Critique Thread / Writing General

Some of your imagery could be better. For example, instead of "making the noise of a helicopter" you could replace that with "screaming like a helicopter" or "filling the room with thousands of helicopters" or something to that effect.


Your reliance on "was" is to my distaste as well; you could easily replace verb phrases like "was knocked" to "blew out".


The sentence structure also repeats itself with compound sentences over and over. It feels robotic; in fact, the whole thing feels robotic.

This reads like powerfantasy fallout fanfiction. Awful fanfiction at that. I hope it's ironic for your sake holy shit. "Get in there and no funny bussiness." Holy shit my duder...

Thanks for the critique, very helpful. I wouldn't have noticed any of that on my own.

"Alright I did take off my pants in his apartment, " I said to him. Maybe I enjoyed watching his face turn from angry to disbelief. Maybe I am doing this to hurt him. He is so attached to the idea of us being together forever that, maybe, telling him the truth might actually be of benefit to him. I didn't deserve his dog-like loyalty. And perhaps, I do like cheating on him. But instead his expression turned into that of dismay and defeat. He looked down at his feet and lowered his head. I utterly destroyed him and I felt not a single ounce of remorse.

Later that night, in an email, he sent me a collection of all the poems he wrote for me. They were utter crap and made me hate him more. He treated us like we were in love in the old world where loyalty and sweetness mattered. I'm young, I have the world to explore. I can't stay with him. A boring romantic who never gets tired of my presence and always tried his best to appease me. And the sad part of it all is that he is the best boyfriend I ever had.

>her
>load
huhuhuhuhuh you said 'load'
say cargo instead

Avoid adverbs. Gross likeness, tumor dog. what the fuck do you mean shooting them like marbles? I thought you shot marbles with a thumb. That's how it was in all the old cartoons I ever saw anyways.

Change 'resembling' to 'like'. I don't buy all this stuff about remembering actions but not names. I just don't buy it. Seems made up to me. Its so pretentious man. Granted that last criticism is a matter of taste. But nothing's going on...

Not an english person or anything, but something compelled me to write lyrics to this song. I have never done something like this before:

>youtube.com/watch?v=_IDhX8REm9Q

The sun’s behind the clouds
The air now smells of ash
If only you could hear me
If only you could see me
I’d conceive of a way to make things last

But dawn has turned to dusk
and my heart starts to run amok
When the daylight comes, at day break
I’ll cringe the second I awake
But in this very moment I can’t explain

Drawn in by your scarlet dress, your sparkling eyes
I walk up and I try to say goodbye
But you say “It’s okay, It’s fine if you stay”
You ask me if I want to dance
I do decide to take the chance
Oh how the night then passed swiftly away!

No more clouds do I see
The sky is filled with stars
We’re holding hands and yawning
Soon the sun will be dawning
How it turned out this way I can’t explain

(Piano Solo in song)

No more clouds do I see
The sky is filled with stars
We’re holding hands and yawning
Soon the Sun will be dawning
How it turned out this way I can’t explain

Any and all criticism is welcomed!

at the root of all these criticisms is that this style seems forced, trying to be higher than it really is. Try to write it as if you were telling a story to a friend. Perhaps that's awful advice that you can disregard out of hand... you don't have to take the positive suggestions, but I suggest you do take the negative ones.

>Avoid adverbs
Shit advice. Adverbs build mood

yeah cause "vaguely" really steeps me in a subtle mood...

passage about two spirits:

pastebin.com/raw/PeyYdW3S

Gonna quote some shit lines that made me cringe with some commentary


> I saw her years ago when a truck full of oranges jumped a curb and spilled some of its load onto the street by our little herd.
Spilled a load eh?
> She had stuffed her blouse full of oranges and she looked like an ancient tumorous dog. When she walked the oranges undulated in her blouse, and a heat bloomed...
Beautiful (not)
> I must keep a log of those actions which are familiar to me so that I can recognize them in patterns. The names come with the repetition.
Oh you must? Are you retarded or autistic?

> For example, I know my mother from the way she moves a pan across the stove, like she’s balancing an invisible ball in the grease. The rolls of fat beneath her arms move just so as she does this, and the socks she downed and wore, the ones with the pink dogs on them, crawl down her ankles with her movements.
Lmao good for you?

> These things are my mother - a moving pan, tremors in her arm, and socks that move on their own down ankles. There are other patterns like this, but hers is hers and that is how I know her.
You really are autistic