Is "The Catcher in the Rye" a perfect novel? Here are some famous authors opinions on it and Salinger
Samuel Beckett: “I liked it very much indeed, more than anything for a long time.”
Vladimir Nabokov: "Salinger, J. D. By far one of the finest artists in recent years."
William Faulkner: “Let me repeat. I have not read all the work of this present generation of writing. I have not had time yet. So I must speak only of the ones I do know. I am thinking now of what I rate the best one, Salinger's Catcher in the Rye, perhaps because this one expresses so completely what I have tried to say. A youth, father to what will—must—someday be a man, more intelligent than some and more sensitive than most, who—he would not even have called it by instinct because he did not know he possessed it because God perhaps had put it there, loved man and wished to be a part of mankind, humanity, who tried to join the human race and failed. To me, his tragedy was not that he was, as he perhaps thought, not tough enough or brave enough or deserving enough to be accepted into humanity. His tragedy was that when he attempted to enter the human race, there was no human race there. There was nothing for him to do save buzz, frantic and inviolate, inside the glass wall of his tumbler, until he either gave up or was himself, by himself, by his own frantic buzzing, destroyed.”"
Ernest Hemingway: "Hemingway, on the other hand, is happy to name Salinger one of his three favorite contemporary authors; when he dies, a copy of “The Catcher in the Rye” is found in his library. "
Phillip Roth: The response of college students to the work of J. D. Salinger indicates that he, more than anyone else, has not turned his back on the times but, instead, has managed to put his finger on whatever struggle of significance is going on today between self and culture.” Roth also has "The Cather in the Rye" listed as one of his 15 favorite novels.
As for me I think it's the greatest thing ever written, nothing written before or after it has come close to the characterization, narration, prose style, and emotional resonance and tenderness of this book. I'm always sobbing whenever I read the final two chapters.