Do all of Shakespeare's plays contain grammatical mistakes?
As I was reading Hamlet, I realised that there were many mistakes in his English and I started to wonder if this was even English at all. I couldn't understand what the characters were saying because of the bad grammar and awful vocabulary. And apparently Shakespeare creates his own new words? Like how am I supposed to understand anyone's writing if they just start creating uncommon new words from their bottoms?
An example of bad grammar: "Horatio Before my God, I might not this believe"
Like did Shakespeare even study English at all or did he just start writing because he was broke? Compared to a writer like John Green, his English is horrible. Why do we even have to study him when his English is below average? I know for sure that he wouldn't be able to pass any English test, except if it was for kindergarten child.
Parker Morris
Not even remotely funny.
Dominic Ross
Contribute with relevant comments please.
Dylan Thomas
>Like did Shakespeare even study English at all or did he just start writing because he was broke? What the fuck are you even on about? Before faking his death, he received an MA from Corpus Christi College, Cambridge, and he even translated some works from Latin into English. It's likely that he was a prolific polyglot, and not a fucking "below average" English speaker
Thomas Roberts
this is funny to me
Jose Brown
Finally some quality bait
Asher Jackson
Could you provide a source to support what you're saying? I doubt he knew Latin. He probably knew Latin as much as he knew English, which is bad.
And why would he fake his death? Is he still alive?
Bentley Cook
Here's a (You)
Levi Hughes
Not really. Especially with a post like
Jackson Torres
Aw come on dude, your troll was almost believable until you compared him to Green. 6/10, almost good.
Tyler Cooper
Nearly walked into that one, self-referential little faggot.
Cooper Hughes
What are you on about? First of all, this is not a troll or a bait thread. Second of all, I compared him to Green to show that he's not as proficient in the English language as much as any common bad writer is. It was to show how bad of a writer he is.
Brayden Cooper
Yup, sounds like a case of autism
Matthew James
I don't know if Shakespeare had autism or not, but that's an interesting theory that should be taken into consideration. Autism could explain his unusual English.
Mason Garcia
haha now this one was a good bait :DDD
(I will be saging my posts in this thread)
Easton Anderson
You should find a copy of The Tragedy of Arthur. Its his most obscure play and rarely performed because its so full of errors. Interesting because its only one of two Shakespeare plays to mention America and because it predicts a naval disaster similar to The Titanic.
Camden Evans
Tragedy of Arthur is pleb tier
Joseph Robinson
Shakespeare loves writing tragedies, but he never realised his own tragedy: his writing.
Is The Tragedy of Arthur even authentic? I'm not surprised it's full of errors; all of his plays are. I doubt it's obsecure for meaningful reasons, I bet it's the result of his hideous English.
Isaac Powell
this thread is giving me a fucking headache
Cameron Collins
Shakespeare's plays give me headaches too.
Joshua Phillips
mentioning John Green ruined it imo
Dominic Williams
Shakespeare lived in a time before the standardization of English; and his improper use of grammar is the playfulness of a man who full knows the rules, and chooses to break them on purpose.
Consider this your token serious response for such a repugnant expression of crass ignorance.
Thomas Price
>And why would he fake his death? Is he still alive?
Of course not. Shakespeare died centuries ago. There is no possible way I could be alive.
Hudson Jackson
>his improper use of grammar is the playfulness of a man who full knows the rules, and chooses to break them on purpose.
First of all, you sound like a hardcore Shakespeare fanboy. Second, your reasoning is flawed. How would I know the difference between a retard's writing and an educated man's writing? By judging the quality of their grammar and vocabulary!
I could argue that the retard's nonsensical writing was done on purpose which shows that he's a man who full knows the rules.
Would you hail me as a genius if I started creating new words and writing without following the basic rules of grammar? No, of course not. Nor should you hail Shakespeare.
Justin Walker
I know, I was being sarcastic.
Brody Thompson
>By judging the quality of their grammar and vocabulary!
All this means is that there is no difference between any writing so long as it's grammatically correct. That is to say the things I wrote when I was ten are the equal of the greatest writers in the world.
I know it's b8, it was just too tasty.
Jacob Peterson
Oh, that's because English grammar is so primitive and word order so rigid that Shakespeare merely had to resort to some concessions.
Jaxon Hughes
wow
Hunter Thompson
face it kit (or should I say william), nobody cares that you're still alive
Hudson Cruz
Let me elaborate: the quality of a writing is measured by the grammar and verbal IQ of the writer, and the depth of its ideas and sophistication.
Joshua Perry
Or maybe it's because Shakespeare is no more than a fraud who lacks the intellectual faculties to write intelligibly.
Henry Stewart
>Horatio >Before my God, I might not this believe >Vor meinem Gott, Ich möchte das beileibe nicht. It's good German; I'd even say it's fancy German. I believe it's not Shakespeare who did not know how to speak English but it's the rest of your upper classes whose Frisian Plattdeutsch skills went down the closet. No wonder he's the only author all the English speakers hold in high esteem.