What are your guys' thoughts on the Battle Engine CID week 1?
Matthew Carter
Praise the Empress and long live the motherland.
Lincoln Lee
Well The battle engines I think will be some of the hardest Models to balance in the game ever.
Its effectively a large based very expensive Solo thats not a warrior model.
Samuel Campbell
Just ordered the Legends of Halaak and a Scarab Pack, with plans to use them in Makeda1. How did I do?
Hunter Young
Legends of Halaak are passable, not super great, but passable.
Scarabs are fucking worthless with every single caster though. You fucked up bad there.
Evan Parker
I was only kidding, I know they're really strong with Makeda1 and you're probably gay.
Kayden Martin
So with the battle pope dead, how does /wmhg/ think the Menothbowl is going to go down?
Who makes the first move? Who will be on which side? Will there be more than the two obvious sides? Who, if anybody, is going to win it in the end?
Nathaniel Price
Amon wins.
Alexander Cox
Fluffwise Kreoss vs Feora is pretty obvious with Vindictus trying to be the power behind the thrown of either. Kreoss is obviously less of a powermongering dipshit than Feora, but Feora is more politically savvy and already has the loyalty of the entire Flameguard and backing from some of the Synod and at least two other Warcasters. I expect that Kreoss will lose the power struggle although I'm not sure Feora will get power or keep it for long if she does.
Matthew Walker
>The Protectorate being led by a heretic Lel.
Gabriel Powell
>God said I'm in charge now tee hee.
Jaxson Bailey
Harby and the Testament are MIA as of Godless and nobody knows where they are. The Northern Crusade is getting recalled and Skorne is all up in the Protectorate's business. Feora is in charge of the largest arm of the Protectorate's military and the one assigned to defending the country itself. You don't think she's going to claim power on the auspices of making Sul Great Again?
Asher Fisher
How did the old man die?
Levi Robinson
>Harby and the Testament are MIA as of Godless and nobody knows where they are ;^)
Hudson Bennett
You really shouldn't fuck with Hexeris in close combat. Or distant combat. Or just at all honestly, he's both powerful AND psychotic.
Thomas Howard
Hexeris stabbed him through the chest IIRC. Before he dies, he goes Super Saiyan, nukes all the attacking Skorne, and brings all the dead Menites killed back to life.
Matthew Morales
Skorne are the biggest assholes, if they ever actually win anything, the entire setting is fucked.
Which means Skorne will never win anything just to protect continuity
Are Skorne Tyranids?
Jackson Rivera
So is hexxy -10hp as well?
Nicholas Bailey
Everblight
Grayson Gonzalez
I just hope to have the Animantarax go back to its late Mk2 at the least. Didn't go in every list, and still wasn't that great a piece, but it fucking worked.
Chase Brown
Skorne are Necrons.
Tyler Wood
Are the joke gargatuans in MKII usuable now, or are they still shelf pieces?
Jason Campbell
Nah, Skorne are Dark Elves.
Necrons are Cryxians.
Man Khador remains my favorite faction, and the reason why I think it will continue to benefit from its themes more then any other faction is because how easily expandable all its infantry is and how thematic yet different they all are:
MOW, Kolduns(+DoomReavers), Winter Guard, Iron Fangs, Kossites and Wild Khador: All present different aspects to be naturally expanded apon.
Who really thinks that Trencher Mechanics or Long-gunners sounds organic or interesting?
Yes Wild Koldun Lords or Koldun Lord Iron Fang: All workable concepts.
Zachary Cooper
Depends on which Joke. The MK is now a really solid piece or so I hear.
The Giant Snake from Everblight now is the only huge model with any form of reposition so thats that.
Easton Harris
I tried to make a thing, turns out Warroom text doesn't rescale well. What a coincidence.
Sebastian Myers
Why not just use War Room and dance yourself the trouble?
Elijah Jackson
Actually the Siege Animantarax has Reposition 3"
Also Xerxis2 has built in Sprint if you count that too.
