Husbando? Or diet-pronto?

You look fine in both picture so stop worrying, some women will like more right and some left so just go what you like the most.

>someone made a cute joke so I have to get fat

Did you grow up in a doll's house? Why are you so sensitive?

I think right is a lot better. I like guys that exude pure masculinity though. Looks stronger. Some girls would prefer left though. I guess so its a toss up of what you like more/type of person you wanna attract. If your goal is husbando mode stay at right bodyfat and keep lifting

You are literally me.
I'm also 6'3, went from slightly more muscular and dry on your left pic to bit more bf% than your right pic.
Still look very much the same though. Are your lifts also nearing 2/3/4/5 ?

Left looks better by a long shot.