Previous Thread:A thread for discussing the Star Trek franchise and its various tabletop iterations.
Possible topics include Star Trek Adventures - the new rpg being produced by Modiphius - and WizKids’ Star Trek: Attack Wing miniatures game, as well as the previous rpgs produced by FASA, Last Unicorn Games and Decipher, the Starfleet Battles Universe, and Star Trek in general.
first for Dukat did nothing wrong (except for sparing the Bajorans)
Jaxson Perry
Second for Pah Wraiths being farmed and sold as personality upgrades for overbearing women.
Christian Adams
Why do you hate bajorans so much?
Evan James
What would a Pah Wraith farm even look like?
Michael Myers
Reminder that the Nebula is best shipfu.
Brandon Flores
An Arboretum tended by Keiko O'Brien.
Parker Price
Because they are the worst race in Star Trek and manage to dampen the spirits of the best show in the franchise. However, like Dukat, I wouldn't mind smashing Kira, so there's that going for them.
Hudson Ross
>the worst race in Star Trek
I see that you have been so fortunate as to have been spared from seeing the Kazon.
Dominic Perry
Or the Kobali.
Ethan Hughes
So I was wondering if you fellas would help me with some original species for my campaign. The idea is that those rascally Iconians or however the fuck they're spelled subtly influenced these guys to be unconscious guards/maintenance crew for one of their relics just by existing, which is starting to come off the rails as the federation's able to explore this reach of space thanks to an ion storm receding.
Here's what I've got so far; Gas Men, encounter suit wearing antagonists who have been raging against the explorers in the reach because the hydrogen scoops everyone uses for fuel is literally using their dead (maybe breeding clouds?) unknowingly. Kind of a classic trek misunderstood antagonist, I was thinking of making them distantly related to the Breen explaining the heavy suit look.
Migratory bovine like species that live in big ships. They have advanced deflector technology that lets them live a fairly pacifistic life, and are able to calculate probability to such an extent that it seems like prophecy. They're fairly fatalistic because of this.
William Wilson
I dig the Bajorans. I think they're very much to humans what humans were to vulcans, a younger race with an energy that could revitalize the stogier parts of the federation.
Jack Lopez
Ok you have a legitimate point. Damn necrophilia.
However, are the kazon really worse? Also, that image is pure cancer and isn't helping your arguement.
Josiah Sanchez
More dudes: A machine race that's obsessed with 'upgrades' that come from some great automated refinery on their world, with the youngest models worshiped for their innovation and advanced processing ability and older models struggling fiercely to scavenge the parts that'd make them socially relevant again.
Sasquach-like aliens who grow their whole lives, and fossilize as they age. The mountains that dominate their homeland are actually the oldest living members of their species, hibernating for hundreds of years between brief periods of activity. Maybe they even build ships out of some, great living cairns that let them slowly take to the stars.
Energy beings that inhabit electronics and speak in a strange mathematical patois. They're obsessively curious and tend to fuck with visitors because their very nature tends to screw up technology.
I've got a few VERY rough designs left, like a species that projects themselves into space instead of traveling it, but I'm interested in feedback or even just some ideas for naming these guys.
Josiah Carter
Kazon were supposed to be a threat but came off like a joke. A bad joke. An old, tired bad joke about Klingons.
And they just kept turning up for two years being just shitty henchmen for a cartoon villain and nothing more.
Not seeing how that image is cancer either, given it's a fairly decent shoop as these things go.
Juan Myers
Really, you don't think a shopped sidecut on an unattractive actress isn't cancerous?
Christopher Cooper
Sidecuts looks fine as fashions go as long as they're not on people who are outright ugly, or just fat. That goes for most fashionable haircuts though. Still, it's better than anything with a big forehead covering fringe or one of those looks that just builds the hair up on top like it's a cake decoration. And she seems reasonably attractive enough, not fat or oddly shaped or with a big man-jaw or whatever.
So in short: no.
Charles Torres
/thread
Noah Foster
Mostly I liked that were more fractious than other races we had seen up to that point. Besides the Klingons and, eventually, the Cardassians, we hadn't really explored a society that was neither unified or utopian.
I liked how the civilian government was more or less staving off a military and religious coup for most of the first few seasons. Hell even the religious orders who've basically just had confirmation that their gods are real can't get over their own infighting for long enough to seize authority.
Nicholas Edwards
The best thing about Bajor and the Bajorans in general is that their problems can't be solved with a speech and a warp away. They're an ongoing situation with many people who have differing ideas about what the future of Bajor should be, and the Federation is not supposed to interfere with that process beyond taking over the station and providing assistance.
And then Ben Sisko is apparently the Messiah, and no amount of waving the Prime Directive in people's faces is going to make them stop believing it. There's religion, politics, terrorists, etc. It's a very exciting setting.
The biggest misstep is that they don't show the counterpoint to all the zealots and terrorists, which is that the vast majority of Bajorans want to live in peace, worship in peace, and generally just move on with their lives. But we don't see them because it isn't exciting.
