Turns out the Elder Things are real and have awoken their city-fortress in Antarctica. Let's also say they are surprised to find modern humans, but are peacefully asking to be recognized by the international community and to have Antarctica recognized as theirs.
How do the nations of Earth respond?
Jackson White
>Turns out the Elder Things are real and have awoken their city-fortress in Antarctica
The Elder Things are dead though, even in the context of their story.
Parker Russell
>Hey guys, let's have a fun what-if discussion!
>NO! What-if is non-canon.
Ian Kelly
Learn to have fun.
Jason Davis
Forget the spoil sportLets start by saying they number around 1,3 million.
Elijah Torres
Ok.
Not like we're using Antarctica.
Ian Nguyen
...
Luis Jones
But what are we gonna do if we wanna study stars or penguins?
A bit more seriously why should they be recognized? What to they have to offer to the international community beyond existance?
Jason Jackson
Well, they're Elder Things, so I can't imagine mankind would be around to oppose their claim much longer.
It doesn't matter if you come in peace when your would-be friends go mad upon seeing you.
Logan Harris
Technology beyond anything we can do.
John Johnson
>Call of Cthulhu memes strike again
I don't think anybody goes mad from seeing an Elder Thing in the lore.
Andrew Green
Nah, they're not Cthulhu or Star Spawn so you don't go mad after looking upon them. They're way more advanced than us considering they made the shoggoths and have a greater grasp of the fundamental metaphysics of reality.
Ian Lee
...
Nathaniel Foster
Can we have sex with them? This is extremely important.
Logan Lee
Then why do they want peace?
Camden Robinson
Why fight when you can get all that trade? Also not alot of Elder Things left. Also they are indirectly responsible for Humanities creation, so little bit of kinship?
Ryder Myers
>implying the elder things would even bat an 5 eyes at humanity.
Ryan Wood
We will have sex with them, or we will innundate them in nukes because they're different than us. Possible - probably - both.
There's not really a middle ground.
Colton Davis
The question is, who gets to have sex with them?
how many can they have sex with at a time?
Andrew Campbell
>Sapiosexual Female Scientist is part of the negotiations with the Elder Things. >ends with her being modified into a pseudo Elder Thing out of desperation because knowing the unknowable is the ultimate extent of her kink.
Elijah Brooks
>Be Elder Thing. >Your people are seek to wait out the madness and desolation caused by the Wars with the Deep Ones and their master. >Awake from cryo to find that some bald apes have come to rule the planet. >So thats a thing...
Evan Price
>Why don't they want to start an entirely pointless war for no other reason than they have superior technology when they could probably get what they want by asking politely?
Carson Murphy
For educational purposes I have found this map that shows the various countries claims on Antarctica. Do you think Russia would be an asshole about this?
Lucas Morris
That's not at all what happened though. Cthulhu is just another alien and the deep ones are indirect servants. Cthulhu has his own star spawn that made war with the Elder Things.
Jacob Hall
There isn't much down there humans can use. And I think Russia mostly does training there anyway. Not a big deal. Especially if they get some sweet Elder Thing Tech from it.
Isaac Thomas
We have yet to figure out out to consistently get along with people who only have trivial skin color or religious differences. I don't have high hopes that we would get along peacefully with something as alien as Elder Things. Some nation would try to enslave them or steal their stuff, or independent parties would.
Robert Garcia
In cannon aren't the elder things relatively friendly to humans?
Inhumane and indifferent to the suffering of individuals, but not actively hostile, even a little interested in fates.
Joseph Martin
Any invader would get BTFO hard by the Elder Thing though. Why pick a fight that doesn't benefit anyone.
Lincoln Myers
They're people. They do things people do. I imagine largely we could coexist, but Elder Things also seem to be staggeringly arrogant. They coexisted with the Yith and Deep Ones and don't even give them a foot note because they were never a threat.
Grayson Brown
They are in cryo and mostly unaware of humans. The did engineer our very distant ancestors as house cats/dogs.
