Veeky Forums, I ask a noble advice here...

Veeky Forums, I ask a noble advice here, my character lost a lot of people dear to him and he is already mentally unstable for the rest of the campaign (He still works as a Paladin despite this, and still can hold his oath), the guy who killed the people he cared is a another player on the party that plays as a thief.
My character is not that kind of guy that would get over her death, and he wants revenge, what would be the most painful and humiliating death he can deal to his fellow party member?

Give the thief a hug and forgive him.

More context is required.

Ok, where do I start here...

>My paladin alongside the thief, a warrior and a cleric were in the same party.
>The thief wasn't exactly the most social guy ever but I guess that was expected from his line of work so I ignore it.
>We went on some missions for the church
>Basically we were doing the crusades, but the objective wasn't to purge the greater evil, only helping people on the way if they needed.
>Some several missions later, our party returns to the city, my character went to greet his friends and family before reporting to the church
>Warrior decides to go drinking in some pub
>Cleric decides to follow me, only to get sidetracked by some people that needed her medical attention
>So I went alone to the church, Bishop speaks greatly about our party deeds to the Pope and the same thinks about giving us some rewards.
>Bishop later warns me about a powerful necromancer going around destroying minor cities
>The thief however, decided while I gave in my report, he decided to walk around the graveyard.
>He mets the necromancer, that promises him great fortune and eternal life, if he could find a way to get him inside the city.
>He agrees to help the necromancer
>Later that night, the warrior passed out in the bar and the cleric was trying to help him get his ass out of there
>My character meanwhile was at the church, getting a new blessing for his armor and confessing his sins to the Bishop.
>Meanwhile the thief was looking for a way to enter the town with the necromancer.
>They find a way to enter through the sewers and get in the main city, before unleashing hell on earth, the necromancer asks the thief if he wants to spare someone in the city.
>He says "Quite the contrary, I have someone I want you to kill and raise"
>Necromancer laughs
>He guides the necromancer to the house that was my character family, he kills each and single one in cold blood and asks the necromancer to revive them as mindless beast.
Text limit, I'll continue on the next

>what would be the most painful and humiliating death he can deal to his fellow party member?
Hungry rat in a cold pot applied to his warm butt. It's not my morbid imagination, it was execution method in Asia.

>A carpet merchant that is my childhood friend happens to see what happens, and runs to the church to tell me
>He gets there after a hour, and warns me what was happening.
>My character at first didn't believe him, but went to check regardless, he asks the bishop to take of his friend.
>City is in a complete chaos already, undead walking everywhere and some hellish beast, but they prove no match for him.
>Gets on home, see the bloated bloody corpses of his family.
>Seeing them in that state, he tries to fight but his feeling didn't let him kill a single one of them, instead he locks them inside the house.
>He takes some minutes to compose himself after what he just saw and lies to himself "It will be fine, I'll take them to the bishop and our cleric later, they will know what to do"
>He starts searching around town for survivors, with no sucess, the only thing he can find is his former friends and allies dead
>He arrives on the bar for a comic moment where the warrior wrestled every single beast and undead that came there, thinking he was in a arena.
>Cleric has passed out because she has some undead phobia or something
>Seeing that they were okay, he leaves to the church to get the bishop and the pope to safety.
>On the way there, he finds his carpet merchant friend as a undead, he traps his friend inside the confession booth and leaves to find someone else.
>He gets to the altar, Necromancer is smiling quite satisfied with his work.
>Both bishop and pope are dead
>He starts villain speech 101.
>The paladin having none of that, decided to try to attack him.
>Plot wall cuz DM
>He keeps me away with a alarming number of undead swarming the church.
>He tells in detail how the thief killed his family and how he tracked the rest of his comrades, and how they are already dead so the only thing I could ever do for them is release their souls.
>Angry Paladin Screams
>Can't get to him
>Thief fucker shows up the smugiest smile he can muster.

>Can't get to him, neither the thief.
>Thief gives me a notthing perssonel kid
>Try to kill everything on his way to that thief
>They simple walk away while my character struggles to keep up with the hoards of undead.
>Have to run away
>Runs to the pub where the warrior and the cleric are.
>Spends the day there fending off some undead, and drinking heavily between kills.
>My character pass out in the wine cellar
>Nightmares about the events
>Wakes up, the cleric and warrior are back to their "normal" selfs
>Walk around the town seeing as it was empty, cleric says that the necromancer is right, she can't reverse this in any way possible.
>Paladin has a mental breakdown, asks for some time by himself
>Cleric wants to go with him, but the Warrior stops her
>After killing his undead family and friends, he decides to bury everyone he killed.
>Warrior n Cleric don't help him, since they are looking for clues or something that could tell them where the necromancer is going next
>Paladin spends four days to make a grave for each person he killed there.
>Get back with the party, they haven't found him yet, but they might have a clue for where he is going next, since we are next to the desert and he took the entire undead legion, the only logical place he could be is a city some miles away from here.
>So it begins a cat and mouse segment, where our party chases them but they can't get either the thief or the necromancer
>Some days later
>Last time the we meet the necromancer inside a old prison.
>Thief gets separated from him, and ends up in a arena inside the prison where prisioners can fight for their freedom.
>Paladin manages to track him down there by some miracle.
>Warrior sees the thief, and locks him inside the arena, and screams "Take care of the loose end, we'll meet up later"
>Thief with only a dinky dagger vs my full plated paladin with a greatsword.
>Paladin won the duel with some trouble due to his speed.

>Thief is on the ground, not mortally wounded.
>He is trying to crawl to any hole he can find calling me a monster
>Asks me about my oaths, if I kill him the church won't forgive me
>Reminds him that no one will know what happened there.
>There is just him and me, a thief that tried to get a hand in eternal life against a paladin that was honor bound by his duty.
>He realizes there is no way he can get away and throws a tantrum.
>DM decides to stop there.
>Friend that is playing the friend is kinda mad my character caught up with him and is going to kill his special snowflake thief.
>He says he doesn't care about where he lives or dies, but you can see clearly he cares about that a little too much.

And that's it basically, he did some things thinking he would kill the entire party and get his eternal life, but got caught in the act and now is angry about his life choices.

>most painful and humiliating death he can deal to his fellow party member
My fellow paladin, let me introduce you to the torture method known as "Human Pig".

Basically, you cut off all of his limbs. Then gouge out his eyes. Then, you cut off his nose and tongue, poison his throat (so that he can't scream).

Pour liquid copper into his ears, then pluck out every single hair from his body. Poison his skin so that those hair will never grow back.

Find a way to prevent him from ever magically growing those parts back, but otherwise heal him of those wounds.

Now that you have your human pig, you can
1) Leave him in a public toilet.
2) Leave him in a pig pen.
3) Submerge him inside a large jar of wine (take care so he doesn't drown).
4) Put on public display.

Just for kicks, find a way to grant him the eternal life he wished.

...