EDH/Commander General /edhg/

"Old news" edition

Previous: RESOURCES

>Official Site: Contains deck building rules and the current ban list.
mtgcommander.net

>Deck List Site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck’s strategy and card choices.
tappedout.net

>Namefag bitchfest, but people often make primers, which go into detail about how they built and play their deck.
mtgsalvation.com/forums/the-game/commander-edh

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the the internet.
edhrec.com/

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen Commander’s color identity.
manabasecrafter.com/

CARD SEARCH

>Official search site. Current for all sets.
gatherer.wizards.com/

>Unofficial, but has GOAT search interface.
magiccards.info/

Thread Question:
How long do you stick with your commanders, /edhg/?

Other urls found in this thread:

discord.gg/UE9Vqzu
tappedout.net/mtg-decks/akirithrasios-wip/
gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Search/Default.aspx?action=advanced&subtype= [Cat]&cmc= =[1]&color= @( [G]|[W])
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Red is gay,

Who should I run for a Goodstuff deck. I want something unpredictable, but not too dickish, and preferably a Wedge.

Red is not nearly gay enough.

shut the fuck up

And we're off to a great start!

If you're playing goodstuff pick your colors first, then pick an inoffensive commander, like one of the Invasion/Planar Chaos dragons or almost anything from Legends not named Angus or maybe Rasputin.

Also nice quads.

Haha, OP, you seemed to have forgotten the Discord info. Here it is:

Veeky Forums EDH General Discord
discord.gg/UE9Vqzu

Don't beat yourself up about it though. Just try to be less forgetful next time.

fuck you queer

>favorite playstyle
>favorite type of porn

I want Izzet plus another color. Maybe Green and go Riku? Or is Riku too common?

And thread's over. Thanks for coming!

There aren't that many Wedge commanders; any of them are gonna get play just for their colors. Surrak is probably the least played RUG commander.

spell slinger
anthing where the male is submissive so i can self insert

EEhhh... what? I thought Surrak was the main twin exarch commander. I would probably use the threaten bitch.

Just proof: Even if the OP is cancer-free that doesn't mean the thread isn't going to be a shitstorm.

Why would you say that when Intet is the least played Temur commander?

Control
Bimbos for now but lately mouth fucking is the way to go

>How long do you stick with your commanders, /edhg/?
Depends on how fun the deck is. I took apart Skullbriar after like 3 EDH nights with him, but Ghave has been kicking around forever.

Gwafa lasted one game, but it was a 4-hour game that was entirely my doing

most played would be Animar

Not him but I genuinely forgot intet even existed.

>implying anti-discordfags aren't just as bad as discordfags

Animar isn't usually a twin deck iirc

So she is on lookup.

Point is there's not much room for "Hipster" in wedges.

Oh shut up, OP.

i need some deck help, please.

tappedout.net/mtg-decks/akirithrasios-wip/

Is it immoral or douchey to use this card in a casual EDH game among friends?

It unironically is. See: Emrakul. Though you can substitute straight mana cost for some other extreme obstacle to getting them to play, such as removing the counters to get the Marit Lage token (let's ignore how Vesuva makes that incredibly easy for now).

Iname's problem is that the card is weak, not that it's expensive. A card like O-Kagachi, who in lore is pretty much omnipotent and who previously atomized the plane just by appearing should be some absurd "I win" thing that has some new and novel way of getting it to play, and if that doesn't fit Commander, maybe you shouldn't fucking print him in Commander.

Why would it be?

>using anything with that faggot's face on the card art

Yes it is immoral and douchey to use that card in any friendly setting.

>9 Mana
It's fine. It'd be douchey if you used that one that let you pick how everyone voted

>Leovold
You know the answer.

What's wrong with Leovold?

>How long do you stick with your commanders, /edhg/?

It's been almost two years, when I started playing again. Even with Ur-Dragon coming out, I'm not gonna take her apart, instead I'm buying two copies just to cannibalize one to improve Intet.

I'm not sure how it came up in conversation, but when talking to a couple of friends the topic of death came up, and I told them they could have my cards on the stipulation they keep Intet in one piece and play it every once in awhile.

>voltron
>bondage

>combo
>harem/MFFF+

>How long do you stick with your commanders, /edhg/?
until it isnt fun to play anymore which is usually when the deck is so tuned its just a game of arch enemy. small exception is yidris cause that deck is super fun

In my local group we have two "tiers" of decks, "anything goes" (MLD, infinite combos, additional turn effects, stax etc) and "casual kitchen table fun".

Expropriate is banned in the kitchen table tier.

Superfriends
desu I don't really have a favorite. Anything with my favorite animuu girls in it

Don't these cards usually say "whichever gets most votes" instead of this nonsense? One motherfucker that doesn't want to lose a land and this dude gets another turn?

You're thinking of will of the council, conspiracy 2 introduced councils dilema.

>Intet

To the flavorfag last thread, I see nothing wrong with Kaalia being a 4 drop on a flavor perspective. She's a human, a cleric who wants revenge. There's not much on her story-wise, but from what I remember scrounging up is she made pacts with Angels, Demons, and Dragons. Not for their power to be hers, but to call on them. So to me it wouldn't make sense for her to be a huge CMC bomb, since she herself is not powerful. If anything, the mana costing is more flavorful because each type gave her a color.

That was the old council ability word. The new one is much better, both in terms of power level and play, since every vote counts.

