EDH/Commander

Edh/Commander general
Objectively the best edition

>Official Site: Contains deck building rules and the current ban list.
mtgcommander.net

>Deck List Site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their decks strategy and card choices.
tappedout.net

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the the internet.
edhrec.com/

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen Commanders color identity.
manabasecrafter.com/

CARD SEARCH

>Official search site. Current for all sets.
gatherer.wizards.com/

>Unofficial, but has GOAT search interface.
magiccards.info/

>Thread Question

What other archetypes/tribes have huge gaps in power level when it comes to the chosen commander?

Other urls found in this thread:

tappedout.net/mtg-decks/niv-mizzet-lord-of-the-game/
magicseteditor.sourceforge.net/
youtube.com/watch?v=zSxd49zAnvA
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

>Didn't post a link in the last thread
>Didn't post a link to the last thread

What are you doing, OP?
Last thread

>What other archetypes/tribes have huge gaps in power level when it comes to the chosen commander?
all of them
what a shitty question

Why don't you play Krenko voltron, /edhg/?

Ohh shit. Must have been deleted in the copy/paste.
Thanks user.

DO IT

Yo Veeky Forums, quick question: any recommendations on good cheap (money-wise) artifacts that just sit on the field and do anything in RUB? Looking for shit like token producers and shit like spine of ish sah that do some cool shit then just sit on the field like a lump

any answer that isn't vampires and Edgar Markov is wrong, there's really no reason not to have him as a vampire tribal commander over anyone else

That.... Dosnt make sense.

Krenko is the best goblin commander, uncontested.

What other tribes/archetypes have an obvious first choice?

>Order a bunch of fun cards to spice up some decks
>Estimate that they will arrive in time for your local playgroup's EDH night
>They don't

Those wellspring things seem to be popular. Etb and die triggers on both I believe. Ichor wellspring don't remember the other.

>wedge dragons
Why? Why did wizards fuck up so badly?
The only fun ones are Oros and Numot, and you're going to get reported for harassment and racism. Prossh is the only good wedge dragon too.

>What other tribes/archetypes have an obvious first choice?
if there isnt a solid choice you always go with kerona the false god
works with every tribe

Clerics with Ayli, Wizards will just be Inala with no one else, and Vamps with Edgar

>you're going to get reported for harassment and racism
>tfw when someone asked what my pronouns were i just said "fag" and "faggot"
i got kicked out really fast

Prossh isn't a wedge dragon, he's a shard. Jund and all the other Alara types are shards, Wedges are the Tarkir triple color types.

How is Oros harassing or racist?

How is Ayli clerics?

>Azami
>Baral
Hmm

tappedout.net/mtg-decks/niv-mizzet-lord-of-the-game/

Hey it's the Niv-Mizzet guy from last thread building my first commander deck, how's this, trying to stay at a lower price but I can go up a bit

>How is Ayli clerics?

She is a cleric, so it's either her or the Partners. Some clerics, like Rotlung, have sac themes so Ayli plays into it better.

Clerics mainly deal with life manipulation and Ayli is great for that, along with most clerics being in primarily white and black.

Why would I want either of those two wizards when I can make a copy of a wizard for 1, which is great advantage for Wizard tribal. I wouldn't use Azami or Baral for Wizard tribal since I can make copies of more wizards with Inala, using those two you mentioned as supplements in an Inala deck.

>Oros deals 3 damage to each nonwhite creature.

Glorious end.
You won't regret it.

I like Intet ; _ ;

>Azami
>Baral
>Hmm

Power gap doesn't mean "there are no other choices", it means those other choices are so much less effective. Baral as the head of a wizard tribal deck is completely ridiculous and doesn't play at all into Baral's strengths.

Why aren't people protesting this on reddit?

What general do I play for them to be a patsy for the real purpose of the deck, Knight of the Reliquary and wood elemental

Karametra. She kinda helps too with ramping you up, even though the objective isn't ramp necessarily, it brings out lands for you to sac.

Dinosaurs are Naya and not Jund becaaaaaaaaaaaaaauuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuse.........................

Big dumb creatures with high toughness is white's domain.

Anyone got an Ib Halfheart deck I could take a look at? Zada's fun but getting kinda boring

you're a true hero user

Give it ten years when they revisit dinosaurs. then they'll be simic :^)

So, what's the dumbest MTG related thing you've ever spent money on?

Consider the following

Probably my collection

Derevi to run Retreat to Coralheim.

Because the plane was pitched as "Vampire Conquistadors", so they had first bid on Black. Then Pirates got added and they got seconds. Dinosaurs were briefly tried as UG, playing up the aquatic angle and being ridden by the natives, then they tried putting them a little bit in every color and realized it was not only a nightmare for draft but that printing them in such limited numbers would be cock-teasing players who want them. They found a home in the Sun Empire to give them three colors to work with and enough presence in a faction to print in quantity.

looks good

You stole the art from another card and turned Denn into a girl?

Yes.

It was fine before. Fix Olivia Mobilized instead, that art is a war crime.

>turned Denn into a girl?
No, Denn is just an elf huntress (male).

pretty sure that's already been done

I know that game!

Never had an issue with Mina and Denn, but yeah, new Olivia's art is just in terrible need for a cropping.

>tfw want to make proxies/alters but can't photoshop for shit even if I had it
You guys make it look so easy.

Yeah, Olivia is the easiest thing in the world to fix.

it is that easy, you literally just cut out the art of the old card and move the new art on a second layer
it takes like 30 seconds tops

what do you want changed, user?

Loads better. Jesus. What the fuck were they thinking with the original art?