Jackson Ward
In cannon aren't the humans relatively friendly to dogs?
Inhumane and indifferent to the suffering of individuals, but not actively hostile, even a little interested in fates.
Caleb Edwards
This is just wrong. They engineered pytoplankton and basic single celled life, everything else is the result of uncontrolled evolution.
They're also probably all dead after moving underground. No cryo even implied.
Tyler Johnson
It actually says that it's possible some deep-sea cities are still inhabited.
Dylan Nguyen
Do they have genders? How do you court their womenz?
Jose Sanchez
They reproduced by spores from memory.
Nathan Long
Can they still be sexed?
Aaron Carter
Nope. They reproduce through spores. You can court one. Is it gay if it's neither male nor female?
Joshua Price
They can give blowjobs and stroke your dick with their tentacles. But no vagina/cloaca/similar organ.
I swear I used to be a normal human being...
Aiden Nelson
No, just xenophila. Nongendered is still not homosexual.
Nathan Morales
Antarctica is rightful Australian clay, so fuck off, we're full.
Justin Hughes
You are still ruled by a foreign Queen cuck.
Christopher Peterson
I crunched the numbers, it turns out it's at least twice as gay. maybe more.
Jacob Peterson
Explain.
Brayden Murphy
>Explain the joke
Lincoln Rodriguez
I thought you actually had numbers and data...
Camden Roberts
I'd wager that the US would be pissed as fuck not to be the strongest fish in the pond anymore.
Sebastian Howard
I wasn't that dude, dude. I just was letting you know >He doesn't have data Because it's a joke.
Noah Long
They're pentaradially symmetrical, so 5. Unless the genitalia are along the apex or bottom.
Sebastian Bell
Or the U.S would not want Russia having access to elder tech..
Michael Ortiz
>they are surprised to find modern humans, but are peacefully asking to be recognized by the international community and to have Antarctica recognized as theirs.
They can fuck off. Every elder city in the world belongs to America
Connor Price
We try to kill them with nuclear fire.
Guess how well that'll go.
Kevin Reed
Wait, I thought the Deep Ones worshipped Dagon?
Asher Rodriguez
The ones underground got fucked by Shoggoths and are definitely dead. The examples remaining above ground were revived just from being thawed, although some were chewed up enough that they were dead.
Like, five of those things just wake up when thawed and it's a pretty integral part of the story because the researchers follow them.
Jace Rivera
Ah perfect a lovecraft thread saves me from having to go to that shithole Veeky Forums I just read the shadow over insmouth and although i liked it i was not really a fan of the ending. Problem is i see no other way he could have gotten the information he wanted across then said retarded twist so i guess the writers hands were kind of tied.
Daniel Sanchez
He does get a lot of his information by enabling the town drunk's crippling alcoholism, which is kind of hilarious.
Jordan King
I could see most of those research stations being converted into embassies of sorts, just to keep things up. Really it's a matter of if there are a small enough number of the Elder things to not seem like a massive threat, and if they have some sweet tech they'll offer in exchange.
Say they offer every country the cure to cancer for their antarctic claims, barring the embassy/research stations, and there's not too many of them, maybe in the millions. That's a city of weird things that could be seen as indigenous people, or at the very least a rare species of animal.
Prolonged war doesn't seem like an overly likely outcome. At the very least, people will be hesitant since the things might have nukes, or worse. Most likely is trade and peace talks while nations gauge their capabilities, though I'd also imagine Elder things would keep themselves relatively isolationist. They would want to keep as much of a tech advantage as they could for as long as they could.
Mason Brooks
If the rest of the Mythos is real too, elder things are some of the best friends we could have. They may be radiates, vegetables, and star-spawn, but mentally they're close to us. They stood against fucking CTHULHU and fought him to a standstill, and they don't have any reality-bending power, just advanced technology.
In the Mythos, they're the embodiment of Badass Normal.
