Reminder to ignore bait, unless it is masterfully crafted.
Initial Topic: How well balanced do you feel the fleets are? Do they play to their strengths? Are their points good? Does any one fleet seem particularly powerful compared to the others, overall?
shaltari are extremely strong when they are played by the theoretical perfect player who can always judge the perfect distance and the perfect time for when to go shields up
Their weakness is that if you misjudge when to pop shields or get scanned with your shields down you're absolutely fucked
Mason Gomez
Damn, forgot to include that in the OP Thanks user.
Xavier Green
>the theoretical perfect player who can always judge the perfect distance and the perfect time for when to go shields up
Isn't Pre-Measuring an integral part of the game though?
Nathan Kelly
Yes it is but what I mean is more situational positioning towards the enemy fleet than just raw distance
Jaxson Ramirez
Note that "best overall" refers to the ship as a whole, not just to it's primary purpose (especially in the case of the Ajax)
The amber is amazing but will prove a little fragile if it goes weapons free on front arc as it'll have to go at least 5" forward and have to decide on shields or potentially getting fucked without them
Good ship regardless but it's thankfully not a no brainer
Luke Sullivan
feels a bit right now like the shaltari at least on paper are just better, havent gotten to play an actual game but the low sig combined with the speed, and the auto defense battery from voidgates just seems tough. I feel like were getting a slight repeat of DZC here desu
Nathaniel Watson
>dfc becomes dzc 2 electric boogaloo >heavy choices become obsolete for the most part >many old units are made completely worthless by new ones thanks to power creep >shaltari are always strongest, the only question is how far ahead they are at the moment
Camden Foster
>All according to keikaku >[muffled spine rustling]
Tbh tho, I really don't see a 1500 point fleet ever taking any more than 2 heavy choices, especially if it's taking a super. It's okay if they're obsolete for the most part, since you don't take all that many anyways.
Matthew Allen
There's a difference between not taking much of something because it's a big point investment and never taking any of it because it's shit.
Jayden Smith
It really depends on how they go from here, I don't think they can really fuck up the balance unless they add in some really fucking weird variants later on.
Jacob Harris
Quick, post the most MAGA list you can in celebration of President Trump's victory.
Xavier Martin
fuck off, /pol/
Connor White
Kill yourself.
Logan Rogers
Attention: This is a Hawk-restricted meme zone Drop[___] Commander memes only beyond this point
Anthony Turner
Please leave. Rich lying politician #1 triumphing over rich lying politician #2 isn't even slightly relevant to wargaming. Politics belongs on /pol/.
To try to keep us on track, it seems like Scourge light cruisers and their medium cruiser equivalents (Yokai/Sphinx and Strix/Wyvern) are similar enough that one may overshadow the other in most situations, similar to how the Akuma overshadows the Shenlong. Any speculation there? I'm not sure the Strix has what it takes to be a good CA ship since all its defensive values are awful but it's still a big target that can't hide in atmos.
Parker Walker
I imagine this would include a number of Moscows
Nicholas Perry
Low energy. Sad!
Also low energy, but something to talk about. All a CAW focused ship needs is to live long enough to close. A Strix is a speedy glass cannon. A Wyvern actually doesn't provide enough of a survival boost to justify it's cost.
Owen Myers
Even if ships share similar properties, the differences might mean they excel in different fleet compositions.
Nolan Moore
Fuck off already.
Dominic Kelly
I dunno, +1 armour is pretty significant and the extra hull amplifies that. CA ships deal a lot of damage for their toughness, so that means they're going to be a priority target. Wyverns and Strix are both meant to run in and gut punch someone before being torn to pieces, but the Wyvern seems like it will take a fair bit more investment to destroy while it approaches.
Cameron Richardson
Strixes come in groups of 2-3 and pack the same firepower as a Wyvern. Being able to fit 3 into a single slot is pretty fantastic considering what you're getting. Plus that extra 2" of thrust can make all the difference. DFC Scourge is like DZC Scourge: you're troops are expected to die to some extent, but they make it up when they close. And if you're really, really clever, you can close without being shot at all.
I'm here for 4 years, baby.
James White
I agree with this. A lot of the time you'll use your PD against the crits, so in close the extra armour really is important. And that's not going into the wyvern having triple the strix's PD.
But it's not just about slots in the fleet, you pay battleship points for those 3 strixes.
Austin Martin
Poor scourge. They're my 2nd choice for three of those.
Brody Williams
For strategy ratings I figure there are a few significant demarkations.
>fast Can reliably beat enemy SRs
>fast-average Can reliably beat all but the enemy's specifically 'fast' battlegroups
>Good medium A bit better than average, but not good enough to be fast-average.
>medium So baseline Dirk Hardpeck offered to let it surrender
>slow Unless it's a no contest....
>don't even worry anymore, you're not going first Wait for admiral cards, I guess.
Where would you place the SRs here?
