>Do you like science fantasy? >What is your favorite science fantasy work? >What are some science fantasy books you'd recommend? >What is the best blend of magic and technology you've found in fiction?
double-posting from the previous thread, kill me please.
fuckin hell I finished the Prince of Nothing trilogy last night. The first book was a MAJOR slog but by the end the characters, settings and themes really grew on me. Looking forward to the Aspect-Emperor trilogy. Questions/discussion follows:
What's Bakker getting at with these books? I know he's a big Veeky Forumstard, having ABD'd in analytic philosophy or somethin. Is the big theme the fact that we (humans/man) are not free but instead driven by our desires/genes/customs/the atoms that make us up? Am I supposed to read this book as materialistic (and probably nihilistic)?
Obviously Kellhus is privy to all this knowledge, so I'm not sure what he represents. Seems like he's the guy that DID finish his dissertation in philosophy and has all the answers. Cnair is "woke". The Consult/Inchoroi are just another extension of humanity (except they are REALLY driven by sex..hints to Freud?)
What did you guys get out of it? How does the Aspect-Emperor series of books compare?
Logan Phillips
>>What is your favorite science fantasy work? Lord of Light full stop accept no substitutes
Owen Evans
Well you might want to finish Aspect Emperor before speculating or getting too married to these ideas, but yes the nature of free will and knowledge is one of the big themes. The other, which is touched on lightly in Prince of Nothing and more heavily in Aspect Emperor, is the old question "Is Good innately Good, or just because God wills it?"
Also Kellhus, mad or not? Was Moenghus right?
Isaac Ramirez
The Consult are the ultimate extension of one fully materialistic route of progress of humanity. Utterly hedonistic and driven by sensation. The Dunyain are the opposite pole. Still materialistic, but driven entirely by logic divorced from most natural urges.
Charles Nelson
A-anything about knights?
Charles King
...
Owen Ward
@ the user who was hating on Christian Cameron for writing domineering women, can you give some examples? I haven't noticed this.
Daniel Johnson
>making hinduism great again.jpg Are you, by chance, a poo in the loo?
Kayden Powell
>What is your favorite science fantasy work? Hyperion, no contest
Angel Walker
Am I a pleb for liking The Deed of Paks?
Ethan Thomas
No, Vedic Brahmanism is just kinda neat.
Xavier Allen
LitRPG is fun, you should all try it. Just like normal books, there are good and bad LitRPG. Super Sales and Daniel Black are two of the good ones.
Gavin Nguyen
Welp, time to get started I guess.
Jordan Thomas
The mum in the Red Knight who encourages her sons to bully each other and a romance that ignores him. The drunkard mum in Marathon shuns her sons, doesn't give a shit that one is killed and another enslaved. The love interest has him whipped when he is her family's slave, knocks him unconscious a few names, and is generally an all round dickhead. Then in Tyrant the female protagonist abandons her infant son to run off and become some nomadic warrior queen.
There's probably more, but I tend to drop his shit.
Colton Bell
So I just finished playing Subnautica and am heavily lusting after stories (both sci-fi and fantasy) involving being stranded or exploring strange lands/planets.
Last books to give me these feels have been the New Sun and Endymion/Hyperion.
Could I get any recs for that? Thanks.
Henry Rodriguez
Annihilation maybe?
Asher Davis
>didn't listen to me when I said to avoid his books >could have stopped at red Knight >ended up reading a bunch of others
Jack Carter
>Annihilation VanderMeer?
Jace Price
desu the only reason I persevered with the Red Knight was because of the (not) Byzantine Empire they go to
Dylan Johnson
Any readable Magical Realism/Historical Fantasy? I don't care if it's pretentious or has GRI or anything. If it's for the lowest common denominator I'm probably going to like it. Just throw shit at the wall and see what sticks
Alternatively, non-european/russian fairy tales
Julian Gomez
Yeah, just don't expect a classic like New Sun if that's what you're looking for. It's more of a thrill ride that you enjoy in the moment but ultimately forget
Sebastian Wilson
Temeraire if you want low-brow Napoleonic Wars with dragons
Colton Long
No, no. Looking exactly for that thrill, New Sun was just an example of a strange world.
Bernard Cornwell's Warlord Chronicles might be what you're looking for.
Jack Johnson
>science fantasy wtf does this even mean? dragons and rayguns? robots and faeries? knights with ipads?
Jaxon Bennett
Saddest fantasy book you've ever read fellas?
