jumps out of the caravan and turns to face the driver.
“Ah…Thank you." He said to him.
“No problem, look after yourself.” Buckley replies and reigns his horses to trot through the gates into town.
The patrol guards, carrying their swords in their scabbards, stand at the top of the parapet walkway above the gate. They smirk at the appearance of the wood elf that they rarely see as they continue doing their rounds. Aywin could here there distorted sounds and knew how discriminately they looked at him. It didn’t really bother him because he was use to people discriminating him by the way he looked or even the way he dressed."
Elijah Carter
Well at least he/she tried. Maybe one day his/her stories will be good.
Ethan Richardson
His writing aside, you should be looking for actual red flags of bad GMs. His backstory being a story hints that he might be bad about railroading, but if Aywin if alive through all of this despite the odds then he will probably be a DMPC which is literally my least favorite Bad DM trait.
Henry Murphy
When did Snoop Dog say four arrows reddit dot com?
Seriously though, say something like "I'm getting burned out on stuff happening, I might join later."
Jeremiah Nguyen
Just scanned the end chapter, seems like all the main characters are alive. By "least favorite bad DM trait" do you mean its the least bad, or the worst?
Tyler Baker
Skip ahead 10 chapters, see if Aywin is still alive and being the main protagonist; he looks like he's a twat and the DMPC.
AH
Check with the GM and see if Aywin was a previous player character or a DMPC. That's also important, he could be logging this stuff from a previous campaign.
Anthony Hill
How does he talk like? Is he an autist?
Kayden Allen
That's not even purple prose. What's the opposite of purple prose?
Joseph Phillips
The worst. An adventure on the rails can be bland and boring at times but you are still the hero.
A DMPC means the players might as well not be there.