Reddit plebs hate this. What do Veeky Forums contrarians make of it?

Reddit plebs hate this. What do Veeky Forums contrarians make of it?

I don't know about contrarians, but I like this book.

Granted, Holden's sexual abuse of Phoebe puts me off a bit, but overall I enjoy it a lot.

It's really good but Salinger wrote better stuff.

He never abused her.

I think you read poorly what is written between the lines.

It's a good book. Redditors probably hate it because they're stuck in the high school mentality that you always have to root for the narrator/main character.
What would you say is better than this besides the generic answer of A Perfect Day For Bananafish?

The biggest pleb-filter of all time

Everyone's a fucking phony XD

It was a fine read. All I can remember from that book is that he rapes his sister, Pheobe.

not an argument