Daniel Allen
all those things are science fantasy, but there's usually a bit more nuance to it than that. Either the lines are blurred sufficiently that the distinction doesn't matter (e.g. sufficiently advanced technology, lovecraftian horror) or the science is so bullshit that it's basically fantasy (Doctor Who)
However, there is an entirely separate classification I refer to as "Hard Science Fantasy" which basically amounts to thorough integration of science and magic on a metaphysical level. Obviously this is a really high bar to set so instead science fantasy is usually roped in as long as it expresses awareness of the science it's violating (e.g. His Dark Materials, Discworld)
Normally it means historical fiction but there's at least a little bit of magic present in the setting. It doesn't rewrite history the way Alternative History does, and the fantastic element doesn't have to be significant, with some examples being subtle enough that the book isn't even put in the fantasy section. In all cases though a recurring theme is that fantasy element isn't the center of the A-plot. Ultimately it has to be about people living their lives and magic just happens to be there
Owen Watson
Not so much a book as a short story but The Paper Menagerie. No written thing has ever brought me closer to crying
Carson Bailey
first for splitting into two generals, one for sci-fi, one for fantasy
Logan Jones
What the hell is a LitRPG?
Alexander Howard
We did that years ago and scifi crawled back begging us to let them in again.
Brody Wood
Western version of anime / light novel.
Jaxon Rogers
I'd never heard this term before. How does anime even work in book form? Is it basically just Wheel of Time?
Nicholas Robinson
That actually happened once. Sci-fi peeps insisted on having their own threads, but they collapsed within a week and just came back here. Fantasy bros didn't even notice they were gone.
Anthony Morgan
I swear to god this board has existed for all of two years. Hmm, ah well. I read sci-fi now but never cared much for fantasy. Maybe sci-fi bros were just poorly led then.
Nathan Collins
shit. this is two days away. time to speed read
Eli Robinson
>the science virgin >the chad fantasist
Dominic Kelly
>have actually successfully written a novel >all I feel is failure because I haven't successfully written a homestuck knockoff
what the fuck is wrong with me?
Asher Mitchell
Six Expressions of Death, Gemmell's Troy trilogy, Cornwell's Warlord Chronicles
Nathan Mitchell
kek
Charles Watson
Kek
Hunter Foster
Vorrh
Nicholas Butler
>White Sand vol. 2 out today >can't find a rip anywhere :-(
Blake Ortiz
THEY'RE IN THE GAME!!!
Generally portal fantasy plus explicit gamification, like numerical stats and leveling up. Guardians of the Flame was an early hybrid, crossing explicitly to a game world but no stats on the other side (the first few are good). Try Drew Hayes's NPCs for a sincere and harmless modern version, JA Cipriano's Legendary Builder series for angel / succubus harem fantasies with game elements. There's a wide range out there but it's all from the deep end of the schlock pool at this point.
Jason Wilson
People actually write this shit?
Cooper Gonzalez
They can churn out a book every month or two. I love it -- it's the new pulp era.
Charles Evans
I can't decide whether to finish Baxter's Manifolds, begin the Annihilation series, or just read this old paperback of Armor I picked up
Matthew Wright
I'll bump this for ya. I need more medieval fantasy adventure stories
Jose Reed
Fuck me, a good hardcover copy of Hyperion would cost me 300 - 500 hundred bones.
Jeremiah Gutierrez
add and remove stuff.
Carson Gomez
Where's the GRI category?
Alexander Nguyen
any more chill stuff that's closer to the turn of the century?
Ryan Richardson
How far into the Manifolds are you? I read the first two; heard the third wasn't that great--and the premise didn't sound too much like what I would enjoy anyhow.
Eli Thomas
Join the Veeky Forums water margin reading group. Threads are on Fridays, this Friday at chapter 35
Benjamin Morales
What does /sffg/ think of The Expanse? I'm halfway into Babylon's Ashes and really enjoying the series. >mfw the plot went full Gundam in book 5 I'd really like to see how the show adapts all of the shenanigans that Alex and Bobbie's pull with the Razorback, but that's probably like 4 years away at the least.
Logan Wright
Webnovels are novels too
Andrew Perez
Just "Time" so far. It was more of a struggle than I thought. I felt like it ran out of steam. Maybe I'm just so jaded that hopping through proto-universes is old-hat.
Blake Nguyen
I'm trying to start reading the Foundation series, made it to part three of book one and I'm struggling to keep going. It's a whole lot of people talking about things happening/things that have happened and not a whole lot of things happening. Think I'm going to abandon it, sadly.