Evan Price
This sounds exactly right to me. They offer everyone the same thing that isn't used for warfare, it doesn't set off any political explosions about enemies getting super tech. Then they can just stay on their continent as isolationists. Good job guy. I'd world build this.
Connor Gomez
Yeah. Offering everyone the same thing is key, and the only political squabbles would potentially be some countries trying to stay and then trade for the cure with allies. That may just result in the Elder things offering a blanket deal to everyone holding the land though, and say that they all have to agree to get it. Either way, I see the nations easily caving to that pressue. Go down as the leader who cured cancer by making first contact with another species in exchange for some useless ice? Easy decision.
From there, most trade is probably minimal. Maybe food, but probably mostly art, music, or entertainment, assuming any of it is enjoyable to one side or the other.
Sebastian Wilson
I think so much of their art and tech would be so alien to us that enjoying or using it would be a pain in the ass. They are so divergent in morphology from us that their ways of thinking and operating tech would be completely alien to us. We'd have to reverse engineer any of it. And they'd always have problems with espionage. I imagine a few countries would try to smuggle some super tech out of the south pole. God that'd be a great campaign. ... A mission to smuggle elder tech out of Antarctica, humans are uncommon in the city. If you get caught you may start a humanity ending war. ...... I may make this campaign.
Chase Bailey
Motherfucker, did you even read In The Mountains of Madness? It's not seeing the Elder Things that drive people insane, it's seeing the Shoggoth that killed the Elder Things.
Cooper Nelson
Yeah. There's a lot of stuff that could be done with it. I'd imagine that even without really being able to enjoy their art, you would still get people trying to study it though. Lots of researchers would have a field day with even the cultural aspects of their society, let alone tech.
Espionage would be similarly difficult, as I'd imagine each nation would be keeping close eyes to make sure nobody else got ahead in the race, while also having to deal with any super-tech security.
Counter-intelligence and stopping theft by other countries might be just as interesting as conducting it yourself. Not to mention any more independent thieves that figure they can just sneak in and pocket a tiny gizmo to sell for millions.
Brayden Campbell
Is there oil around Antarctica? This is very important
Eli Anderson
And whatever Dyer saw beyond that mountain. It's implied to be the true form of a bunch of eldritch abominations, including fucking YOG-SOTHOTH
Robert Turner
The straw that broke the camel's back. Dyer and Danforth were already close to their breaking points after reading the Elder Things' history in those murals.
Alexander Ward
I always personally enjoyed the idea that he saw some sort of weird cold-mirage reflection of Kadath through the Cold Wastes where they bordered, and seeing the implied immensity of the ultimate city just spooked him to the limit.
Jason Cruz
It's weird how much of a hopeful note they are. They're what mankind can aspire to become to survive the coming dark. They rose to the level of Mi-Go and other supernations and remained merciful and sane by a human standard.
Jack Hughes
Hol up if they're in Antarctica, where did they get those sticks?
John Brooks
human research station.
Lincoln Ortiz
The giant blind albino penguins run the local racket. You got fish, buddy, they got what you want.
Levi Wood
Might be bone or metal. Maybe they have a greenhouse somewhere
Juan Morris
>the penguins are behind everything I knew it!
Juan Martinez
The penguins are, in reality, the real reason why the majority of cosmic horrors have left Earth alone. They fear what wrath the penguins have in store for them.
Mankind exists solely because the penguins allow us to.
I, for one, welcome our penguin overlords.
Kevin Cox
>Australia >Ruled by the Queen >Not by their Emu Overlords Get your shit together, user.
Jaxson Rodriguez
>going to Antarctica >not bringing sticks so you can roast marshmallows
Ryder Gonzalez
>He thinks that mere animals could best the true rulers of the continent
Nice try Australians, try winning in EW2.
Noah Jones
>Australians >Having any chance of winning Emu War 2 After they performance in the first one, they should be grateful that their Emu masters didn't genocide their whole race.
