What does Veeky Forums think of Zadie Smith? Just read "Martha, Martha" and it sucked

What does Veeky Forums think of Zadie Smith? Just read "Martha, Martha" and it sucked.

Other urls found in this thread:

nybooks.com/articles/2016/08/18/fences-brexit-diary/
twitter.com/AnonBabble

I read White Teeth because I wanted to try to read more female authors, and that sucked too. Just a hodge podge of identity politics, poorly developed characters, and a dull plot. Sad!

She wouldn't be at all famous it it wasn't for her being a woman of colour. That said, she is pretty much the perfect author for the typical London liberal, as by reading her they can virtue signal just how tolerant and multicultural they are

I read White Teeth for a similar reason. Overall, it was just okay, but I would give another one of her books a try. If you're looking for good female authors, Lorrie Moore has become one of my favorite writers, male or female. Her book Self-Help is great.

I live in Canada and I am surrounded by this, not just in literature but in every form of art. It makes me incredibly sad to see and it feels like literature and art in general are being prostituted to post-colonial ideals of multiculturalism.

Is this how minorities want it to be? Does giving mediocre artists from these groups really help anything? If the aim is to shout down racism and conservative views isn't there a better way to do it? Is it too much to ask that western society operate around something other than insincere guilt and apologism? I guess putting on a mask of self-denying acceptance is easier than seriously considering it and that it is for this reason why all these half baked rehashes are allowed to flourish.

>woman of colour
dont let them gaslight you into using this fucking phrase

mfw I just made the headgear connection

kek

There appears to be a clear correlation between stylish headgear and literary prowess.

Lol I'd never seen and actual picture of this negress, who obviously is genetically probably ~75% white. No wonder she can write not totally horribly.

«Cool mom»-core

Not interested in reading anything from her. Looks like a real bitch.

t. intimidated by the presence of strong females in the literary community

I read Swing Time over the summer, and plan on reading White Teeth eventually.

Swing Time wasn't poorly hashed out, nor was it absurd beyond readability, it was a solid novel about growing up as a lower-class mixed-race girl in London. Maybe it's because Smith has matured as a writer, but the identity politics didn't disrupt or corrupt the telling of the story, even though marginalization was the central theme. If I were looking for things to praise, it also spoke to the self-imposed isolation and abasement in the 21st century, in realistic terms. Is it a crowning achievement for Western Literature? No. But 99% of what I read wouldn't fit into that category. I'm happy enough to read a contemporary novel where the characters come alive, the plot is coherent, and it addresses something of the modern condition.

She's not like Dan Brown level airplane fodder, but obviously her fame/recognition is a result of the marketability of being black.

> Lorrie Moore has become one of my favorite writers, male or female.

How embarrassing, I hope for your sake you're a woman

>Is this how minorities want it to be?

lol they have all of zero say in the matter. This shit is done for resentful white women in charge of publishing not minorities. Their idea is if even a nigress can write a book then we don't have to feel jealous of white men

>white women in charge of publishing
Jews are in charge of publishing, not white women.

Ultimately true but in structure its both. There's only so many Jews in the world, they need bitter roasties to do the heavy lifting for them

Thanks. Currently reading "A Gesture Life" by Chang-rae Lee and it's similar to your description in many ways.
>inb4 minority virtue cucked
I am reading both for literature classes and will return to the "white is right" reading list soon enough.

>she is pretty much the perfect author for the typical London liberal, as by reading her they can virtue signal just how tolerant and multicultural they are
This. She got a huge deal for White teeth, having published nothing else, while still being at university. She was obviously perfect, you couldn't invent a better writer to appeal to the Hampstead goons who make up UK publishing

this is the whitest woman i've seen trying to be a person of colour outside of Rachel Dolezel

Nope

talentless quadroon. there I said it.

There’s a certain smugness in her work that irks me. Probably to do with her being English as opposed to being “black” and a woman. She’s worth the read to stay abreast of what’s currently popular but that’s all I take from her work...I treat Junot Diaz the same way.

what does her father look like, he must be white as shit so pale like looking directly at the sun

>English smugness
"magic dirt" theory, I see.

...

...

...

She looks Italian to me

>Franzen as tall as DFW
what

These hacks didn't deserve Dave

who's Dave?

DFW

A lot of reviews of her novels I've read have indicated diminishing returns since 'White Teeth,' though to date I've only read NW and
Swing Time and enjoyed both: NW for its almost Eimear McBride-ish stream of consciousness (even though the more traditional Felix chapter shone the brightest, at least for me); and Swing Time many of the same reasons mentioned.