I'd go: Fast:
Nicholas Wilson
VF: 25 (large vanguard group, double super)
Samuel Hill
The difference between a battleship on its own and a battleship plus a support frigate seems like the really big one, as it decides which battleship shoots first.
Huh, I never considered painting the Lima's little doughnuts a different colour. That's a neat idea.
Jose Williams
I wouldnt say Shaltari are ahead in DZC right now, frankly id plant that flag on the PHR atm, they have some crazy good choices for things that almost dont make sense for them.
I also wouldnt say heavy choices are totally useless, the only ones that are subpar are the standard original heavy choices, but then alot of the original units have been left behind and some need a slight tweak to make them more appealing.
Connor Cooper
I'd say they're about equal. And really it's not just that some old stuff needs buffing, some new stuff needs dialing back as well. Valks, Panthers, Ferrums and Helios spring to mind.
Cameron Fisher
Io class frigate when?
Brandon Clark
I feel the Saint Petersburg is growing on me as a denial piece
Just point it on approach towards a critical location in orbit and dare your opponent to try and score it
Lincoln Turner
Possibly never, the Io isn't a combat vessel. It's a small labour ship, doing tasks like mining, clearing wreckage and construction of orbital stations. Fun fact: PHR crews regularly sing the class's name as they go off to work.
Elijah Gray
>guy asks for PHR battlecruiser suggestions >first reply is to make two Perseus
Gavin Long
Wut
Michael Fisher
Normies on Facebook are just enthralled by the Perseus, I have no idea
Tyler Howard
I've got a better idea for a jack-of-all-trades ship: >Noah Class Battlecruiser, armed with two of every weapon: >2 light broadsides (one on each side) >2 medium broadsides (one on each side) >2 heavy broadsides (one on each side) >2 bombardment batteries (one on each side)
Joshua Taylor
Brother.
I know it will be tricky but I just love it to megawatt-induced death.
David Davis
I like two heavies and two bombardment per side more tbqh
>ROW ROW ROW YOUR BOAT
Carson Cook
>Argonaut Class Battlecruiser Fund it.
Wyatt Allen
Wasn't Argo the boat, with the Argonauts being the crew?
James Phillips
what would you do to dial back those units without making them mostly useless
Juan Rodriguez
>12 max damage >good chance to hit max damage >capable of outright blowing up anything smaller than a BC, capable of bringing a BC to near-catastrophic, and will cripple any battleship U C M U C M U C M
John Turner
Ferrums shouldn't have scout and their focus could be toned down. Right now they're the best scouts as well as great AA and AT, with the added bonus of being able to skullfuck skimmers with ease. They're too good at too many things.
Panthers need a shorter range of around 30" and possibly lower accuracy. The range is the big one.
Helios need something. Haven't thought as much about them, but fucking up one of their capabilities should do it. Make them worse AT maybe, or just lower the shot number.
Valks can go wherever they like with impunity right now, enabling reaction fire against them when they building hop is an idea I've heard that I quite like.
>12 max damage >not 16 >forgetting the noble medium mass driver You should be ashamed.
Kayden White
>Panthers need a shorter range of around 30" and possibly lower accuracy. The range is the big one. >getting rid of particle weaponry's main trait Wew
Leo Taylor
It's damage control for a conceptually broken unit that should never have left the drawing board, things are going to get messy.
Samuel Johnson
This unit is pretty op right now and the range is the biggest problem.
Something must be done about it.
Hudson Robinson
I'm also a fan of the St Peter, looks cool and hits like a truck. As people have said, it is great for area denial. I don't want to put my orpheus above a cluster the Moscow is lined up on
Grayson Hernandez
Yes.
Battleriders. Parasite warships. Gunboats. Whatever you want to call them.
Leo Collins
>Facebook well that explains it
Hunter Campbell
Its the heavy cal guns. I think people see 3+ save and thing space marines. They think they will need it as a budget Achilles.
Jose Carter
Why oh why couldn't the Perseus have been mediums+heavies
I would take one
Logan Wood
Mediums+heavies would have been absolutely perfect, possibly even as a second light cruiser type.
Tyler Lewis
As a CL it'd have been amazing but even as a regular cruiser with a nose gun I would still have taken that loadout
Medium/Heavy, Heavy/Carrier, Heavy/Bombard, Light/Bombard, and Carrier/Bombard for the PHR when?
Kevin Sanchez
While I still hope we get the rowboat (Heavy/Bombard) it wouldn't surprise me if they stick with only PHR troopships having bombardment as a thematic thing.
Brayden Mitchell
Medium heavy and light bombard are the only useful combos we're missing
Everything else would be either Perseus tier crap or redundant
Connor Jackson
Carrier bombard might be pretty interesting.
Eli Cooper
What's a better combat brick?
2theseus 2europa Or 1orion 2europa
Ryder Garcia
I'm building my fleet around 2 groups of 2 Orion and 1 Orpheus each with a shitkicker group up front running 1 Theseus, 4 Europa. Out back I've got a headhunter of 1 Bellerophon, 2 Pandora.
