Player wants to be a human barbarian raised by lizardfolk. Fluff-wise it was because his parents were on good terms with the lizards, and because they were reliable they saw no need to waste a child with good potential just for a free meal.
I was thinking of giving him the option of having Cunning Artisan for free; that seem fair to you guys?
Asher Wood
Speaking of the prewritten stuff, what do you think of the selection for Tales from the Yawning Portal?
Austin Smith
Any chance someone could add the Gunslinger class to the Trove?
Aaron Hall
saves me the trouble of converting a bunch of 1e adventures
Liam Richardson
Fuck it doesn't have it, here we go.
Cooper Jones
Sounds good to me.
Bentley Nguyen
I mean, there's nothing there that would convince me to actually use pre-written stuff, but from what I've read, it is a competent greatest hits album.
Sebastian Rivera
>party trapped in underdark >thrown to an arena naked >"amuse the crowd and earn your gear back for the fights to come" >dwarf breaks into a racy bar song >effeminate warlock dancing around to it >slaps on asses are had >drow crowd lusting hard for that butt everafter >fastforward holding cells >same warlock talks his way into wardens office >trying to seduce a key out of him >mage hand to rub his package as they talk across his desk
>my fucking face when my players pulled me into the magical realm
Tyler Cruz
i was wanting to run the sunless citadel for ages now, was either gonna run 3.5 for it or tweak it up to 5 on my own until i saw they had it on there
all over that shit
Aiden Russell
Could we add this in too?
Aiden Taylor
Fucking drow
Thomas Thompson
>the warden is a man You have strange drow.
Connor White
How about no?
Brayden Rivera
Why user?
David Cox
Continuing sorcerer discussion >Spell Points instead of slots >Expanded Spell lists >More metamagic (lore sorcerer spell secrets as a metamagic, divided between lesser and greater) >Improved metamagic (either as options for more points or just buff it like sculpt magic instead of careful spell) >Lesser metamagic at 3 (twinned, subtle, lesser distant, empowered, careful, quickened, heightened, lesser spell weaving changing damage type to fire, cold, poison, lightning, necrotic, and acid >Level 10 feature now change a spell on a long rest and greater metamagics (sculpted, maximized, greater distant, and greater weaving radiant, psychic, thunder and save changes >Level 17 feature now exploding dice up to Cha Mod (does not work with maximized) and for each exploded die a sorcery point is regained
Josiah Nguyen
1. It's bloated and overdesigned. K.I.S.S. 2. It strangely has the opposite problem of most homebrew in that it is underpowered, and thus will cause any player who wants something like it to be more useless in a party than a vanilla Beastmaster Ranger. 3. It doesn't really have a thematic niche that would allow a DM to allow it in their world
Elijah Ramirez
Oh and pyromancer is called elementalist Can switch between Fire, Cold, Poison, Acid, and necrotic (dat plane of salt) 3 times per long rest as a bonus action. Flavored as these are the planes which intersect with the material plane the most, allowing those magically inclined individuals access to them.
Grayson Martinez
Curse of Strahd is the best written in both story, potential, freedom and atmosphere but it's a bit cheating since it is piggybacking off what was already one of if not the best of the early DnD modules.
Ayden Robinson
Are there any Pathfinder stories that people consider good enough to port over to 5e?
Nicholas Turner
i would dig taking spellpoints over casts per day but no fucking way i'd be any good with how much to give per level and what spell level should cost what number of spellpoints for purposes of balance
Andrew Bailey
starting the party on moving from LMoP to storm king's thunder tonight. words of wisdom?
Isaiah Garcia
Page 288 of DMG friend
Julian Morales
Going to start playing Princes of the Apocalypse today, what am I in for? Any particular classes that would be good for it?
Dylan Bennett
oh well shit i forgot that's an actual variant rule thing now. cheers.
Daniel Parker
Play genasi with the adequate sorcerer subclass for dat flavor&immersion
Kevin Phillips
>It's Bloated and overdesigned. Explain more on this cause to me it's about the same design as a paladin, it has war magic instead of extra attack, free magic weapons, and all of the subclasses synergize with itself. I don't see it as overdesigned it's just a magic swordsman/gish.
>2. It strangely has the opposite problem of most homebrew in that it is underpowered, and thus will cause any player who wants something like it to be more useless in a party than a vanilla Beastmaster Ranger.
War magic, Enspell, Aegis, arcane casting, divine smite, AOE buff, multiple free spell castings... seems pretty strong to me. In fact, I would go out on a limb and say it might be a bit too strong.
>3. It doesn't really have a thematic niche that would allow a DM to allow it in their world
Cult of magic, martial fighters, red mages... it seems flexible, I made it work.
Carter Thompson
Not really.
Joshua Mitchell
If that's what you want the level 17 feature to be, wild sorcerers should get something else at 18.
Xavier Hall
How would I play as a lucky wizard?
If we were going by the classic
>str >dex >con >wis >int >lck
I want my wizard to be Int/lck but obviously there is no lck stat
Lincoln Morgan
No. It's shit.
