I'm in the US and I wrote an ETH smart contract and made like 82 ETH but I think the contract is pretty much illegal - basically i made a clone of an obscure "digital trading cards" site with my own branding and added 'ponzi' elements (you earn ETH if someone buys after you) and it went 'viral' and got popular in a crypto group i run.
What are my options as far as not going to jail? i didnt start out intending to defraud the government but now i think i might have to because if i pay tax ill be basically telling on myself...
Some people have said "the government doesn't know about your ETH" but let's say I sent some ETH from coinbase to Binance and also sent ETH from my contract to Binance so there's a connection there which some simple chain analysis (literally looking at one single transaction and seeing the history of the address to which some ETH was sent) would reveal
I guess what I want to know is 1) should I file my taxes for 2018 given that coinbase connection to this 'illicit' eth i mention above and 2) what is the likelihood that they will actually analyze the chain and look at this address i sent eth to and sniff around? I don't have a real job so I have nothing else to file.
Basically I had 'legit' dealings with crypto in 2018 but got 82 eth from this contract in 2019. I think I might be fucked, I never imagined I'd have this kind of problem in my life.
Swap into monero and then say you were paid in monero for a service. You'll still have to pay short term gains taxes (= income tax) but at least if they develop the ability to easily read chain data for all taxes years from now and check you, you'll at least have broken the trail.
Colton Lewis
IRS doesn't care as long as you pay taxes, they still want drug dealers and other criminals to pay taxes. That's all they care about. However you should try to stay under the radar, use a chink exchange to get monero then transfer the monero and sell for a coinbase supported coin
Ayden Brown
Heres the skinny: I did a TON of things in 2017. mined, bought, sold traded a lot on trex and a small amount on binance. I know that technically every single trade is a taxable event so i have a massive amount of work to do in that regard IF they somehow have access to binance trade records. if not maybe i have more options.
It's like this for 2017: bought ETH on CB, sent some to binance at some point (not sure exactly when) bought BTC at bitcoin atm mined a lot and sent to trex eventually moved some tokens i had off of trex and to binance (one address) and did a bunch of trading there on binance
I deployed my eth contract last month and made the 82 eth. however I sent some of that ETH to the same binance address mentioned above.
I KNOW for sure that the IRS will eventually get Coinbase info (might be a few years) but I dont want to be fucked down the road. what do?
Carson Gomez
I'm in the us too ill cash them out for you for 30%
Nicholas King
I am not worried about cashing out - I can do that myself. I am worried about the paper (transaction) trail
Robert Ortiz
>literally nothing, the point of the blockchain is to provide an immutable of everything you do
Dylan King
I know a guy who pays cash
Mason Young
not sure what you are >implying here the point is that they can get my binance address from both trex and coinbase and from there there's a giant list of me sending my 82 ETH in.
David Rivera
Cash out and report it for the coming year under gambling and you won't have to worry.
Brody Flores
that seems like a terrible idea - they audit me and now what where'd i gamble? it just makes no sense
Parker Jackson
Judt tell them you're a web developer who made a useful web app and the eth came from donations
Matthew Flores
>Guys I ran a ponzi scheme help me get fucked.
Owen Johnson
dude I have cashed out over $400k over the past 3 years and reported it all as gambling, after consulting with an accountant and haven't had any trouble. go talk to one and I guarantee you he'll tell you the same thing.
Ryder Bennett
whatever you do, PAY YOUR TAXES. The IRS wants everyone to pay their taxes, they will not turn you in if it looks shady as long as you pay your taxes. If you're a drug dealer, they still want you to pay your taxes. They will not try to get you in trouble unless you avoid paying your taxes.
also put a couple of your ETH towards an accountant or tax lawyer and do this right. You don't have to incriminate yourself and you don't have to get into trouble for this.
t. married to a lawyer
Liam Garcia
the thing is they can check the contract code although its kind of tough and obfuscated a bit, i could easily just swap the data contract out for another one without the "ponzi" elements, that's not really the issue
the real issue is just that i didnt do any "KYC" (didnt make anyone register an account) so i just have this large anonymous amount of eth
what's with this "drug dealer" meme?