Jordan Morales
What should I read first? Hyperion or shadow of the torturer
Cooper Watson
I would advise against it. It doesn't really begin to take proper turns until later. Have you even gotten to any mention of The Mule yet?
I haven't read beyond the original trilogy because I can't see how it can be continued.
Jackson Phillips
Whatever you think is wisest, my lord.
Anthony Phillips
No mention of the Mule, don't know what that is. I'm a little less than halfway through, in the Mayors section. You'd advise against giving up or against reading it? I'm willing to give it more time because I did really like the beginning, but it's becoming kind of a chore.
Carter Green
Thank you my son. I guess it doesn’t truly matter right?
Grayson Morgan
Diaspora
Blake Perry
>Mayors section I assume that means where early Foundation leaders keep BTFOing retards using superior technology, right?
I say keep reading, it really does get into proper sci-fi mind-fuckery, in my pleb opinion. Once the Second Foundation becomes a topic of interest, this is where it starts to get great.
Blake Clark
Diff. user curious about this one. Will Egan make me feel like a tard for not knowing my maths in this one? I like Schild's Ladder, save for the aforementioned math lessons.
Oliver Taylor
Grimnoir Chronicles?
Justin Hernandez
Monument by Ian Graham
Gavin Ramirez
could i get my nigger paolo bacigalupi in the post apoc section?
Logan Carter
Jack McDevitt has done quite a few "research team goes somewhere and gets in trouble" stories.
Though after the third or fourth disaster in the Academy series you start to wonder why they don't give the research teams bring along more serious gear than stuff that archeologists would take on a trip to dig up dinosaur bones in Utah.
Connor White
Is Three-Meme not there because of contrarians, or because Veeky Forums genuinely can't enjoy anything? Also, take down the Stephenson, and the entire genre of Cyberpunk.
Eli Ward
Add Embassytown, replace Consider Phlebas with either Use of Weapons or The Player of Games, remove Ringworld and the Diamond Age
Daniel Lee
How about some Big Dumb Object books that feature being stranded and exploring, such as: Ringworld, Pushing Ice or Bowl of Heaven
Anyone here even read Bowl of Heaven? I only read the sequel, Shipstar, and didn't even notice that it was a sequel until a good deal into it. It was alright.
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell
Hunter Long
doesnt larry niven suck now and just get his fans to write for him?
Josiah Smith
Split modern, you can't have Dick next to Watts (did I mention you need to add Blindsight
GoT in somewhat hard space. was okay
Isaiah Walker
MALAZAN IS SHIT
SHIT!!!!!!
Isaiah Howard
Reading Rendezvous With Rama for the first time right now, and it fits that. Really fucking good, too.
Sebastian Brown
>Will Egan make me feel like a tard Yes
Dominic Brown
Board was around since 2010, I think. I was on Veeky Forums since 2006 though..
Luke Fisher
Check these out, they are the best of what litrpg has to offer.
Luke Torres
CAN I READ THIS AS A STANDALONE?
Ian Jackson
And they make good pocket change from it. If you're a good author you should try your hand and get money for a new pc or 40' tv
Angel Sanders
>gamer for life
Isaac Sanders
Just admit you want the dick. No need to play a stuck up bitch. yeah gamer 4 lyfe turned into shit
Angel Ramirez
rats!
Yeah, I was thinking of Veeky Forums, and I'm still here like 11 hours later, so that should tell you something about my Veeky Forums problem.
Mason Gomez
i dont know how anyone could think those books are litrpgs. there are two that i would consider pseudo litrpgs. because they have stats but they arent actually litrpgs. this picture has to be a troll or something.
Juan Edwards
True litRPGs are too autistic for this board.
Logan Gray
ignore these , when they're talking about removing Stephenson and cyberpunk. A couple dudes here have a massive hateboner for cyberpunk for some reason, those books shouldn't be left off the chart because they have an extreme bias against it.
Aaron Hall
Add a category for "transhumanism".
Lincoln Taylor
The Mule make his first appearance in book two, which I'm currently reading. I find the books highly average, The Mule makes it slightly more interesting but not much desu. Maybe it gets better, I'll keep reading.
Christian Nguyen
am I blind or is book of the new sun not on there
Wyatt Jackson
I tried it. It was like logh with no battles just tons of geopolitical (galactopolitical?) dialogue
Jeremiah Hall
One can like cyberpunk and dislike Stephenson at the same time