As a result, we see the best of the Cardassians in contrast to all the bad things they supposedly did, and the worst of the Bajorans. I don't think that this was on purpose, but just kind of a thing that happened over the course of the series.
Jace Walker
This is a good way of putting it, though I'd argue Kira very much is the best of the Bajorans,
Brody James
Kira had her arc. She started as the worst of bajor and over time learned that things were more complicated than sitting in a cave plotting to kill spoonheads.
Colton Young
I agree, though in Kira's case she's a main character. I probably should elaborate: We don't see very many Bajoran guest characters who represent the best of their people. Arguably, Bareil, maybe the guy who raised Odo. I can't honestly think of many others who aren't zealots, terrorists, or former terrorists of some stripe.
Evan Bell
Shakaar is a pretty good one. He goes from a leader of a resistance cell to a quiet farmer to leader of Bajor simply because he's unsatisfied with what the Provisional Government was doing.
Josiah Miller
True. I'd forgotten about Shakaar. It's still a very short list.
Cooper Bailey
I mean on paper a fleet of feuding space gangsters could be a cool idea. they just needed something they never really got.
Hunter Phillips
So there was a Pah Wraith farm on the Enterprise D? No wonder Troi crashed it into a planet, the ship was literally cursed.
Michael Gomez
Looking back at DS9 it's actually quite interesting how little they did with the Emissary thing for half the show.
It wasn't forgotten entirely, but that Sisko went and spoke to their gods was, well that was it for the most part. Only quite late on did he start actually having to deal with visions and stuff.
That we see more of the worst of the Bajorans nails it. We do see some good from outside the main characters but it's not as distinct as when we see something we don't expect to be good, like when Quark occasionally catches a case of being a decent person against his better judgement (and suffers for it in some way usually). We do see plenty of Bajorans just getting on with stuff, often being characters who are clearly good-guys (like with Ro and Sito Jaxa over on TNG) but when it's Kira it just blends into it being because she's a main character rather than the mascot for her entire planet.
It's all too easy to see Winn as the mascot character for them instead because she's so distinct and memorable.
>Gas Men GAS MAN!
Nobody will get this.
Ryder Walker
Nah. Troi crashed the D because she's incompetent. She's always been some form of incompetent, stupid, or useless, they just made it painfully obvious in Generations.
Jason James
From the TNG tech manual, where they got the idea to have that sequence in the first place.
Troi didn't crash it. Just didn't manage a best-case landing, given they were punted by the drive section exploding, forcing them out of orbit and into the atmosphere.
Joseph Russell
Shakaar was very forgettable in general. Despite his position as First Minister, he rarely ever appeared on the show. He spent more time being a vehicle to further drive Odo's growing attraction towards Kira than ever really doing Bajoran government things. Not to mention he was largely bland overall. Bareil was at least introspective and had his dynamic with Wynn. Shakaar never really had a character outside of "Kira's boyfriend".
Gavin Parker
I forgot Shakaar wasn't Bareil. That's how much of a non-entity he is.
Thomas Williams
Hey. Hey, user. You there.
You're getting upset about a hairstyle because you've conflated it with a sociopolitical ideology that you don't like.
John Sanders
Seems pretty fair to me, people are getting upset over moustache styles when they are similar to certain peoples from the past.
Jonathan Johnson
Hardly. It's unattractive to have a hairstyle where half your head is shaved while the rest grows long. It has nothing to do with ideologies, it just makes the person wearing it look like an idiot. Hold on to that conclusion though, I hear kneejerk futures are rising.
Henry Sanchez
I admit I don't get it.
Wyatt Brooks
Shakaar is in 2 episodes. He's mentioned a bunch over the course of the latter seasons, seeing as he's First Minister. In his 2 episodes all we really learn about him is that he's a charming man and he'd really rather be growing crops on his farm. The problem there is that he's given no goals or end game. He's a passive character as he's essentially dragged into the plot. That'd be fine if he appeared in a dozen more episodes and grew into his role, but as it is he's eminently forgettable.
Whereas Barail has numerous goals that are made clear throughout his appearances. He wants to stop Winn, he wants to become Kai and he wants to establish a proper peace treaty with the Cardassians. Those are tangible objectives that drive his character. And that makes it easier to relate with him in the short term.
Owen Gonzalez
Actually, if you think about it, Shakaar is a pretty good example of Bajorans overall. Aside from their priests and military, the Bajorans are pretty goddamn passive. It took 50 years for them to make the Cardassians throw up their hands and go away despite an active resistance movement. And even then, the most proactive members of their military after the provisional government was formed felt their best option was a coup attempt led by Frank Langella and that guy from Wings, rather than work with the Federation until they were back on their feet.
Josiah Cox
Say, howsabout a little storytime? My treat!
Here's a fun little offering from Star Trek: The Manga - Volume 1. Yes, really.
Connor Young
...
Wyatt Butler
We get a Kirk the size of a barn door? Yes please!