That Archenemy life counter.

How often do you guys change your decks sleeves? I just changed a decks sleeves that I made only a year ago, but the matte dragon shields got so grimey I had to change them. It's my favorite deck, so use it a lot, but it's not something I have really had to worry about before.

Alternatively, do you ever clean the sleeves off? When dealing with double sleeved shit it seems like some method to clean them off would be faster.

How is it dumb? That thing is really useful.

"She's mobilized for war, she's gotta have a lot of space to move around in!"

Here you go Samutanon, because you never shut up about her

are you implying shes some sort of fast mover
almost like a speedster?

The main thing is I don't have photoshop and I haven't really explored alternatives.

I don't even know what I want but I am exploring into foil proxies although the issue I have now is none of these shits from magiccards.info have borders.

GIMP is free, and very versatile, though takes some getting used to.
Paint.net is free and familiar if you've ever used MS Paint, but needs some extra plugins for full functionality.

magicseteditor.sourceforge.net/
It's literally what was used for that Olivia Full art. Just make sure you use quality images and know what you're doing (Not really a skill, just knowledge) and you're good.

I'm after something maybe more interactive and different than the usual aggro I play, at the moment I have my eyes on gahiji enchantress or wort spellslinger. What do you guys think/recommend

read that as gachi enchantress

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

S C R Y F A L L

It can't be that b-
Oh shit, it's terrible.

>close-up for more details
>loads of bats behind that could suddenly turn into an army of vampires
>menacingly smug

>framing is terrible
>literally alone, not even enemies in sight
>terrible desire to show off her sword while shouting at nothing

...

...

>that heart-shaped pupil on the left
HNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNG

Here's menacing smugness spread across almost 8 million pixels.

>what you gonna do about it, faggot?

Will EDH get a lot cheaper with the 40% decline in players?

see
youtube.com/watch?v=zSxd49zAnvA

nailed it

Fuck off back to /pol/ with your shitty psyops, no one is buying your shit

>twin redhead yuri elves

>Repeating the "8 million" line

The 20 million is total players, 12 million is active players. It's two different statistics for measuring the playerbase.

>he actually listens to Rudy

>psyops
What even is this?

>inb4 thread is autosaged as well

>tfw no interesting esper commanders
>tfw oloro is gay and sharuum is too complicated

...

Is Jin-Gitaxis a fun commander? I've got a kitchen table Thassa control/counter deck with some shenanigans but I want to spice things up a bit.

The card quality has become really bad and cards warp out of pack. So nothing is holding value over the past few years. Sad state for MTG.

>Thassa control/counter deck
>fun
>kitchen table
>fun kitchen table control/counter deck

user I don't understand

It's "Psychological Operations". What it means in this context is /pol/ made a thread about trying to kill MtG by way of what's basically aggressive shitposting. There are some bad statistics floating around because someone noticed official sources have referred to the playerbase as 20 million and then 12 million later, so they're spinning it as "the game has lost 8 millions players" when it's really "There are 20 million people who have played Magic at some point and own some cards, but only 12 million of them are likely to show up to the next FNM/Draft/Prerelease or buy a box on release day." WotC tracks players as "the big nebulous whole who have shown any interest in the game" and "the players who are buying product right now".

And three masters sets in 1 year. And a FTV ensuring easy to get reprints too. Nothing but reserved list cards are holding value.

>Rudy
>listening to any kind of """"Investors"""" who see the only value of a game as what absurd prices the secondary market sets instead of player enjoyment

I'm hoping for more interesting esper commanders that aren't just around artifacts or lifegain.

10/10 so much fun to see opponents Top Deck as you mill for Mad Lab and Leveler!

>/pol/ made a thread
This is already a thread, you stupid idiot. And it sounds like you're obfuscating the stats to make it look like mtg isn't dying.

Also, only a 60% retention rate for a hobby that is all about the long term is fucking terrible.

Did someone pass out a pamphlet of stock lines to use?

You know what? I'll prove it.
brb, going to walmart to get a pack of ixalan

You've got literally three MtG SJW drama threads up right now, post in them instead.

so the card stock doesn't have problems?

>obfuscating the stats
I'm providing context for the stats. Chopping up the stats to fit your narrative isn't any better.

>Also, only a 60% retention rate for a hobby that is all about the long term is fucking terrible.
The retention rate for players is like 11 years, if I remember right. So, with a game that's been running for 25 years, it's inevitable.

>bought about half of my jeleva thievery deck today at lgs
>person I regularly play with the most works there
>sees what I'm buying
>If you sit down in front of me with this deck I'm instantly conceding

:(

I wish og card was better, I like that art

Must have, it's the exact same lines they use every single time

Do you mean the Channelers or MinaDen
is Minaden bad

>FTV ensuring easy to get reprints

You don't actually know anything about FtVs, do you?

/pol/ please go anyone that cares to follow up on anything already knows you are full of shit, your scare tactics already worked on whoever doesn't really care about magic and never cared to fact check. Now the folks left are the ones that do or the ones that don't give a shit either way. You are just wasting your time with other /pol/ shitposters. Trolls trolling trolls, if you catch my drift.

Go back to talking about how all the recent superhero movies are the jews trying to erode faith in christ or talk about the masonic influence driving both parties behind the scenes or something equally ridiculous.

Reprints are bad for "investors" but they're good for growing the playerbase. It's the exact opposite of killing Magic, it's punishing idiots who thought anything other than reserved list cards wouldn't get reprinted eventually.

You get a refund if that happens though, right?

That they inject hundreds of thousands of singles into the market?

Yea.