She's intimated that Americans can't understand Kafka, so there's that. Meanwhile she's decried the Beats, and I want to tell her that's because she can't understand them/they're not for her.

She's an idiot with an inflated impression of grandeur, her husband is a moderately successful novelist from N.Ireland, she made some commentary on the place last year and it was so basically wrong it was embarrassing

Pretty sure Franzen was a Scandinavian name last I checked so not surprising.

That's Mr. Foster Wallace to you

The beats were genuinely awful though

you can tell this man is running circles around her brainlet head right now

You are fucking clueless

>when his height begins with a 5

Your whiplash assumption really strengthens your argument friend

lorrie moore is great, "people like that are the only people here" is one of my favorite short stories

pure, unfettered, concentrated nodishernibletalent

I'm not your friend, guy

>DUDE RACE AND LESBIANS
pretty much everything she writes

I haven't read that yet, I'll check it out

>ust a hodge podge of identity politics, poorly developed characters, and a dull plot. Sad!

What'd you expect from reading a mulatto woman?

That's why you should say "colored woman."

Franzen's almost the only thing in that picture that isn't pure distilled cancer. On the other hand his shorts and flip flips need to be given orange jump suits and handed over to ISIS.

>dull plot
>reading for plot
why do you even read?

> tfw your parents are proud of you

Don't like Zadie Smith's writing but these pictures are very sweet

Theresa nothing sweet about race mixing.

*lol there's.

>he never made a chocolate cream pie

> implying I wouldn't want to stick my white penis into a qt black girl
> not wanting to give your children the gift of beautiful mixed race skin
> implying that when your kids hit their 60s they won't look a day over 30

a qt is a qt, patootie

Race-mixed people are freaky looking and have a lot of mental problems due to lacking an identity. Should not be encouraged.

This, we don't need anymore Elliot Rogers

> "grr i get no pussy but at least i don't get black pussy grr"

if you guy's really hate identity politics then why is every second comment here about here race?

All politics is identity politics.

in some vague way your right; but that's a pretty pointless comment.

No, it's not. Every ethnic group plays identity politics, while whites are supposed to play the losing politics of abstract idealism. You're only speaking out against identity politics because whites are starting to play, too.

We don't hate identity politics, we hate niggers, Jews and women
Get it straight

>You're only speaking out against identity politics
I wasn't.
>whites are supposed to play the losing politics of abstract idealism
where did you get this notion from?
Ah. Yes. Right.

Whites are not allowed to act in their collective interests as whites and if they do they're called nazis and supreemists, whereas jews, latinos, blacks, etc., are and are even encouraged to.

and what are our collective interest?
And who are these shadow people stooping us from reaching these goals?
Try not to be vague in your answers.

>tfw when my dad dresses better than Franzen
Wow.

>and what are our collective interest?
Our collective interest at the very minimum is in the resistance to those who collectively seek to limit and marginalise us.

>And who are these shadow people stooping us from reaching these goals?
There's nothing shadowy about them, they declare very openly and publicy their intent to discriminate against white men in what they claim to be in the name of equality.

It's in white peoples' collective interest to protect our genetic legacy and territories. There's no shadow people inhibiting that, there are jews who very openly oppose it by morally crucifying whites who speak out in favor of such things, which is why so many whites are afraid, hesitant, or unaware that they even can openly identify with their own group interests.

>That's why you should say "colored woman."
no you should say exactly what is meant by the phrase. Nonwhite.

Everything is gaslighting nowadays, it seems.

I keep hearing this, but in what substantive, systematic ways has this marginalization actually come to pass in any meaningful capacity? If you say college campuses, you have to account for community colleges as well.

If you look at any major industry or organization, from media to banking to Hollywood to publishing and beyond, you will find jews stacked from top to bottom. Jews have replaced the former white/WASP elite, and quickly due to jewish ethnic nepotism, and since this new elite views white men as their enemy, and always have, they actively promote and establish policies to exclude them, replacing them with female functionaries and non-whites in the name of diversity.

My friend you are the type of fellow who would ask Noah where is flood is all the way until the water rises past your throat.

>Wanting kids that don't look like you

Is rather we call them “unwhites.”

FPBP

They push all the Diversity BS even harder in the UK than elsewhere. I cannot believe how many books I've read recently set in the UK where some PoC character gets wedged in where one from the Home Counties would do. All written by Oxbridge authors whose publishers hire diversity consultants to get the details right.

She gets hyped in the Guardian but I doubt many people ever read her books.

This.

In the past publishers didn't cater to minorities for the simple reason they don't read much fiction.