Christian Diaz
AAR of our Beyond the Mountains of Madness campaign
>tl,dr: Everyone who understood the construct died inside or was left behind. Instead of orchestrating a coverup, we announced our discovery to the world, started WW2 in 1934 over access to the city of the Elder Things, and ended the world by nuking Berlin with a bomb built using plundered elder thing physics knowledge
Hudson Butler
>mentally they're close to us No. Just no. It's not about "boohoo no fun alloed" it's about mythos entities. I say entities because they aren't even "beings" since they "are" not like e "are". They exist differently than us.They can't relate, they can't comprehend and even if they could, we wouldn't have any idea. They exist in multiple times and dimensions, they use a """""""technology""""""" called magic that rapes everything our reality and society is built upon. So yeah, they write and talk and build "cities", except these probably "exist" also in the dreamworld, their language does not use air vibration to communicate. Try to explain that to a human. We nuke them, it fails, and then they brain rape us for good
Jacob Ramirez
>They exist in multiple times and dimensions Confirmed for knowing Shit about Elder Things.
Colton Richardson
Not dead, just hibernating or some shit.
Owen Barnes
From what I understood, just a few were hibernating and the rest got fuckmurdered in the shoggoth uprising.
Daniel Long
>implying a human can know about mythos go fuck a Cow
Isaac Sanchez
I would but your mom is busy.
Tyler Bell
IIRC, there were still thousands of them in the city, and that's just what the narrator saw.
Adam Jones
Yeah, but weren't those dead?
Sebastian Rodriguez
The ones brought up for dissection APPEARED to be dead as well.
Evan Thompson
Wasn't there a shoggoth running around the town?
Noah Fisher
I don't remember anything like that, although admittedly it's been a while since I read it.
Josiah Fisher
Everything you just posted is fanon. None of it is supported by the evidence in the story.
Oliver Peterson
Concerning Elder Things, it actually says in the story "they were men, whatever else, they were men"
So HP Lovecrafft would disagree with you.
Not that they wouldn't be selfish pricks with no qualms about backstabbing humans if it helped them to survive another war with the Polyps or the Shoggoth Rebellion though.
Bentley Jenkins
>"The Elder Things are dead though, even in the context of their story." >story is literally about Elder Things coming back to life and killing / dissecting a human expedition
Asher Gomez
One thing I never understood about at the mountains of madness is why haven't the shoggoths taken over the world by now?
Alexander Martin
Considering humans evolved from leftover shoggoth drippings, they already have
Eli Perry
They just wke up? We nuke them and ensalve them.
They are more developed then us, they have better tech then us, they are more intelligent then us.
The only thing they do no thave now is time. If we give them time they will become a treat we cannot win against. And will get enslaved. Our only path forward is to attack first and hope it enough.
Jose Turner
>We try to nuke them and they wipe us out FTFY
Samuel Reed
They don't see a need?
They don't particularly hate us (well, unless we piss them off), they probably don't even think of us as different than the penguins which they eat.
They're happy to roll around, defacing their creator's cities, and forming mass conglomerations to think about higher dimensions.
Charles Lopez
Meanwhile, the narrator and his buddy are able to piece together their history just by looking at the murals on the walls of their abandoned city.
But please, continue telling us how they're all so far beyond our understanding, oh gosh you guys for reals tho
Cameron James
you would be right with many Lovercaftian races but the Elder Things are actually pretty cool guys.
Ryder Richardson
In one RPG, as a nice touch, Elder Thing knowledge was partially psychic. As in, you look at a bit of Elder Thing tech and writing (in person) for long enough, and you get a general idea of how it works, or what it says.
This psychothaumic resonance is like the Elder Things including a manual, it's just that we're stuck using the French side, because we don't have 5-lobed brains, so while we get a general idea... it's not complete, and other people will have a different idea which is just as accurate.
So let's say you have five scientists, all looking at the history murals, they'll get the same general sequence of events, but disagree with specifics, or the meaning of particular glyphs.