Technically Morghoul3 can also make the SA apparate.
Landon Butler
I do love the Kings. Sadly the Sea King is ridiculously overpriced.
Jonathan Martin
Lylyth 3 has repo 5
Cooper Baker
Alright, I should have Said Gargossal.
Wyatt Wilson
But what about the Desert Hydra?
Luke Morris
I like muh physical cards, and I prefer being able to cross-reference rules and check damage boxes on a binder page instead of pulling them up and/or ticking them off one at a time in the app.
I also play tabletop games to take a break from being at a computer or on a smartphone constantly in the first place.
Logan Moore
>Trollbloods Mountain King: Great Glacier King: Mediocre Sea King: Bad
>Circle Woldwrath: Great Storm Raptor: Mediocre/Bad
>Skorne Mammoth: Great Desert Hydra: Good/Great (and, honestly, if the infantry meta comes back, which PP seems to be trying to make happen, it's a solid Great)
They're mostly pretty good. Unfortunately the two with the best models (Storm Raptor and Archangel) are among the worst.
William Moore
An Archangel (or 2!) works pretty well with Lylyth3 in the right build. Double Dragon might be a meme, but it's a deadly meme for a lot of things.
Legion Army - 75 / 75 points [Theme] Oracles of Annihilation
Why does seem so plausible that under the effect of Avatar of Slaughter, it's sad yellow turns into mad red?
Alexander Sanders
Oh, yeah, it's definitely playable with a list built around it, but it doesn't drop in basically anywhere like the Mammoth or Mountain King.
Thomas Wood
>Who makes the first move? Feora
>Who will be on which side? Kreoss will get the nice guys on his team like Tristan and Durst, while Feora will obviously get Thyra and probably Malekus as well.
>Will there be more than the two obvious sides? Remember, both Kreoss and Feora have to answer to the Scrutators, of whom Vindictus is one. In fact, he might even get epic'd into the rank of Visgoth. The conflict is going to start when Feora starts making moves under command's nose OR when Kreoss becomes unsatisfied with their leadership choices. Vindy is probably going to lead the visgoth-loyal forces against them (along with Reznik), but will be quickly defeated/have his army stolen by Kreoss so the two-way civil war can begin in earnest.
Later on, the Harbinger and the Testament are going to come back to Caen, possibly at the head of a host of Menoth's spirit warriors. Even if this latter part doesn't happen, they're going to draw a lot of warriors to their side, either creating a third major team in the Menothbowl OR tipping the scales in one side's favor.
>Who, if anybody, is going to win it in the end? I want it to be Vindy, but I know it will probably be Kreoss.
Charles Perez
>sending your long ranged infantry into battle with a huge ass flag that tells the enemy where you are
Brody Collins
>local organizer selling $3k worth of Cryx for $1.5k on FB IT'S OVER, WARMACHINE IS FINISHED
Cameron Kelly
Man those faces are sculpted like shit
Jace Sullivan
That's pretty standard for used miniatures. He'll be lucky if he gets what he's asking
Charles Rodriguez
Well let's see, shall we: Legion: Both are okay, BB will make a huge comeback when infantry does, AA is already viable Trollbloods: GK and MK both have their niches Skorne: Mammoth was always good and Hydra just found its niche as the anti-shooting Garg Circle: WW is amazing with the right casters, Thunderchicken is pure jank
Ian Miller
>Thunderchicken is pure jank
How so?
Ayden Allen
GK is not very good
MK is the perfect Gargant
Kayden Smith
Finally got arcs on my Circle, and everything fits into a PP halfbag (tourney).
I'm happy.
Michael Rodriguez
>MK is the perfect Gargant Funny way of spelling Mammoth.
Joshua Thomas
To be fair, MK lacks the Mammoth's tendency to fishhook everything in range of those goddamned tusks. Trying to get my Mammoth to the store with my other titans feels like trying to pull one coathanger out of a big pile. I should have fallen for the magnetism meme.