Asher Rogers
Halfing Wizard.
Human Variant Wizard.
Anything Wizard and take Lucky at 4.
Jaxon Myers
Halfling divination wizard with the lucky feat.
Levi Thomas
You play as a halfling divination wizard with Lucky feat. You think things and they happen.
Tyler Davis
>What is the best official adventure, and why is it picrelated?
Calling Curse of Strahd 'the best' isn't very impressive since the other adventures are all terrible. It's just a rehash/expansion of an AD&D setting with a central plot line that doesn't make sense or work unless you force your players onto rails. It seems like it's trying to have old school hexcrawler feel but there's nothing to encounter that doesn't force you back onto the path of 'get the mcguffins, kill vamp'.
Jordan Barnes
Nice was thinking of Divination anyway. Sounds the most useful for getting the party out of a sticky situation
Eli Hall
>Now That's What I Call Dungeons Yo Baron, I can dig it!
Carson Richardson
Which would you say are the least terrible?
Owen Flores
>that feel when the rest of party obeys the "Keep Out" sign of the evil wizard's lair
Jordan Bailey
Why wouldn't I just play an Eldritch Knight if I wanted to be a gish?
Henry Taylor
I wish we had some new official books for classes and subclasses
Nicholas Cooper
Damn, forgot about wild sorcerer. What would you suggest? I'm thinking something about increases to force damage as that is the damage of pure magical energy though its not too random. I definitely want sorcerers to get damage. They're defined by a limited spell list that they use metamagic to fit to their needs and, while they have less utility than wizards, they bring the pain much more effectively.
Nolan Barnes
Me too. My group allows UA but I always feel hesitant using playtest material and it's nice having a lot of shit in one book to reference.
Josiah Wood
I'd agree that Curse of Strahd is 'the best' but with the caveat that it's 'the best' in the same way that the shit sandwich with barbecue sauce on it is 'the tastiest'. I have fond memories of Hoard of the Dragon Queen 'cuz that was the first full campaign I ran but I also acknowledge that it's pretty bad.
I was not prepared for this party. How are meager skelemans and the occasional lesser Devil supposed to compete?
Jacob Ramirez
You should know, the DM may hate you.
Because you will become the DM.
Carson Rodriguez
>Bloated The number of features is more than any PHB class when you consider their spellcasting, something that can be seen in that guy's other "Pugilist" homebrew. Combine that with their spellcasting which has a bunch of exclusive spells that no other class has and you have something that has too many things to keep track of for my taste.
>Balance Enspell is just a concentrationless Magic Weapon, Aegis is a concentrationless Shield of Faith that only gets better than a 1st level spell at 13th level, their spell progression is like a Ranger which is not exactly known for having great spellcasting, their melee smites are worse than a Paladin's and their ranged smites are even worse than the Arcane Archer UA, War magic is good I won't lie, but overall it just doesn't excel at any category. Compare that to other gishes who either have crazy offense (Paladin) or Crazy defense (Eldritch Knight) and they end up as versatile but lacking in the kind of abilities that will make a party appreciate their presence since their effects are largely incremental and subtle.
>Setting I'm not saying they can't fit in, just that their fluff crowds the already crowded "Magical Society" niche. If your setting has room for it fine, but many don't.
I'm not saying your fun is wrong, but the Magus really isn't as broadly applicable as the Gunslinger. If you want it in the Mega, go ahead since my original post was mostly a joke.
Angel Watson
Even though they said that they won't make things like "Complete" books from 3.5, I hope they would try to balance them again and make an "Adventurer's Compendium" that had all the UA material revised, and maybe some new things in on itself. But I think that would be enough for the character building we need for 5e. I don't see the appeal of having hundreds of classes and options, it bogs down character creation and encourages munchkinnery.
Levi Allen
>Using UA material You brought this on yourself
Ian Smith
Tucker's Meager Skelemans I guess?
Juan Russell
Someone did put all the UA into one file (Excluding things like Plane Shifts and such, UA only)
Bryn Shander is not as fun as it sounds. Goldenfields would've probably been a better place to send the party.
Enjoy Chapter 3, let your players explore the Sword Coast for a few sessions, there's a lot of great adventures in there. Definitely try to tie in some foreshadowing, and build up the Giant threat.
For sure read the PDF, I would've loved to have read it before I ran SKT.
Blake Morales
>something that can be seen in that guy's other "Pugilist" homebrew I keep pointing this out from time to time, but the Pugilist has literally the exact same number of named abilities as the Monk.
Not gonna bother reading the magus, though.
Landon Roberts
Rate my party >gnome lore wizard >dwarf ancients paladin >warforged totem barbarian >dragonborn draconic sorcerer
Jack Hill
> lore wizard It's shit.
Asher Cox
And they brought back the original writers/designers for the new book as consultants.
Samuel Hall
>named abilities as the Monk And at least 3 of them are ribbons unless the DM loves his inner city shit.
Lincoln Wood
>t-there's no winning...
Luke Scott
I'm going to DM HotDQ for the following party, How do you think it'll go?
Are you gonna write this up? I'd love to read it if you do!
