EDH/Commander General

Wrong discord in OP
discord.gg/4F4gz

That's the proper one

Nth for reposting my thoughts about scarab god. Im unusually annoyed by this because the god doesn't scream zombie tribal at all, and people want to build that anyway.

>Target opponent looses life
yes? i was stating things they could have fucked up but didnt.
just imagine the god would read "target opponent" and "exile from your graveyard" and you suddenly have a card that is not even good in EDH.
they didnt do that. im happy.

>especially when you're paying life

Nth for reposting mocking you.

I caught on, don't worry about it.

rtfc.
he screams zombie tribal.
you dont loose life.
please stop reposting this.

>Can't wait to curbstonp scrubs that thought taking 20 damage cumulatively from his first ability is good

rtfc

also there's no reason you shouldn't abuse the first ability too. i think you probably shouldn't build full-retard with the tribal effects, but going on a zombie focus with your creatures and putting in some of the good zombie generation seems very much worth it. scrying more than 6 per turn is almost like tutoring every turn if your deck is consistent enough.

I'm sorry seeing the discord gets your jonnies all jostled, user.

>good zombie generation

zombie token generation i mean

Army of the Damned
From Under the Floorboards
Endless Ranks of the Dead
Liliana's Mastery
Dread Summons
Noosegraf Mob
Diregraf Colossus
Grave Titan

all probably worth it

scrying for six, if you are in a 4 player game thats 18 collective damage. 24 for 5.
i have a feeling if built well and with a lot of zombie generation you may very well be the archenemy.
> rarely pay more than 5 for commander
> high control over your own deck
> fast-ish global clock

Oh lmao. I stand corrected. Jesus.
I still wouldn't build zombie tribal though.
Fuck this card is busted and will be an autowin in draft
Honestly this card is retarded strong, what the hell were the designers thinking.

Im mega pissed at myself because im usually one to rtfc. Sorry.
Aaaaaaa
Ok im calmed down

I'm sorry when your furry club is excluded you get your fee fees in a tussle

youre the one coming up with illegitimate discord links, you lanky bitch

Intruder Alarm/Thornbite Staff combos incoming.

How retarded is this card on a scale from 1-10

What a waste of a commander.

In edh its okay, in nearly every other format completly retarded. See Snapcaster, Bob, Deaths Shadow...

Considering it RBx? 6-7/10 I'd say can get some combo pieces out, mostly outlets but still. In 5c gets Saffi back if that was the only thing you needed to go off

Pretty sure he's just Legendary to keep his damage prevention ability from getting out of hand.

Guess I'll be making myself an UB zombie tribal.
Thanks, Scarab God.

What's the chance of other planeswalkers having an X cost?

We'll probably see it again but I doubt it will be a regular thing.

> have gisa and geralf lying arround
> swap the commander for this god
> add some all player mill

>Brother started brewing Locust as soon as it was spoiled
>Friend said he wanted to play a new deck, was thinking BR, right before Scorpion was spoiled
>I already have a UB Grim-Grin deck I could switch out for Scarab

Godwars incoming.

>tfw I don't know if I want to keep Grimgrin as my zombie Commander, or switch him out for Scarab God

I find grimgrin underwhelming compared to the new God

So...Theros Block commander wars 2?

WotC already said that they're are planning for more creatures with God type and that's why they changed 'Indestructible+condition' formula with Grixis Gods, so prepare for Godwars I guess.

How much is Scarab gonna go for?

Depends on how much use it has for modern.

It's difficult to say. It's a casual all star mythic. It's gonna be THE commander to go for for zombies, which are already really popular. But print runs of new sets are so insanely high and it's in a set with lottery cards. I wouldn't be able to even guess.

That's ridiculous. Modern won't have any bearing on its price at all. Even with no Modern usage whatsoever, the Theros gods range in price from $2 to $12.

I'm gonna build the shit out of it

If it doesn't have any use in modern though it won't be any pricier than any other card in standard. We have no idea what else is in the set so we don't know where value lies yet, but even if the card is a fucking great mythic played in standard you aren't getting above 15. The range you gave for the gods is mostly correct. Expect this to be high on release as usual, then dip down as more packs are opened.

>How consistent do you try to make your decks?
Lol no

My best deck is a deck where everything combos with everything else and there is absolutely zero consistency. It's a blast

List?

Here

tappedout.net/mtg-decks/mono-red-goblin-artificer/

I'm debating a switch to Daretti Stax because my UB control deck isn't the best in my 5-man group

That looks quite fun to play.

Mono W superfriends?

Why not just put him on the 99 for Atraxa?

Two trash decks, wonderful.

Someone is triggered.

Flaming hot

Easiest question of my life.