Brayden Reed
>that feel
Gabriel Carter
Seriously what were they thinking with that model Did they not expect those tusk to get caught on EVERYTHING
Benjamin Green
Well there's that one list Tom Guan played a while back where it does one very specific job rather well. Apart from that it's utter trash.
>GK is not very good Depends on your warlock.
Justin Torres
>Depends on your warlock.
No.
If the MK is the gold standard of Gargants, as in it's 'just right' on the power curve, the GK is under powered as any list (now that Una is dead) that has a GK in it is better served by a MK. Even Gunny.
Christopher Phillips
Out of curiosity, in MK Gunny lists, what are you putting Snipe on?
I've been enjoying playing him with a sniped GK for long range Thunderbolts, but with it much harder to win on scenario now it seems weaker.
Tyler Perez
used minis almost never sell for even msrp. he's probably selling for %60 but will get haggled down.
Luke Rivera
>10 years of game design around scenario means the game just cannot be separated from that. Trying to force the issue is just going to destroy the game.
You heard it here first guys, game is dead, close it down.
Jace Martinez
Can't we just say the game is taking a hard turn onto a neglected road and is rocking a bit, possibly more than anticipated?
Joseph Bailey
Never, there are only extremes. You're either on Team PP is Perfect or Team Everything is Fucked.
Nathaniel Wood
What are you talking about WE MUST OVERREACT IMMEDIATELY
Brody Ross
LET'S GET THAT CHANGE.ORG ONLINE PETITION STARTED
Ryan Anderson
Whassup, I haven't been following the game for like... when did Mark 3 come out?
I heard rumors that Severius kicked the bucket (RIP in peace battle pope), and that Goreshade pulled a Magnus (Ghyrrrshyld the forgiven)?
Anyone mind enlightening me?
Colton Harris
Read this thread and the previous one. I can't believe Hexxy has a kill on his belt now while my nigga Amon does not.
Wyatt Cox
Going by the old thread's logic Hexxy has two kills. Kallus just meatpuppeted some Skorne rando and got better after Hexxy killed him. Fluff Hexxy is not a person to engage in CQC.
Jackson Flores
Vinter invaded, Caine found his son Julius and decided not to kill him. Feora showed up to try to distract Leto's army, Vinter almost kills Leto and Julius but Magnus throws acid on him and stabs him in the back. Leto abdicates the throne to Julius, Magnus rejoins the Cygnaran army and Caine quits.
Skorne gets to the capital of Ios, nearly conquers the city. During the battle Goreshade enters the Fane of Scyrah with his Eldritch bros to kill Nyssor and Scyrah. Scyrah wakes up and nukes one of the Eldritch, Nyssor nukes the rest. Scyrah considers nuking Goreshade but realizes that Nyssor spared him because he might actually be able to save the Iosian people, but only if he's alive. She uses a large chunk of her remaining power (implying it will cut her life span significantly) to bring him back to life with out erasing everything he learned as an eldrich.
Two years pass, Khador and Cygnar sign a treaty that says Khador can keep what it has of Llael but they have to pull out of the Thornwood. However they have to give up Llael if a rightful heir to the Llaelese throne is found. Turns out Julius already found one of the old king's daughters and immediately announces it and says Khador has to leave. Ayn calls bullshit, Julius uses it as an excuse to send Stryker, Maddox, and Magnus to invade Riversmet. Also he announces he's gonna marry the princess of Llael.
>cont.
Nolan Garcia
Deneghra makes a pistol-wraith copy of Caine to find out if he has any gifted kids, turns out he does. In the process of kidnapping her the Phantom kills the leader of the Black 13th, the other two join up with Caine to rescue his kid.
