Was slavery all that bad?

Was slavery all that bad?

Other urls found in this thread:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_Revolution
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

It was bad if you believe that humans are inherently deserving of personal liberties and rights.

If you were a slave yes, it was pretty bad.

Right Click
Hide Thread

>humans are inherently deserving of personal liberties and rights.
this is the spookiest shit i've read all day

No shit

What do you mean by slavery? It was a pretty varied institution.

NO
Some slaves were richer than normal or free people in Ancient times. That says everything.

Slavery is relative and continues to this day. But wait you argue the average negro never left the plantation. How many wage slaves leave their hometown?

Only a small minority of humanity was ever truly free.

The average life of a black slave was much safer and stable than the hellish conditions they came from.

You rent a house
You lease a car
You buy furniture with no resale value
Virtually every piece of personal property you own is worthless
If you lose your job you lose everything

How are you any different from a slave? At least a slave is guaranteed a job and a roof over their heads

>How many wage slaves leave their hometown?
Most?

Eh...at least you have full legal protections and a set of rights that are more or less protected in most western democracies.

I'd take being a modern day wage slave over being an actual slave in any other era of history any day of the week. It's easy to draw parallels until you realize massa can have you endure 40 lashes for looking at him wrong.

>Only a small minority of humanity was ever truly free.

This is true. Most are slaves to causation, regardless of station.

>How are you any different from a slave?
Slaves can't take out loans to get a degree in finance.

>at least you have full legal protections and a set of rights that are more or less protected

Good luck trying to afford a good lawyer if you're wrongly arrested and poor.

I'd take living today over living in any era, outside of the future.

In the end even early wage slavery was worse than what we have now, the thing that changed the world wasn't the level of "freedom" but instead the level of automation

>early wage slavery was worse than what we have now
In some parts of the world, yeah.

I'd say automation is just one factor, the other is a series of workplace reforms.

You are not a slave.
You are a whiner.

I would love to have some neggress sex slaves.

>Some slaves were richer than normal or free people in Ancient times.
The operative term here is "some"
Also ancient times is extremely broad. Are you referring to ancient Rome? China? Nubia? New Jersey?
>That says everything.
Not without backup it doesn't.

Yeah, Ancient as Rome and Greece and such.
Im not defending slavery but, It was better actually than feudalism.

the simple act of making someone do something for no pay seems at least slightly wrong, and then even more so if the situation lasts until they die.

Debt slavery sounds alright. The idea that an individual who has committed a grievance owes society a debt that just be paid either in currency, or labor. Ideas of mandatory military/civil service stem from beliefs such as these.

So it depends on how the individual views right and wrong when the question pertains to a person's ability to exercise their free will.

>spook

Kill yourself reddit

Working chattel slaves to death was bad. Cutting people's balls off was bad. Kidnapping children to sell them in far away lands was bad.

If you were the right type of slave in the right society, you might be able to live a good life or even come to power, like Mamluks and Habshis. House servants probably got off the easiest, though they still had worse conditions than their paid equivalents. Agricultural chattel slaves had it worse, while others were usually used for jobs too degrading or dangerous for hired labour such as mining.

Workplace reforms of course are important, but those were only necessitated by the automation. The automation led to a growth in capitalism, which in turn led to the profit makers maximizing profit which led to the reforms, to avoid the economy from turning socialist and all their heads being chopped off.

got a sauce on that crop brah?

it was pretty bad as a concept, but not much worse than wage labour in certain aspects.

>WAHH REDDIT REDDIT REDDIT REDDIT REDDIT
keep crying, property
some steins;gate doujin

>In some parts of the world, yeah.
don't quite get this. Early industrial factory conditions, right in the middle of europe or US, were way worse than almost anything we see today. Everybody, including 8-year old kids or so, working twelve hours a day, wage only barely above what allows you to stay alive, flat out beating down of any form of resistance, and so on and so forth.

>child labour existed before the Industrial Revolution but with the increase in population and education it became more visible. Many children were forced to work in relatively bad conditions for much lower pay than their elders,[100] 10–20% of an adult male's wage.[101] Children as young as four were employed.[101] Beatings and long hours were common, with some child coal miners and hurriers working from 4 am until 5 pm.[101] Conditions were dangerous, with some children killed when they dozed off and fell into the path of the carts, while others died from gas explosions.[101] Many children developed lung cancer and other diseases and died before the age of 25.[101] Workhouses would sell orphans and abandoned children as "pauper apprentices", working without wages for board and lodging.[101] Those who ran away would be whipped and returned to their masters, with some masters shackling them to prevent escape.[101] Children employed as mule scavengers by cotton mills would crawl under machinery to pick up cotton, working 14 hours a day, six days a week. Some lost hands or limbs, others were crushed under the machines, and some were decapitated.[101] Young girls worked at match factories, where phosphorus fumes would cause many to develop phossy jaw.[101] Children employed at glassworks were regularly burned and blinded, and those working at potteries were vulnerable to poisonous clay dust.[101]
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Industrial_Revolution

I'd been listening to the Yale course on ancient greece and apparently "slavery" was a pretty wide spectrum, going from antebellum USA all the way to "basically a farmer like any other, except for not being allowed to engage in politics" or even being "slaves of Apollo" which seems to not have been different from normal life in any way at all. I suppose you could argue those forms weren't as bad.

Still, liberty. Gotta have it

xD you frickin memed me there

bet you haven't even read stirner ya finoik

The ugly truth is that blacks who were brought as slaves actually won the lottery compared to those who were left behind.

Slavery in itself isn't always detrimental on a physical level to the slave, and while it may have been better to work on a plantation relative to remaining in Africa that is hardly a good argument that conditions were "good".

I myself find slavery being immoral if it is the result of nothing more than one's race. Indentured servitude is alright with me though.

I've got an idea. Why don't you all come over to my house, be my slaves for 10 years and then decide. None of you would have a problem with that, right? How bad could it be?

It fucks up the economy and labour in the long run.
Manifested in very fucked up forms and it was a gamble if you got in the well off positions since they were few.

Debt slavery or debt forced labour you can make trumped out charges to enforce it and often the duration is unknown let alone the fact you can potentially die during the service and the person you are indebt to may not look out for your welfare such as throwing you into mortal danger.

>Was

Yes humans are really expensive when you cant mass produce them in factories in Africa, even if blacks fuck like cockroachs thousands of them died before they got to the New World on the ships so there was shortage of expendable labor so we had to resort to making our nigger slaves fuck, some of us got horny and fucked some of the slaves to speed up the process and also create tamer nigger slaves compared the pure african savages on the boats.