Poetry Critique Thread

Yelling goats edition.

We've got a prose one up, but the poetry thread died.

My piece, still working on a title:

In a grey mountain land, searching for God,
I happened on a cave, toothy and cold.
Shouting, anguished, within. I turned to my guide,
facing somber dissent. Heedless, I entered.
Where the small den halted, bleak light fell through the rock,
on a thin brackish pool, in which a figure lay.
That tormented wraith writhed, bones in black water,
endless life lamenting— one it could not take.
An ending I offered, a fool's pity.
It shrank from me in fear— by this I left.

Returning to the guide, I bid us continue the search.
Met with my ignorance, their gaze sought the ground in dismay.

...

It is equal to living in a tragic land
To live in a tragic time.
Regard now the sloping, mountainous rocks
And the river that batters its way over stones,
Regard the hovels of those that live in this land.

That was what I painted behind the loaf,
The rocks not even touched by snow,
The pines along the river and the dry men blown
Brown as the bread, thinking of birds
Flying from burning countries and brown sand shores,

Birds that came like dirty water in waves
Flowing above the rocks, flowing over the sky,
As if the sky was a current that bore them along,
Spreading them as waves spread flat on the shore,
One after another washing the mountains bare.

It was the battering of drums I heard
It was hunger, it was the hungry that cried
And the waves, the waves were soldiers moving,
Marching and marching in a tragic time
Below me, on the asphalt, under the trees.

It was soldiers went marching over the rocks
And still the birds came, came in watery flocks,
Because it was spring and the birds had to come.
No doubt that soldiers had to be marching
And that drums had to be rolling, rolling, rolling.

I like this. The last four lines especially remind me of the feeling of not remembering your dreams, but knowing that they happened.

This has a fantastic flow to it, the only line I'm not quite getting is "That was what I painted behind the loaf," but this may just be a result of me not considering the poem for long enough.

Because you've never been desperately poor and hungry.
It's a poem by Wallace Stevens, who is probably one of the best poets of the last century.
You just confirmed that you're a pleb, that's all.
The only reason I posted it was to see if some user would be like, "tipsssz fedora so shiit xdxdxd hehe huhu ha"

You're right, I've never been desperately poor and hungry, and I haven't studied anything by Stevens.

Glad I could help you jack off your ego-fueled metaphorical hard-on, but these threads really do work better if people post their own work.

Lol, shut up you waste of semen.
You have nothing worth posting. Your attempt is full of cliches, and not in a good way.

If the internet didn't exist to coddle you, you'd be working your 9-5 and talking about flat pack furniture with your fat and fucking ugly wife right now, instead of daydreaming about being a "writer" because you think it's cool to be an "artist"

Suck me off, you cunt. Stop posting here.

he didn't even post anything?

He's the OP

...

Anime is for fucking losers too
Pathetic

...

this is the truth of my love
perhaps forever untold:

i am attracted to other feminine forms
in a purely transient manner
and i abstain from action
which i believe could hurt

after that? you, my love
my angel, my house mate
my lover, my partner

born somehow in this cosmos
to the side of me
and i to the side of you
i would wed thee. for now
i see a beauty in you
that grows beyond the sublime beauty i initially glimpsed

the only thing that causes me concern:
my fantasies
my jealousies

but my love burns true
to the thought of you
i would explore this world with you
i would grow old with you
i would laugh with you
i would play with you
i would plan with you
i would pray with you
i would create with you
raising children
consciousness
peace and laughter

my strangely addictive fantasies
i don't know what it is i seek
if it comes to a choice
you win a million times

sexual union
deepening connection
i want to live and love
and i want to invite you
to come with me

how intertwined these threads of existence are
yet i would not dare unpick this knot
my entireity,
i dream it remains forever entangled with yours

Oh what responsibility
to have another tied to me
i hope i can fly
so you can soar free

Oh dance
dance with me

The was a goat, young and stout.
Who turned his head, upon a shout.
'Allahu Ackbar!' yelled an ape, from a mountain.
Who grabbed goat nape, and gushed like fountain.
The goat's eye froze with fear, solid as glass.
Then Abu Hajaar, fucked the goat in the ass.
And so goat cried, 'Baaaah! Baaaaah!'
The man plowing hard, screaming, 'Allaaaaah!'
And just when goat, thought it most hurt.
Came rolling thunder, in dreaded 'BRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRTTTTT'
The desert winds, carried no sound.
For pink mist and chunks, lay on the ground.
Where goat and Hajaar, were never found.
Bodycount.

How do I write short poetry?
Are there rules?

read lots and lots of haiku
understand why you want to write short poetry
understand many people will be unimpressed even if you write the next 'world of dew' or 'lighght'

I wasn't planning on sharing it with others. But I'm curious as to why others would be unimpressed

because short works are rarely held in the same esteem as longer (read: usually bloated) works
and stuff like Saroyan is labeled 'pretentious garbage' by people who refuse to acknowledge anything shorter than a sonnet is a poem capable of greatness.

I hardly hear them now.
Just auditory clues,
cues to signal– keys to
slot in neuropaths and
drafts to notes to sheets to
this music. Peace in the
pieces– where I sit but
don't listen. These songs that
tend to sidle step in,
change some stone to flesh and
numb law to love. I want
rest but instead this sly
test sets in for the night.
I hardly hear them now.

>Saroyan is good and lighght isn't everything wrong with top-down establishment-dictated poetry

lighght is beautiful
one of the prettiest words ever made
right behind Joyce's endlessnessnessness