Tristan Durant starts having visions about something consuming the Protectorate so he tells Sevvy. They head south and run in to Hexxy trying to take Tower Judgement. Hexxy kills Sevvy but Tristan stops him from taking his soul, Sevvy's last act is to go Godly and nuke a bunch of Skorne. Hexxy then tries to invade Imer with Zaadesh and Xekaar. Feora, Thyra, Tristan, and Malekus barely defend the city until Kreoss shows up to save the day. The Visgoth's recall the Northern Crusade, power struggle between Feora and Kreoss is immanent.
Jose Barnes
Amon could take him...
Caleb Hill
Isn't Amon just punch man
Carter Jones
>Remember, both Kreoss and Feora have to answer to the Scrutators, of whom Vindictus is one.
That has literally never stopped Feora from doing whatever the fuck she wants.
Ryder Mitchell
The Scrutator getting worked over by Hexeris before Tristan and Sevy show up almost doesn't notice over how WTF he still is over how Feora split the Scrutator vote and walked out of what ought to have been a judicial lynching over getting involved (unsuccessfully) in a Cygnaran Civil War into being proclaimed a hero of the Protectorate. Nothing short of blood is going to stop her, and she's already taking that into account in her maneuverings.
Noah Taylor
What does she even want? To be Heirarch? To invade Cygnar?
Evan Williams
She wants to be the new leader of the Decepticons-I mean the Protectorate
Nathan Diaz
>What does she even want?
Power?
Connor Diaz
None of that matters. All that matters is whoever gets the true hero on their side, will win.
Nicholas Cruz
Played Rasheth v Denny1 pirate theme. My god it was so fucking dull. I'd kill some of his guys, they'd come back next turn, he'd try and shoot some guys, it'd bounce off the Krea's animus. Eventually my opponent cracked and went full tilt for the Mammoth as I'd moved the Castigate bubble away from it. He killed it and thought Denny was safe. So did I until I realised that I could still sneak a Master Tormentor inside Denny's stealth range. See, he stayed 12" away from the PGMT to account for 2" apparition, 4" walk, and 5" stealth. And for a while I was unsuccessfully trying to sneak Karax in through his infantry. Then I remembered the PGMT had Sprint, so I just walked forwards, whipped a dude, ended in 5", popped feat, and killed her with 2 Sunder Spirits on straight dice.
Someone would've hit deathclock if we'd been using it though.
Nolan Gray
It's been rocking a bit for nearly a year now and instead of trying to keep it stable, they are rocking it harder.
Daniel Torres
Well that's Feora then, since she has the loyalty of literally all of the Temple Flameguard.
Jeremiah Cook
He'll probably die to Durst, after beating on his armor ineffectually for like 15 minutes Viper vs. Mountain style.
Caleb Hernandez
The protectorate is crushed, without a leader AND the Old hag unleashed the Grymkin against their asses?
ISIS is in for a ride yo.
Brayden Roberts
Did they spoil the new mercenary casters yet?
Angel Lewis
If it's not Gorten2 I'm going to fucking jump out a window.
Eli Thompson
Ossrum2 Cygnar partisan
Jacob Robinson
See ya
Jonathan Fisher
Magnus3 (Merc partisan) and ashlynn2
Elijah Allen
>Magnus3 Where are you getting this information?
Juan Morales
It's more that they've called their strength in. And they do so have a leader. They have two leaders.
Blake Moore
He's right, hyperbolic but right. There are a lot of poor decisions in SR2017.
Jordan Price
>There are a lot of poor decisions in SR2017 Such as? Putting assassination on a pedastal as far as tie breaks are concerned is a sign that PP thinks it will be harder to pull off, which seems about right to me. Look at a SR16 scenario like Recon. You've got 2 flags right out to the side that can only be dominated for 1 point, then a rectangle in the middle that there's no hope of ever controlling. To me SR17 emphasises control of the map and positioning far more, which is what I want in a strategy game. Take the circle zones for example. They can be controlled by a unit, but only if the WHOLE unit is inside. This means that I can place my infantry outside of the circle at a range where you can't stand inside the zone and reach me, and your infantry can't both deal with my threat AND score in the same turn. In turn this puts more emphasis on using solos, as they can control one of these zones by themselves.
