Oh great, people talking about Dune. I recently finished Children of Dune, and....
SOME SPOILERS SOME SPOILERS
SOME SPOILERS SOME SPOILERS
What's so good about the 2nd one? It was nice, but I didn't get all of it. Scytale, Bijaz, re-introducing Idaho was all very enjoyable, but I don't really get everything Frankie's preaching at with some of the epigraphs,expository dialogue and character thought. Some of it goes over my head and demands being re-read with me wondering if it's all just superfluous bogus. And if it is, is it intentional? Does Frank sometimes intend to bewilder you just to demonstrate how far removed from our own lives these people are? Am I missing some important subtext or cryptic meaning that actually answers why the jihad had to happen, why Paul first resented the idea, then came to accept it because it prevented a much worse course for human society and would lead to a better one? Or did his prescience make him understand fully that there was no way back, he had fulfilled the prophecy and would never be able to undeify himself in beholding of the Fremen, so he exercised basic damage control while trying to use prescience to somehow alter it?
Then there was Children of Dune. The hell was up with that "vision battle" with The Preacher? What allowed lil L to start the metamorphosis? Why was it so hard to not end up possessed?
And a whole bunch of other convoluted stuff. How do you guys tie it all together? It gets quite messy in CoD. Still, I liked it. It was absolutely enthralling, in fact. Will read the rest of the books, too. Despite the stimulating, yet brittle, sometimes silly prose. Despite the engrossing, yet strangely, sometimes poorly formulated plot.
World building is sparse. Character development? I'll be honest. How to even judge them? I can't relate to any of them, or even fully understand them, the way they're presented. To me, this isn't a bad thing. It's what I love about these books.
So yeah, I dunno. The books are weird and of dubious literary merit by traditional standards(that doesn't matter, btw). But oh boy, they're evocative, grand, inspiring, insightful, creative and original, if not in all ways. Talk about Dune, faggots.