Lovecraft ripped off Gogol

Both the excerpt and the pic related were made by Nikolai Gogol when Lovecraft was 14. Almost exact same style and theme of storytelling can be found in Howard's first works, I assume were just blatant copying.
Just read this:

Viy (1834):
"...Suddenly in the midst of the sepulchral silence the iron lid of the coffin sprang open with a jarring noise, and the dead witch stood up. She was this time still more terrible in aspect than at first. Her teeth chattered loudly and her lips, through which poured a stream of dreadful curses, moved convulsively. A whirlwind arose in the church; the icons of the saints fell on the ground, together with the broken window-panes. The door was wrenched from its hinges, and a huge mass of monstrous creatures rushed into the church, which became filled with the noise of beating wings and scratching claws. All these creatures flew and crept about, seeking for the philosopher, from whose brain the last fumes of intoxication had vanished. He crossed himself ceaselessly and uttered prayer after prayer, hearing all the time the whole unclean swarm rustling about him, and brushing him with the tips of their wings. He had not the courage to look at them; he only saw one uncouth monster standing by the wall, with long, shaggy hair and two flaming eyes. Over him something hung in the air which looked like a gigantic bladder covered with countless crabs’ claws and scorpions’ stings, and with black clods of earth hanging from it. All these monsters stared about seeking him, but they could not find him, since he was protected by his sacred circle..."

>i exist in a contextless state

Memecraft was a hack

Gogol states in his author's note that Viy, the King of the Gnomes, was an actual character from Ukrainian folklore. Scholars believe that the conception of Viy may have been at least partially based on old folk tradition surrounding St. Cassian the Unmerciful, who was said in some tales to have eyebrows that descended to his knees and which were raised only on Leap Year. It is likely that Gogol had heard about the character and designed Viy on his various forms.[1]

The demons summoned into the church come from the Slavic superstitions of "midnight dead". Evil people, it was believed, automatically became Devil's subjects upon death. Earth would not hold them so that every night they would crawl out of their graves and torment the living. In the story, the demons have "black earth" clung to them, as if they crawled out of the ground.

The water sprite (Rusalka) seen by Khoma during his night ride bears relation to the "midnight dead". It was widely believed, in Russian and Ukraine, that rusalki were spirits of unbaptized children or drowned maidens, who were in league with the Devil. They were known to drown their victims or tickle them to death. They were described as beautiful, and deadly, and bear relation to the young version of the witch, and Gogol's frequent portrayal of women as beautiful yet evil.

Incantations, exorcism, and the magic circle come from Ukrainian beliefs of protection from evil forces. The circle relates to "chur", a magical boundary that evil cannot cross. Even though Khoma died from fear, the creatures could not touch him.

Additionally, the final notion that Khoma died only because he let fear win over him appears to stem from John of Damascus, who said "... all evil and impure passions have been conceived by [evil spirits] and they have been permitted to visit attacks upon man. But they are unable to force anyone, for it is in our power either to accept the visitation or not."

Gogol ripped off Ukrainian folklore

Was he even translated into English at the time?

Who cares, lovecrapt is shit, and his fanbois are even worse

The context you live in is the context of those digits.

checked

Pssst... everybody rips off someone else.

All the greats stand on the shoulders of giants.

Cormac used to say that novels were made of other novels.

Lovecraft is just the figurehead of a whole movement of post-Poe weird fiction writers from about the 1890s with the publication of "The Great God Pan" to about the end of the 1960s when Richard Sharpe Shaver stopped writing fiction. These guys made horror cosmic, either in a fantasy or science fiction mode, or both together. There were probably over a hundred of these writers altogether. Lovecraft didn't invent anything or do anything particularly well. He just epitomized a certain aesthetic and approach, and pulled the different strands together, so we call the trend Lovecraftian. It's just a handle, for convenience. Most of these guys wrote for pulp fiction magazines during the glory days before World War II when paper shortages killed that format. Since 1968, Lovecraft's legacy has kind of devoured the weird fiction genre to the point where a lot of the other writers have been pushed to the margins if not forgotten, and all the new entries are just Lovecraft pastiche. You'd be mistaken if you think that anyone knowledgeable thinks Lovecraft invented the genre.

>Viy (1834)
>Lovecraft born in 1890
>made by Nikolai Gogol when Lovecraft was 14

That is not dead which can eternal lie, And with strange aeons even death may die.

lovecrap fags BTFO'd

...

wtf is going on with that nigga's eyes?

Hey can you give me some recommendations for good post-HPL weird fiction/horror?

That just reads like Gothic in general though. You need to read more.

Every time he proves something by induction a new pair grows on top of the last one.

Laird Barron, A Season in Carcosa (Anthology), various short stories by Ligotti, Robert Shearman.

I've never specifically heard Gogol mentioned but most people who are even a little bit deeper into Lovecraft are aware that his work is an amalgamation of Machen, Blackwood, Chambers, MR James, and a litany of earlier horror writers filtered through HPL's worldview and interests. Calling writers "rip offs" as if being influenced is the same thing as consciously setting out to exploit another writer's work is childish.

>can be found in Howard's first works
But Lovecraft's first works were not like that. They were more an imitation of Poe. You have Lovecraft's pastiche timeline messed up, therefore you are a shub-nigger.

i fucking love viy. the film is actually pretty good too

Well what are THOSE novels made from?

it seems wrong to see him be called "Harold"
all this time I thought the H.P. stood for hairy penis and now it stands for harry penis

>Was he even translated into English at the time?
He was not. Not commercially, at least. But I'm sure some of his works found their way into the hands of some english-speaking enthusiasts at the time, and could have weel been translated and shared in writer's circles. It's possible that Lovecraft could have heard of him.

Derrida BTFO

Agreed, if there was anyone who's style Lovecraft hardcore imitated throughout all of his writing, it was Poe.

hey, are you that poster i told about Viy the other day? you seem to like it. Make sure you read Gogol's Portrait, too!