Andrew Russell
Recon is a bad scenario, I agree. I was surprised they viewed that one as the one to carry over, and now are doing a complete re-haul of it.
These scenarios require less map presence then before, not more as you're saying. Winning by 6 is just broken, and the way to fix it (fixed game length) is almost just as broken.
I'm at work now so can't type too much on my phone but removing the idea of scenario victory is like removing rock from rock paper scissors, then it's just scissors and paper, it's just not good game design.
A friend of mine had some good insight during our CID game last night "Why make scenarios more confusing/busy, but in the same stroke make them matter even less" It's at odds with itself from the start
Benjamin Wood
Actually if you keep track, it's pretty much "Hexeris tanks half the Protectorate warcaster lineup". The guy's skillset means that he can't lose so long as he has troops or warbeasts, and if he runs out, he'll GTFO.
>well, a third >maybe a quarter >but certainly about that
Charles Flores
The games I've played we just used the old win-at-5-points rule. Worked fine.
Jacob Bailey
The sweetest thing would be for her to beat Kreoss but then get stabbed in the back by Thyra.
William Edwards
I don't see how that would happen. Feora saved Thyra's life and gave her a purpose and a way to channel her grief and anger. Thyra's fanatically loyal to Feora.
Jaxon Taylor
That's why it would be cool to see a betrayal, as long as the reason for it isn't too stupid.
Adam Evans
I guess I just don't see how engineering said betrayal would be anything other than stupid. Thyra's the least likely person to turn on Feora. Malakus would be a better bet, as he's only really Feora's PR guy. Thyra owes Feora everything, in her own view. I just don't think it would be anything other than contrived and drama for its own sake.
Zachary Gonzalez
Yeah but that's not the proposed changes and we're never going to see that happen in sr2017.
Luke Garcia
On the Old thread's notches on belt post:
Goreshade almost killed Vyros and Ossyan Vyros is the reason Goreshade is an eldritch Abby almost killed Naaresh Vlad killed Harbinger Vindictus captured Vlad Kromac almost killed Borka and Madrak Venethrax was gonna fuck Everblight's waifu till he gave Abby the powers to run away Rhyas almost killed Thagrosh and killed a dragon Xerxis almost killed Grayle and Kaya and killed an Iosan warcaster Kreuger attempted to kill Lortus and got his shit fucked Mohsar teleported an entire Skorne contingent including warlocks (notably Mordikaar) away iirc Baldur had his shit pushed in by Lylyth Asphyxious killed a lich lord and sent Terminus to the void Haley fucked up a bunch of people, Deneghra included Stryker fucked up a fair number of people, Terminus, Magnus and Voyle included Caine almost killed Macbain, and killed a king and a merc warcaster I can't remember the name of Karchev killed Cathmore Sloan almost killed Karchev and Irusk Deneghra fucked up Karchev and I think Strakhov Kaelyssa killed Zaal and fucked up Zerkova Butcher fucked up Siege Terminus held his own vs. Damiano and Kreoss Vinter fucked up Makeda for days Hexeris killed Kallus and Severius Magnus killed Vinter Carver killed Barnabas and fucked up Midas
Samuel Gonzalez
Denny blew a Trencher.
Ian Martinez
Wasn't there also a story where Rahn bullied Scaverous?
It may also be worth mentioning that Sorscha once froze Haley solid and almost killed her.
Juan Torres
Madrak killed an Omnipotent. I can't remember which one.
Grayson Price
Hey /WMG/, some Skorne player who's been out of it for a while due to school and work.
I've always loved both the SA and the Mammoth, but haven't had luck running the SA in any list. With the CID rules for the SA, how successful would a list running both of these be? Is my prediction of just getting absolutely wrecked on accurate, or is my hope of doing some serious work viable?
I just like big models.
Austin Kelly
Well, you actually stand a chance to win Spread the Net on scenario, Battle Engines are surprisingly useful for that.