Gavin Jackson
Who/what are "The Ancients" referenced in terms of the Vow of the Ancients paladin? I mean, I get that they're supposed to be fey/elfy themed paladins without being too obvious, but I don't get it.
Connor Perez
>Bloated Okay, fair point.
>Balance I see this class as the more magic focused option as opposed to the Paladins offensive and EKs defensive, but fair point. The Enspell and Aegis feature come with more benefits than just being a concentrationless Magic Weapon. Like removing resistances and immunities or causing status conditions, I think that gives them some solid usage in a party. They also have much better spell options than the ranger does.
>Setting To each his own I suppose.
Alexander Bell
What's the one site everybody uses for their formatted homebrews? The lords of the wild. The everliving treants. The eternal fae. Any nature bullshit you can think of probably lives a long ass time.
Ryder Rogers
Is there a published adventure in which the Mariner fighting style would actually be useful?
Angel Ramirez
Fey or other miscellaneous nature spirit things I guess.
Brandon Barnes
*Tabaxi
Nathan Watson
Nah.
Arcana cleric, oathbreaker, necromancer, moon druid (assistant tank at early levels and gotta turn those skellingtons into giant scorpions later on), and, sure, lore bard.
Jayden Garcia
Is Storm King the best lengthy campaign with the most magical feel?
the idea of dragons v giants and airships sounds amazing
Grayson Kelly
Megaanon here. No.
Parker Roberts
Nature spirits of the Material plane.
Jaxson Rogers
let me correct the record: >halfling diviner with lucky feat >nuclear druid >auxiliary grave cleric >dragon-hunting kobold >fighter with diamond pickaxe >sanic tabaxi There you go
Gavin Morris
Like tongue of the sun and moon and timeless body.
Lincoln Morales
Adventure paths are something Paizo actually does fairly well. Personally, I wouldn't mind seeing Skulls and Shackles or Iron Gods in 5e.
Jace Reyes
Megaanon, been asking for a while now, but why no Plane Shift material on 5etools?
Andrew Rodriguez
Shitty homebrews btfo.
Ryder Myers
Where is the Mariner fighting style? No, but it COULD be useful in a Spelljammer or nautical themed campaign -- though that may sound improbable to you, a ship is a battlemap you can reuse 100s of times.
Isaac Lewis
/5eg/ I need some help.
I love 5E, and so does my regular group. We've been running two alternating games, a PF one and a 5Eberron one. Now after adding a new player we are talking about converting the PF game to 5E and one of the player is having trouble with figuring out their changeover.
If PF, they're playing a Bard (sandman) and does a lot of sneakiness, stealing spells, and a lot of illusions.
He just linked me a home brew bard college on DndWiki, which I have told people to never link me because I think the place is a tire fire, instead I was wondering folk's opinions on one of the variant ideas about feats about some class features (with a bit of adjustments) being made into feats rather than even considering something from the wiki and making it as a counter offer to the player.
What would be some appropriate features turned feats from Illusionist and arcane trickster and what adjustments would you make.
I wanted to gauge you guys on this while I make some of my own brewings and compare what comes up. Thanks Anons.
Jacob Clark
Mega is always good for uploading, as is mediafire and googledocs.
Justin Gomez
>What's the one site everybody uses for their formatted homebrews? homebrewery.naturalcrit.com/ >Any nature bullshit you can think of probably lives a long ass time. Hell, a 20th level elf druid lives like 7000 years, so they'd probably qualify.
Easton Gray
BTFO
Connor Price
Hey megaanon Thanks for being great Will other 3rd party shit be added or is ToB it?
Ayden Myers
>necromancer+animal shapes druid Fuck, I was meeming it up that day but forgot to put it into my all-star party
William Perry
>misfire rules
How about no?
Camden Rogers
Ah well worth a shot.
Brody Diaz
>3 of them are ribbons What's the third one? Street Smart and Rabble Rouser are ribbons for sure, what's the third?
Jeremiah Moore
Megaanon, you've missed one of the seeker invocations from the Lore Wizard Arcana, the one that grants languages.
Isaac Cox
Quicken/Twinned spell will probably always be the top picks for Metamagic because they let the Sorcerer break the rules for concentration and the action economy. Whether the character has them permanently or can choose between using those or another Metamagic is irrelevant because they are the most flexible options and will be picked 99.9% of the time. Taking away the worry of "I need to take Quick/Twin Spell to not be useless all the time" by allowing them to swap out Metamagics isn't a bad thing.
Jonathan Wood
Kek
Dylan Phillips
That's a good idea, thanks!
Can anyone tell me a bit more about the adventure? Is it mostly in dungeons, on land, etc etc?
Blake Sullivan
How do you like your Halflings? Do you like them as just short people? Short people with big heads? Thicc short girls?
Austin Morris
Without spoilers, I'd say there's more than a few dungeons. If I remember correctly.
Matthew Kelly
>Int 8 wizard >catgirls.pdf >how do I make a dark souls character >13+DEX+CON+DEX+WIS+DEX dragon sorcerer barbarian monk