>they will not turn you in if it looks shady as long as you pay your taxes
why do you say this? honestly wondering
I am happy to pay my taxes, just curious. this is not about tax evasion, i just dont want to get into deep shit because i sold myself out for no reason
Isaiah Kelly
holy shit
Send your ETH to an exchange. Withdraw it to another eth public key. Voila, you have clean ETH. Government is not gonna look at your public key, look at where the eth came from, look at the exchange, ask and correspond to find out which address you deposited from etc.
Kevin Turner
>also put a couple of your ETH towards an accountant or tax lawyer and do this right. I am happy to do that. You don't have to incriminate yourself and you don't have to get into trouble for this. THIS is my concern. "anonymous people paid me ETH for digital trading cards" seems unbelievable
>Government is not gonna look at your public key, look at where the eth came from, look at the exchange, ask and correspond to find out which address you deposited from etc. that's the thing though, how do you know? you are just speculating. i think in a few years they probably will.
Dominic Gutierrez
fake your own death
Ayden Bailey
>Government is not gonna look at your public key all it takes is 2 clicks on any US-based thing to see >this guy sent ETH from coinbase and polo (or w/e) to the same address... but that address received 82 ETH on dates x and y from other addresses
if i get audited they'll obviously ask about that address, why wouldnt they?
James Cook
You have to flee to another country and fake your death and then live a life on the run. Feels bad when you accidentally create a ponzi happens to best of us.
Noah Davis
RIP
Jordan Murphy
say it was sent by accident
Aiden Mitchell
lmao the 'ponzi' thing is actually pretty small part of it, people love the card game. i just thought since i had the skill to do it why not implement something that would get people interested... didnt expect it to get huge
i did no marketing either
"i have no clue where that 82 eth came from or what happened to it afterward" somehow i think the IRS wont buy this
Thomas Torres
shapeshift you retard.
after that, just don't cash it out and start buying shit with eth directly
Nolan Torres
don't declare it then, the irs is unconstitutional and immoral af, just tell them to fuck off and keep it in cryptos or cash out for gold
Jaxson Russell
It's not really a lot. Shuffle across exchanges like Wex, Binance, Kucoin. Shapeshift (use Tor) to Monero, pass across a few wallets, Shapeshift back (use Tor) in different increments. Cash out using BTC ATMs and LocalBitcoins over a month or two.
Colton Perez
I don't care about cashing it out. I am insane and believe that crypto will replace fiat yadda yadda. Or I can cash out some other way - no big deal.
The problem is just this: I know the post is long but this is the main issue
Alexander Howard
just say you mined it then
Hunter Taylor
so you’re worried about getting tracked right? i can sell you a solution for 200 links let me know if you’re interested
Carter Young
if you give me a valid and workable solution I'd happily send you something, but most of the suggestions ITT are non-starters
I mined 82 ETH? with no record of it or anything?
Connor Hall
what record of should there be? say its back pay from a mining group you used to be in
Oliver Stewart
I assume the IRS expects some documentation, without that I'll just have some shady recent transaction from me mixing the ETH... it'll just be some chunk of ETH for this year alone
Julian Campbell
>most of the suggestions ITT are non-starters please explain how faking your own death is a non starter
Adrian Hernandez
and by 'documentation' what i mean is (if you dont know) you can literally track every ETH transaction back to the point where it was mined
Jacob Moore
say its a back dated lump sum then, sheesh baby's first tax avoidance
Cameron Bell
yeah but they won't, if the people who work at the irs had any intellegence they wouldn't be working at the irs, they would be in the private sector
Joshua Moore
thanks Basically just cash out some of your crypto use that money to "pay" for said ether "offline"
They can't claim that you made the contract and scammed people if you tell them you bought that ether from someone else offline.