People still don't realize in my playgroup you never ever ever ever ever say extra turn.

>take x turns or permanents
you already know

i use it in every deck that runs blue. its pretty limited by the 9 mana it takes to use

Very interesting.

A terrible deck type with a high loss ratio chosen by a man who enjoys being made into a slave and dominated by others.

A man who desires to dominate all those around him.

A man who chooses to attach many things to his commander who enjoys being tied up.

A deck that can suddenly overwhelm opponents and a man who wants to be flooded by women.

A homosexual.

I really want to play a voting deck.

>Reanimator
>Futa

Cheating in huge bombs
Straight Shota

daily reminder that fast mana should be banned

haven't really played enough different EDH decks to have a preferred EDH style but I"m gonna say aggro/combo
traps/genderbender

Group Hug
Gay sex with armor on

>combo/harem
i like to see a lot of positions.

boy did they cater to you with gays of meletis

Ghave HUEG Sacc with some infinites
Futanari X Shota, with me as the Shota.

Is anybody else really annoyed how Wizards keeps printing cards that become worse the more players you add in Commander products? First True-Name and now this.

You don't fucking make a multiplayer card that becomes WORSE when you add players! That's bad design!

Control or hatebears
thick or BBW

fucking retard

nod a argumen

>liking anime girls
>gay
No wonder so many people think Freud was a nutjob.

Well, you got someone

I dunno about you, but he's going into my Brago deck. Whenever I want, I can bounce him and reset the target.

Ramp into the stratosphere
Futa and male on female

Man fuck animar

>Flexible midrange/goodstuff
>Lesbian BDSM/slaveplay

how do you guys feel about pic related as a commander? I'm trying to decide between him, sygg and the scorpion god

Hard control/whatever Geralf is
gay furry+scaly

woops

Artifact memes
A specific and underappreciated subset of omorashi

Not the place to ask but here I go anyway: why is such a large percentage of furry art out there gay stuff? If it is the obvious answer, why are so many flurries gay?

It is really shitty actually. I played Queen Marchesa voting tribal and it was garbo.

???

The card literally becomes worse the more players are in the game. It's at its best in a two player match because you only have one player to choose from and thus will always get a hit, guaranteed. Every extra player you add to the game makes it weaker and weaker. Commander is a multiplayer format.

This is True-Name Nemesis all over again, weaker obviously but has the same fundamental problem that they're using a Commander product to introduce a card that's not meant for Commander, a card that's at its worst and weakest in Commander and at its best in any other format. Why don't they just put these cards in some random normal set?

hes fucking awful

Sygg is pretty open-ended, while Scorpion God will be shitty BR Hapatra. Unesh is best if you just want blue goodstuff and fatties.

Furries and gays are both degenerate (not judging, but having sex with someone of the same sex as you is degenerative to the species, as is sex with animals) both being degenerates means their will likely be overlap. it may be "homophobic" to say (and could likely constitute as hate speech in canada), but it's true.

Beats me. I'm actually mostly into pretty vanilla stuff in bed and porn, and I'm not involved in furry "culture" at all. If I had to hazard a guess it'd be that furry weirdness overlaps with more sexually open/outright strange people who are more likely to create porn, whereas more mainstream stuff is targeted at the straight majority. If that makes any sense.

Voltron
muscle bareback

Not that guy but it's more complicated than you think. There is a huge amount of non gay stuff but it still dwarfs in comparison. I personally believe, that fictional art allows for the exaggeration and mixture of male/female attributes that gays want. More so than 3D. I think that we can apply animalistic traits that we perceive as masculine (like being territorial) when creating characters. Along with that, for the non complete mega muscle gays, it is really easily to apply female attributes to male fury characaters than it is to 3D. Really? The majority of traps/twinks/other will never look as feminine as modified 2D artwork. At least, not in a coat affective mass consumer based porn way

I'm actually thinking about making this guy. Any recommendations?

Cats

is this bait i cant tell

Hes actually okay in 1v1.

Every card with felidar or oresko in it

cEDH is branding him as a threat already.

he is pretty strong with Mirri.
As early as turn 2 you can have a 4/4 attacking. Then it only gets stronger in the late game

I guess I'll go with Sygg then

seems like most people build him as unblockable ninja rogues, is there any silly dumb combo stuff I can do?

gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Search/Default.aspx?action=advanced&subtype= [Cat]&cmc= =[1]&color= @( [G]|[W])

...

>swing in turn 2 with my 4/4 lifelinking sacred cat
wew

Eminence was a mistake.

or for 5 with loam lion

>Swing in with a 7/8 steppe lynx

>he doesnt gave duelists heritage
Cuck

>Steppe Lynx fetchland rampant growth turn 2
ebin cat maymays

Turn 1: Steppe Lynx
Turn 2: Explore - Windswept Heart/Terramorphic Expanse/Evolving Wilds, crack, crack, general effect, swing w/11/12 on turn 2. Live the dream.

So Eugene is the Soul of Tarkir.
Is O-Kagachi possibly the Soul of Kamigawa?

O-Kagachi has been eluded to being the world soul of Kamigawa, yes.

Eugene?

Ugin

so wait all the other souls are no name big creatures? soul of ravnica/innistrad, etc

oh shit are we really making one shot lolcats?

wild nacal can be a 1cmc 2/2, 3/3 with lush growth. also a 10/10 flying cat.