I'm not sure about the Theseus but the Orion will slow the Europas down enough that they can't play intercept so well. I think given your choices I'd pack the Theseus, over the game they'll go a foot further across the board and scrag a few other scoring units.
Julian Bailey
Either
Europas with Orions go slower but they're not going to be using their full thrust most of the time anyway
Asher Hall
One day we may reclaim Earth
Easton Martin
...
Zachary Roberts
...
Justin Walker
...
Joseph Sanders
finally got my "lack of patience" starter box and put it all together while still waiting for my commodore
A few observations
1)I'm appreciating how big these ships are. For how much bigger they are than DZC models, they're nice and detailed while being cheaper.
2)holy fucking shit you have to sand the fuck out of PHR cruisers to even make them fit together
3) I gave in and built a Hector just so I could play starter set games and I think I'll have spare cruiser hulls anyway, I can afford one mediocre choice
Carson Peterson
...
Dylan Thomas
Taking a little break from hedgehog spaceships to start a dropzone army. I think i'll probably paint over the skull, I wanted a sort of feral look but it just looks a bit too comical
David Butler
Give the skull a moustache and a hat
Angel Butler
when do we figure its ok to start getting mad? December, January?
Lincoln Carter
Once its been one year since the campaign ended, so December 3rd.
Ryder Gray
I'd say after thanksgiving weekend, but yeah around one year. I can't imagine its much longer though, that's another 3 weeks away.
Jacob Morris
well the last update specified by the middle of this week, but no dice so far
Blake Phillips
My first painted Ships.
Shiryu - Obsidian Class Heavy Cruiser
Camden Gutierrez
Aphrodite and Capella - Amethyst Class Frigates
Jack Parker
KeK
Kayden Rodriguez
Basecoats are a go! Now I need to double-time their compatriots on the ground for a DZC demo this weekend. Who needs sleep?
Brayden Young
Fun game last night with the following at 999pts :
Vanguard (SV 20) - Atlantis - Moscow
Line (SV11) - Lima - 2 x New Cairo
Line (SV10) - 2 x Osaka
Pathfinder (SV9) - San Francisco - 2 New Orleans - 2 New Orleans
New Cairo's performed really well and Osaka's felt solid too. I'm a big fan of the light cruisers now!
Jayden Foster
That looks pretty good, user! How'd you get the fluorescent effects on the core?
Jack Torres
Why are Toulons so cute?
Ayden Torres
Did you play against Scourge?
Matthew Reed
They try really hard to achieve their dream of being like Moscow-sama someday
Colton Bell
Who wouldn't want to be like her?
Leonidas-chan a best, but spunky redhead 2gud.
Jace Morris
How many Toulons is too many?
Matthew White
if you cant see the board anymore through the toulans you still dont quite have enough
Hmm- how would 2x moscow work as a battleship substitute?
Liam Campbell
Painted the core white and then used a glaze over it. (waywatcher green with a tiny bit of the yellow GW glaze)You need to apply it 3-4 times, but wait each time untill it's dry. I used waywatcher green
Adam Rodriguez
No, I think a moscow and a Avalon or Atlantis will though.
It will cost more but there will be benefits to having that layout over a BB. Moscows will struggle against PHR without a laser and they are only 6 damage of concentrated fire away from crippletown which could mean their doom. The BC have speed and extra hull to keep them up.
William Davis
One important thing in DZC is that nearly every 'big' attack requires some form of setup. Limited arcs, weapons free, etc. Are you out of a 90 degree turn from a burnthrough ship? Congrats, they'll never bring the main weapon on you.
Able to get more than 45 degrees out from a scourge or Shaltari heavy, they won't be able to weapons free you. Same with dodging arc on PHR.
Course Change is secretly the best order. It's how you win passing engagements by arc dodging, particularly if you're UCM.
John Taylor
I have an atlantis and was planning on a moscow, I'd just been thinking a heavy heavy setup where avalon + lima snipegroup and then 2x moscow + jakarta brawler group.
Elijah Sanchez
Avalon fuck me.
Also I think I've settled on a naming scheme for my fleet. Homeworld themed shit.
Jaxon Richardson
Fucking hell this thread is dead. Did the jellies get us?
Isaiah Sullivan
I dunno. I've asked a lot of questions the past weeks, and I've gotten a lot of sensible replies and a handfull of retarded ones.
I now have no more questions to ask and models to paint and assemble. There is few memes getting shitposted and even less loreposting.
We have the occasional list-builder whom wants feedback on their latest attempts at fleetbuilding but nothing that can really keep a thread alive.
Do you have anything you want to contribute to this thread?
Ryan Diaz
Not many games being played yet, everything has been theoried out. Lot of guys still waiting for their stuff
Adam Flores
Exactly, this is the problem. We are still just waiting around. Many players still don't have their sets. Those that do are probably busy painting and assembling.
It is sad, around 2 months ago I was hoping to be buying up a new york class BB to join up with my Battlecruiser pair. Instead, here I am with no fucking models.