It's extremely fun. It can be slow to start though, considering I've got a mana curve like a mountainside

Looking to make everyone collectively miserable in Mono Black. Naturally I'm already running Pox, Small Pox, Death cloud etc. Commander is looking to be pic related. So I have forced permanent sacking as the main theme, with a heavy discard sub-theme, what are some Mono black hidden stax gems.

>from a graveyard
>a graveyard
spicy, so mill zombie tribal?

>hidden stax gems
No such thing. But here's something not a lot of players play for obvious reasons.

Yeah I'm gonna run Magus of the Abyss to at least somewhat replicate the effect.

Bitterblossom + or other "Everyone sacs" like Merciless Executioner.

Just buy or proxy The Abyss and Nether Void.

Gibbering Descent is bit overlooked, it can have some good interactions on hellbent.

>even if the card is a fucking great mythic played in standard you aren't getting above 15
Has there not been any $40 mythics that are only standard playable in a while? I mean I don't think this card would be that much, but it's not unheard of.

Leave him in the 99. He goes back to your hand when he dies, there's no sense making him the Commander.

>He goes back to your hand when he dies, there's no sense making him the Commander.
Yeah, getting your Commander out for a reliably cheap cost has never been good ever.

>he goes back to your hand when he dies
>he avoids commander tax
>this is apparently a bad thing

I wonder what's your reasoning for saying that.

>How consistent do you try to make your decks? Is there too consistent for this format?
Not too consistent I would say that there is "too fast" for this format however
I try to make my decks do one thing and one thing very well. My decks are very consistent.
The longer you play the more you realize theres really not enough room in your 100 card deck for multiple strats imho.
I also play competitive tables once a month with my buds so I assume that influences my casual decks too

>scry x
you could have sold me on that alone

>hottest general
you literally gargle semen if you disagree with me

I have a thing for dommes.

Well, yeah.

How do i build Roach God? I was thinking about mill+etb goodstuff+ some zombie tribal support and zombie token generators, do i have enough space for all of these things or will it be a janky deck that doesn't focus much on anything?

first card I would put in
that and mind grind would be the only two mill cards i would auto include
maybe the theros god too

What a bunch of plebs

> How dare you look me eye to eye, worm!

You still have fight in you, you WILL be broken in before dawn...now GET UNDRESSED!

Blue mill + black token generation and every zombie Lord you can find. Training Grounds to reduce his cost.

Honestly I'd rather run him in the 99 of Sidisi, but whatever floats your boat.

>tfw my fetish is dominating women who think they are doms
why is there never any porn of this?

Wait, so does this mean Samut successfully broke his conditioning?

Holy shit, Lazav just got an upgrade AND I have somewhere to stick grimgrin. In Grixis this would be super spicy with Rakdos, Lord of Riots.

Hi, I heard Griselbrand got fired, so I'm here to apply for his job.

Adriana's flavor is a perfect match for her effect. All the other Conspiracy legends have effects that encourage strange play styles or interactions with opponents and built in politics, but Adriana's just a simple guardswoman and her effect is just simple combat.

Holy fucking shit

Rough.

At least he doesn't replenish itself like griselbrand does.

...

Oh, that interesting.
Expensive as fuck, and I'm not going to us it, even in EDH, but interesting.

So now I need to buy a box. Fuck...

Just buy the singles nigger. As good as Scarab God and Razaketh look for EDH, even if you have to drop 30$+ for both, do not fucking buy a box, you're only going to get disappointment out of it.

Hm... Honestly I think it won't replace Sidisi, Undead Vizier, just because she can sac herself and he needs something else on board.

I was thinking more of a reanimator dude with zombie support cards to sweeten the deal, blighted agent becomes a 4/4, and given its ANY creature you can probably jack some pretty good cards like Thaila and stuff.

>bolas and the three gods would be $120 straight up
>tutorbrand is going to be $5-15
>a box costs 160
I know what you mean user, but my inner gambler is telling me to do it. Previously I'd just buy singles I wanted on the cheap, like anointed procession but I don't think I'm going to get the chance.

2slow/10
at least wanderer gives you value right away

>>a box costs 160
since when are they over 100?

>tutorbrand
>not tutorphed
I want this meme to die.

I'm sure that Bolas+ the gods will be less than $120. Preorder prices are not real.

Your inner gambler is an idiot and will lose you money and net you a bunch of worthless chaff

Do you live outside of the US or something? All of your prices are inflated significantly.

But what if he opens a masterpiece? :^)

I think he's talking about some kind of knockoff dollar like leaf dollar or kiwi dollar or cunt dollar

Canadian dollerydoos. Actually, it'll be the same price to get the singles or a box, and I get a chance at getting that sweet lord of extinction and omniscience.

Hey fair enough, I'll still buy a box and post what I get so y'all can call me a faggot when I get a bunch of draft chaff.

No one knows who kothoped is and I couldn't think of a better name. Tutorbrand is fine.

Ancient Grudge has met its match.

This actually pretty nice