Publishers (run by jewish/white saviors) figured they could sell more books to minorities by hyping minority authors and more recently by inserting minority characters into children's books.

Still isn't working. Face it: the novel was a creation of English culture because reading for pleasure is too. Less so in other cultures.

good lord have any of them ever consumed a non-soy based foodstuff

>it's another episode of Jewish Marxist conspiracy
You people do realize that most people don't subscribe to your brand of truther stormfaggotry because it's all bullshit, right? Not because you are some persecuted minority protecting a dangerous secret. I'm sure all those rejection letters are because you're white men, though, and not because your stories are the brainchildren of your NEET autism.
>inb4 any reply
U can't touch me, I'm immortal

link to piece on northern ireland? Its always shocking when you hear these contemporary novelists talk about ANYthing, how they know absolutely nothing at all. I suppose thats what you happens when you study critical theory and nothing else until youre 36. Thyats whats so shit about DFW; every fucking allusion and idea is just some po-mo nonsense; the history is 'critical' history, the view of personal psychology, everything is just this ivory tower navel gazing.

>I'm immortal
More like a jew or shabbos goy who needs to take his subversive or uninformed opinion back to red&it where it belongs.

>tfw a qt negress repeatedly tried to fuck me but i didnt because i fell for /pol/ memes

Nobody of the internet generation has a political belief. They just love trannies or hate them and furiously abuse themselves to trap porn. Whether they're PC snowflakes or stupid racists they're all victims of the same paradigm shift: keep politics out of politics, let the great unwashed froth at the mouth for/against transgendered children or whatever nonsense is on twitter this week leave the politics to the people who know what theyre doing. It makes sense from a division of labor perspective and really keeps the double digit IQ's where they belong.

Possibly this:
nybooks.com/articles/2016/08/18/fences-brexit-diary/

I've never read her novels, only her essays and journalism - they've not given me an appetite to read more of her.
What strikes me is how she never seems to have an original thought. Take away how highly polished her prose is; the content, her ideas in everything I've read by her, are utterly banal and commonplace. It's boilerplate Polly Toynbee or any other Grauniad op-ed writer.

>women having original thoughts

When has this literally ever happened

Smith's focus on identity politics was her publisher's idea to promote racial awareness while she rides the BWC. In that regard she just like her mother who loves white cock. Franzen's fucked her. Dave blew her out. She doesn't believe in her own work because it's a means to an end. The end being the type of whore who asks the hwhite man she fucking to call her a filthy nigger while he splits her sweetwalls and empties his sac in her womb.

Franzen totally fucked her but Dave has higher standards than that mannish halfbreed

white teeth is by far her worst book and she was like 25 when she wrote it, her later books and especially NW are good

Then why does white teeth always get mentioned like its her magnum opus?

df only met her afaik at that italian lit fest all these pictures were taken at and he was with his wife, you can see her in the videos
franzen has never fucked
zadie has been with her husband since undergrad or some shit

bc it was a big hit in 2000 and is the only book of hers that a lot of casual readers have read

Like that means anything. These tumblr types are always self centered whores who always give themselves every excuse to whore out

OK but why didn't her other books receive recognition if they're allegedly any better

calling a forty-something woman who has just been teaching lit classes and writing since she was 20 and is as techphobic as franzen 'tumblr' is the most retarded thing I've seen since further up this thread, if anything Zadie thinks she's too level-headed and fair-minded to side with any political "extreme" and is more likely to side with people against being pc than with what you think of as "tumblr's side"
because like 5 books a year get any attention, are you not understanding the concept of someone's best work not correlating to it being their best known work to the wider public?

>calling a forty-something woman who has just been teaching lit classes and writing since she was 20 and is as techphobic as franzen 'tumblr' is the most retarded thing I've seen since further up this thread, if anything Zadie thinks she's too level-headed and fair-minded to side with any political "extreme" and is more likely to side with people against being pc than with what you think of as "tumblr's side"

The above is one sentence with no capitalization or punctuation. You're black, aren't you?

You're mixing up being literally tumble and being spiritually tumblr. She's a dirty fucking hypocritical whore and you're probably one as well if you're defending her

franzen is like 6'3" or 2
eugenie not being a solid 5'8" surprises me

The ss I read reads like a college fiction class submission. I see what people mean now about identifying creative writing students by the formulaic structure of writing.

>ivory tower naval gazing
I am baffled by the creativity of perjoratives used on this website

I'm proud to say I have never read anything from any of them

zadie has more in common with every other sheltered english professor than with tumblr teens