Is this workable? I'll post my address if so
Jonathan Peterson
just tell them you did through local bitcoins or something like that
Gabriel Mitchell
>sheesh baby's first tax avoidance heh again I don't care about tax avoidance i just don't want to end up in jail for violating some weird currency legislation
but again "just say x" seems like a really weak defense
that sounds like a great idea but then i have a sort of inverse problem - where'd i get the funds to buy it in the first place
Connor Wood
thanks OP
0x5b2727bbe02521934781bebba03b70ecc8edde1c
Easton Wood
your legit earnings you do have some right?
or you can say you borrowed some from friends and hope they don't ask for documentation regarding that
Gabriel Wilson
9/10 criminals that end up behind bars self incriminate, the irs are fucking brainlets, don't declare and they won't know
James Hughes
i'm sure you can do the basic research on illegal income taxation yourself
something to consider: it's under 82k. So they know if they come after you over where you got the 82k, you're just going to exercise your right to remain silent and plead the fifth a lot. which is what you should do if they do come for you.
they'll have to spend time trying to track down how you made the money, hire an expert to read your smart contract code, etc. given the difficulty of the investigation they won't be able to justify bankrolling it
Dylan Reyes
I have nothing other than my crypto stuff from last year which would implicate me in this pretty much yeah but what about last year? they are gonna get coinbase info one way or the other, they have already started.
Justin Bailey
1. Trade your eth for monero 2. Trade your monero into eth 3. ???? 4. PROFIT!!!
Michael Myers
>yeah but what about last year I told you self incrimination was the road to failure
Aiden Jones
>they are gonna get coinbase info one way or the other, they have already started
my guess: 3 years from now they will have my transaction data and will see that i bought/sold eth and sent money to my bank account
Luke Harris
see
Adrian Hernandez
I think undocumented borrowings should be fine.
Isaiah Green
>Sent coinbase coins and illicit coins to the same address. Wtf is wrong with you?
Connor Russell
am I getting some linkies OP? hahaha eth would be fine too :^)
Daniel Walker
>I think undocumented borrowings should be fine. people could theoretically lend me this amount of money, the problem is in the pudding. "My dad lent me $90k" "ok let's see the withdrawal" - ?
Joseph Long
say it just appeared in your account, I used to play poker with dodgecoin on a website called pokershibes and someone depoisted 50 grand in my account once, say it just appeared
Tyler Morales
continuing, most likely your best course of action is declare the 82k as regular investment income. they'll take your word for it just make sure not to snitch on yourself if they come knocking
Chase Harris
say you don't have access to your dad's bank account? I'm just throwing ideas here like how I'd go about it I don't think they really have a right to ask for that. Do they? brb I'll read up on it
Nathan Wilson
the US government is is scrambling to figure out what the fuck a crypto currency even is, the IRS doesnt have the time, the resources or the understanding to heavily research and investigate what you are doing. as long as there is no lawsuit against you or something and you withdraw less then 20 000 USD per year you should be fine.
Josiah Perry
this is why you should open your coinbase under a false identity
Christian Cruz
> I sent some of that ETH to the same binance address mentioned above.
This is your ONLY problem then. How much was it? If it wasn't much, and if it wasn't too far in the past, start paying for stuff with ETH using this address.
I know a few services that accept ETH, sites that sell youtube views, twitter followers, facebook likes, etc. Scour sites like blackhatworld and offer to pay in ETH from this address.
Your goal here is to claim that you are just one of the guys that got paid from this address. As long as a long time hasn't passed where this address had no activity, and you didn't send too much the first time, just do this over an extended period of time.
Jaxson Williams
Wait a minute you sent your ENTIRE earnings from the ponzi to the address linked to your identity in one go? What was the dollar value of the ETH deposit at the time of the deposit?
Nathaniel Campbell
>swap ETH for XMR >put XMR some XMR on a ledger >sell some XMR for BTC also put on ledger >hide it somewhere >???? >lambo in 14months
Joseph Walker
Fuck sake OP.
Zk-snarks coin mixing contract. Monero via a non-US exchange. Done.
And why even cash out? Leave it in Monero. If you get desperate just cash a little out.
Justin Johnson
This is the full situation attempting to tl;dr: - modest electronic trail from coinbase+trex to binance (even a brainlet could click around and find transfers from coinbase+trex to a single wallet consistent between the two) - binance wallet visibly had 82 ETH go through it with no explanation - all the IRS would have to do is ask Binance if that account belongs to me (I did KYC on binance so they have my name and such)
it would take some knowing/doing, they'd have to basically have my coinbase info AND look at my transactions, but that opens the can of worms
"it just appeared out of nowhere" - fuck man I can come up with a lot of excuses but I don't see how any of them hold water really, the IRS can't be that incompetent, and if they are I should be able to get away with something simpler than making up dumb excuses
Brayden Green
are you retarded?
