The ancient Greeks are thrown around a lot here, as well as on Veeky Forums.
My simple question is this: where should I start? I intend to take some time off more modern works so I can understand the roots of it all a little better.
I have the Iliad, the Odyssey, and Plato's Republic. If there's a preexisting guide to this all any pointers would be appreciated.
Also I guess general classical literature thread once I've had an answer.
>There aren't many extant greek texts to even read
Don't make me cry user.
Andrew Hughes
The great Hellenist Moses Hadas has a book I see from time to time in good used book stores (I also still possess a copy) called Ancilla to Greek Reading, which might prove helpful. If I were (you) I'd read Hesiod first (quick, easy, informative) and then move on to the historians Herodotus (fun) Thucydides (great) Xenophon (conclude with Anabasis) after which (you) can read the major plays and early lyric poets, etc.
Jack Smith
USE THE THOROUGH CHART FFS
Alexander Ward
>thorough chart >only listed work is for aristotle is metaphysics
Would one endure irreversible psychological damage if they were to not start with the Greeks, and instead with the existentialists?
Cameron Sullivan
If you are sixteen that is fine. They look romantic and mysterious when you're young, but by the time you're in your mid-twenties you start to realize how dull they actually are compared to other writers and thinkers.
Chase Murphy
What if I'm 23 and find myself in awe that Nietzsche put to words a century ago all that I've ever felt?
Juan White
Yeah, existentialists are usually just edgelords who think they reached some amazing new way of seeing the world when in truth they are just the natural symptom of the culture at the time.
Fucking buddhists and greeks were way ahead of them more than 2500 years before
Thomas Martin
He's a Greek philology teacher that can't shut up about the Greeks for 15 pages.
If it wasn't for the marxist and pre-analytic thinkers, the history of German philosophy from Romanticism to Heidegger would be: "People Discover the Presocratics and the Tragedians - The Animated Series."
Jack Nelson
>if it wasnt for how things are really?
Michael Brooks
idk man, I started reading some Nietzche and his ideas seemed outdated, extremist, and overall obsolete. I understand where he's coming from, but with the spread of knowledge through means of mass communication, he just comes out as a bit ignorant to me.
Noah Foster
I must be some sort of turbo-pleb because I get more enjoyment reading about the Greeks than reading the actual works themselves.
Zachary Parker
>not starting with the Sumerians
Nicholas Nelson
Secondary literature is great. Veeky Forums unfairly disparages it. It's interesting reading the thoughts of people who have dedicated a lot of their time to studying primary stuff.
Levi Nguyen
Secondary literature is like having a discourse with someone who read the same shit as you, it's wonderful.
Alexander Gonzalez
>not starting with Shakespeare and never reading anything else
Liam Howard
>Veeky Forums unfairly disparages it It's a desperate measure against the endless hordes of plebs and pseuds, terrified of approaching, reading, and interpreting works by themselves, who would rather have not only their own opinions, but the very writing of the author, replaced by the current Wikipedia article.
Veeky Forums is the voice of reason in a world where even the most seminal of writers face a trial in absentia.
Cooper Mitchell
add the bible too
job and ecclesiastes shits on all existentialist texts
Liam Cook
>Ecclesiastes 1:10 >Is there any thing whereof it may be said, See, this is new? it hath been already of old time, which was before us.
Luis Taylor
I've read Gilgamesh, were do I go on from this?
Adrian Miller
Nowhere, you're done
Easton Hill
Both of those charts are horrible, desu. >no Aesop >no Plutarch >people out there actually reading Works and Days I mean what the fuck
Parker Lopez
Plutarch's lives are a (famous) abbreviation; his moralia are probably best relegated behind plotinus and proclus.
Aesop is good but not particularly "greek"; his fables have near universal appeal, but do little to shed light on the greek mind.
>doesn't like amd prioritize hesiod
The pleb filter caught another one, guys.
Isaiah Russell
Works and Days is literally a guide to tilling fields, you can't be fucking serious.
Liam Thompson
pleb
Nolan Adams
Fuck the greeks.
There is literally no reason to study ancient greek metaphysics.
Their philosophies(ex. Epicureanism, stoicism, scepticism) are cool, but reading texts like The Republic forces you to trudge through the absurd metaphysics.
You can start with later stories and philosophers without being clueless. Thinking you have to read the entire philosophical cannon to understand any of the later parts of it is retarded.
Illiad/oddysey is nice though, as a lot of the greek and homeric mythological stories.