Leo Robinson
Re: the sidecut issue... Yeah, they're pretty fugly imo. The only time I've seen one done well was when Vulvatron (formerly of GWAR) was rocking one, and that's only because she actually did something with the big gap where her hair should've been.
But hey, it's a fad and it'll die out soon enough to be replaced with something just as stupid. I just want the pixie cut to make a comeback... is that so much to ask?
Joshua Reyes
...
Carson Myers
...
Nathaniel Johnson
...
Leo Perez
Fun fact: I always wanted to storytime this on /co/ for April Fool's, but a) I never had the time and b) I'm not sure I'd have gotten away with posting a manga, even an OEL manga.
Oliver Foster
I even considered storytiming it on /a/, but I KNOW they'd never let me.
Cooper Brooks
>Her body is a mixture of mechanical implants and organs form nine different species Aboard U.S.S. Deviantart nobody can hear you scream.
Brandon Jackson
...
Asher Green
...
Charles Williams
Another factor keeping me from posting this on /co/ is the fact that this is the only scan of any of Tokyopop's Star Trek manga, and it's kinda ass.
John Hernandez
...
Tyler Collins
...
Leo Brooks
...
Sebastian Jackson
...
Eli Hill
...
Kevin Diaz
...
Mason Mitchell
...
Camden Murphy
...
Carter Watson
...
Cooper Gomez
...
Xavier Sullivan
...
Zachary Baker
...
Luis James
Personally I think the religious crap that was Bajorans major hat for most of early episodes was the reason why people hate them. It' gave them that holier than thou-vibe that is annoying in real life religious people, now imagine that in fictional people you are supposed to like.
Ryder Kelly
...
Connor Roberts
...
Gavin Rivera
...
Aaron Johnson
...
Hudson Young
...
Nathan Parker
...
Eli Cooper
...
Logan Bell
...
Grayson Cook
...
Noah Hall
And then add Winn Adami to that picture of religious nutjobs bombing schools just because it doesn't conform to their believes and you can start to understand how much viewers don't really like Bajorans outside Kira.
I get the idea they had with Winn as this antagonist and bad guy, but when she is the basically the face of anything relating Bajor in general, and being the smug shit she was, it's no wonder most people stopped caring shit about Bajorans at that point.
Josiah Martin
...
Juan Cox
...
Aiden Moore
...
Ryder Garcia
...
Ethan Roberts
...
Jason Reyes
...
Justin King
...
Jaxon Lee
Who saw that one coming from a mile away ? It's the genesis of the Borg
Christopher Smith
The only reason I posted this was because somebody was asking in the previous thread if there were any TOS era Borg stories Honestly, when I first read this the twist hit me like a sock in the jaw.
Matthew Martin
>Shakaar
They were thinking of having Li Nalas fill that role, but they weren't sure if they could convince the actor to come back for future episodes.
Christopher Jackson
Well it's better Origin story than some of the other writers have come up with.
Austin Young
Pretty much my thinking but with more of a dose 'Oh here we go...'
The sidecut is basically a cyberpunk fashion, I mean we're at the right time for it but nobody's got the chrome in place.
Gabriel Baker
kek
Isaiah Cruz
>spoiler mein negro of superlative taste
Camden Mitchell
>Nobody will get this. A nice cup of steaming cold tea.
Carson Wilson
>the ultimate evolution in martial-arts
Noah Young
Truly, man has reached his apex. The battle-q-tip surpasses even the great philosophers for artistic merit.
Nathan Thompson
>bombing schools just because it doesn't conform to their believes To be fair that part of a larger plot to kill Bareil.
Jeremiah Martin
>relativistic time dilation Has this EVER been referenced in the main canon? It's obvious from the way tech and travel works in Trek that time and space are absolute rather than relative.
Nathaniel Wilson
The rules of the Alcubierre-White warp drive essentially dismiss relativistic issues by moving space around the ship rather than moving the ship through space. So, in theory (and in setting), there should be no time dilation while using a warp drive. But then, using the Alcubierre-White model, there should also probably be a cataclysmic release of exotic radiation at the exit point of the warp bubble, so it's all really just whatever suits the story.
Lincoln Long
I thought the deflector dish deflected the radiation away pretty much as fast as it accumulates and thereby prevents a ship from becoming a planet-smasher.
William Murphy
Well then boom, there you go, problem solved by "science"
Gabriel Cook
Anyone ever design their own ship for a game (or just for fun)? How hard is it?
John Sanders
I don't find it hard, but then I've designed hundreds of ships for different settings. Unless you mean full designs with deck plans. That shit is a lot of work for full sized starships.
Wish I could find the plans for that Runabout sized yacht I did for a guy's Star War game. Did you want a ship designed? Always interested in making new ships.
Michael Barnes
I've been working on one, concepting it is all I've done since I'm shit at actually drawing and stuff. Surprisingly this is very, very similar to what it would like so that's what I've been using to help me with the design and concepting.
Hudson Roberts
It's covered in the TNG tech manual but for the most part, not a big issue except if sustained cruising at impulse.