Nicholas Gutierrez
> 3 years from now they will have my transaction data Good you have time then. This is illegal in the US but not everywhere. If it's an option, renounce your US citizenship and move to a country where this won't get you into trouble,
Asher Russell
Do you think you could claim it from the sale of items?
Alexander Rodriguez
Is what you did even illegal? Is a ponzi scheme illegal if it's done with digital funny money and nit currency?
Mason Morgan
>(I did KYC on binance so they have my name and such) told ya 9/10 criminals self incriminate
Zachary Mitchell
*not
Jason Baker
coinbase - linked to my identity trex - linked to my identity binance - "chink exchange" as described above but they have my identity 2017: mined/bought/sold, sent things around, did lots of trading. Sent ETH from both trex and coinbase to a single binance address at various points.
I assume IRS will have trex data eventually but I am certain they will have coinbase eventually which means I'll get dinged for not paying taxes if I don't file.
2018: made 82 eth from this contract sent it in various increments, 10, 20 at a time.
if you look at the binance deposit address you can see that basically my activity for 2017 and then these chunks in 2018
if I DO file I will pop up on the radar and they might scrutinize my accounts for that reason alone and from there they could find that Binance address
Dylan Cooper
Why don't you do another smart contract game and make a million. You are stressing about something which might never even affect you.
Jack Scott
That's the most above board plan, I am just afraid to go to prison for money laundering and such since we didnt do KYC on the "collectible card" sales
understood just wondering how to play it from here
Nolan Martinez
not so sure if it's gonna sound plausible but could you cash out some and claim that you paid after you received the eth? that'd leave some doubts due to the moral hazard that'd accompany it but at least it'd make more sense right?
Jason White
>solution: make more money and then claim that instead ? heh
Mason Morris
don't mention the contract and etc. and pretend it has nothing to do with you did you register the domain under your name?
Joseph Young
dont give away anymore info, if this ponzi meme is a crime don't tell them, you have a good chance of getting away with it if you don't say anything, if you do declare there defiantly going to book you for it. I wouldn't worry about it mate, the irs are brainlets
Asher Ramirez
Can you prove though that you sold something? You might need proof of such correspondence e.g. if it's for freelancing services, you might need to provide chat logs from Upwork, or posts on /r/Jobs4Bitcoins/ or Bitcointalk discussing the job and the payment.
Dominic Foster
If you are terrified of getting done for tax evasion just pay the tax. Nobody gives a shit about an internet card game.
He could just roll the ETH into his new earnings and it looks legit. He is obviously skilled just also a dumbass. All he had to do was do the monero switcheroo before cashing out and he would be fine.
Listen to this man.
Aaron Brown
It doesn't matter how many taxable events you did in 2017. The IRS only cares if you pay taxes. The maximum amount of taxes you can owe is a short term gains on your gains within 2017. Just pay whatever is the correct amount for short term gains and the IRS won't ask any further questions.
The IRS doesn't go through auditing to make sure you didn't spend income on illegal activities. They just check that you paid at least as much as you owe in taxes. Ponzi schemes are under the CFTC/SEC/etc., not the IRS.
So, just do the Monero wash and pay your taxes, and then it won't matter.
Colton Rodriguez
Transfer to multiple monero wallets. Cash monero back into Ethereum classic. Wait 2 years. Cash out your millions but make sure you pay taxes.
Elijah Stewart
This board was better when it was filled with libertarian retards like me
Parker Parker
I don't think OP has a cashing out problem but has a problem being linked with his illegal ponzi styled trading card game.