Dominic Howard
Start with "On Nature"
Nicholas Robinson
Nietzsche isn't an existentialist by anything other than technicality. Greek philosophy really does only appeal to teenagers. I was forced to take an ancient philosophy course last term, and I kid you not every dumb boy that wasn't on their phones or skipping every lecture was gushing over Socrates and the Hellenistics.
And Veeky Forums wonders why I call these types '>reads philosophy once' philosophers. In this case, it was Plato's early dialogues. Something about Socrates insulting the court appeals to middle class kids with a love of the anti-state aesthetic (despite Plato being a ridiculous statist).
One can see these kids on Veeky Forums too, how many threads on stoicism or Diogenes do we get a week?
Ayden Watson
The 'start with the greeks' meme is kinda unclear. Some people mean the greek epics, some people mean the greek philosophers.
Andrew Williams
this makes me want to read it even more.
Hunter Sanchez
Hesiod is a bad poet.
Jayden Cox
Hesiod in one of the few ancient writers that I fundamentally hate as a person >you gotta work for everything >except me, the Muses just made me a great poet >Sucks at poetry >hobnailed hexameters
Landon Peterson
what a horrendous post
Evan Baker
Stoic spotted.
Christopher Turner
the only people who say Nietzsche was an existentialists are existentialists who want to include the glory of Nietzsche in their lackluster roster
Nolan Ward
No, he technically is one, he just does not resemble the common type because he doesn't wine about how everything and everybody bullies him.
Isaiah Perez
>existentialism >denies free will pick one
Luis Stewart
The Iliad is literally a story of guys running back and forth on a battlefield as their luck changes, you can't be fucking serious.
Plato's dialogues are literally a bunch of boy lovers talking at dinner parties, you can't be fucking serious.
Herodotus is literally a bunch of tall tales, you can't be fucking serious.
Did you read him in Greek?
Nicholas Howard
Why not start with the Sumerians? (Or the Egyptians?)
Xavier Barnes
Unironically, BEFORE the Greeks, you should get to know, in order:
Pettakere Chauvet Coliboaia El Castillo Lascaux Grotte de Cussac Pech Merle La Marche Les Combarelles Chauvet Niaux Cosquer Font-de-Gaume Altamira La Pasiega Gargas
Jayden Hernandez
Don't forget Ajita Kesakambali.
Cameron Collins
>One generation passeth away, and another generation cometh: but the earth standeth for ever.
Jeremiah Sullivan
Ridiculous. Long before you allow yourself to get to the early humans you must have already deciphered the veiled expressions of the logos in the winding pathways of trilobites in a younger mud.
Ryan Price
How come all those charts fail to mention the most influential Greek work?
Luke Thompson
>2017 >Not starting with the Big Bang
Out! Out! Out!
Samuel Harris
He doesn't deny free will you dope. No, I cannot read ancient Greek. I am relying on somebody I know fairly well that can. Mathematics is for children.
Ryder Flores
Shit post and previous posts kys
Aiden Adams
the problem with interpreting works yourself is the undeniable fact that you are certainly, absolutely certainly, incapable of coming up with new, genuinely intriguing opinions about the works. you cannot read greek. even if you can, are you erudite enough to grasp how the language's subtleties have transferred over thousands of years? are you so well-read in the field you have no need to read the opinions of others more intelligent than yourself?
probably not. decidedly not.
there isn't enough time on this hellish joke of an earth to specialize in every conceivable topic. read secondary lit.
Zachary Martinez
I'm just gonna read the Iliad and Odyssey, the Aeneid, and Palto and Aristotle. Is that okay bros? Or rally just want to understand Nietzsche, Kant, Wittgenstein, and a couple of others.
Luke Murphy
If you just want to understand philosophy, skip all the stories and focus on philosophy! Essential texts are the Five Dialogues (Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Meno, Phaedo) and the Republic by Plato, and Metaphysics, The Nicomachean Ethics, and Politics by Aristotle. The Symposium, Poetics, The Eudemian Ethics are also relevant, but not as crucial. You should also have a basic understanding of Greek mythology (I recommend "Mythology" by Edith Hamilton) and history.
However, if you want a more rounded perspective on intellectual and cultural history as a whole, especially to read more literary works, then the essential works are: The Iliad and The Odyssey; Theogony and Works and Days by Hesiod; The Oresteia (Agamemnon, The Libation Bearers. Eumenides) by Aeschylus; The Theban Plays (Oedipus Rex, Oedipus at Colonus, Antigone) by Sophocles; and Medea by Euripides. The works of Aristophanes and Sappho are also popular.