Ayden Gomez
Send some if that ETH my way buddy, I'll cash it out for ya
Evan Rodriguez
are you retarded make another binance account, exchange to XMR, exchange back and cash out
alternatively just directly send it to coinbase and cash out beacuse literally not a single government worker will waste his time looking at your eth transactions on the internet, EVEN IF he did he could not prove that you are the one running the money, you might have exchanged it with someone else who wrote the site
or just send me the money and I'l take care of it and you never have to worry again :^)
James Taylor
>dont give away anymore info, if this ponzi meme is a crime don't tell them, you have a good chance of getting away with it if you don't say anything, if you do declare there defiantly going to book you for it. I wouldn't worry about it mate, the irs are brainlets >If you are terrified of getting done for tax evasion just pay the tax. Nobody gives a shit about an internet card game.
fuck
Isaiah Gray
This. It's just an online game ! With money involved
William Morris
are you sure this card game is even illegal user, give us an outline of the business structure, if you wern't pushing it as a ponzi then I don't think theres anything wrong and you could declare as income.
David Wright
the other guy sounds more rational tbf
Landon Hughes
Just claim your profit under capital gains and the IRS wont bother you. My plan is to claim my money into a Tax Free Savings account, but i live in Canada so idk if you have similar TFSA's in america
Evan Mitchell
>He could just roll the ETH into his new earnings and it looks legit. He is obviously skilled just also a dumbass. All he had to do was do the monero switcheroo before cashing out and he would be fine. The issue isn't really the contract/etc because like i said i can pretty much switch the data contract on the back end and it won't be super obvious what happened. they'd really have to scrutinize it with some programmers and such.
the issue is this and this those two posts contain the pertinent details I'm getting a lot of conflicting advice from everyone honestly, just look at this post quality has changed m8 but i appreciate that you are here and entertaining these ideas of mine :^)
>He could just roll the ETH into his new earnings and it looks legit. He is obviously skilled just also a dumbass. All he had to do was do the monero switcheroo before cashing out and he would be fine. hindsight etc I was just an idiot and didn't consider all of this It sounds dumb and yeah muh ponzi but there's an actual card game here and the muh ponzi thing was just a tiny aspect that is kind of ignorable
basically if they dont actually READ the contract it won't even come up.
im just worried about "yeah man I totally got this 82 ETH from selling cards to an ethereum card game"
The problems are these: 1) it's all anonymous. i did no KYC. this is a big no no. pic related, same sort of thing.
so pretty much i need to weigh - the odds that i will report this to the IRS and have them forward my info to the SEC and tell them that im doing illegal shit
against
- the odds that they'll get coinbase's info 3-5 years from now and THEN look at my transactions and THEN follow it all back the problem is basically what said, i just had to do the switcheroo before moving it around but didnt and now this is the position im in.
see above in this post, KYC problems and such
Julian Jenkins
considering online gambling is also illegal in most of the US, i would say OP's clock is ticking before his asshole is raided at pound-me-in-the-ass federal prison
Aaron Wright
i don't really get why you're worried man. worst case scenario, you get fucked on taxes, but it was all free money anyways. this shit is so damn new, you think the govt can figure shit out about eth ponzi/game contracts? the best move is to wait. better solutions and options for figuring out taxes will come along. granted, this could go both ways and the govt might actually become capable of tracking this all a lot better, but realistically, that's not going to happen in the U.S. at this point, unless the ongoing withering of the IRS results in the agency being more aggressive and seeking out easy targets like crypto
Nolan Flores
I saved your address and will consider it it's not a real ponzi scheme thats just what comes to mind when people see/hear about it, like a lot of the crypto games out there today.
the point is that they COULD make that distinction
let's say they don't
the bigger issue is that i just sold a lot of digital trading cards to anonymous nerds in a chat room (my group) to whom i am also anonymous
so I report this and now I've self-incriminated OR I don't report it and maybe they find out somehow later because i didn't have the foresight to commit fraud properly
so which is best?
Josiah Ramirez
There's no way for them to know you ran a ponzi unless someone complains and the contract address gets investigated.
The IRS won't look into where it's from, if you just claim a zero-cost-basis and pay taxes with that... I don't think they can even figure out what the smart contract does, if they even figure it that it came from one.
Just claim it's an online store or a donation address of some sort. Not their job to check it, that's the anti-money-laundering side of things, and if you have other excuses for having such earnings, you'll most likely not get that specific address source probed too much if at all.
Your only real concern here is if someone files a complaint against your ponzi somewhere.
Luis Roberts
when I said "sale of items" I was referring to the original source of money used to buy the ethereum offline in the first place